FAFSA student loan interest rate exploding - default risk with no relief options?
I just checked my FAFSA loan status and I'm absolutely freaking out. My original $42,500 in federal loans from 2018 has somehow ballooned to over $61,300 with these insane interest rates! I've been making the minimum payments for 2 years but it feels like I'm just throwing money into a black hole. My SAI score qualified me for some grants but obviously not enough. I just got laid off last month and my forbearance options are already used up from the pandemic. My servicer is telling me I don't qualify for income-based repayment because of some paperwork issue with my tax returns? They're threatening that I'll default in 60 days without any options to stop it. This system is PREDATORY. Even credit cards have interest rate limits and bankruptcy options. My brother's medical debt has more consumer protections than my student loans! I tried consolidating to get a better rate but was denied. Has anyone successfully fought back against these insane policies? Or found ANY relief options that actually work? I'm about to have my wages garnished and my credit destroyed for trying to get an education.
18 comments


Hugh Intensity
welcome to the club... system is RIGGED against us. my original loan was 36K now its 52K and ive been paying for 5 years!! they dont even apply payments to principal until u pay all interest first so ur basically trapped forever. administration promised loan forgiveness then backed out. try calling FSA but good luck getting thru lol
0 coins
Sunny Wang
•Have you tried asking for an economic hardship deferment? My servicer acted like that wasn't even an option until I specifically asked about it by name. This whole thing is such a mess.
0 coins
Effie Alexander
I understand your frustration, but there are actually several options you might not be aware of. First, the paperwork issue with income-based repayment can be resolved - it sounds like you may have a mismatch between your reported income on the IDR application and your tax returns. This happens frequently. Second, you should immediately apply for an economic hardship deferment since you've been laid off. This is different from forbearance and won't count against your forbearance limits. You'll need to provide documentation of your unemployment benefits or job loss. Third, look into loan rehabilitation if you do go into default. It's a one-time opportunity to restore your loans to good standing through a series of 9 on-time payments based on your income. The system isn't perfect, but there are more protections than most people realize.
0 coins
Sunny Wang
•Thank you for these suggestions! I'll definitely ask about the economic hardship deferment. Do you know if I need specific forms for that or can I just call and request it? My servicer seems to "forget" to mention certain options unless I ask very specifically.
0 coins
Melissa Lin
OMG I'm going through almost the exact same thing!!! My interest capitalized during the pandemic and added like $9k to my principal even though I thought payments were paused?? Make it make sense! I've literally been crying about this for weeks. Has anyone figured out how to get the IDR waiver to actually work? I applied 3 months ago and they keep saying my application is "in process" whatever that means.
0 coins
Effie Alexander
•The IDR waiver is separate from a regular IDR application. The waiver program has specific requirements and is taking longer to process because of the volume. Call FSA directly (not your servicer) and ask for the status of your SPECIFIC waiver application. Be sure to note the date you submitted it and through which channel (online portal, mail, etc). Your servicer often won't have visibility into the waiver processing status.
0 coins
Lydia Santiago
I went through something similar last year and finally got it resolved after months of fighting the system. What worked for me was using Claimyr (claimyr.com) to actually reach a real person at Federal Student Aid. I kept getting disconnected or put on 3+ hour holds until I found them. Their service let me skip the phone queue and got me connected to an FSA agent in about 15 minutes who was actually helpful. The agent discovered my servicer had been incorrectly calculating my IDR payments and fixed the issue on their end. They also helped me submit the correct hardship documentation. They have a video that shows how it works: https://youtu.be/TbC8dZQWYNQ After getting that sorted, my payment dropped from $780/month to $162/month based on my actual income. Don't give up - there are options but sometimes you need to reach the right person who actually knows the rules.
0 coins
Sunny Wang
•Thank you for this! I've spent literally HOURS on hold with FSA and either get disconnected or talk to someone who just reads from a script. I'll check this out because I'm desperate at this point. Did they help you get the right forms for economic hardship?
0 coins
Lydia Santiago
•Yes! The FSA agent I reached through Claimyr sent me the exact form I needed for economic hardship (it's called the Economic Hardship Deferment Request) and confirmed exactly what documentation I needed to attach. Made a huge difference talking to someone who actually knew the rules.
0 coins
Romeo Quest
yall need to stop whining and pay what you agreed to tbh. i paid off my loans by working two jobs and living with roommates for 5 years. nobody forced you to take out loans. these forgiveness programs are just making inflation worse for everyone. personal responsibility matters.
0 coins
Sunny Wang
•My loans were 5.8% when I signed, now effectively much higher with capitalized interest. Did you also deal with a once-in-a-century pandemic, record inflation, and a housing crisis simultaneously while paying yours? The rules have changed drastically since most of us signed. But thanks for the incredibly helpful "just work harder" advice.
0 coins
Melissa Lin
•Classic boomer mentality. My parents paid $600/semester for state university in the 80s. Same school now costs $14,000/semester. Wages haven't kept up AT ALL. But sure, it's exactly the same situation 🙄
0 coins
Val Rossi
Financial aid advisor here. There's a lot of confusion in this thread I want to clear up: 1. For immediate help with potential default: Call your servicer and request an Administrative Forbearance specifically while you resolve the IDR application issues. They must grant this while paperwork is being processed. 2. For the tax return issue: You can submit alternative documentation of income (recent pay stubs) instead of tax returns for IDR qualification if you're having issues with your tax documents. 3. For long-term solutions: The new SAVE plan (replacement for REPAYE) caps undergraduate loan payments at 5% of discretionary income instead of 10%. 4. If you're unemployed: Your IDR payment should be $0 during this period. 5. Interest capitalization rules have changed under the new regulations - interest should not be capitalizing except in specific circumstances now. I recommend filing a complaint with the FSA Ombudsman if your servicer is providing incorrect information or not processing your applications properly.
0 coins
Sunny Wang
•Thank you so much for this detailed information. I didn't know about Administrative Forbearance - my servicer definitely didn't mention that as an option. I'll call tomorrow and specifically request that while I sort out the IDR application. Do you know approximately how long the SAVE plan application takes to process? I applied 3 weeks ago and haven't heard anything.
0 coins
Val Rossi
•SAVE plan applications should take 2-4 weeks to process under normal circumstances, but there's currently a backlog due to high volume. While waiting, make sure your Administrative Forbearance is documented - get a confirmation email or letter. For the SAVE plan, call weekly for status updates and document who you spoke with each time.
0 coins
Eve Freeman
I had a similar nightmare with defaulted loans. What eventually worked for me: 1. Filed a CFPB complaint against my servicer (surprisingly effective) 2. Got into the Fresh Start program to get out of default 3. IMMEDIATELY applied for income-based repayment with my $0 income 4. Requested a recalculation when I found employment The system is absolutely broken, but there are pathways through it. Don't ignore it though - that makes everything worse. And DOCUMENT EVERYTHING - dates of calls, who you spoke with, what they told you. This saved me multiple times when they tried to claim I hadn't submitted paperwork.
0 coins
Sunny Wang
•Filing a CFPB complaint is a great idea - I hadn't thought of that. Did you need a lawyer or any special documentation to file the complaint? And how long did the Fresh Start process take from application to completion?
0 coins
Eve Freeman
•No lawyer needed for CFPB! Just go to consumerfinance.gov/complaint - super straightforward form. Fresh Start took about 45 days total, but the collections calls stopped within a week of my application being confirmed. Definitely worth doing ASAP.
0 coins