Back to Washington Unemployment

Kiara Greene

Washington ESD unemployment disqualified after missing work due to hospitalization overpayment repay situation

So I'm sitting here staring at two separate letters from Washington ESD and honestly don't even know where to start. The first one hit about six weeks after I got out of the hospital - I had an emergency appendectomy back in January and missed eight days of work. My employer apparently reported my absences to ESD as job abandonment, which I didn't even know was happening while I was literally recovering from surgery. ESD then sent me a disqualification notice saying I was fired for misconduct. I had been collecting UI benefits for about three weeks before that determination came through. Now here's where it gets worse. Because of that disqualification, ESD is saying I was not eligible for the benefits I already collected - roughly $2,800 - and they want that money back as an overpayment. I work in warehouse logistics and was making decent money before this whole disaster, so $2,800 is not nothing. I never even knew my employer was going to characterize my absence that way. I had texts showing I contacted my supervisor from the hospital, I have discharge paperwork, the whole thing. I filed an appeal of the disqualification but I'm not sure if that automatically pauses the overpayment repayment demand or if those are two completely separate tracks. And I honestly cannot get anyone at ESD on the phone to explain what's happening. Has anyone dealt with both of these at the same time - appealing a disqualification AND fighting an overpayment that stemmed from that same disqualification? Do I need to submit separate paperwork for each one or does winning the appeal fix the overpayment automatically?

Three days into week seven of my own appeal process and I stumbled onto this thread - but before I get into my situation I want to flag something that actually helped me get answers when I was drowning in the same kind of phone loop you're describing. I found a service called Claimyr (claimyr.com) that essentially gets you through to a live Washington ESD agent without you having to sit on hold for four hours. There's a video walkthrough at https://youtu.be/7DieNd3C7zQ that shows how it works. I was skeptical but I used it when I was trying to get clarification on my own appeal status and it genuinely connected me. For your situation specifically - where you have both an active appeal AND an overpayment notice running at the same time - getting a real agent on the line to confirm whether those two tracks are linked in your account is probably the fastest way to avoid accidentally triggering a collections action while your appeal is still pending.

0 coins

Not sure I'd rely on a third party service when ESD has a callback option on their main line now - has that stopped working for people?

0 coins

Week four I tried the callback option twice and never got a call back either time, so at least for me it wasn't working. Maybe it depends on claim type or volume that week.

0 coins

The callback thing is pretty hit or miss from what I've seen on here. Some people swear by it, others have been waiting weeks.

0 coins

Month two of dealing with almost the identical situation here - employer called it job abandonment, ESD called it misconduct, overpayment notice showed up about three weeks later. The thing I wish someone had told me upfront is that the appeal and the overpayment are technically on separate tracks but they are very much connected in outcome. If you win the appeal and the disqualification gets reversed, ESD is supposed to automatically recalculate and waive the overpayment that resulted from that disqualification. The key word is 'supposed to' - in my case I had to follow up after my appeal was approved because the overpayment balance was still sitting there in my account flagged for collection.

0 coins

That's actually really useful - so winning the appeal doesn't trigger an automatic system correction? I need to follow up separately after the fact?

0 coins

In my experience, yes. I called after I got my appeal decision letter and specifically asked an agent to confirm the overpayment was going to be cleared. It took another week after that call before my account updated.

0 coins

This matches what I went through too. The appeal hearing officer doesn't directly touch the overpayment balance - that's a separate department basically.

0 coins

Got my disqualification letter back in March after a firing dispute and learned this whole process the hard way. The misconduct standard in Washington is actually harder for employers to prove than a lot of people realize - it's not just 'you did something wrong at work,' it's more like you deliberately violated a known workplace rule in a way that shows you didn't care about keeping your job. Missing work because you were hospitalized is basically the opposite of that definition. Your documentation - the hospital discharge papers, the texts to your supervisor - is exactly the kind of evidence that tends to flip these decisions at the hearing level.

0 coins

I'd question whether the texts to the supervisor are enough on their own or if OP needs a letter from the hospital too - does ESD require both?

0 coins

Both is definitely stronger. The discharge paperwork proves the medical necessity and the texts prove you notified your employer. Either alone leaves a gap the employer's rep can try to exploit at the hearing.

0 coins

Also worth getting a written statement from your doctor if you can, confirming the dates you were medically unable to work. I brought one to my hearing and the judge referenced it specifically in the decision.

0 coins

Just hit the six-month mark dealing with ESD after my own termination mess and I want to add something about the overpayment specifically. Even while your appeal is pending, do NOT ignore the overpayment notice. There's usually a window to either appeal the overpayment separately or request a waiver if repayment would cause financial hardship. Missing that window because you assumed the disqualification appeal covered everything is how people end up with the overpayment going to collections. I made exactly that mistake - sat back assuming my appeal would handle everything and got a collections letter while my appeal was still being scheduled.

0 coins

Hold on, so there's a separate appeal window specifically for the overpayment? What is the deadline for that and where do I file it?

0 coins

Using Claimyr to reach an ESD agent is honestly how I finally got the clearest answer on this - found it at claimyr.com and there's a demo at https://youtu.be/7DieNd3C7zQ. The agent told me overpayment appeals generally follow the same 30-day window from the notice date as other ESD appeals. But confirm your specific dates with them because every notice has its own deadline printed on it.

0 coins

The hardship waiver option is real and underutilized. If your income dropped significantly because of the whole situation, you can request that ESD consider not collecting even if the overpayment is confirmed.

0 coins

Just past the two-week mark since my appeal hearing and still waiting on a written decision - but reading your post I want to flag the hospitalization angle specifically. Washington has what I'd describe as a protection for people who miss work due to genuine medical emergencies. The employer's ability to call that misconduct depends heavily on whether you followed whatever notification procedures your workplace had. If your employer had a call-in policy and you texted your supervisor from the hospital, that probably counts as notice even if texting wasn't the 'official' channel. Hearing officers look at whether you did what was reasonably possible given your circumstances.

0 coins

Not sure the texting point is universally true - some employers have very specific call-in requirements and hearing officers have ruled against claimants who used informal methods. OP should check their employee handbook if they still have access to it.

0 coins

Fair point - I should have said it depends on the handbook language. If there's a specific 'must call the HR hotline' policy that the claimant bypassed, that could complicate things. But a text directly to a supervisor is usually treated as reasonable notice absent a strict written policy.

0 coins

I actually do have the employee handbook still - going to dig through it tonight to check the exact call-in requirements. Good catch.

0 coins

Somewhere around the four-week point in my own appeal I noticed something a lot of people miss: the burden of proof at an ESD appeal hearing actually sits with the employer in a discharge case, not with you. They have to demonstrate misconduct, you don't have to prove you weren't guilty of it. That shifts things meaningfully in your favor when your absence was medically documented. I went into my hearing thinking I had to prove my innocence and my advocate corrected me on that the morning of the hearing.

0 coins

I'd gently push back on this being universal - I think the burden distribution can depend on who filed the initial claim and how the disqualification was triggered. Sometimes ESD makes an initial determination that shifts the dynamic.

0 coins

You're right that it's worth verifying with a UI advocate or WorkSource counselor before your hearing. The general principle is correct for misconduct discharge cases but the nuances matter.

0 coins

WorkSource WA has free advocates who help with exactly this kind of prep - looked into it for my own hearing and they were really thorough about explaining what to expect.

0 coins

About ten days after my own overpayment notice arrived I found out about the waiver process and want to explain it because it took me a while to understand. The hardship waiver is separate from both the disqualification appeal and the overpayment appeal. It's basically you telling ESD 'even if you determine I owe this money, paying it back would cause me genuine financial hardship.' You have to document your income, expenses, and demonstrate the repayment would leave you unable to cover basic needs. I submitted one alongside my appeal documents as a sort of backup plan.

0 coins

Filing the waiver as a backup alongside the appeal is smart - does filing a waiver admission that you owe the money, or is it truly separate from the question of whether you owe it?

0 coins

Completely separate. ESD treats them as independent questions. Requesting a waiver doesn't mean you're conceding the overpayment is valid, it just means if they ultimately decide it is valid, you're asking them not to collect it due to hardship. I confirmed this with an agent.

0 coins

This is exactly right. I was scared to file a waiver for the same reason and my advocate explained that it's a totally separate track with no bearing on the merits of the underlying appeal.

0 coins

Coming up on three months since my termination and I want to share what I wish I'd known in week one. The appeals process through the Office of Administrative Hearings moves faster than people expect once it actually gets scheduled - my hearing was set within about five weeks of my appeal filing. The bigger delay is usually just getting the scheduling letter. During that whole waiting period your overpayment technically sits in a kind of limbo where collections is supposed to be paused, but you should absolutely verify that pause is active on your account rather than just assuming.

0 coins

The OAH scheduling timeline was faster for me too - about four weeks. The hearing itself was under an hour and mostly consisted of me presenting documents and my employer's HR rep presenting their account notes.

0 coins

Knowing it moves that quickly once scheduled is actually reassuring - I filed the appeal nine days ago so hopefully the scheduling letter comes soon.

0 coins

Keep an eye on your eServices inbox too, not just physical mail. Some scheduling letters come through there first and I almost missed mine.

0 coins

Wrapping up week eight of my situation which started similarly to yours - disqualification, overpayment notice, couldn't reach anyone for weeks. The phone situation with ESD is genuinely terrible right now. I eventually used Claimyr (claimyr.com) and got connected to an agent in about twenty minutes when I'd been trying for days on my own. The agent I reached was actually the one who explained to me that my overpayment collections hold was not automatically applied and I needed to request it be noted in my file. Would not have known that without getting through to a real person.

0 coins

Roughly two weeks into my own appeal, I had a similar experience getting through - the agent I reached was helpful and direct in a way the automated system never is. Getting that collections hold confirmed verbally AND in writing if possible is probably smart.

0 coins

Yes - I asked the agent to note it in the account and then followed up by sending a written message through eServices referencing the call date, so there's a paper trail.

0 coins

The eServices message trail is underrated for exactly this reason - it timestamps everything and gives you something to reference if there's ever a dispute about what you were told.

0 coins

Around the fifth week of my appeal waiting period I started obsessing over whether I should have submitted more documents upfront. For anyone reading this who hasn't had their hearing scheduled yet - you can submit additional evidence any time before the actual hearing date. The OAH will tell you in the scheduling letter exactly how to submit exhibits. Don't panic if you forgot something in your initial filing.

0 coins

Really glad to hear this - I submitted what I had quickly and have since found two more things that would help my case. Good to know I can still include them.

0 coins

Just make sure you send copies to ESD legal AND to the OAH and check the scheduling letter for exact submission deadlines, usually a few days before the hearing.

0 coins

And send them in a way you can track - certified mail or through the eServices upload if that's available. Hearing officers sometimes don't have exhibits that were submitted late or by unreliable methods.

0 coins

Finishing up week twelve since my situation started and want to address the moment a lot of people dread: what happens if you lose the appeal. Even then, you still have options. You can request reconsideration from the OAH, you can escalate to the Commissioner's Review Office, and you still potentially have the hardship waiver available for the overpayment. The process doesn't end at the first hearing loss. I know someone who lost at the OAH level and won at the Commissioner level. Also - separately - for anyone still struggling to reach ESD while all this is in progress, Claimyr at claimyr.com with the walkthrough at https://youtu.be/7DieNd3C7zQ has been mentioned here and I'll confirm it worked for me too when I needed to get a real agent mid-process.

0 coins

Possibly worth noting that the Commissioner's Review Office doesn't hold a new hearing - they review the record from the OAH hearing. So the evidence you present at the OAH level is really critical since that's what gets reviewed going forward.

0 coins

That's an important clarification. Everything you present at the OAH hearing becomes the official record. It underscores why preparing thoroughly for that hearing matters so much.

0 coins

The Commissioner's Review timelines are also much longer - worth factoring into your financial planning if you're counting on benefits being reinstated.

0 coins

All of this is why getting a UI advocate involved before the OAH hearing rather than after is so valuable. They know what goes into the record and how to build it.

0 coins

About six weeks after my own disqualification letter I finally talked to a WorkSource WA navigator who changed how I understood the whole thing. The 'misconduct' category that ESD uses has specific legal parameters - it's not whatever the employer calls it in their termination paperwork. An employer writing 'job abandonment' on the separation form doesn't automatically mean ESD concludes misconduct. ESD makes its own determination based on the facts, and the appeal hearing officer makes their own determination on top of that. Your employer's characterization is just one input.

0 coins

This is something I didn't understand at all when I first got the disqualification letter - I assumed the employer's paperwork was basically the final word.

0 coins

Almost everyone assumes that at first. The key is understanding that ESD applies a specific legal standard to 'misconduct' that's separate from whatever HR terminology the employer used.

0 coins

And hearing officers sometimes explicitly note in their decisions that the employer's characterization was not consistent with the statutory definition of misconduct. I've read several published OAH decisions where that phrasing appeared.

0 coins

Just over two months into my claim dispute and I want to add something about the documentation angle specifically for hospitalization cases. When I went through something somewhat similar, the hospital's record of your admission dates is obtainable even after the fact through their medical records department. If you need to supplement your discharge paperwork with something more detailed showing you physically could not have been at work, a summary from medical records can serve that purpose. My hearing officer specifically commented that medical documentation was the most credible exhibit I submitted.

0 coins

I have the discharge summary but not the full admission records - probably worth requesting those as well.

0 coins

The admission and discharge dates are the most critical parts. Some people also get a letter from the treating physician confirming the dates they were under care. That's especially useful if the surgery was an emergency admission where the paperwork is less tidy.

0 coins

HIPAA request process for your own records is usually pretty fast - most hospitals have a turnaround of five to ten business days and many have online portals now.

0 coins

About a month into navigating my own claim problem and I keep seeing people mix up the overpayment appeal with the hardship waiver in this thread and elsewhere, so I want to lay out how I understand the three separate things you might file: one is the disqualification appeal to the OAH, two is a separate overpayment appeal if you dispute that the overpayment amount is correct, and three is the hardship waiver if you agree there's an overpayment but can't repay it. All three have different forms, different deadlines, and go to different parts of ESD. You might need all three depending on your situation.

0 coins

This is the clearest breakdown I've seen of these three tracks. The overpayment appeal specifically addresses whether the dollar amount is calculated correctly, which is different from whether the underlying disqualification was valid.

0 coins

Exactly - someone could win their disqualification appeal, get benefits reinstated, but still have a residual overpayment calculation error that needs to be separately addressed.

0 coins

This happened to a friend of mine - won the appeal but the overpayment balance was miscalculated during reinstatement and she had to file a separate correction request.

0 coins

Just received my fourth weekly check after a long adjudication battle and I want to offer some encouragement because reading threads like this in the thick of it felt overwhelming. My situation involved a termination dispute, an overpayment notice, and three months of uncertainty. I won at the OAH level, the overpayment was cleared about two weeks after the decision letter came, and my back-paid benefits hit my account about a week after that. The process works, it just takes longer than it should and requires you to stay organized and persistent.

0 coins

Genuinely needed to hear this - thank you. The 'it works but takes longer than it should' framing actually helps me calibrate expectations.

0 coins

Keep copies of absolutely everything - every letter, every submission, every confirmation number from calls. That documentation saved me twice when ESD's records didn't match what I had been told.

0 coins

The back-pay timeline you described matches mine too - about a week after the decision letter. I was bracing for months and was pleasantly surprised.

0 coins

Roughly five weeks from when I first filed my appeal I stumbled onto the fact that you can check your appeal status through the Office of Administrative Hearings website directly - you don't have to wait for ESD to update your eServices account. The OAH case tracking shows when your case was received, when it was assigned to a hearing officer, and when a decision was issued. This was enormously helpful for my own anxiety during the waiting period.

0 coins

I had no idea the OAH had its own tracking - going to look that up right now.

0 coins

You'll need your appeal case number from the acknowledgment letter ESD sends after you file. That number is what you use to track it on the OAH side.

0 coins

The OAH tracking doesn't always update in real time - mine showed 'received' for almost two weeks before it updated to 'assigned.' Don't read too much into delays between status changes.

0 coins

Coming in from the other side of a similar fight - about four months total from first notice to final resolution. The thing that surprised me most looking back was how much the initial appeal letter mattered. I wrote mine quickly and vaguely because I didn't understand the process. A UI advocate at WorkSource WA told me later that a more specific initial appeal letter explaining exactly why the disqualification was wrong can shape what the hearing officer focuses on. If you haven't had your hearing scheduled yet, it might be worth contacting OAH to ask if you can supplement your initial appeal statement.

0 coins

Mine was pretty vague too - I basically just said I disagree with the determination. Is it too late to send a more detailed statement before the hearing is scheduled?

0 coins

You can definitely submit a written statement of your position before the hearing. Address it to the OAH with your case number and explain the specific factual basis for your appeal - the hospitalization, the notification to your supervisor, the documentation you have.

0 coins

The hearing officer reads the file before the hearing so a pre-hearing statement actually can influence how the proceeding is structured. Worth doing.

0 coins

Somewhere in week three of waiting I finally connected with a UI legal advocate through Unemployment Law Project - they offer free consultations for Washington claimants dealing with appeal hearings. They were the ones who explained to me that my overpayment was directly tied to the disqualification and that clearing the disqualification would trigger a mandatory review of the overpayment. They also prepped me for the hearing in a way I could not have done alone.

0 coins

I'll look them up - Unemployment Law Project. Is that the same as WorkSource or a separate organization?

0 coins

Separate organization, specifically focused on UI legal assistance. WorkSource is broader employment services. Both are worth contacting but for appeal hearing prep specifically the Unemployment Law Project is more specialized.

0 coins

Northwest Justice Project is another option for free legal help in Washington if you can't get an appointment with Unemployment Law Project quickly.

0 coins

About seven weeks from my termination date I got a call from ESD that I almost missed because I didn't recognize the number. The agent was calling to verify details about my separation before my hearing date. I want to flag this for anyone in the appeals process - ESD may contact you as part of their pre-hearing review. If you miss that call it can delay your case. Make sure your contact information in eServices is current and your phone is set to accept calls from unknown or government numbers.

0 coins

Updated my number in eServices just now after reading this - good thing I saw it.

0 coins

Also check your eServices messages regularly because sometimes what would have been a call becomes a written inquiry instead, and failing to respond to those can also affect your case timeline.

0 coins

I missed one of those eServices messages early in my process and had to scramble to respond within what turned out to be a pretty tight window. The notifications don't always come through reliably.

0 coins

About to hit the one-year mark since my own termination dispute wrapped up and I still check this forum occasionally because I remember how lost I felt. For what it's worth, every piece of documentation you're describing - hospital discharge paperwork, supervisor texts, your employee handbook - is exactly the evidence profile that tends to succeed at OAH hearings in hospitalization cases. The main things that sink these cases are gaps in notification to the employer and claimants who can't demonstrate they took reasonable steps given their circumstances. You appear to have both covered. Stay organized, stay responsive to ESD communications, and get an advocate if you can.

0 coins

Thank you for coming back and posting this. Knowing someone who's been through it and out the other side is reading these threads is actually weirdly comforting.

0 coins

Genuinely happy to help where I can. Document every single step from here - every call, every submission, every date. That paper trail is what gives you leverage if anything goes sideways.

0 coins

Agreed on the documentation point completely. I kept a simple spreadsheet with every date, action, and reference number and it paid off multiple times over the course of my case.

0 coins

Washington Unemployment AI

Expert Assistant
Secure