


Ask the community...
Just want to add another tip for families going through this - make sure both the student and parent have their FSA IDs ready before starting! We learned the hard way that you can't complete the consent sections without being properly logged in with the correct FSA ID. Also, if you're a divorced parent like me, double-check which parent should be the contributor based on the custody situation - the new FAFSA is very specific about this and it affects who needs to provide consent in the parent section.
This is such a good point about the FSA IDs! I just went through this process with my daughter and we wasted so much time because she forgot her FSA ID password and had to reset it in the middle of filling out the form. Also totally agree about the divorced parent thing - the FAFSA instructions about which parent counts as the "contributor" are way more detailed now than they used to be. For anyone reading this, make sure you read that section carefully because it's not always the parent who claims the student on taxes.
As someone who just went through this process with my twins, I can confirm that both student AND parent consent sections are absolutely required! What really helped us was creating a checklist beforehand. Here's what we learned: 1) Student must log in with their own FSA ID and complete their consent section (cannot be done by parent), 2) Parent logs in with their FSA ID for the parent consent section, 3) Both sections have multiple consent checkboxes - read them carefully because some are mandatory and others are optional, 4) Save your progress frequently because the system can time out. The whole process took us about 45 minutes per child once we got organized. Don't rush through the consent sections - they're the most important part and mistakes here will delay your SAI calculation!
This checklist approach is brilliant! I wish I had thought of that before we started. We're new to this whole process and honestly felt pretty overwhelmed by all the different sections and requirements. Your point about saving progress frequently is especially helpful - I've heard horror stories about people losing hours of work when the system times out. Quick question though - when you say some consent checkboxes are optional vs mandatory, how can you tell the difference? Are the mandatory ones marked differently or is it just trial and error when you try to submit?
One thing nobody mentioned: check if your state has any grants or scholarships that might be available regardless of your FAFSA SAI. Our state has a program for students with over 3.5 GPA that offers partial tuition coverage at in-state public universities, and it doesn't use the federal methodology at all.
Don't give up hope! I was in a very similar situation last year - SAI of 36,500 with a household income around $120k. While we didn't qualify for Pell Grants, my son still received a decent aid package from his school. Here's what helped us: 1) Applied to schools known for generous merit aid, 2) Had him apply for every local scholarship we could find (even small $500 ones add up!), 3) Contacted financial aid offices directly to explain our situation. The key is casting a wide net - some schools surprised us with institutional grants we weren't expecting. Also, don't forget about work-study opportunities and look into your state's aid programs. The sticker price isn't always what you'll end up paying!
This gives me so much hope! Your situation sounds almost identical to ours. Can I ask which types of schools ended up being most generous with merit aid? Were they private or public universities? And did you have any luck with the local scholarships - where did you find those? I feel like I need to be more strategic about where my daughter applies and focus on schools that might offer better institutional aid packages.
Update: I just got off the phone with my school's financial aid office. They were actually really understanding and said they've been seeing this problem a lot. They're setting up a special appeal process for students affected by the multiple-in-college change. I have to submit last year's award letter, this year's SAI calculation, and a statement about how this affects our ability to pay. They said they can't promise anything, but they're trying to find institutional funds to help bridge some of the gap. Fingers crossed! Thanks everyone for your help.
That's great news! Make sure your statement is very specific about the exact dollar amount your family can afford to contribute and why. Don't be vague - say something like "My family has budgeted $X,XXX per year for my education, and cannot exceed this amount because [specific reasons]." Schools respond better to precise numbers and concrete explanations.
I'm so sorry you're going through this - the new FAFSA changes have really blindsided a lot of families. It sounds like you're doing all the right things by reaching out to your school's financial aid office. Just wanted to add a few more suggestions that might help: 1. Ask your financial aid counselor about work-study opportunities if you haven't already - sometimes there are positions that weren't advertised widely 2. Check if your state has any emergency financial aid programs for students affected by the FAFSA changes - several states have created these specifically for situations like yours 3. Look into whether your school has any department-specific scholarships in your major that you might not have applied for yet Also, don't feel bad about considering community college for some courses if needed - I know it's not what you planned, but taking a few summer courses at CC to lighten your course load (and costs) during the regular semester can be a good strategy. You're being smart by exploring all your options instead of just taking on massive debt. Keep us posted on how your appeal goes!
does anyone know if we will get more money with negative sai than we would have with the old efc system??? my brothers sai was like -1200 and mine is -3400 but we have same parents lol
Great question! The new SAI system generally results in more generous aid packages than the old EFC system for many families. The fact that you and your brother have different SAI values despite having the same parents could be due to several factors: different college costs, different student income/assets, or possibly your status as dependents in the household (like your age or year in school). Most students with negative SAIs will qualify for maximum Pell Grants and often receive better institutional aid packages than under the old system. The new formula was specifically designed to be more generous to low and middle-income families.
I'm going through the exact same thing right now! Reading through all these responses has been so reassuring. I was panicking thinking I somehow skipped entering our tax information, but it sounds like the automatic IRS data retrieval is supposed to handle that. My daughter's SAI came back as -$2,100 and I was worried something was wrong with the calculation. It's frustrating how different this new system is from the old FAFSA - I wish they had better explanations or tutorials walking parents through what to expect. At least now I know our negative SAI is actually good news for financial aid eligibility! Thanks everyone for sharing your experiences.
Micah Franklin
One more thing to consider - if your FAFSA SAI came back higher than expected, you might want to submit an appeal for special circumstances to NC State's financial aid office. If your financial situation has changed since the tax year used for FAFSA (which is 2023 taxes for the 2025-26 academic year), you can request a professional judgment review. Common reasons for successful appeals include: - Job loss or reduction in income - Extraordinary medical expenses not covered by insurance - Support of extended family members - One-time income that inflated your tax return (like a property sale) The financial aid office has discretion to adjust your aid package based on current circumstances rather than just the FAFSA formula.
0 coins
Ruby Blake
•That's really helpful information. My husband actually took a lower-paying position in late 2023 (after most of the year was at his higher salary), so our 2023 taxes don't really reflect our current situation. I'll definitely look into the professional judgment review. Thank you!
0 coins
Liam Murphy
Hey Ruby! Congratulations on your son's acceptance to NC State! I'm a current NC State parent and wanted to share a few more resources that really helped us close the funding gap: 1. Check if your county has a Community Foundation - many have scholarships specifically for students attending NC universities. We found three through our county that totaled $4,500. 2. Look into professional associations related to computer science - organizations like the NC Technology Association often have student scholarships that aren't widely known. 3. Don't overlook the smaller "random" scholarships - we found one through a local Rotary Club for $1,000 that only had 8 applicants because it was so specific (had to write about community service AND be going into STEM). 4. NC State's Computer Science department specifically has industry partnerships with companies like Red Hat and SAS that offer scholarships directly to incoming CS students. Email the department chair directly - sometimes these opportunities don't make it to the main scholarship portals. The lack of communication from scholarship organizations is SO frustrating, but keep applying! We ended up piecing together about $8,000 from 5 different small scholarships. It's totally doable, just takes persistence!
0 coins