MOHELA exit IDR plan warning forfeit benefits when leaving SAVE forbearance — what does this actually mean?
So I've been sitting in the SAVE forbearance limbo for a while now and I'm honestly at the point where I'm considering switching to a different repayment plan just to get some clarity on what my payments even look like going forward. But when I went into my MOHELA account to look at my options, there was this warning message that popped up — something about how if I exit my current IDR plan I would forfeit benefits and progress. I didn't screenshot it in time and now I can't get the same warning to appear again no matter where I click. My situation: I have Direct Loans, I work for a nonprofit so I'm trying to protect my PSLF qualifying payment count, and I've been in this administrative forbearance since the SAVE plan got tangled up in litigation. My qualifying payment count on MOHELA has been frozen at the same number for what feels like forever. I'm not even sure if the months in this forbearance are counting toward PSLF or not — different things I've read online say different things. What I'm really trying to figure out: does that forfeit warning mean I'd lose my PSLF qualifying payment count if I switch plans? Or is it just about IDR progress (like time toward IDR forgiveness at 20 or 25 years) and not the PSLF count? Those feel like two different things to me but I could be totally wrong. And if I switch to, say, IBR or PAYE, would my PSLF qualifying payment count just carry over? Has anyone else seen that warning and actually understood what it was telling you? I really need to get someone at MOHELA on the phone to explain this but I haven't been able to get through.
82 comments

Vera Visnjic
Three weeks into trying to reach MOHELA about my own SAVE forbearance question and completely losing my mind waiting on hold — I finally tried Claimyr (claimyr.com) and got connected to an actual MOHELA agent way faster than I ever managed on my own. If you need to talk to someone about that forfeit warning before you make any moves, that's the route I'd take. The agent I reached actually walked me through what the warning on my account meant line by line.
0 coins
Mason Lopez
AuthorJust pulled up claimyr.com on my phone — I'm going to try this tonight because I genuinely cannot afford to make the wrong move on the plan switch without talking to someone first.
0 coins
Jake Sinclair
same situation here, been trying for weeks to get through. adding this to my list to try
0 coins
Brielle Johnson
does it actually work for mohela specifically? i feel like every tip i try ends up being for a different servicer
0 coins
Honorah King
About six months into the SAVE forbearance myself and I want to clear up something I completely had backwards when I first saw that kind of warning. I used to think that your PSLF qualifying payment count and your IDR forgiveness progress were basically the same counter — like one number tracked everything. They're actually two totally separate things. Your PSLF count is the number of qualifying payments toward the 120 you need while working for a qualifying employer. Your IDR progress is the number of months counting toward the 20 or 25 year forgiveness timeline if you're not going for PSLF. The forfeit warning MOHELA shows when you try to leave SAVE is almost certainly about the IDR side — specifically certain credits or progress that SAVE was tracking. It shouldn't mean you're wiping out your PSLF qualifying payment count just by switching to a different qualifying IDR plan like IBR. But I'd verify that directly with MOHELA before switching because account-specific stuff can vary.
0 coins
Mason Lopez
AuthorOkay this is the clarification I needed most — I kept reading them as the same number and panicking. So when it says I'd forfeit benefits, it's most likely talking about SAVE-specific IDR benefits, not the PSLF count I've built up?
0 coins
Oliver Brown
This matches what I was told when I called in a few months back. The rep said my PSLF count wouldn't reset if I moved to IBR, it just picks up wherever it left off on a qualifying plan.
0 coins
Mary Bates
wait so the 120 payments doesn't start over if you switch plans?? i thought you had to stay on the same plan the whole time
0 coins
Clay blendedgen
Month four of my own SAVE forbearance and I want to flag something about the months sitting in this limbo. I went into my MOHELA account last week and the payment count hasn't moved in a long time. What I've seen referenced in a few places is that whether these administrative forbearance months count toward PSLF is not a simple yes or no — it depends on what the Department of Education has officially communicated about THAT specific forbearance period. I'd check your notices on MOHELA and your StudentAid.gov account rather than going by what people say online (including me), because the official guidance can change and what shows on your account is what actually matters for your records.
0 coins
Mason Lopez
AuthorChecked my MOHELA account right after reading this and my qualifying payment count hasn't moved at all since the forbearance started. I have no way of knowing from the site itself whether these months will retroactively count or not.
0 coins
Ayla Kumar
Mine is the same, frozen solid. I keep checking every couple weeks hoping something will update and it never does.
0 coins
Lorenzo McCormick
i called mohela about this exact thing and the rep told me to check my notices and my studentaid.gov account because they couldn't confirm what would happen to the count during the forbearance period. not very satisfying but at least honest i guess
0 coins
Carmella Popescu
Late last year I went through almost exactly what you're describing — staring at that warning message trying to decide whether to stay put or switch. Something I had completely wrong before I actually read the fine print: I assumed that IBR and PAYE would be just as good for PSLF as SAVE was, like they're all IDR so they all count the same. The qualifying plans for PSLF are specifically listed and you want to confirm whatever you're switching TO is on that qualifying list. IBR generally is, but I'd double check on StudentAid.gov rather than take my word for it.
0 coins
Mason Lopez
AuthorFound the PSLF qualifying plans list on StudentAid.gov and IBR is showing up there, that's a relief. Still going to confirm with MOHELA directly before I do anything.
0 coins
Kai Santiago
paye is on there too but i've heard it's closed to new enrollees now? not sure if that's still the case, worth checking your options in the loan simulator on studentaid.gov
0 coins
Lim Wong
The loan simulator on studentaid.gov is actually really useful for this. It lets you compare what different plans would look like for your specific loans which helped me understand the tradeoffs before I called.
0 coins
Dananyl Lear
This whole thread is making me realize I've been treating all IDR plans like they're interchangeable and they're really not. I need to actually read what I'm enrolled in.
0 coins
Noah huntAce420
Day one of actually sitting down to research this and I've already found three different answers to whether SAVE forbearance months count toward PSLF — one blog says yes, one says no, one says maybe. The only thing I trust at this point is what shows in my own MOHELA account and official notices from the Department of Education. I don't think any of us randoms on a forum can tell you with certainty what those months will count as.
0 coins
Mason Lopez
AuthorHonestly same. I've read so many contradictory things that I've stopped trusting any single source that isn't directly from MOHELA or StudentAid.gov.
0 coins
Honorah King
This is the right take. The situation has been changing enough that something written six months ago might already be outdated.
0 coins
Jake Sinclair
someone in my friend group said they heard from a MOHELA rep that the months do count but then another friend heard the opposite from a different rep on the same day lol. At this point calling is almost making it more confusing
0 coins
Ana Rusula
Step two of my own plan-switch decision process this week — after getting nowhere in the MOHELA chat, I ended up using Claimyr (claimyr.com) to get through to an agent. What I found out specifically about the forfeit warning: the rep explained that the message is there because switching out of SAVE means you'd lose any SAVE-specific payment credits that were part of that plan's one-time adjustment benefits, not your PSLF qualifying payment count. She said your PSLF count lives in your file and doesn't belong to any one plan. That said, she told me to get that confirmed in writing through my account because she could only speak to what she saw on her screen that day.
0 coins
Mason Lopez
AuthorLooked through my MOHELA account after reading this — there's nothing in writing there that explains it this clearly. I'm going to push for a written confirmation or a notice when I call.
0 coins
Mary Bates
wait so the warning is JUST about the SAVE-specific credits and not the pslf count at all? why would they write it in a way that makes it sound like everything is at risk
0 coins
Fidel Carson
MOHELA's warnings are written to cover every possible scenario so they end up being maximally terrifying without being specifically helpful. classic.
0 coins
Brielle Johnson
Getting this in writing is the smart move regardless. Document everything with MOHELA, every call, every chat, every notice.
0 coins
Isaiah Sanders
Somewhere around week eight of waiting for my own forbearance status to clarify and I need to push back gently on the idea that switching away from SAVE right now is definitely the smart move. I had it in my head for a while that getting OUT of the limbo would be better than staying in it. But if the months do end up counting toward PSLF retroactively — and I've seen some language suggesting that's a possibility for certain borrowers — then leaving might mean you don't get those months counted the same way. I'm not saying stay or go, I'm saying know what you're giving up before you decide, which sounds like exactly what you're trying to do.
0 coins
Mason Lopez
AuthorThis is exactly the tension I'm sitting with. If those months count retroactively I'd hate to have switched for no reason. But if they never count I'm wasting time standing still.
0 coins
Ayla Kumar
Same boat. I decided to wait another month before making any moves just to see if anything changes with the guidance.
0 coins
Oliver Brown
My own account showed something interesting last month — a small batch of qualifying payments appeared that I wasn't expecting, but then they disappeared in the next update. No idea if that was a glitch or a preview of something.
0 coins
Lorenzo McCormick
that disappearing payment count thing has happened to multiple people in my facebook group for PSLF. something keeps updating and rolling back
0 coins
Xan Dae
Second letter received from MOHELA in the past month about my SAVE forbearance status and I'm still not clearer on what to do. I want to flag for OP and others: I went through Claimyr (claimyr.com) last week because I had been failing to get a live person for so long I was starting to think it was impossible. The agent I reached told me something that actually changed my thinking — she said that for people with PSLF as their goal, the question of whether to exit SAVE isn't just about the IDR benefits warning, it's about whether the plan you're moving to is a qualifying plan AND whether your employer certification is current. If your ECF has lapsed, moving plans is kind of beside the point until that's sorted too.
0 coins
Mason Lopez
AuthorOh — I haven't thought about whether my employer certification is current. Let me check when I last submitted a PSLF form.
0 coins
Carmella Popescu
This is a genuinely important point that gets lost in the plan discussion. Your ECF and your plan qualification are both necessary, not just one or the other.
0 coins
Vera Visnjic
The employer certification piece tripped me up too. I thought my form from two years ago was good indefinitely but the guidance I saw suggested submitting more frequently to stay current.
0 coins
Kai Santiago
Right now I'm on IBR and looking at this thread nervously because I switched FROM SAVE a few months ago without really understanding the warning. Something I had completely wrong before I made the switch: I thought the PSLF Help Tool on StudentAid.gov and the actual PSLF form submission were the same thing — like using the tool meant I'd already submitted my form. The tool helps you fill it out and your employer signs it through the same system, but it's a separate process from tracking your qualifying payment count. I bring this up because if you're switching plans as part of a bigger PSLF strategy, make sure your form is actually submitted and not just started in the tool.
0 coins
Mason Lopez
AuthorWent back into the PSLF Help Tool just now and I can see my form status — it does show as submitted and employer-approved, so that part I apparently had right without realizing it.
0 coins
Fidel Carson
i made this exact mistake. i got to like 80% complete in the tool and then closed the window and thought it was done. it was not done.
0 coins
Lim Wong
The tool saves your progress but it only submits when you and your employer complete all the steps. If your employer hasn't signed it electronically it's not in MOHELA's hands yet.
0 coins
Ayla Kumar
Just got a letter from MOHELA this week about my account status and it mentioned the administrative forbearance but gave no timeline for when it ends. I want to share the exact sequence of steps I've used to track everything in this chaos: first I document every notice date and what it said, then I log into MOHELA and screenshot my qualifying payment count, and then I log into StudentAid.gov and do the same. If the numbers ever disagree I'd have a record. For the forfeit question specifically I'd want that in writing from MOHELA before switching anything.
0 coins
Mason Lopez
AuthorStarting a documentation folder tonight after reading this. I've been too casual about keeping records and if something goes wrong I'll have nothing to point to.
0 coins
Noah huntAce420
Keeping screenshots with dates is so important. I've had my payment count display differently on different days and without a log I couldn't prove what it showed before.
0 coins
Jake Sinclair
the fact that we all have to become meticulous record keepers just to manage our student loans is honestly a whole problem in itself
0 coins
Lorenzo McCormick
Got off a MOHELA chat two hours ago where I tried to get this exact question answered — does the forfeit warning affect PSLF or just IDR — and the rep kept pointing me to the general FAQ page. I finally found something in my own notices that said the warning is specifically about payment credits accumulated under SAVE's rules and doesn't wipe your PSLF qualifying count. But it took forever to find that language and I had to read the notice three times.
0 coins
Mason Lopez
AuthorCan you describe which section of the notice that was in? I want to look through mine more carefully now.
0 coins
Honorah King
The notices are buried in the correspondence section of your MOHELA account if you haven't found that tab yet. Easy to miss if you're just checking the dashboard.
0 coins
Isaiah Sanders
I went through every notice in my MOHELA correspondence inbox last month specifically looking for language like this and found nothing that clear. It might vary by what notices they've sent each account.
0 coins
Fidel Carson
About two months ago I was in an almost identical position and I ended up NOT switching plans specifically because I couldn't get a straight answer about the forfeit warning. Sitting here with my payment count still frozen and no timeline from MOHELA. I don't think there's a clearly right answer right now for people with PSLF goals — staying in the forbearance might protect you if those months count retroactively, but switching to a confirmed qualifying plan might protect you if they don't. The variable nobody can tell us is what the Department is actually going to do with the SAVE months.
0 coins
Mason Lopez
AuthorReading this and feeling both validated and more anxious simultaneously. At least I know I'm not missing something obvious.
0 coins
Ayla Kumar
Two months waiting with the same frozen count here. I've genuinely started to think the answer won't come until the litigation is fully resolved.
0 coins
Oliver Brown
My coworker switched to IBR back in January and has been getting confirmed qualifying payments since then. She said her PSLF count has been updating normally. That's the tradeoff — you lose the maybe-they'll-count SAVE months but you start getting definite qualifying payments again.
0 coins
Lim Wong
First real attempt at researching this issue systematically and something nobody has mentioned yet: the loan simulator on StudentAid.gov actually shows you projected PSLF eligibility across different plans for your specific loans. It won't tell you about the SAVE forfeit warning language but it'll show you which plans you're eligible for and what your payment would look like on each one. That comparison took a lot of the abstract scariness out of it for me and helped me ask better questions when I finally reached a MOHELA rep.
0 coins
Mason Lopez
AuthorRunning the simulator now — I never thought to use it this way, I always used it just to look at payment amounts.
0 coins
Dananyl Lear
The simulator is way more useful than I realized. I always ignored it because I thought it was just for picking a payment amount but it actually shows a lot more.
0 coins
Mary Bates
does the simulator account for the current forbearance situation or does it just show normal plan scenarios
0 coins
Jake Sinclair
Somewhere in week five of tracking this whole situation on a spreadsheet and I want to point out something that helped me understand the warning better than any forum post: I called my loan servicer and specifically asked them to quote me the language they're seeing on their end about what the forfeit covers. The rep read me language that specifically said payment credits under the SAVE plan terms — not PSLF qualifying payments. When I pushed and said 'does this affect my PSLF count' she said no, that count is in your file and doesn't reset when you change plans. But she also said to get it confirmed in writing, which I'm still trying to do.
0 coins
Mason Lopez
AuthorAsking them to read me the exact language they're seeing is a really smart approach — I'm going to do that specifically when I get through.
0 coins
Carmella Popescu
Asking them to frame it as 'does this affect my PSLF count specifically' rather than just asking about the warning in general is the key. Reps answer the question you ask, so being specific helps.
0 coins
Isaiah Sanders
The fact that we all have to call and cross-examine MOHELA reps to get clear answers about what a warning message means is genuinely absurd. The warning should just say what it's about.
0 coins
Noah huntAce420
Agreed that specificity is everything when you call. I've gotten completely useless answers by asking vague questions and gotten really useful ones by being precise about what I need.
0 coins
Dananyl Lear
Got my employer to sign my latest PSLF form last month and now I'm watching my MOHELA account to see if the qualifying count updates. Something I had totally backwards before all of this: I used to think deferment and forbearance were basically the same thing with different names — like both just paused your loans and that was it. They're actually different in how they're treated for PSLF. With deferment generally your payments are paused and those months typically don't count toward PSLF. Administrative forbearance placed by your servicer works differently and can depend on what specifically triggered it. I'd check with MOHELA about which one you're actually in before assuming what the months will or won't count as.
0 coins
Mason Lopez
AuthorLooked at my MOHELA account description of my current status and it does say administrative forbearance, not deferment. That distinction matters based on what you're saying.
0 coins
Mary Bates
wait i thought they were the same thing too. so deferment is definitely worse for pslf?
0 coins
Honorah King
For PSLF, deferment months generally don't count. Administrative forbearance is more complicated and depends on what kind it is and what guidance covers it. This is a question for MOHELA specifically about your account.
0 coins
Brielle Johnson
Last Thursday I finally got through to MOHELA after trying for days and I want to share what the rep confirmed for me since it's directly relevant to this thread. The forfeit warning when you try to exit SAVE is specifically about losing SAVE-specific payment reduction credits — the stuff that made SAVE payments lower than other IDR options in some cases. It is NOT about losing your PSLF qualifying payment count. The 120 payments you've accumulated don't belong to any plan, they're tracked separately. The rep said if you switch to a qualifying plan like IBR you just continue building from where you are. That said this is one rep on one day and I'd confirm for your specific account.
0 coins
Mason Lopez
AuthorThis is the clearest direct-from-MOHELA answer in this whole thread. Thank you for sharing it. I still want to hear it for my own account but this gives me a lot more confidence about what I'm dealing with.
0 coins
Fidel Carson
Finally a concrete answer. All of this should be on a clearly labeled FAQ page somewhere so we're not all calling in one by one to get the same information.
0 coins
Oliver Brown
Confirmed basically the same thing on my call a few weeks ago. PSLF count stays put, SAVE-specific credits are what's at risk. The warning language is just written to cover all scenarios.
0 coins
Ayla Kumar
I really needed to see this written out clearly. I've been so scared to touch anything in my account because of that warning.
0 coins
Mary Bates
About a week ago I went through what felt like an identical spiral on this and ended up staying on SAVE forbearance just because I was too scared to click anything after seeing that warning. Reading this thread I think I let the scariest possible interpretation run away with me. The warning made me think I was going to delete my entire PSLF progress if I touched a single button.
0 coins
Mason Lopez
AuthorThat's exactly where my brain went too — worst case interpretation of ambiguous warning language.
0 coins
Jake Sinclair
MOHELA really needs a plain language explanation next to that warning. 'You will forfeit certain plan benefits' means nothing without specifying which benefits.
0 coins
Dananyl Lear
The lack of plain language explanation for stuff like that is a real accessibility issue. Not everyone has the time or background to research what a vague legal warning means.
0 coins
Oliver Brown
Right at the decision point myself when I saw that warning on MOHELA — and the thing I had completely wrong at first was thinking that filing a complaint would somehow affect my loan account negatively, like mark me as a problem borrower or something. I was scared to push back at all. But when I finally filed something through the FSA Feedback Center after MOHELA couldn't answer my questions, nothing bad happened to my account and I eventually got a written response. If MOHELA can't give you a clear written answer about what you'd forfeit, the FSA Feedback Center and the FSA Ombudsman are legitimate options.
0 coins
Mason Lopez
AuthorI didn't even know the FSA Ombudsman was a real option for this kind of situation. Adding that to my list of paths forward if MOHELA can't give me a clear answer.
0 coins
Brielle Johnson
The FSA Ombudsman is specifically for when you've exhausted other options and still can't get a resolution. It's worth knowing about.
0 coins
Isaiah Sanders
Filing through the Feedback Center also creates a paper trail which is valuable if you ever need to escalate further.
0 coins
Fiona Gallagher
Final update from my own SAVE forbearance saga — after months of trying to get a straight answer through MOHELA's regular channels, I went through Claimyr (claimyr.com) one more time and specifically asked to speak with someone in the PSLF department rather than general servicing. That made a huge difference. The specialist confirmed in that call that my PSLF count was not affected by my SAVE enrollment or by the forfeit warning, and she told me to expect a written summary in my correspondence section within a few days. It showed up in my MOHELA account correspondence inbox exactly as promised.
0 coins
Mason Lopez
AuthorAsking for the PSLF department specifically is the tip I needed — I've been talking to general reps who clearly aren't specialists in this.
0 coins
Honorah King
Requesting a specialist versus just whoever picks up is such an underrated strategy. The difference in quality of information is real.
0 coins
Carmella Popescu
And getting it confirmed in your correspondence inbox is the gold standard for this. Screenshot it immediately once it appears.
0 coins
Mary Bates
wait they have a specific pslf department?? i've just been calling the main line and accepting whoever i get
0 coins