FAFSA loans with ridiculous interest - am I stuck with predatory lender?
I'm completely freaking out about my student loan situation. I have a federal loan for $23,750 originally, but the interest is KILLING me. My monthly payment is $389.45, but only about $55 goes toward principal each month! I just got my statement and it shows I've paid almost $9,500 total, but barely $3,600 went to principal. The rest? ALL INTEREST. The worst part? My servicer estimates I'll pay over $102,000 in interest over the life of this loan. HOW IS THIS LEGAL?? I just found out that my loan servicer was actually shut down by the Department of Education for misleading borrowers about 4 months after my loan was disbursed. But I'm still stuck with this predatory loan structure apparently. Has anyone successfully escaped this kind of situation? Can I get this loan discharged or transferred to a better servicer with reasonable interest? The accrued interest is already up to $41,345.76 according to my latest statement. I feel sick every time I make a payment knowing almost nothing goes to principal.
18 comments


Javier Gomez
First, we need to clarify what type of loan you actually have. Is this a Direct Federal loan, a FFEL loan, or a private loan? The fact that your servicer was shut down by the Dept of Education suggests it might be a federal loan, but those interest numbers seem really high for federal loans. If it is federal, you should be eligible to switch servicers. Go to studentaid.gov and check your loan details. You can also apply for income-driven repayment plans that might help reduce your monthly payment. For servicers that were shut down for predatory practices, there are sometimes discharge options available, but it depends on the specific circumstances.
0 coins
NebulaNinja
•Thanks for responding! It's definitely a federal loan through FAFSA - that's how I got it for school. The loan statement has the Federal Student Aid logo and everything. I'll check studentaid.gov today. I honestly didn't know I could switch servicers!
0 coins
Emma Wilson
OMG I think we have the same servicer!!! Mine was Granite State Management or something?? My interest is crazy too but not as bad as yours. From what I've heard we're all getting transferred to new servicers automatically but idk when that's happening. Did you get any emails about that?
0 coins
NebulaNinja
•Yes! That's them! I did get some email about a transfer but I thought it was a scam so I deleted it. 🤦♀️ Do you know who we're being transferred to? I should probably dig through my spam folder...
0 coins
Malik Thomas
I work with financial aid applications, and this doesn't sound like a standard federal student loan. The interest rate and payment structure you're describing is more consistent with a private loan or possibly a Parent PLUS loan with an extended term. Federal Direct loans have fixed interest rates that haven't exceeded 7.08% in the last decade. With the original loan amount and payment figures you provided, your effective interest rate appears to be much higher. Here's what you should do: 1. Log into studentaid.gov to see your actual federal loan portfolio 2. Verify if this loan appears there 3. If it does, apply for an income-driven repayment plan immediately 4. If it doesn't show up, you may have a private loan, which has fewer protections The servicer being shut down is relevant - if it was Navient, PHEAA, or Granite State, there may be specific remedies available.
0 coins
NebulaNinja
•Thank you for this detailed response. I logged into studentaid.gov and found my loan - it is a federal loan, but it's a Parent PLUS loan that was transferred to me. The interest rate is 7.9% but there are also a bunch of capitalized interest charges from deferment periods I didn't know about. That explains the insane interest accumulation. I'm looking at income-driven repayment options now.
0 coins
Isabella Oliveira
same thing happened to my cousin, she had to file bankruptcy cuz of it. the whole system is rigged!! these lenders prey on kids who dont know any better and then ur stuck forever. good luck!!
0 coins
Ravi Kapoor
•Actually, that's incorrect. Federal student loans typically cannot be discharged through bankruptcy except in very rare cases of extreme hardship. Please be careful about spreading misinformation that could lead people to make serious financial mistakes.
0 coins
Freya Larsen
This doesn't sound right at all. My federal loans have much lower interest. Are you sure this is a FAFSA loan and not a private loan? Check your original paperwork. Also, have you been in contact with them about this? If your servicer was shut down for being predatory, you might qualify for Borrower Defense to Repayment.
0 coins
NebulaNinja
•I thought all student loans were FAFSA loans! I'm learning so much from these responses. I've discovered it's a Parent PLUS loan that was transferred to me (my mom took it out but I agreed to pay it). Apparently those have higher interest rates. I'm going to look into this Borrower Defense to Repayment option though!
0 coins
GalacticGladiator
Hey there, I was in a similar situation last year with my FAFSA loan through a problematic servicer. I needed to speak directly with Federal Student Aid representatives but kept hitting the endless hold times and getting disconnected after waiting for hours. I discovered a service called Claimyr that helped me get through to an actual FSA agent without the insane wait. They basically hold your place in line and call you when an agent is available. I was skeptical at first, but it worked really well - check out their demo video here: https://youtu.be/TbC8dZQWYNQ or their website at claimyr.com. The agent I finally spoke with helped me understand my loan structure and transferred me to a new servicer. They also helped me apply for an income-driven repayment plan that dramatically reduced my payments. Definitely worth getting a human on the phone who can actually access your account and explain what's happening.
0 coins
NebulaNinja
•Thank you so much! I've been trying to get through to someone for weeks and keep getting disconnected after waiting for 45+ minutes. I'll check this out - I really need to talk to someone who can explain what's happening with my specific loan. Thanks for the recommendation!
0 coins
Ravi Kapoor
Financial aid professional here. Based on your numbers and discovering it's a Parent PLUS loan, several things are happening: 1. Parent PLUS loans have higher interest rates than Direct Student loans (7-8.5% range depending on disbursement year) 2. It sounds like your loan experienced negative amortization - where your previous payments weren't covering all interest, causing it to capitalize 3. Servicer transfers don't change your loan terms, unfortunately For solutions: - Apply for an Income-Contingent Repayment plan (the only IDR available for Parent PLUS loans) - Consider consolidation to potentially access better repayment options - Look into Public Service Loan Forgiveness if you work in qualifying employment - Check if your specific servicer is part of any settlement agreements or discharge programs The closure of a predatory servicer doesn't automatically qualify you for discharge, but you may be eligible for certain benefits depending on specific circumstances.
0 coins
NebulaNinja
•Thank you for this detailed explanation! I had no idea Parent PLUS loans were so different from regular student loans. I'm definitely going to look into the Income-Contingent Repayment plan. I don't work in public service so that option is out. Would consolidation reset my payment timeline? I've already been paying for 3 years.
0 coins
Ravi Kapoor
•Consolidation would indeed reset your payment timeline and potentially extend the total repayment period. You'd essentially be starting fresh with a new loan. However, if you consolidate and then enter an ICR plan, any payments made after consolidation would count toward the 25-year forgiveness timeline for that plan. Also important: make sure any payments you've already made are properly counted. With servicer transfers, payment histories can sometimes get lost. Keep your own records of all payments made.
0 coins
Omar Zaki
wait so lemme get this straight, the govt shut down your lender for being predatory...but still makes u pay the predatory loan????? wtf kind of system is this??????
0 coins
Javier Gomez
•It's actually more nuanced than that. When the Department of Education terminates a servicer's contract, they're not necessarily declaring all loans they serviced as predatory. They're often citing contract violations, poor customer service, or mismanagement. The loans themselves are still valid federal obligations, but they get transferred to a different servicer who hopefully will manage them properly. That said, there are specific cases where loan discharge might be available - like the Borrower Defense to Repayment program if your school misled you, or servicer-specific settlement programs like we've seen with Navient.
0 coins
NebulaNinja
UPDATE: Thanks everyone for your helpful responses! I've learned so much. I was able to confirm this is indeed a Parent PLUS loan at 7.9% interest that my mom took out for me, which explains the high interest rate. I've applied for an Income-Contingent Repayment plan and am also looking into consolidation options. I was also able to get through to someone at FSA (thanks for the Claimyr tip, it actually worked!) and they explained that several periods of deferment had caused interest capitalization, which is why the interest growth seems so extreme. They're sending me information about the specific borrower protections available in my situation. I feel much better now that I understand what's going on, even though the situation still isn't great. I'll update again once I hear back about the ICR application!
0 coins