Back to MOHELA

Ethan Anderson

How to switch from SAVE to IBR with MOHELA when the plan shows as suspended

Ok so I'm losing my mind a little bit here. I was on SAVE for about a year and a half and my loans are with MOHELA. At some point my account just went into administrative forbearance without me doing anything, and I finally looked into it and realized SAVE has been in this legal limbo situation for a while. I don't want to just sit here waiting forever because I'm trying to make progress toward forgiveness — I work for a county health department so PSLF is the whole plan. I went on StudentAid.gov to try to change my repayment plan and I found the IDR application but honestly the whole thing confused me because I wasn't sure if I should be applying for a new plan from scratch or if there's some kind of switch option. I want to get onto IBR specifically because I've heard from coworkers that IBR months might actually count toward PSLF even during whatever is happening with SAVE right now, but I'm not sure if that's accurate or if I'm confusing something. Also nervous that switching will mess up my payment history or reset something. Can someone walk me through how to switch from SAVE to IBR with MOHELA? Like do I do it on StudentAid.gov, do I contact MOHELA directly, what actually happens to my account while it's processing?

Claimyr got me through to a MOHELA agent in like 20 minutes when I was stuck on this exact same situation — I had spent weeks trying to get someone on the phone through the regular way and kept getting disconnected or just waiting forever. The site is claimyr.com and they basically hold the line for you so you're not just sitting there. Worth it if you need to talk through your specific account situation with an actual human, especially if you're asking about PSLF implications of switching plans.

0 coins

Is this legit? Sounds kind of sketchy that a third party is calling MOHELA on your behalf

0 coins

Yeah it's legitimate — you're not giving them your loan account access or anything like that, they just navigate the hold queue and connect you when an agent picks up. I was skeptical too but it worked.

0 coins

I'd been assuming the only way was to just call and suffer through the hold. Good to know this exists.

0 coins

Wait, do you actually have to call MOHELA to switch plans or can you just do it on StudentAid.gov yourself?

0 coins

You submit the IDR application on StudentAid.gov — there's a section where you pick which plan you want. You can specifically request IBR. MOHELA then processes whatever StudentAid.gov sends over. The confusion is that MOHELA and StudentAid.gov are kind of two separate pieces of the same system, so you do the form on the gov site but MOHELA is who actually updates your account.

0 coins

That's what I thought but the application interface kept making me feel like I was just reapplying for SAVE again. Is there a specific spot where you choose IBR as the target plan?

0 coins

Yeah there's a dropdown or selection step where you can say which plan you want. If you don't specify it'll sometimes default to whatever it calculates as lowest payment which during the SAVE situation might behave weirdly. Specifically pick IBR in the application.

0 coins

ok but does it matter which version of IBR, like original IBR vs new IBR or is that not a thing anymore

0 coins

I got burned by not understanding this for about six months. I assumed my loans being in forbearance meant I was still 'on' SAVE and that everything was fine. Turns out the forbearance paused my payments but my plan designation was kind of in this weird state. Here's how it actually works from what I've pieced together: SAVE is under litigation so the department put everyone on it into administrative forbearance. If you want to actually be on IBR and making qualifying payments toward PSLF, you need to submit an IDR application on StudentAid.gov, select IBR specifically, and MOHELA will process it and update your plan. The switch itself doesn't erase your payment history or reset your PSLF count — your qualifying payments already counted stay counted.

0 coins

Six months in the same fog — yeah that tracks for where I am. So the qualifying payment count I already have from before SAVE doesn't disappear when I switch to IBR?

0 coins

Correct. Your PSLF qualifying payment count is tracked separately from which IDR plan you're currently on. Switching plans doesn't wipe it. The bigger question is what happens during the forbearance months themselves — those are generally not counting as qualifying PSLF payments, which is part of why getting onto an active qualifying plan actually matters.

0 coins

This is the part that stresses me out. Every month I sit in this forbearance limbo is a month not moving toward my 120 qualifying payments.

0 coins

My sister works in public health and she went through this switch a couple months ago. She ended up using Claimyr to get through to MOHELA because she kept getting dropped on hold and had a hard work schedule that made calling during normal hours a nightmare. From what she told me after talking to the agent, MOHELA confirmed the IBR application does have to go through StudentAid.gov first before they can do anything on their end. The agent also walked her through what her new estimated payment would look like under IBR versus what she'd been expecting.

0 coins

Does IBR payment end up being way higher than SAVE was? That's my hesitation.

0 coins

For my sister it was higher than what SAVE would have been, yeah. But she said given everything with the litigation she'd rather be on a stable plan that she knows is counting toward PSLF than wait on SAVE indefinitely.

0 coins

That's basically where I landed too. SAVE had a better calculated payment for me but I switched because I wanted to actually be making progress.

0 coins

I work at a nonprofit and went through this exact switch a few months back. What tripped me up was thinking I had to call MOHELA first to 'unlock' the ability to change plans. I wasted two weeks trying to get through on the phone before realizing the application is just on StudentAid.gov and you do it yourself. Go to the loan simulator or the IDR application directly, select IBR, fill it out, submit it. MOHELA gets the request and starts processing. During processing they may put your loans in a short administrative forbearance while they handle the transition — that part is normal and temporary.

0 coins

Two weeks on the phone rabbit hole before figuring this out — ugh. So you just went to StudentAid.gov and filled it out yourself with no call needed?

0 coins

Exactly. No call needed to initiate the switch. Where a call might help is if you want to confirm your PSLF qualifying payment count is accurate before switching, or if something looks wrong in your account after MOHELA processes the application. Those are worth a call. But the actual plan switch starts on StudentAid.gov.

0 coins

ok that's actually really helpful i've been dreading calling them for the same reason

0 coins

wait does switching from SAVE to IBR affect the PSLF employer certification stuff at all or is that completely separate

0 coins

Completely separate. Your PSLF employer certification form through the PSLF Help Tool on StudentAid.gov and your IDR plan are two different things. You can switch plans without redoing any employment certification stuff.

0 coins

oh good i just did my employer certification like two months ago and panicked a little

0 coins

Yeah the ECF and the IDR application are totally unrelated processes even though they're both on StudentAid.gov

0 coins

Had three calls with MOHELA dropped before I finally used Claimyr to actually get through — claimyr.com was the thing that finally worked for me. I'd been trying to ask specifically about whether my payment count would be preserved when switching plans and I couldn't get a straight answer through the message portal. When I finally talked to someone they confirmed the payment count stays intact and also told me my account would go into a brief processing forbearance of a few weeks while they moved me from SAVE to IBR. That heads up was really useful because I would have panicked otherwise.

0 coins

Few weeks of processing forbearance is what you got? Did that forbearance count toward anything or was it just a pause?

0 coins

It was just a pause — not counting toward my PSLF qualifying payments during that window. But the agent was clear it was temporary and once the plan switch was done I'd start accumulating qualifying payments again under IBR since I work for a qualifying employer.

0 coins

That temporary processing forbearance is the part that gets me. Every pause adds up when you're counting toward 120.

0 coins

Is there any way to avoid the processing forbearance or do you just have to accept it?

0 coins

ok genuine question — what actually makes IBR a 'qualifying' plan for PSLF? like why does the plan type matter at all

0 coins

My loans sat in a non-qualifying repayment period for almost two years before I understood this. For a payment to count toward PSLF it has to be made under a qualifying repayment plan — income-driven plans like IBR, PAYE, ICR and SAVE (when active) qualify. Standard 10-year qualifies too. What doesn't qualify are graduated, extended, or other plans. The issue with SAVE right now is the litigation has the plan frozen, so payments aren't being collected and the forbearance months generally haven't been announced as counting. IBR is not in litigation so if you're on IBR and making payments while working full time for a qualifying employer, those months count.

0 coins

ok that actually makes it click for me, so it's about the plan itself being legally in good standing not just any monthly payment

0 coins

Yeah exactly. I thought for a long time that any payment I made counted, didn't realize the plan type mattered so much.

0 coins

Anyone know if you have to recertify your income when you switch from SAVE to IBR or does MOHELA just carry over whatever income info they already have

0 coins

You'll go through the IDR application which does include an income step. You can often link your tax information through the IRS data retrieval tool on the application, so it's not like you're starting totally from scratch, but yes you're submitting your income information as part of the IBR application process.

0 coins

ugh ok. my income changed a lot this year compared to last year's taxes so i'm worried about what that does to my payment

0 coins

If your income changed significantly you can provide current income documentation instead of using last year's tax return. The IDR application has options for that. Worth doing if your current income is lower than what your taxes would show.

0 coins

oh i didn't know that was an option. my taxes were higher last year so this is actually good news

0 coins

what is the timeline like after you submit the IBR application on StudentAid.gov? like how long before MOHELA actually switches your plan

0 coins

Mine took about three to four weeks from application submission to MOHELA updating my plan. During that time I was in processing forbearance. I checked my MOHELA account periodically and eventually the plan listed changed from SAVE to IBR and my payment amount updated.

0 coins

three to four weeks and you were just waiting with no confirmation in between?

0 coins

MOHELA sent me a letter when the switch was complete, and I could also see the status update in my account on StudentAid.gov. But there's not a lot of real-time tracking during that window, yeah. It's kind of a waiting game.

0 coins

that in-between period would stress me out so much

0 coins

I'll add one thing that caught me off guard. When I switched to IBR my autopay didn't automatically carry over at the new payment amount. MOHELA sent me a notice with the new payment amount and I had to verify my autopay was set up correctly for the new amount. Definitely check your bank after the switch goes through so you're not accidentally not paying or overpaying.

0 coins

Oh that's a really good call. I would have assumed autopay just continued.

0 coins

Yeah I had the same assumption. The autopay was technically still active but it was tied to the old amount and my account looked weird for a bit. Just double check everything once MOHELA confirms the switch.

0 coins

This happened to me too when my loans transferred. Autopay stuff always seems to need attention after any account change.

0 coins

I want to push back a little on the idea that IBR is automatically the right move for everyone coming off SAVE. Like for some people depending on their income and family size, IBR payment could be significantly higher than what SAVE had them paying, and if they're not working toward PSLF maybe the payment amount matters more than the plan type. Just something to think about for people reading this thread who aren't necessarily chasing forgiveness.

0 coins

Fair point — for me it's specifically about PSLF which is why IBR makes sense. But yeah if someone isn't going for forgiveness the payment amount calculation matters.

0 coins

Exactly. PSLF folks have good reason to care about qualifying plan status above all. But there are other IDR options too like PAYE or ICR depending on your loan types, and what MOHELA shows available to you depends on your specific loan situation. Worth using the loan simulator on StudentAid.gov before committing.

0 coins

the loan simulator actually does a good job of showing you side by side what different plans would cost you each month. i used it before switching and it helped a lot

0 coins

just want to say i've been lurking this thread and finally feel like i understand what's been happening with my account. i've been in SAVE forbearance for months and had no idea i could just go apply for IBR myself on StudentAid.gov without having to get through to MOHELA first

0 coins

Glad it helped. One thing — after you submit the IBR application and MOHELA processes the switch, do check your PSLF qualifying payment count to make sure it still looks right. It should, but it's worth verifying once everything settles.

0 coins

will do. and i'll double check the autopay situation too after the switch goes through based on what someone said above

0 coins

same here, this thread answered like four questions i'd been googling for weeks

0 coins

Does submitting the IBR application cancel the administrative forbearance or does MOHELA keep you in forbearance until the switch is fully processed

0 coins

Generally you stay in a processing forbearance while MOHELA handles the application, so the forbearance continues but the reason shifts from 'SAVE litigation' to 'processing an IDR application.' Once the switch is done and IBR is active, you should start entering a billing cycle again with your new IBR payment.

0 coins

So basically one forbearance ends and another short one takes its place during processing. Got it.

0 coins

I called about this specific question because I was confused too. The agent explained it the same way. If you can't get through, Claimyr at claimyr.com worked well for me to actually reach someone — I had tried the message portal and never got a useful answer, only form responses.

0 coins

Good to know there's a way to actually reach a human for stuff like this

0 coins

My situation is a little different — I have some loans with MOHELA that are federal Direct Loans and I had one private loan through SoFi that MOHELA was servicing separately. I made the mistake of thinking all my MOHELA loans could go on IBR and went through the whole IDR application process and then got confused when my SoFi private loan didn't update. Had to eventually figure out that the federal loans and the private SoFi loan are two completely separate accounts even if MOHELA services both.

0 coins

Oh wow I didn't realize MOHELA services private loans too — that would have thrown me off completely.

0 coins

Yeah it's a whole separate login and account. IBR and PSLF are federal programs so they don't apply to the private loan at all. Just flagging because I wasted time being confused about why the IDR application wasn't affecting that private loan.

0 coins

This is a really important point. Federal IDR plans and PSLF only apply to federal Direct Loans. If you have private loans that MOHELA services for a lender like SoFi, those are on completely separate rules.

0 coins

wait so MOHELA has two totally different types of accounts for some people? that's genuinely confusing

0 coins

Something I want to flag for anyone counting PSLF payments really carefully. When MOHELA updates your plan to IBR make sure your employment certification is also current. I switched plans but my employer certification was almost due for the annual update and I almost let it lapse during the switch because I was focused on the plan change. MOHELA processes the IDR switch and the PSLF certification separately so it's easy to let one fall through while focusing on the other.

0 coins

Really glad you said this — my last employer certification was about eight months ago so I should probably be thinking about submitting a new one soon.

0 coins

Yeah the certification itself just confirms your employment during that period and helps MOHELA update the qualifying payment count. I try to submit one every year even if it's not technically required at that exact moment. Better to have the count up to date so I know where I stand.

0 coins

Same approach. I basically treat the annual recertification window as a check-in on everything — payment count, plan status, employer info. All at once.

0 coins

MOHELA AI

Expert Assistant
Secure