< Back to FAFSA

Dominic Green

Can anyone share legit student loan companies for FAFSA refund shortfalls?

Hey everyone, I just got my financial aid package for next year and there's a $8,750 gap between my FAFSA award and what I actually need (tuition went up AGAIN). I know I need a student loan to cover the difference but I'm worried about getting scammed. I've heard horror stories about predatory lenders targeting students after FAFSA results come out. Can anyone recommend legitimate student loan companies that work well with federal aid packages? My parents can't cosign so I need options that work for independent students. The financial aid office just gave me a generic pamphlet with like 20 companies listed and no real guidance. I've got a decent credit score (689) if that matters. Just don't want to get trapped with insane interest rates or hidden fees when I'm already stressed about my SAI calculation being way off. Thanks in advance!

Hannah Flores

•

whatever u do STAY AWAY from SuperiorLending!! they said low rates then jacked mine to 13.4% after i signed!!

0 coins

Dominic Green

•

Whoa that's terrible! Thanks for the warning. Did you ever find a better company to work with?

0 coins

Hannah Flores

•

i ended up with earnest. not perfect but WAY better tbh

0 coins

Before you look at private loans, have you exhausted all your federal options? There's a difference between your initial FAFSA award and your maximum federal loan eligibility. As an independent student, you should be eligible for up to $12,500 in Direct Unsubsidized Loans annually, which might cover your gap without needing private loans. If you've already maxed those out, some reputable private lenders that work well with federal aid packages include: - Earnest (good for independent students without cosigners) - SoFi (competitive rates, especially if your credit improves) - Ascent (offers non-cosigned loans based on future income potential) - Discover Student Loans (no fees) I strongly recommend reaching back out to your financial aid office and specifically asking about increasing your federal loans first. Many students don't realize they can accept more than what's initially offered in their award letter.

0 coins

Dominic Green

•

Thank you for this detailed response! I actually didn't know I could request more federal loans - my award letter only showed $5,500 in Direct Unsubsidized. I'll definitely contact financial aid tomorrow about increasing that amount before looking at private options. If I can get the full $12,500 that would solve everything!

0 coins

have u tried scholly? its not a loan but they helped my roomate find like $3000 in random scholarships nobody applies for

0 coins

Dominic Green

•

No, I haven't heard of Scholly! That sounds like a great option to look into before taking out loans. Thanks for the tip!

0 coins

Grace Lee

•

FAFSA is such BS these days!! My SAI calculation said my family could afford $22,000 a year but we can barely pay our mortgage! The whole system is designed to force students into debt. My sister got stuck with Sallie Mae and they've been NIGHTMARE to deal with - hidden fees, terrible customer service, random interest rate increases. I'm still paying off $67,000 in loans and I graduated 4 years ago. If you HAVE to get a private loan, at least avoid them. College Ave was slightly better for me but honestly they're all just circling vultures waiting for desperate students.

0 coins

Mia Roberts

•

While I understand your frustration with the SAI calculation, it's important to note that the system recently changed from EFC to SAI for the 2025-2026 academic year, which uses different formulas. The calculation is frustrating, but there are legitimate options that aren't predatory. OP, if you need to contact Federal Student Aid directly to discuss your SAI calculation or loan options, I'd recommend using Claimyr (claimyr.com) to get through to an agent quickly. I was on hold for hours trying to resolve my SAI appeal until I found their service. They helped me get through to a real person at FSA in about 15 minutes. You can see how it works here: https://youtu.be/TbC8dZQWYNQ

0 coins

Grace Lee

•

Sorry for the rant. You're right that the SAI system is different now. I'm just still bitter about my own experience. And yeah, talking to an actual human at FSA makes a huge difference - they can sometimes adjust things that the automated system misses.

0 coins

The Boss

•

my cousin works in financial aid and she always says to do this when you have a gap: 1) ask financial aid office about additional institutional grants (some schools have emergency funds they don't advertise) 2) max out subsidized loans before unsubsidized 3) look for departmental scholarships in your major 4) THEN look at private loans just my 2 cents but hope it helps lol

0 coins

Dominic Green

•

This is super helpful advice! I didn't even think about checking with my department for major-specific scholarships. I'm in engineering so maybe they have something. Will definitely follow this order before pursuing private loans.

0 coins

I was in a similar situation last year with about $7,000 gap after my FAFSA package. I'd recommend applying to multiple lenders simultaneously to compare offers. Most have a pre-qualification process that doesn't affect your credit score. When I did this, I got offers ranging from 6.5% to 12.8% for the same loan amount! Also, don't overlook credit unions - my local one actually had better rates than most of the big online lenders everyone recommends. And definitely call your financial aid office to ask about professional judgment reviews if you have any special circumstances that weren't captured in your FAFSA (job loss, medical expenses, etc.). They can sometimes adjust your SAI which could increase your federal aid. Good luck! The system is complicated but you've got this.

0 coins

Dominic Green

•

Thank you! I hadn't thought about credit unions at all. And that's a huge difference in interest rates - definitely going to pre-qualify with multiple places before deciding. Really appreciate the encouragement!

0 coins

Has anyone tried Parent PLUS Loans? My mom got one for me

0 coins

Parent PLUS loans are only available if you're a dependent student, and the OP mentioned they're an independent student without the option for parents to cosign. Also, as the name suggests, PLUS loans are taken out by the parent, not the student - they're in the parent's name and are the parent's legal responsibility to repay.

0 coins

Dominic Green

•

UPDATE: I just wanted to thank everyone for the amazing advice! I followed the suggestions here and: 1. Called my financial aid office and discovered I could access an additional $5,000 in federal Direct Unsubsidized loans I didn't know about 2. Found a $2,000 scholarship through my engineering department that still had open applications 3. Used Claimyr to reach someone at FSA who helped explain why my SAI was calculated incorrectly - turns out there was a reporting error on my FAFSA that they're helping me fix Between these three things, I should be able to cover almost the entire gap without private loans! I might need a small one for the remaining $1,750, but that's WAY better than the $8,750 I was looking at before. This forum is seriously a lifesaver. Thank you all!

0 coins

FAFSA AI

Expert Assistant
Secure

Powered by Claimyr AI

T
I
+
20,087 users helped today