Bucknell not fully covering -1500 SAI - still $8500 gap after CSS Profile?

i went through this EXACT thing with Bucknell last year!! had a -1300 SAI and they still wanted us to pay like $7k after all aid. we appealed and got nowhere. ended up having to do parent plus loans anyway 😫

Former college financial aid counselor here. Many people don't realize that even with an excellent SAI score, private universities like Bucknell aren't obligated to meet 100% of demonstrated need. Each school has their own financial aid formula beyond just the FAFSA SAI calculation. I would recommend: 1. Request a formal financial aid appeal - specifically mention any circumstances not captured in your FAFSA/CSS Profile (medical expenses, caring for elderly relatives, recent job changes) 2. If you have better offers from similar-caliber schools, provide those documents during your appeal 3. Ask specifically about merit scholarships your student might qualify for that are separate from need-based aid 4. Inquire about work-study opportunities that could offset some costs Many schools hold back some discretionary funds for appeals, so it's always worth trying.

Just wanna say the whole college pricing system is RIGGED!!!! These fancy private schools advertise how generous they are but then still expect families with NEGATIVE SAIs to pay thousands. It's all a big scam to make you feel like you're getting a "discount" from their inflated sticker price. Meanwhile they're sitting on BILLION$ in endowments. 🤬

I successfully appealed our aid package at Bucknell two years ago and got an additional $3,500 per year. The key was providing detailed documentation of everything. Our SAI was around -900, so not quite as low as yours, but still negative. Make sure you: 1) Address it to a specific financial aid officer (call to get a name first) 2) Include ALL competing offers with official documentation 3) Be very explicit about the exact amount you need to make it work 4) Have your student write a personal letter explaining why Bucknell is their first choice Be prepared for lots of back and forth. We had to call the financial aid office almost daily for two weeks, which was incredibly frustrating. They kept putting us on hold for 30+ minutes or dropping our calls entirely.

Have you tried using Claimyr to reach someone at Federal Student Aid to discuss your SAI calculation? I was having a similar issue (negative SAI but still huge gaps at private schools) and couldn't get answers from anyone. I used their service at claimyr.com to get through to an actual FSA agent who verified my SAI was calculated correctly but also explained some nuances about how private schools interpret it. They have a video demo at https://youtu.be/TbC8dZQWYNQ that shows how it works. It bypasses the hold times completely. The agent I spoke with gave me specific language to use in my appeals.

my daughter ended up choosing a state school because of this exact issue. even with our -1200 SAI these private schools wanted us to pay $10k+ per year. its ridiculous!!!

One strategy that worked for us with a similar situation at another prestigious private college: request a meeting with both financial aid AND admissions together. Often admissions has separate merit scholarships they can offer if they really want your student. Also, sometimes schools have specific supplemental grants for students pursuing certain majors or activities. What is your daughter planning to study? There might be departmental funds available.

one more thing - for bucknell specifically, check if your daughter qualifies for the posse scholarship, mcguire scholars, or the arts merit scholarships. those can be stacked on top of need-based aid and might help close the gap!

Update on my earlier advice: If your appeal doesn't work out, consider asking Bucknell about their monthly payment plan option. Most families find breaking the $8,500 into 10 monthly payments of $850 more manageable than taking out additional loans. Also, some private scholarships allow applications even after you've started college, so you could potentially reduce costs for sophomore through senior years.

I'm in a very similar boat with my son and Bucknell! We have a -1800 SAI and they're still expecting us to pay $9,200 annually. It's so frustrating because their website makes it sound like families with negative SAIs should get full coverage. I've been lurking in this community for months reading about everyone's experiences, and based on what I've seen here, I'm planning to submit a formal appeal next week. We have some documentation about my wife's reduced hours due to caring for her elderly mother that wasn't fully captured in our CSS Profile. Reading through all these responses gives me hope that persistence really does pay off. Thank you everyone for sharing your strategies - especially the tip about getting admissions involved and checking for department-specific scholarships. My son is interested in business, so I'll definitely look into what the business school might offer. Has anyone had success appealing this late in the process? We're getting close to deposit deadlines and I'm worried we've missed our window.

As someone who's been through this process with multiple kids, I want to emphasize that you absolutely should not give up on appealing! I've seen families with similar SAI scores successfully get additional aid from Bucknell, but it requires being very strategic and persistent. A few additional tips based on what I've learned: 1. When you call the financial aid office, ask to speak with a senior counselor or the director - not just whoever answers the phone. The front-line staff often can't make decisions about additional funding. 2. Frame your appeal around "changed circumstances" rather than just asking for more money. Even if your financial situation is the same, emphasize anything that wasn't fully captured (like the medical expenses you mentioned). 3. If you have any connection to Bucknell alumni, now is the time to reach out. Sometimes a well-placed phone call from a donor or active alum can make a difference. The squeaky wheel really does get the grease in financial aid. Don't be afraid to be politely persistent - they have money set aside for exactly these situations, but they won't offer it unless you ask (repeatedly). Your daughter's stats must be strong if Bucknell accepted her, so they clearly want her there. Use that to your advantage in negotiations!