FAFSA student loan doubled despite 12 years of payments - Mohela won't answer my calls
I've been making payments on my student loans for 12 YEARS now. Instead of decreasing, my loan has DOUBLED in size! I'm absolutely at my breaking point. My loans have been transferred between servicers multiple times without my consent, and it seems like my payment history gets partially erased with each transfer. Now Mohela has my loans and the interest rate is showing 8.5% which is WAY higher than the fixed rate I originally signed for. I've tried calling Mohela dozens of times - either no answer or I get some new trainee who transfers me to a supervisor (starting my hold time all over again). I've wasted entire days on the phone. Does anyone have advice on how to actually get through to someone who can help? I feel like the system is designed to make us fail. At this point, I'm wondering if there's any way to get these loans discharged or at least get bankruptcy protection. I'm seriously running out of hope here.
29 comments


Amara Nnamani
This is unfortunately really common with federal loan servicing transfers. I went through something similar when my loans were transferred from Navient to Aidvantage. The interest rate issue is concerning though - if you have federal loans, they should maintain their original fixed interest rate regardless of servicer transfers. Do you have your original loan documents? That's crucial to proving what your real rate should be. Also, request your full payment history from FSA directly - they should have records even if the servicers 'lost' them during transfers.
0 coins
GalacticGuru
•Thank you for responding. Yeah I do have my original promissory note somewhere in storage. I'll dig it out this weekend. How do I request my payment history from FSA directly? Their website is so confusing and every link seems to just send me back to Mohela.
0 coins
Giovanni Mancini
omg im going thru the EXACT same thing!!! my loans got transferred 3 times and now they're saying i missed 4 payments from 2019 that i KNOW i made. this whole system is a scam to keep us paying forever. btw have u tried the PSLF program? my cousin got her loans forgiven after 10 yrs of payments but she had to work for the government
0 coins
GalacticGuru
•I have all my bank statements showing the payments! But Mohela says they need documentation from the previous servicer, not from me. It's maddening. I don't qualify for PSLF unfortunately - I work in the private sector.
0 coins
Fatima Al-Suwaidi
I had similar issues with Mohela. After weeks of trying to call, I finally found a way to get through to them. I used a service called Claimyr (claimyr.com) that holds your place in the phone queue and calls you when a rep picks up. Saved me hours of waiting. They have a video showing how it works here: https://youtu.be/TbC8dZQWYNQ. After finally getting through, I discovered they had applied my payments to the wrong loan group which explained why my balance wasn't decreasing as expected. Make sure you get everything documented in writing once you reach them.
0 coins
GalacticGuru
•Thank you!! I'll check out that service. Honestly at this point I'd try anything to actually speak with someone who can help. Did they fix your issue once you finally got through?
0 coins
Fatima Al-Suwaidi
•Yes, but it took multiple calls and I had to be extremely persistent. Make sure you get a case number for each call and take detailed notes including the name of who you spoke with. I also filed a complaint with the CFPB which seemed to accelerate their response.
0 coins
Dylan Cooper
Financial aid advisor here. Your situation sounds like it might have several compounding issues. First, check your SAI (Student Aid Index, formerly EFC) on studentaid.gov - this gives you access to your complete federal loan history regardless of servicer. Second, if your interest rate genuinely increased from what you originally signed for, that's potentially illegal and you should file a formal complaint with the Consumer Financial Protection Bureau. Regarding the doubling of your loan despite payments, this suggests that you might have been on an income-driven plan where your payments weren't covering the accruing interest. This is called negative amortization and it's a significant problem in the student loan system. You might want to look into the SAVE plan (replacing REPAYE) which has better interest subsidies, or loan consolidation. Feel free to ask follow-up questions about any of these options.
0 coins
GalacticGuru
•Thank you for this detailed response. I checked my account on studentaid.gov but it still directs me to Mohela for detailed payment history. I'll definitely file a CFPB complaint about the interest rate. Regarding the negative amortization - yes, I was on IBR for a while when I was earning less, but even after increasing my payments to more than the minimum for the past 4 years, the balance keeps growing. It feels like they're applying payments differently than they should be.
0 coins
Dylan Cooper
•That's very concerning. When you do get through to Mohela, specifically request a payment audit. They should be able to provide a detailed breakdown of how each payment was applied (principal vs. interest) and also verify the correct interest rate. If they can't provide this, mention that you're filing a CFPB complaint - sometimes just saying this gets you transferred to a higher-level representative who has more authority to fix issues.
0 coins
Sofia Morales
the government WANTS us to die in debt!!!! this is all BY DESIGN, wake up! they sold our loans to wall street just like the 2008 mortgage crisis. did you know the dept of education makes BILLIONS off student loan interest??? this is why they make it impossible to get help or file bankruptcy. its modern debt slavery and we're all trapped
0 coins
GalacticGuru
•I hate to admit it but after 12 years of this nightmare, I'm starting to believe some of what you're saying. It definitely feels like the system is designed to keep us trapped.
0 coins
Dylan Cooper
•While there are legitimate criticisms of the student loan system, federal student loans aren't securitized and sold on Wall Street like mortgages were. The Department of Education does collect interest, but that money goes back into federal programs. The real issue is the complexity of the system and the poor servicing quality, which makes it extremely difficult for borrowers to navigate their repayment options.
0 coins
StarSailor
Have u tried going to ur congressperson's office? My sister had a similar issue with FedLoan & she contacted her representative's constituent services. They have staff who deal with federal agencies all the time & can sometimes cut through red tape faster than we can as individuals. Also did u check if ur eligible for the IDR waiver or account adjustment? They're counting some forbearance periods toward forgiveness now.
0 coins
GalacticGuru
•That's a great idea about contacting my representative - I hadn't thought of that. I'll look up their office contact info today. And no, I haven't checked about the IDR waiver - where would I find information about that?
0 coins
Dmitry Ivanov
I work in the financial aid office at a university, and this kind of situation happens more than you'd think. Here's what I recommend: 1. File a complaint with the FSA Ombudsman Group (studentaid.gov/feedback-center/) - they're specifically designed to mediate disputes between borrowers and loan servicers 2. Request an administrative forbearance while your issues are being investigated - this will temporarily pause payments without penalty 3. If your loans were indeed transferred without proper notification or your interest rate was changed improperly, request a full accounting of your loan history through both the current and previous servicers 4. Consider loan consolidation through studentaid.gov directly (not through a third party) - this could potentially lock in a new fixed interest rate that's the weighted average of your current loans The fact that your loan doubled despite 12 years of payments strongly suggests either capitalized interest from forbearances/deferments or potentially being on an income-driven plan with payments lower than the monthly interest accrual. Let me know which part you'd like more details on.
0 coins
GalacticGuru
•Thank you so much for these specific steps. I'll start with the Ombudsman Group today. Quick question about consolidation - would that reset the clock on any potential forgiveness options? I've heard conflicting information about this.
0 coins
Dmitry Ivanov
•Great question about consolidation. Under normal circumstances, consolidation would reset your forgiveness timeline. However, under the current IDR account adjustment (which is ongoing through 2024), they're giving credit for time spent in repayment prior to consolidation. So if you consolidate now, you shouldn't lose your progress toward forgiveness. This is a temporary policy though, so I'd recommend acting soon if you decide to consolidate.
0 coins
Giovanni Mancini
has anyone else noticed that the FAFSA website is down like ALL THE TIME?? i tried to access my account yesterday to check my loan details and got an error message. typical govt incompetence
0 coins
GalacticGuru
•Yes! I've tried logging in multiple times this week and kept getting error messages. It's like they make every part of this process as difficult as possible.
0 coins
Amara Nnamani
After reading through this thread, I think you might want to look into the Fresh Start program if you've had any periods of default. Also, I recently discovered that if you request your records through a formal FOIA request to the Department of Education, they have to provide your complete loan history regardless of servicer transfers. It sounds extreme, but sometimes these formal legal approaches are the only way to get accurate information when servicers are giving you the runaround.
0 coins
GalacticGuru
•I hadn't defaulted yet, thankfully, but I'm definitely getting closer to that point with how unmanageable this has become. The FOIA request is an interesting idea - I never would have thought of that. Do you know how long that process typically takes?
0 coins
Amara Nnamani
•FOIA requests can take anywhere from a few weeks to several months, unfortunately. But the benefit is that you get official records directly from ED rather than filtered through a servicer. While you're waiting, definitely pursue the Ombudsman route that others suggested, as that's likely to get faster results for your immediate issues.
0 coins
Dylan Cooper
One thing I haven't seen mentioned yet - have you looked into whether you qualify for any discharge programs based on your school or career? If you attended a school that has since been found to have engaged in misleading practices (like many for-profit colleges), you might be eligible for Borrower Defense to Repayment. Similarly, if you work in certain fields (teaching, healthcare in underserved areas, etc.), there are specific forgiveness programs beyond PSLF. The recent changes to income-driven repayment plans have also made forgiveness more accessible.
0 coins
GalacticGuru
•I went to a state university that's still operating, so I don't think Borrower Defense applies in my case. I don't work in any of the qualifying fields for specialized forgiveness either. I'm definitely going to look into the updated income-driven plans though - is SAVE the newest one that replaced REPAYE?
0 coins
Dylan Cooper
•Yes, SAVE (Saving on a Valuable Education) is the newest plan that replaced REPAYE. It has several significant improvements, including better interest subsidies (meaning your balance won't grow as much if your payment doesn't cover monthly interest) and potentially lower monthly payments. For undergraduate loans, it calculates your payment as 5% of discretionary income rather than 10%. It's worth exploring even if other IDR plans haven't worked well for you in the past.
0 coins
Christopher Morgan
I'm so sorry you're going through this nightmare. Reading through all these responses, it's clear you're not alone but that doesn't make it any less frustrating. Based on what everyone has shared, I'd suggest tackling this on multiple fronts simultaneously: 1) Use that Claimyr service to actually get through to Mohela, 2) File complaints with both the FSA Ombudsman and CFPB about the interest rate issue, and 3) Contact your congressional representative's office for help navigating the bureaucracy. The fact that your loan doubled despite 12 years of payments is absolutely unacceptable and suggests serious errors in how your account has been managed. Don't give up - you have more options than you realize, and there are people (like the financial aid advisors in this thread) who genuinely want to help you get this resolved.
0 coins
Sean O'Brien
•Thank you so much for summarizing all the great advice in this thread! It's really helpful to have a clear action plan. I'm feeling more hopeful after reading everyone's responses - it's good to know there are actual steps I can take and that others have successfully resolved similar issues. I'm going to start with the Claimyr service tomorrow morning and file the complaints this weekend. Really appreciate this community for having my back when I felt completely lost in the system.
0 coins
McKenzie Shade
I've been following this thread closely and wanted to add one more resource that might help. If you're still having trouble getting through to Mohela even with the queue services, try calling their "vulnerable borrower" line if you qualify (it's for borrowers experiencing financial hardship). The wait times are often shorter and the representatives tend to be more experienced with complex account issues. Also, when you do get through, immediately ask to speak with a "loan resolution specialist" rather than general customer service - they have more authority to investigate payment application errors and can put holds on your account while issues are being resolved. Document everything with dates, times, and rep names. Your situation sounds like it involves multiple systemic errors that should absolutely be fixable once you get the right person looking at your account.
0 coins