< Back to FAFSA

Skylar Neal

Running out of time to find private student loans with best rates - need recommendations ASAP

I'm in a serious time crunch trying to figure out private student loans. FAFSA + school aid is covering about 60% of my costs, but I need to find private loans for the remaining $18,000 before the semester starts in 3 weeks. I've heard horror stories about predatory lenders and insane interest rates, but I don't know where to look for reputable options. Is there a centralized website or resource that compares private student loan providers, interest rates, and repayment terms? My credit score is decent (720) but my situation is complicated because my parents aren't cosigning. Any advice from people who've navigated private loans successfully? The financial aid office at my school basically just handed me a pamphlet with 2-3 random lenders and said "good luck." Feeling overwhelmed!

sallie mae and discover r the most common ones. i got mine thru sallie mae but honestly wish i had shopped around more cuz the interest is killing me now

0 coins

Thanks for the response! Did you have a cosigner with Sallie Mae? And if you don't mind sharing, what kind of interest rate did they give you?

0 coins

Quick advice from someone who's helped many students navigate this: you want to compare at least 5-7 lenders before making a decision. Look at Credible.com or SimpleTuition - they're comparison sites that let you see multiple loan options at once. With your 720 score and no cosigner, expect rates around 7-9% variable or 8.5-11% fixed right now. Key things to compare beyond just the interest rate: - Origination fees (some have none, others charge 1-3%) - Repayment flexibility during school (interest-only? deferred?) - Hardship programs if you struggle after graduation - Any loan forgiveness if something happens to you Bigger providers include SoFi, Ascent, College Ave, Discover, Earnest, and Sallie Mae. Some credit unions have excellent rates too if you're eligible for membership.

0 coins

This is INCREDIBLY helpful, thank you! I had no idea about those comparison sites. Do you know if these rates are typically higher for graduate students vs undergrad? I should have mentioned I'm starting a master's program.

0 coins

IMO don't even waste your time with private loans!!!! Can you defer a semester and work full time to save up? Or do community college first for gen eds? The FAFSA system is already frustrating enough but private loans are a NIGHTMARE. My brother has been paying his for 6 years and the balance has barely moved. AVOID AT ALL COSTS!!!!

0 coins

I appreciate the concern, but deferring isn't an option for me. This is for a specialized master's program that only starts once a year, and I've already put down non-refundable deposits. Community college isn't applicable for grad school unfortunately.

0 coins

have u checked ur schools financial aid portal? mine had a list of preferred lenders that supposedly vetted for better student terms. idk if it was actually true but it gave me somewhere to start at least

0 coins

This is good advice. Most schools maintain a "preferred lender list" that they've verified meet certain standards. However, always compare these against other options - sometimes the school has arrangements with these lenders that may not always translate to the best rates for you specifically.

0 coins

I was in almost the exact same situation last year - needed $22K beyond FAFSA and institutional aid, decent credit score but no cosigner. Here's what worked for me: 1. Applied through Credible to compare 8 different lenders at once (took about 20 mins) 2. Got pre-qualified with College Ave, Earnest, and Ascent 3. Used those offers to negotiate with my credit union, who ended up giving me the best rate (7.1% fixed) My advice: the no-cosigner situation WILL limit your options, but it's definitely doable with your credit score. Ascent and College Ave specifically have good independent student options. Also, call the financial aid office again and specifically ask if they have a dedicated loan advisor - sometimes they're different from the general counselors and know much more about private loan options.

0 coins

This is super encouraging to hear! I didn't even think about negotiating with lenders using other offers. I do belong to a credit union so I'll definitely check with them too. Did you find any significant differences in loan terms beyond just the interest rates?

0 coins

I spent DAYS trying to get through to someone at Federal Student Aid to see if I could increase my unsubsidized loan amount before resorting to private loans. Kept getting disconnected or wait times over 2 hours. Finally used this service called Claimyr (claimyr.com) that got me connected to an agent within 20 minutes. The agent explained I could actually appeal for additional unsubsidized loans since I'm independent, which reduced how much private funding I needed. Saved me thousands in interest! They have a video showing how it works: https://youtu.be/TbC8dZQWYNQ

0 coins

does that service actually work? i tried calling fafsa like 5 times last month and gave up

0 coins

On GOD the private loan system is PREDATORY!!! I got a Sallie Mae loan with my mom cosigning 4 years ago, and now I'm paying $780/mo with HALF going to interest. My friend got a similar amount but through a credit union and pays like $580. DO YOUR RESEARCH AND COMPARE EVERYTHING!!

0 coins

That's a huge difference in payments! This is exactly why I'm trying to research carefully. Did your friend need a cosigner for the credit union loan?

0 coins

One more thing I forgot to mention in my previous comment - make sure you understand the difference between fixed and variable rates. Variable might look tempting because they're lower initially, but they can (and usually do) increase over time. With the current economy, I'd strongly recommend fixed rate loans even if the initial rate is a bit higher. Provides peace of mind knowing exactly what you'll pay each month for the entire loan term.

0 coins

That's a really good point. I think I'd definitely prefer the predictability of fixed rates, especially since I'll be on a tight budget during school. Did you make interest-only payments while in school or defer completely?

0 coins

To answer your graduate student question: Private loan rates are typically based on credit profile rather than degree type. However, as a graduate student, you qualify for higher Direct Unsubsidized Loan limits ($20,500/year vs $12,500 for undergrads). Have you confirmed you're maxing out your federal unsubsidized loans before turning to private? This should always be your first step as federal loans have better protections and potential forgiveness options. Also, some lenders actually offer specific graduate student loan products with slightly better terms, recognizing the higher earning potential. SoFi and Discover both have graduate-specific options worth investigating.

0 coins

Yes, I've already maxed out my unsubsidized loans at $20,500. My program costs about $65K per year with living expenses in a high-cost city, and I got about $15K in institutional aid. I'll definitely look into the graduate-specific products you mentioned!

0 coins

After I used Claimyr to reach someone at FSA, I learned about the Graduate PLUS loan option, which might be better than private loans. Have you considered that? It's federal, so you get income-driven repayment options and potential forgiveness. The interest rate is higher than Direct Unsubsidized loans but might be better than private options, especially without a cosigner.

0 coins

I actually did apply for Grad PLUS but got denied due to some credit issues from 2 years ago (late payments on a medical bill that went to collections briefly). That's why I'm having to look at private options unfortunately.

0 coins

Since you're committed to this path, at MINIMUM make sure any private loan you get has: 1. No prepayment penalties 2. Deferment options if you lose your job 3. Some kind of hardship program 4. Death/disability discharge I've heard horror stories of people getting sick, being unable to work, and watching their loan balance balloon with no recourse. At least with federal loans you have income-based options.

0 coins

This is excellent advice. I'd add that some lenders offer a 0.25-0.50% interest rate reduction if you set up autopay, which is definitely worth doing. And some give graduation rewards (small percentage of principal reduction) if you graduate on time with good grades.

0 coins

when ur comparing loans make sure ur looking at the APR not just the interest rate. my sallie mae loan said 9.5% interest but the APR was actually like 11% cuz of all the fees they tacked on. didn't realize till after i signed :/

0 coins

That's a really important distinction - thanks for pointing that out! I'll make sure to look at the APR and read all the fine print.

0 coins

I just went through this exact process 6 months ago and here's what I wish someone had told me upfront: create a spreadsheet to track ALL the details from each lender. Include columns for interest rate, APR, origination fees, monthly payment estimates, deferment options, and any special benefits. Also, don't just apply to one lender at a time - most let you get rate quotes with soft credit pulls that won't hurt your score. I applied to 6 different lenders in one week and was shocked at the range of offers I got (from 6.8% to 12.4% for the same loan amount). One thing that really helped me was calling each lender's customer service line before applying to ask specific questions about their hardship programs and repayment flexibility. The quality of their answers told me a lot about how they'd treat me as a borrower. Given your timeline, I'd start with Credible today to get multiple quotes at once, then dive deeper into the 3-4 best options. With 3 weeks left, you have enough time to be thorough but not enough to procrastinate!

0 coins

FAFSA AI

Expert Assistant
Secure

Powered by Claimyr AI

T
I
+
20,087 users helped today