SAVE Plan suspended by court ruling - what happens to my income-driven repayment now?
Just saw a notice on studentaid.gov about the SAVE Plan being suspended by a court ruling on July 18! I've been counting on switching to SAVE when my loans come due in September because my payments would be cut in half compared to REPAYE. Does anyone know what this means for those of us planning to use SAVE? The announcement was super vague, just saying they're "assessing the ruling." Are we just screwed now? Has anyone gotten any communication from their loan servicer about this?
20 comments


Ravi Kapoor
Yep, just saw it too. Complete disaster for me also. I did some googling and apparently some Republican states sued to block SAVE, claiming Biden didn't have authority to create the plan. The court agreed and now it's on hold. No idea what happens next but I'm freaking out because my payments were going to be $178 under SAVE but like $380 under the old plans.
0 coins
CosmicVoyager
•This is completely insane! They can just pull the rug out from under millions of borrowers with no warning? I haven't received ANY communication from my servicer either.
0 coins
Freya Nielsen
Financial aid advisor here. This is a complex situation. The Department of Education is likely going to appeal this ruling immediately, but meanwhile, they have to pause SAVE enrollment. If you were already enrolled in SAVE before July 18, there's a chance your plan status won't change, but that's not guaranteed. If you were planning to enroll but hadn't yet, you'll need to consider PAYE or REPAYE as alternatives for now. The difference is PAYE caps at 10% of discretionary income while REPAYE is 10% but with different calculation methods for discretionary income.
0 coins
CosmicVoyager
•Thanks for the explanation. So basically even if I was planning to use SAVE, I now need to look at the old plans? This is going to increase my payments by hundreds each month! Do you know how long the appeal process might take?
0 coins
Freya Nielsen
•Unfortunately appeals can take months or even longer. Your best immediate option is to look at PAYE if you qualify (need to have received your first loans after Oct 1, 2007 and have no loans prior to Oct 1, 2011). If not, then REPAYE is your option. You can use the loan simulator on studentaid.gov to compare what your payments would be under each plan.
0 coins
Omar Mahmoud
It's completely ridiculous how borrowers are being treated as political footballs. The court's stay means the Department cannot process new SAVE applications or recalculations while this is being fought out. If you're already enrolled in SAVE, they haven't clarified if you'll be kicked off or allowed to remain while the case proceeds. Either way, contact your loan servicer ASAP to understand your options - but be prepared for extremely long wait times as millions of borrowers will be calling.
0 coins
Chloe Harris
•i tried calling nelnet and was on hold for TWO HOURS before giving up lol. anyone get through to a human yet??
0 coins
Diego Vargas
I was able to get through to a MOHELA rep after trying for days. They said they don't have any official guidance yet on what to do with pending SAVE applications or existing enrollees. They're basically waiting for the Dept of Education to tell them what to do. The rep advised applying for PAYE or REPAYE now as a backup, which is what I did. So frustrating!
0 coins
NeonNinja
•How did you even get through?? I've been trying to reach MOHELA for THREE days with no luck. Just endless hold music and then disconnects. I'm about to lose my mind.
0 coins
Anastasia Popov
•Hey everyone, if you're struggling to get through to student loan servicers like MOHELA or Nelnet, I found this service called Claimyr that got me through to an agent in about 20 minutes instead of waiting for hours. It basically holds your place in line and calls you when an agent picks up. The video demo at https://youtu.be/TbC8dZQWYNQ shows how it works. Seriously saved my sanity when trying to figure out what was happening with my SAVE application after this court mess.
0 coins
Diego Vargas
•@profile7 I called at exactly 8:00am ET when they opened and still waited 45 minutes. Their system is completely overwhelmed.
0 coins
Sean Murphy
this is SUCH BS!!!! just another example of the system being rigged against us. we make plans based on what the government says we can do, and then they just change the rules whenever they want. my payment is going from $0/month to $211!!!! where am i supposed to find an extra $211 in my budget with no warning?????
0 coins
Omar Mahmoud
•You may qualify for a temporary hardship forbearance if the payment increase causes financial difficulty. Just be aware that interest will continue to accrue during forbearance, so it should be a last resort option.
0 coins
Chloe Harris
has anyone heard if this affects PSLF too? i'm 7 years into my 10 years of payments and now im panicking that they'll change those rules too
0 coins
Freya Nielsen
•This court ruling specifically targets the SAVE plan, not PSLF. Your progress toward PSLF should be unaffected. However, if you were on the SAVE plan making qualifying payments toward PSLF, you may need to switch to a different income-driven repayment plan to continue making qualifying payments.
0 coins
NeonNinja
The timing of this is absolutely horrendous. With payments already resumed after the COVID pause ended, and now this change right before the school year starts... I'm supposed to be helping my daughter with college expenses and now I have to find an extra $150/month for my own loans. Has anyone had luck getting their servicer to approve a temporary payment reduction?
0 coins
CosmicVoyager
•I haven't heard of any temporary reductions, but would love to know if that's an option. It feels like they designed this to cause maximum chaos for borrowers.
0 coins
Anastasia Popov
After digging through some news articles, it sounds like the legal challenge is specifically about how SAVE calculates discretionary income and the undergraduate-only subsidy. Since the court issued a stay rather than a permanent injunction, there's actually a decent chance this gets resolved before too long. In the meantime, I'd recommend everyone: 1) Apply for a different IDR plan as backup, 2) Document all communications with your servicer, and 3) Keep checking studentaid.gov for updates.
0 coins
CosmicVoyager
•Thanks for this info. I'm going to apply for PAYE today as a backup. This whole situation is just so stressful.
0 coins
Aaron Boston
I'm in a similar boat and just wanted to share what I learned from calling my servicer (FedLoan) yesterday. They confirmed that if you had a pending SAVE application before July 18, it's essentially frozen - they can't process it but they also can't throw it away. The rep suggested I could either wait to see if the court decision gets overturned, or withdraw my SAVE application and apply for PAYE instead. She also mentioned that if the ruling gets appealed successfully, any payments made under a different IDR plan during the suspension period should still count toward forgiveness timelines. Still a mess, but at least there's some clarity on the process.
0 coins