Do I need to recertify income when switching from PAYE to RAP?
So I've been on PAYE for about three years now and my employer just mentioned that the Repayment Assistance Plan might actually lower my monthly payment given where my income is sitting. I went to look into switching and hit a wall of confusion immediately. My main question is do i need to recertify income when switching from PAYE to RAP — like does MOHELA or StudentAid.gov require me to submit fresh income documentation the moment I request the plan change, or does my existing IDR recertification carry over until my next annual date? I don't want to accidentally trigger an early recertification that bumps my payment up before I've had a chance to figure out if RAP is even the right move. My MOHELA account currently shows my next recertification date as several months out, and I'd hate to lose that if the switch resets the clock. Anyone been through this recently?
65 comments

Liv Park
Went through almost the exact same plan-change question a few weeks ago and ended up spending hours trying to get a straight answer from MOHELA by phone. The hold times were brutal and I kept getting disconnected before anyone picked up. Someone in another thread recommended Claimyr — claimyr.com — and I was skeptical but tried it. It basically gets you to an actual MOHELA agent without you sitting on hold yourself. Got through in way less time than my previous attempts, and the agent walked me through exactly what documentation they'd need for my situation. Definitely worth it if you need to talk to someone at MOHELA and don't have hours to burn.
0 coins
Leeann Blackstein
Just looked this up after reading your comment and went to the site. Does it actually work for MOHELA specifically or is it more of a general thing? I've been trying to reach MOHELA about my own IDR recertification for weeks.
0 coins
Liv Park
Pulled up my notes from that call and it was definitely MOHELA I reached through it. The agent I spoke with was able to pull up my account and answer the plan-switch question directly. Worked for my federal loans serviced through MOHELA on StudentAid.gov, not sure about private loans.
0 coins
Ryder Greene
That hold time problem is so real. I've been disconnected three times in the last month trying to get answers about my payment count. Might try this.
0 coins
Carmella Fromis
The question you should really be asking MOHELA before you do anything is whether the plan change request itself counts as a new IDR application that resets your recertification date — because that's the thing that actually determines whether you lose those months you've already banked. Here's how it works as I understand it: when you apply for a different income-driven plan, the servicer typically processes it as a new application, and that can start a fresh 12-month recertification clock. So your existing recertification date may not carry over. But the income documentation part depends on how recently you certified — if your income info is recent enough, they may not require new docs right away, though that varies. I'd ask MOHELA directly: 'If I submit a plan-change request today, does it reset my recertification anniversary date?' That's the key question.
0 coins
Charlee Coleman
AuthorThat reframing actually helps a lot — I was so focused on the income docs piece that I hadn't thought about whether the anniversary date itself resets. So even if they don't ask me for new income info right away, the clock could still restart?
0 coins
Carmella Fromis
Checked through some of the StudentAid.gov IDR documentation to make sure I'm not steering you wrong — yes, that's the distinction. The income verification step and the recertification date are technically separate things, and a plan change can affect the date even if they don't immediately request new income proof. MOHELA would have the specifics for how they're handling it right now.
0 coins
Theodore Nelson
This is the part nobody explains clearly. I switched plans last year and was completely blindsided when my recertification date changed. Wish someone had flagged this for me before I submitted.
0 coins
AaliyahAli
Had to figure out my own plan-switch situation a couple months back and the MOHELA agents I eventually reached were actually pretty knowledgeable once I got one on the phone. Getting there was the hard part. I ended up using Claimyr (claimyr.com) after two failed attempts on my own — the second time I was on hold so long my phone died. What the agent told me about income recertification when switching plans was that it depends partly on how far out your current recertification date is and what income data they already have on file. She said to ask specifically about whether the plan change triggers a new 12-month window or carries over the existing one, because apparently it's not automatic either way.
0 coins
Charlee Coleman
AuthorReally useful to know the agent phrasing that actually got you a clear answer. Did she mention anything specific about PAYE vs. newer plans? My situation is that I'm moving away from PAYE and I want to make sure the qualifying payment history I've built doesn't get messed with.
0 coins
AaliyahAli
Looked back at my notes from that call — she didn't specifically mention PAYE but she did say that qualifying payment counts for PSLF purposes aren't affected by a plan change as long as the new plan is also a qualifying repayment plan. The recertification date question is separate from the payment count question. Those are two different things to ask about.
0 coins
Ellie Simpson
qualifying payment counts not being affected by plan changes is the thing I was most worried about when I looked into switching. good to hear that's apparently not the issue
0 coins
Arjun Kurti
wait so if im on paye and switch plans my pslf count stays the same?? that's what I need to know before I do anything
0 coins
Raúl Mora
Something worth flagging here because I see this confusion come up a lot — PAYE (Pay As You Earn) is a federal IDR plan administered through StudentAid.gov, and any recertification or plan-change paperwork for it goes through the IDR application on StudentAid.gov, not a separate MOHELA form. MOHELA then processes whatever the IDR application generates. So when people say 'I asked MOHELA about recertifying' — that's the right instinct for clarifying your account status, but the actual application is submitted on StudentAid.gov. Worth knowing before you go in circles like I did early on.
0 coins
Charlee Coleman
AuthorWent back to look at my StudentAid.gov account after reading this and yes, I can see the IDR application tool there. So I'd submit the plan change request through StudentAid.gov and MOHELA would then update my account based on that — is that the right flow?
0 coins
Raúl Mora
Found the same thing when I went through my own plan change — yes, that's the basic flow. You submit on StudentAid.gov, MOHELA receives it and processes it, your account on the MOHELA side of StudentAid.gov gets updated. Sometimes there's a lag between submission and when you see the change reflected in your payment amount or recertification date.
0 coins
Margot Quinn
The lag is real. Mine took almost three weeks to show up after I submitted. I was checking every day getting increasingly stressed thinking something went wrong.
0 coins
Evelyn Kim
ok so i'm reading this thread and also confused about whether RAP and IDR are the same thing or different things?? like is RAP one of the IDR plans or is it something else entirely because I've been seeing it mentioned more lately and i don't know if it's something my federal loans would even qualify for
0 coins
Carmella Fromis
The alphabet soup in federal student loans is genuinely confusing and you're not alone in this. The short version: IDR is the category (income-driven repayment), and there are multiple specific plans under that umbrella. Whether RAP is currently available for your loans and how it compares to what you're on now — that's something to check on StudentAid.gov or ask MOHELA directly, because the plan landscape has been shifting and I don't want to tell you something that's out of date for your specific loan type.
0 coins
Evelyn Kim
ugh ok so I need to actually call. I hate calling. they always put me on hold forever and then I have to explain everything from scratch every single time
0 coins
Diego Fisher
Something nobody has mentioned yet: before asking MOHELA about whether income recertification is required, it's worth asking them what your current IDR recertification date actually shows in their system, because sometimes what you see on your account and what they have on record don't match, especially if you recently had loans transferred or processed any paperwork. I found out the hard way that my recertification date in my account was different from what the agent pulled up on their end. So confirming that first gives you a cleaner baseline for the plan-change conversation.
0 coins
Charlee Coleman
AuthorHadn't even considered that discrepancy angle — I've been assuming whatever my MOHELA account on StudentAid.gov shows is authoritative. So you're saying to specifically ask the agent to read back the date they see on their end and compare?
0 coins
Diego Fisher
Dug up my notes from that call — yes, exactly that. Ask the agent to confirm the recertification date in their system. If it matches your account, great. If it doesn't, get that resolved before you do anything else because a plan change on top of a date discrepancy just makes the mess worse.
0 coins
Henrietta Beasley
This happened to me after my loans transferred to MOHELA. The dates were off by like four months. Took two calls to get it straightened out. Definitely check this first.
0 coins
Lincoln Ramiro
so weird that the dates can be different on the same account. the whole system is a mess honestly
0 coins
Faith Kingston
Came here to share what worked for me because I went through a PAYE-related plan change question a few weeks ago and was completely stuck. After striking out on the MOHELA contact page messaging (no reply for over a week) I tried Claimyr — claimyr.com — and finally got an agent on the phone who could actually look at my account and tell me what MOHELA would need from me specifically. The income recertification question for my situation turned out to have a specific answer that depended on when I'd last submitted income docs, which the agent could see in my file. No amount of reading FAQs was going to give me that account-specific answer.
0 coins
Leeann Blackstein
The 'account-specific' point is key. I keep trying to figure out my situation from general articles and forum posts but everyone's situation is slightly different. At some point you just have to get someone on the phone who can see your actual file.
0 coins
Faith Kingston
Exactly what I found. The general information is useful for knowing what questions to ask, but the actual answer for your account depends on what's in your file — when you last recertified, what income data they have, what your loan type is. The agent can see all of that and you can't always see it yourself in the portal.
0 coins
Ryder Greene
the messaging not getting a reply is my experience too. I've sent two messages in the past six weeks with nothing back. is that normal or am I missing something
0 coins
Theodore Nelson
One thing that tripped me up when I was looking into an IDR plan switch: I assumed that since I was already on an income-driven plan, switching to a different income-driven plan would be treated like a minor update. It wasn't. MOHELA processed it like a new application. That meant they did ask for income documentation, and there was a period where my loans went into administrative forbearance while the new plan application was processing. The forbearance was fine in terms of pausing my payment, but I had to ask MOHELA specifically about whether those months counted toward my PSLF total, because the answer to that depends on the type of forbearance.
0 coins
Charlee Coleman
AuthorThe administrative forbearance piece is something I definitely hadn't thought about. If my loans go into forbearance while the plan change processes, does that gap affect my qualifying payment count for PSLF? That's a real concern for me since I'm trying to protect the payments I've already made.
0 coins
Theodore Nelson
Checked my account notes from that period — the answer I got from MOHELA was that it depended on the specific forbearance type, and they'd noted it on my account. For PSLF purposes you want to ask MOHELA explicitly: does this administrative forbearance count toward qualifying payments or not. Don't assume either way.
0 coins
Carmella Fromis
This is exactly the right question to ask and I'd put it in writing through the MOHELA message system so you have a record of their answer. Verbal assurances on the phone are harder to follow up on if something looks wrong later.
0 coins
Arjun Kurti
wait does any of this apply to private loans too or just federal? asking bc I have loans that were originally through a lender and now serviced by mohela and i don't even know if I have paye or what plan im on
0 coins
Raúl Mora
The plan type question is worth asking but let me flag something first — if your loans are private loans that MOHELA happens to service for a lender like SoFi or Laurel Road, then federal IDR plans like PAYE and RAP don't apply to them at all. Those are federal-only programs. Private loans serviced by MOHELA have different terms set by the original lender. You'd need to check your loan agreement or contact MOHELA specifically about those loans to understand your options. They're handled through a separate login from your federal loan account.
0 coins
Arjun Kurti
oh wow I did not know that. I've been assuming everything was the same because it all says MOHELA. so I need to figure out first whether my loans are federal or private before any of this thread even applies to me?
0 coins
Raúl Mora
Found the simplest way to check — log into StudentAid.gov with your FSA ID. If your loans show up there, they're federal. If they don't show up there, they're private. That's the fastest way to know which situation you're in.
0 coins
Lincoln Ramiro
this is why the whole system is confusing. two totally different types of loans, same servicer name, completely different rules
0 coins
Henrietta Beasley
Something I'd add from my own experience going through a plan change: screenshot everything before you submit the new application. Your current payment amount, your recertification date, your qualifying payment count if you're tracking PSLF. All of it. Because if something looks off after MOHELA processes the change, you'll want that baseline to point to when you call. I didn't do this and spent a lot of time trying to reconstruct what my numbers were before.
0 coins
Charlee Coleman
AuthorGoing to do this tonight before I submit anything. My PSLF qualifying payment count especially — I want that documented before any plan change goes through.
0 coins
Henrietta Beasley
Smart move. And while you're in there, also note what your payment history shows for the last few months just in case there's any question about whether certain payments posted correctly during the transition.
0 coins
Margot Quinn
Cannot stress the screenshot advice enough. Went through a transfer once without documenting anything and it was a nightmare sorting out discrepancies afterward.
0 coins
Ellie Simpson
One more thing worth knowing before you submit a plan-change request: ask MOHELA whether they'll need to verify your income at the time of the switch even if your annual recertification isn't due yet. Some situations trigger an off-cycle income check — like if your income changed significantly — and knowing upfront what they're going to ask for means you can gather your documents ahead of time instead of scrambling after you've already submitted.
0 coins
Charlee Coleman
AuthorMakes sense to frontload that preparation. My income hasn't changed dramatically but I'll ask the question anyway so I know what to expect. Last thing I want is the application sitting in limbo while they wait for a document I didn't know they needed.
0 coins
Ellie Simpson
Exactly. And if you end up having to call MOHELA to ask, have your most recent tax return and a recent pay stub ready because those are typically what they reference for income verification. Having them in front of you speeds the call up a lot.
0 coins
Leeann Blackstein
I'm going to offer a slightly different angle here — before worrying about whether income recertification is required when switching plans, it might be worth asking whether switching is even the right move for your PSLF timeline. If you're close to 120 qualifying payments, the plan you switch to also needs to be a qualifying repayment plan for PSLF, and not all IDR plans have the same status. I went down the path of switching and then had to call MOHELA to confirm my new plan would still count toward PSLF. The answer was yes in my case, but I should have confirmed that before I submitted, not after.
0 coins
Charlee Coleman
AuthorHow many qualifying payments am I into the PSLF count — that's information I should be verifying with MOHELA anyway as part of this. And you're right that confirming the new plan qualifies for PSLF should probably be step one before anything else.
0 coins
Leeann Blackstein
Pulled up my own PSLF tracker on StudentAid.gov while typing this — it shows qualifying payment count there, though it can lag behind what MOHELA has actually processed. Good to check both places and ask MOHELA if there's a discrepancy.
0 coins
Ryder Greene
the PSLF tracker lagging is so annoying. mine shows a number that I know is at least two months behind because I can see payments my MOHELA account shows as qualifying that haven't shown up in the count yet
0 coins
Margot Quinn
Quick practical note: when you do call MOHELA to ask about the plan switch and income recertification, ask them to put a note in your account about what they told you. Agents vary a lot and if you call back and get someone different, having a note in your file from the previous call gives the new agent context. I started doing this after getting contradictory information from two different MOHELA agents on the same question.
0 coins
Charlee Coleman
AuthorHadn't thought about asking them to document the call in my account — that's a really practical tip. Does that actually happen reliably or is it hit or miss?
0 coins
Margot Quinn
Went back and looked at my own call log notes — in my experience it's somewhat hit or miss whether the note actually appears, but asking puts the agent on record saying they'd do it. At minimum I always write down the date, time, and name of the agent I spoke with on my end so I have something to reference.
0 coins
Henrietta Beasley
The agent name and time note is essential. I keep a running doc with every MOHELA call I've ever made. Sounds excessive until you need it.
0 coins
Emma Johnson
Late to this thread but adding because I saw Claimyr mentioned a couple times and want to second it from my own experience specifically for MOHELA questions about IDR plans — claimyr.com. I had been trying to get clarity on a recertification question for weeks through the message portal with no response, and Claimyr got me to an agent the same day. The agent was able to confirm the specific income documentation MOHELA would need for my plan change and walked me through what would happen to my recertification date. That account-specific information is just not available any other way.
0 coins
Lincoln Ramiro
Three separate people in this thread recommending the same thing is enough for me to try it. I've been avoiding calling MOHELA because the last time I tried I was on hold so long I gave up.
0 coins
Emma Johnson
The hold time avoidance is exactly why it's useful. You don't sit there waiting — it handles the queue part for you. By the time I was connected the agent was ready to go and I didn't have to explain that I'd been waiting forever.
0 coins
Ryder Greene
Circling back to the original question because I want to make sure the actual answer is clear for anyone who finds this thread later: the short version based on everything in this discussion seems to be — plan changes can trigger income recertification requirements depending on your situation, the recertification anniversary date may reset when you switch plans, and the specifics depend on what's in your MOHELA account. There's no single universal answer, which is frustrating, but it means calling MOHELA with the specific questions from this thread is genuinely the right move.
0 coins
Charlee Coleman
AuthorComing back to say I finally got through to a MOHELA agent and asked all of these questions. The agent confirmed that for my specific situation, switching plans would likely start a new recertification window, and they did want updated income documentation. Knowing to ask that exact question made the call so much more productive than it would have been if I'd called without knowing what to ask.
0 coins
Ryder Greene
Really glad you updated the thread. The 'new recertification window' thing is exactly what I was worried about for my own situation and it confirms I need to actually call before I do anything.
0 coins
Theodore Nelson
Thanks for the update. This is one of those questions where everyone's situation is a little different but the framework for how to ask is the same, and this thread gives people that framework.
0 coins
Carmella Fromis
Good outcome and good process. Document everything going forward — your new recertification date once it's confirmed, your qualifying payment count, all of it. Plan changes are one of those moments where having a clear before-and-after record really matters if anything looks off later.
0 coins
Lincoln Ramiro
genuinely didn't know any of this before finding this thread. I've been on the same IDR plan for four years and never thought about what would happen if I switched. now I'm wondering if I should even look at whether I'm on the best plan for my situation or just leave it alone because the switching process sounds complicated
0 coins
Raúl Mora
The question you should probably ask StudentAid.gov's loan simulator is whether a different plan would actually lower your payment enough to be worth the administrative hassle of switching — because for some people the difference is small enough that staying put makes more sense. The simulator can show you estimated payments across plans without committing to anything.
0 coins
Lincoln Ramiro
Logged into StudentAid.gov to find that simulator and found it under the repayment section. Running my numbers now. This is actually useful, didn't know this tool existed.
0 coins
Leeann Blackstein
the loan simulator is underrated. I used it before my last plan decision and it saved me from making a switch that would have barely changed my payment while restarting my recertification clock
0 coins