


Ask the community...
I went through this exact same situation with my Finnish company working with US clients! The W-8BEN-E definitely looks overwhelming at first, but it's actually quite straightforward once you break it down. For your Dutch V.O.F., here's what worked for me with a similar business structure: **Key sections to focus on:** - Part I: Basic business info (name, address, etc.) - Part II: Use your BTW/VAT number as the TIN - Part III: Check box 14a for treaty benefits and reference Article 7 (Business Profits) of the US-Netherlands tax treaty - Part XV: Check this for partnership classification (V.O.F. is treated as partnership for US tax purposes) - Part XXX: Don't forget to sign and date! **Pro tip:** Before submitting, double-check with your US client that they need the W-8BEN-E (for entities) and not the regular W-8BEN (for individuals). Some companies accidentally send the wrong form. The most important thing is getting the entity classification right - partnerships like your V.O.F. typically get better treaty benefits than corporations. Once you complete your first one, keep a copy as a template because many US clients will ask for updated forms annually. If you're still feeling uncertain, consider reaching out to a Dutch tax advisor who has experience with US forms - many offer quick consultations for exactly this type of question.
Thank you so much for this clear breakdown! It's really reassuring to hear from someone who's been through the same process. I feel much more confident now about tackling this form. One quick follow-up question - when you mention Article 7 (Business Profits) for the treaty benefits section, do I need to write out the full article reference, or is just "Article 7" sufficient? I want to make sure I get the formatting right so there are no delays with processing. Also, your tip about keeping a copy as a template is brilliant! I definitely didn't think about the fact that other US clients might need this same information. This whole process has been such a learning experience.
I completely understand your confusion - the W-8BEN-E can be really intimidating the first time you see it! I went through the exact same thing with my Belgian company when we started working with US clients. Based on the great advice already shared here, I want to emphasize a few key points that helped me get through this: 1. **Don't overthink the TIN section** - Your BTW/VAT number is perfect for this field. The IRS recognizes it as a valid foreign tax identifier. 2. **Double-check your entity classification** - Since you mentioned you're a V.O.F., you'll definitely want Part XV (Partnership) rather than any corporate sections. This is crucial for getting the right treaty benefits. 3. **Keep it simple with treaty benefits** - Article 7 of the US-Netherlands tax treaty should cover your consulting services, assuming you're working remotely from the Netherlands without a physical presence in the US. 4. **Save everything** - Once you complete this form, save a copy and document exactly what you filled in. Most US clients require updated forms annually, and having a reference makes future submissions much faster. One last tip: if you're still feeling uncertain after reviewing all the helpful advice here, don't hesitate to reach out to your US client's accounting team. They've seen these forms countless times and can often clarify exactly what they need for their specific situation. You've got this! The first one is always the hardest, but it gets much easier once you understand the structure.
This is such a helpful thread! I'm dealing with a similar situation for my Norwegian consulting company and feeling much less overwhelmed after reading all these responses. @Isabella Silva your point about keeping everything documented is spot on - I wish someone had told me that when I was dealing with my first international tax forms. Creating a template and reference guide seems like it would save so much time and stress for future clients. One thing I m'curious about - has anyone here had experience with what happens if you make a mistake on the W-8BEN-E after submitting it? Like if you realize you checked the wrong box or entered incorrect information? I m'always paranoid about getting these forms wrong and want to know if there s'a straightforward way to correct errors if needed. Also, does anyone know if the US client typically reviews these forms before processing payments, or do they just file them away? I m'wondering if there s'usually an opportunity to catch mistakes before they become a bigger issue.
I think everyone's missing something important here - are you actually making ANY income from fitness coaching yet? The IRS is super picky about hobby losses vs actual businesses. If you're not making money from fitness coaching for several years, they might disallow ALL your deductions regardless of when you buy the equipment.
This is so true! My friend tried deducting her "fitness business" expenses for three years but wasn't making profit and got audited. The IRS reclassified it all as a hobby and she had to pay back all the deductions plus penalties.
This is such a great question and I'm glad you're thinking ahead about the tax implications! As someone who's been through a similar transition, I'd suggest being really careful about the timing and documentation. One thing that hasn't been mentioned yet is that you might want to consider starting with a smaller equipment purchase to test the waters - maybe just a few key pieces that would clearly be for business use only. This way you can establish a pattern of legitimate business expenses without a huge upfront investment that might raise red flags. Also, since you mentioned you already have two other side businesses, make sure you're tracking everything separately. The IRS likes to see clear business boundaries, especially when you're claiming home-based business expenses across multiple ventures. Have you considered reaching out to a CPA who specializes in fitness professionals? They might be able to help you structure the equipment purchases in a way that maximizes your deductions while minimizing audit risk. The peace of mind might be worth the consultation fee!
That's really smart advice about starting small! I'm actually in a similar boat - just getting into fitness coaching and was about to drop a few thousand on equipment. The idea of testing with smaller purchases first makes so much sense, especially since I'm still figuring out what my clients will actually need. Quick question though - when you say "clear business boundaries," do you mean separate bank accounts for each business? I've been mixing expenses from my different side hustles and now I'm worried that might cause issues. Also, any tips on finding a CPA who actually understands fitness businesses? Most of the ones I've talked to seem confused about the home gym deduction stuff.
Absolutely yes to separate bank accounts for each business! It's honestly one of the most important things you can do for your taxes and audit protection. I learned this the hard way when my accountant had to spend hours untangling mixed expenses from my different ventures - it cost me way more in accounting fees than just opening separate accounts would have. For finding a fitness-specialized CPA, I'd recommend checking with your state's CPA society directory and filtering for those who list "fitness/recreation" or "small business" as specialties. Also try reaching out to local fitness studio owners or personal trainers in Facebook groups - they're usually happy to share who they use. The International Health, Racquet & Sportsclub Association (IHRSA) also has resources for fitness professionals that might include CPA referrals. One more tip: when you do start buying equipment, take photos of it being used for business purposes (client sessions, virtual training setups, etc.) along with your usage logs. Visual documentation can be incredibly helpful if you ever need to defend your deductions!
Quick question - I'm in a similar boat and wondering if I should just use TurboTax or something to catch up on my unfiled years? Anyone tried that route?
I tried using TurboTax for multiple unfiled years and it was a nightmare. The software isn't really designed for prior year returns, especially multiple years at once. I ended up making mistakes that triggered notices from the IRS. If you have very simple returns (just W-2 income, standard deduction), it might work, but even then, you have to purchase the previous year's software separately for each year you need to file. It ended up costing almost as much as hiring a professional would have, with none of the expertise.
I went through this exact situation last year - 7 unfiled returns! After reading all the advice here, I ended up going with an Enrolled Agent and it was absolutely the right choice. Here's what I learned: the main advantage of an EA isn't just filing the returns, it's dealing with all the complications that come with being behind. When the IRS started sending me notices about penalties and interest, my EA handled all of that correspondence. She also knew exactly which forms to use for prior year filings and caught several issues that would have caused problems later. The cost was higher than a regular preparer (about $300 per return vs $150), but she saved me way more than that in penalties she got waived. Plus, she set up a payment plan for the taxes I owed, which I had no idea I could even do. My advice: definitely go with an EA for multiple unfiled years. The peace of mind alone is worth it when you're dealing with the IRS on back taxes.
This is really helpful to see everyone's experiences! I'm in the same boat - my status changed to "STILL being processed" after exactly 21 days too. Based on what I'm reading here, it sounds like this is definitely a meaningful status change that indicates additional review rather than just different wording. I'm curious though - for those who got through to actual IRS agents, did they give you any sense of what triggers these reviews? Is it truly random or are there patterns? I have a pretty straightforward return with just W-2s and standard deduction, so I'm surprised mine got flagged. Thanks for all the insights everyone!
Great question! I've been through this exact same situation twice now. The "STILL being processed" status is definitely a meaningful change - it indicates your return has moved beyond the standard processing queue and into what the IRS calls "extended processing." This typically happens when your return is selected for additional verification, whether that's identity verification, income matching, or review of specific credits/deductions. In my experience, the timeline extends to 6-10 weeks from the original filing date. The key is checking your tax transcript for specific transaction codes that can give you more insight into what's causing the delay. Don't panic though - most of these extended reviews resolve without any issues or additional action needed from you!
This is such a helpful breakdown! I'm new to this whole tax thing (first year filing independently) and the uncertainty was really stressing me out. Your explanation about the "extended processing" queue makes so much sense - I was wondering if I did something wrong or if my return was being audited. How do you check your tax transcript for those transaction codes? Is that something I can access online or do I need to call the IRS? Really appreciate everyone sharing their experiences here, it's way more informative than the generic IRS website explanations!
Zoe Stavros
Does anyone know if this impacts household employees who didn't receive a W-2? I paid my house cleaner through Venmo all year (about $6,000 total) but didn't use a payroll service. Now I'm worried they'll get a 1099-K and have to pay self-employment taxes when they're technically a household employee.
0 coins
Nia Harris
ā¢You've actually identified a different issue. If you paid someone $2,400 or more in 2024 as a household employee, you're required to provide a W-2 and pay employer taxes. Without the payroll service, you should have been handling this yourself by getting an EIN, filing Schedule H with your return, etc. Since you didn't treat them as a household employee for tax purposes, they will indeed likely be classified as self-employed based on the 1099-K they'll receive from Venmo (since you exceeded the $5,000 threshold). At this point, they will need to pay self-employment taxes.
0 coins
Grace Thomas
ā¢@e6cbb7815e22 You may want to consider consulting with a tax professional about potentially filing a corrected return or amended paperwork to properly classify your house cleaner as a household employee retroactively. While it's more complicated now, it might save your cleaner from having to pay the full self-employment tax burden. You could still file Schedule H with your 2024 return to report the household employee wages and pay the employer portion of Social Security and Medicare taxes. You'd also need to issue a W-2 (even though it's late) and potentially pay some penalties, but this could be much less costly for your cleaner than them having to pay both the employee and employer portions of Social Security/Medicare taxes as self-employed. The key question is whether correcting this classification now would be worth the penalty fees versus having your cleaner pay the higher self-employment taxes. A tax professional familiar with household employee rules could help you run the numbers.
0 coins
Dmitry Volkov
This is a great discussion that highlights how confusing the intersection of payment app reporting and household employee taxes can be! One thing I'd add is that if you're ever in doubt about whether your babysitter received a 1099-K, you can actually check with them in January/February when tax documents are being sent out. Since you have a good relationship (they're a friend), a quick "Hey, did you get any tax forms from Venmo?" conversation could help you both prepare for tax season. Also, for anyone reading this thread who might be in a similar situation in the future - consider asking your payroll service about their payment options before assuming there are extra fees. Many services now offer free or low-cost direct deposit specifically because it avoids these payment app reporting complications. The $5,000 threshold for 2024 that Andre mentioned is definitely key information. The IRS has been flip-flopping on the 1099-K thresholds for payment apps, so it's worth checking the current rules each year rather than assuming they stayed the same.
0 coins