< Back to FAFSA

Amina Diallo

Private student loans after FAFSA - which companies are trustworthy for covering the gap?

After doing all the financial aid stuff, I still have a $7,800 gap in my college costs that FAFSA, merit scholarships, and the federal loans don't cover. I'm getting bombarded with emails from private loan companies - Sallie Mae, College Ave, Discover, and some I've never heard of. How do I know which ones aren't trying to scam me with hidden fees or crazy interest rates? Has anyone had good/bad experiences with any specific lenders? Also, should I take out loans for just one semester at a time or the whole academic year? The financial aid office wasn't very helpful when I asked. Thanks in advance for any advice!

GamerGirl99

•

went wth Sallie Mae last year to cover my gap and REGRET IT!!!! their interest rate jumped after 6 months and customer service is TERRIBLE when i tried to ask why. Just got an automated message saying 'thats in your terms' but nobody would explain which term exactly changed

0 coins

Amina Diallo

•

Ugh that's exactly what I'm afraid of... how much did your rate jump? Did you find a better option after?

0 coins

I've had to use private loans for three years now after exhausting my federal options. The key factors to compare are: 1. Interest rates (fixed vs. variable) 2. Origination fees 3. Repayment options 4. Deferment options while in school 5. Co-signer release terms I've used Earnest for two years and have been satisfied with their transparency. College Ave was decent too. I'd recommend getting quotes from 3-4 lenders and comparing their terms side by side. The differences can add thousands to your total repayment. As for timing, I always borrow for the full academic year rather than semester by semester. It simplifies the paperwork and usually gives you slightly better terms since you're borrowing a larger amount at once.

0 coins

Amina Diallo

•

Thank you so much for the detailed breakdown! I hadn't even thought about co-signer release terms. Did you need a co-signer for your loans? My parents have OK credit but not amazing.

0 coins

My daughter had good experience with Discover student loans. No origination fees and they gave her a 1% cashback for good grades. Make sure whoever is co-signing has good credit because that REALLY affects your interest rate!

0 coins

Amina Diallo

•

That cashback for good grades sounds nice! I maintain a 3.7 GPA so hopefully that would help. Thanks for the tip about co-signer credit too.

0 coins

Malik Jenkins

•

Have you checked with your school's financial aid office about payment plans? Sometimes you can spread the gap payments throughout the semester instead of taking a loan. Also, always borrow for the whole year at once - it's one credit check instead of multiple hits to your credit score. If you must go with private loans, I'd suggest avoiding variable rate loans right now since interest rates are volatile. And watch out for lenders who advertise low rates but then add origination fees that basically offset any savings. Lastly, have you maxed out your Parent PLUS loan eligibility? That's often a better option than private loans if your parents are willing.

0 coins

Amina Diallo

•

Thanks for these suggestions! I did ask about payment plans but with my gap being almost $8k, the monthly payments would be too high for me to handle with my part-time job. And my parents got denied for the Parent PLUS loan due to some old medical collections on their credit report. :

0 coins

i got a sallie mae loan last fall and its been fine for me. interest rate is high but thats just how it is now i think. they gave me $500 for referring my roommate too lol

0 coins

Amina Diallo

•

Wait they have referral bonuses? That's interesting. What interest rate did you end up with if you don't mind me asking?

0 coins

Eduardo Silva

•

I had to deal with this same situation last year!! So frustrating that even after filling out FAFSA and getting federal loans there's still a huge gap. I ended up going with SoFi because my brother had used them before, but I'm kinda regretting it now because they're not great with customer service when things go wrong. One thing I wish I knew before - apply to a bunch of places within a 14-day window and it only counts as ONE hard inquiry on your credit instead of multiple!! The financial aid office never told me this and I spread out my applications which totally tanked my score.

0 coins

Amina Diallo

•

That's a super helpful tip about the 14-day window for applications! I had no idea, thank you! Sorry to hear SoFi didn't work out great for you.

0 coins

Leila Haddad

•

Have you tried calling Federal Student Aid to see if there are any additional grant programs you might qualify for? Sometimes there are state-specific or program-specific grants that don't automatically show up when you complete FAFSA. I was in your same situation last year and found an additional $3,500 in grants just by asking the right questions. I spent DAYS trying to get through on their phone lines though. Eventually I used this service called Claimyr (claimyr.com) that got me past the wait times and connected to an actual human at FSA who was super helpful. They have a video showing how it works: https://youtu.be/TbC8dZQWYNQ Definitely worth trying before taking on private loans.

0 coins

Amina Diallo

•

I hadn't thought about calling to ask about additional grants! That would be amazing if I could find even a couple thousand more. I'll check out that Claimyr service too - the FSA phone lines are impossible to get through normally.

0 coins

Emma Johnson

•

Whatever you do, GET EVERYTHING IN WRITING and read ALL the fine print!!! My brother got completely screwed over by Citizens Bank - they promised him one rate on the phone but the actual loan documents had a much higher variable rate buried in page 18 of the terms. Also be super careful about "forbearance" options - some private lenders will let you postpone payments if you have financial hardship but STILL CHARGE INTEREST that gets added to your principal. So you end up owing way more in the long run.

0 coins

Amina Diallo

•

That's terrifying about your brother's experience. I'll definitely read every single page of any agreement. Did he challenge them on the rate discrepancy?

0 coins

GamerGirl99

•

Oh and to answer your other question - DEFINITELY do the whole year at once! Each loan application is another hard inquiry on your credit report, plus most lenders have minimum loan amounts (like $1000 or $1500) so you might end up having to borrow more than you need if you go semester by semester.

0 coins

Amina Diallo

•

Thanks for confirming! Seems like annual is definitely the way to go based on everyone's feedback.

0 coins

Malik Jenkins

•

After getting input from several people here, I'd suggest you make a spreadsheet to compare your options. Here's what to include for each lender: - Interest rate (noting if fixed or variable) - Any rate discounts for autopay or good grades - Origination fees - Repayment terms (years) - Monthly payment amount - TOTAL amount paid over life of loan - Deferment/forbearance options - Co-signer release timeline - Customer service ratings (check Consumer Affairs website) When I did this comparison, the differences between lenders added up to over $4,000 in total repayment costs for a $10,000 loan. So it's definitely worth your time to research thoroughly.

0 coins

Amina Diallo

•

This is such a smart approach - I'll definitely create a spreadsheet with all these factors. Thank you so much for the detailed breakdown of what to compare!

0 coins

FAFSA AI

Expert Assistant
Secure

Powered by Claimyr AI

T
I
+
20,087 users helped today