Back to Washington Unemployment

Keisha Taylor

Unemployment overpayment after starting new job and turning down first job offer - Washington ESD hit me with this

So I've been dealing with this nightmare situation for the past few weeks and I genuinely don't know what to do. Quick background: I got laid off from my warehouse supervisor job back in January and filed for unemployment. Everything was going fine, filing my weekly claims, doing my job searches, the whole thing. Here's where it gets complicated. In late February I got two job offers kind of at the same time. The first one came in on a Wednesday - it was an okay offer but the pay was lower than what I was making and the commute would've been brutal, like 90 minutes each way. I turned it down. Then on that Friday I got a second offer that was actually better than my old job - better pay, closer to home, benefits, the works. I accepted it and started the following Monday. I reported everything on my weekly claim like you're supposed to. Reported the earnings from my first week at the new job. Thought I was done with ESD. Then last week I get this letter saying I owe $4,200 in overpayments. The letter mentions something about 'refusing suitable work' tied to that first offer I turned down AND something about not properly closing out my claim when I started the new job. I'm completely lost. How can I owe money for turning down a job I legitimately didn't want? And I DID report my new job earnings. Has anyone dealt with something like this where there were two separate issues wrapped into one overpayment notice?

That Wednesday offer you turned down - that's probably the main issue ESD is focused on. When you decline a job offer while collecting benefits, Washington ESD treats it as 'refusing suitable work' and can disqualify you going back to that date. The $4,200 figure they're hitting you with likely covers the weeks between when you turned down that offer and when you started the new job. The good news is you can absolutely appeal this, and the 'suitable work' question actually has some nuance to it - the commute and pay difference you mentioned could legitimately work in your favor during an appeal.

0 coins

Wait so the whole thing might hinge on whether that first offer counted as 'suitable'? I genuinely thought I was making a reasonable call declining it. The pay was like 18% lower than my previous wage and the commute was insane.

0 coins

18% wage cut is actually meaningful in an appeal. Washington ESD's own guidelines acknowledge that a significant pay reduction can factor into whether a job is considered suitable for someone. Document every detail you remember about that offer - the exact wage, the commute distance in miles, what the job duties were compared to your previous role.

0 coins

yeah same thing happened to my brother in law, he turned down something that paid way less and ESD came after him too. he ended up winning his appeal though so theres hope

0 coins

While you're figuring out the appeal process, one thing I'd really recommend is getting on the phone with an actual ESD agent before your appeal deadline hits. I know, I know - calling ESD is basically its own form of torture. I spent three days trying to get through when I had my overpayment issue last year. Someone in a different forum thread pointed me toward Claimyr (claimyr.com) and it was genuinely the first time I actually got through to a live person. There's a demo video at https://youtu.be/7DieNd3C7zQ that shows how it works. The reason I'm suggesting calling first is that an ESD agent can actually pull up your claim and tell you exactly which weeks they're flagging and why - that information is gold going into your appeal.

0 coins

Three days trying to get through - yeah that tracks with what I've experienced. I've been calling every morning and just get the busy signal recording. I'll check out that Claimyr thing, the appeal deadline is making me nervous so I need to move fast.

0 coins

calling before you appeal is actually smart advice. sometimes ESD has flagged the wrong weeks or there's a data entry thing that caused the overpayment notice, and an agent can catch that before you have to go through the whole formal process

0 coins

I second getting actual claim details from an agent first. My overpayment notice last year had an error in it - they had my start date at the new job wrong by a whole week which threw off the calculation entirely.

0 coins

Your situation actually has two separate issues tangled together and they should probably be addressed separately in your appeal. The 'refused suitable work' question about that Wednesday offer is one thing. The 'didn't properly close claim when starting new job' issue is a different thing. For the second part - when you reported your earnings that first week at the new job, did you also indicate that you were no longer available for work? There's a specific question on the weekly claim about availability. If you answered that you were still available while working full time, that could trigger the second part of the overpayment.

0 coins

Honestly I'm not 100% sure how I answered that availability question. I was focused on reporting the earnings accurately and I might not have thought carefully about the availability question. Is that something that can be corrected retroactively through an appeal?

0 coins

Your weekly claim answers from that period will be on record. During an appeal you can explain what your intent was and that you may have misunderstood the question - it matters a lot whether ESD sees this as an honest mistake vs. deliberate misrepresentation. Honest mistakes usually end up as non-fraud overpayments which have different repayment rules.

0 coins

the fraud vs non-fraud distinction is HUGE. non-fraud overpayments have way more flexible repayment options and you can sometimes get a waiver if repayment would cause you financial hardship

0 coins

Just want to flag something about the first job offer situation. The commute thing - Washington ESD doesn't have a specific mileage cutoff but they do look at what's considered reasonable given the local job market and what you were commuting before. 90 minutes each way is legitimately a lot and could support your case that it wasn't suitable. The 18% wage reduction is probably your stronger argument though. ESD guidance generally suggests that a job paying substantially less than your previous wage, especially early in a claim, can be considered unsuitable. I'd lead with the wage argument in your appeal and use the commute as supporting detail.

0 coins

Leading with wage makes sense. I've been going back and forth on how to frame this. I do have the offer letter still - it shows the hourly rate. Should I actually attach that to my appeal paperwork?

0 coins

Absolutely attach it. Any documentation you have - offer letters, emails about the job offers, your old pay stubs showing your prior wage - all of it strengthens your appeal. The more concrete evidence you can put in front of the appeals judge, the better.

0 coins

yes attach everything, I cannot stress this enough. I went into my appeal with basically nothing and lost. went back for a second hearing with documentation and won. paper trail matters so much

0 coins

Something I haven't seen mentioned yet - there's a strict deadline on appealing overpayment notices. If your letter just arrived, you need to look at the date on it and count from there, not from when you received it. The window to file an appeal is 30 days from the date on the notice. Missing that deadline means you lose the right to appeal the disqualification itself, though you can still potentially request a waiver of the repayment amount separately. On the Claimyr note from earlier - I ended up using it when I was dealing with my own appeal situation and needed clarification on some specific dates. Got connected to an agent in the same day which I genuinely didn't think was possible. Claimyr walked me through the whole queue situation. Definitely worth it when time is tight.

0 coins

30 days from the DATE on the letter, not from when I got it - okay that's important. The letter is dated 6 days ago so I still have time but not a ton of it.

0 coins

file sooner rather than later is my advice. I waited until day 28 and there was some technical issue with the online system that almost made me miss it. gave me a heart attack. file it now

0 coins

you can file the appeal online through eServices which is faster than mailing anything. just make sure you get the confirmation number showing it was received

0 coins

I went through almost this exact thing about eight months ago - took a job, before that turned down something that wasn't right for me, then got hit with an overpayment notice. The part about the new job earnings - Washington ESD processes those reports and they should have shown up as a reason to stop benefits automatically. If they kept paying you after you reported earnings, that's on their end and that's actually a strong point in a waiver request. You'd essentially be saying 'I told you I was working, you kept paying me, that's not my fault.' Judges respond to that.

0 coins

Mine actually did stop paying after I reported the new job earnings. The overpayment they're claiming is from the weeks before I started the new job - specifically they seem to be tying it to when I turned down the first offer.

0 coins

That changes the picture a bit. So the overpayment is entirely about the period between declining the first offer and starting the second job? In that case the whole case really does come down to whether that first offer was 'suitable.' Your wage documentation is going to be everything.

0 coins

right if ESD stopped paying once earnings were reported then at least there isn't a continuing overpayment issue, its contained to those specific weeks which makes the appeal cleaner

0 coins

My coworker went through an overpayment appeal earlier this year for a 'refused suitable work' situation and she mentioned using Claimyr to get through to ESD when she was preparing. She said the agent she spoke with actually helped her understand what specific documentation would matter most for her type of appeal before she filed it. That kind of inside knowledge before you submit can honestly change the outcome. Worth looking into at claimyr.com before you put your appeal paperwork together.

0 coins

Getting pre-appeal guidance from an actual agent sounds incredibly useful. I keep second-guessing what to include and what might actually hurt my case.

0 coins

an agent might also tell you whether this is likely to result in a formal hearing or whether it might get resolved at the lower review level first. knowing that changes how much prep work you need to do upfront

0 coins

For anyone reading this later who's confused about the suitable work standard in Washington - here's how I understand it from my own experience appealing a similar issue. When ESD looks at whether a job you turned down was 'suitable,' they're weighing things like how long you'd been unemployed, what your previous wage was, what the offered wage is, what the job requires you to do, and how far you'd have to travel. Early in your claim they give you more room to decline lower-paying work. Someone who was making $28 an hour and gets offered $22 two weeks into their claim has a much stronger argument than someone who's been out of work for six months getting offered $22. Timing matters a lot.

0 coins

Two weeks in is actually pretty close to my situation. I was maybe three weeks into my claim when that offer came in. Does the short time on the claim actually help me here?

0 coins

Generally yes - ESD's own guidance acknowledges that it's reasonable to hold out for comparable work earlier in a claim. Three weeks in, 18% wage cut, brutal commute - that's actually a pretty defensible position. Write it up clearly and factually, don't be emotional about it in the appeal letter.

0 coins

the 'early in claim' thing is real but i wouldn't rely on it alone. lead with the wage like others said and let the timing be supporting context

0 coins

Not sure if this helps but I want to share what worked for me in a similar situation. I was really spinning out about my overpayment notice and kept going in circles trying to figure out the right approach. A friend suggested Claimyr after I complained about not being able to get through to ESD for the fifth day in a row - claimyr.com - and once I actually got an agent on the phone and explained my specific situation, they pointed me toward a form I didn't even know existed for requesting reconsideration before formally appealing. Saved me a whole step. Sometimes talking to a human who knows the system is worth more than a hundred forum posts.

0 coins

A reconsideration step before the formal appeal - that's actually new info for me. I didn't know that was an option. Did it resolve your issue or did you end up appealing anyway?

0 coins

For mine it resolved at the reconsideration stage, didn't need to go further. But the agent told me upfront that my situation was pretty clear-cut. For something like yours with the suitable work question it might not resolve that way, but it's still worth knowing about.

0 coins

the reconsideration option exists but honestly the timelines get complicated if you try to do both. make sure any reconsideration request doesn't eat into your appeal deadline

0 coins

Let's talk about what actually goes INTO an appeal letter for a 'refused suitable work' disqualification because I've seen people write vague appeals and lose cases they should have won. Your letter needs: the date you received the offer, the wage offered vs your previous wage (with percentages if possible), the commute distance and time, what the job duties were and how they compared to your previous role, and a clear statement that you acted in good faith and continued your job search after declining. Factual and specific beats emotional every time.

0 coins

Writing it out like that makes it feel more manageable. I do have most of those details. The job duties comparison is interesting - the first offer was actually in a different industry from my warehouse background, is that relevant?

0 coins

Industry differences can be relevant, yes - especially if the skills don't transfer directly or if it would represent a step down in terms of your career path. It's secondary to the wage argument but worth including.

0 coins

also include that you kept filing your weekly claims and doing your job searches correctly during that period. shows you weren't trying to game the system, you were actively looking

0 coins

and keep the tone neutral, like you're explaining facts to someone who wasn't there. appeals judges see a lot of angry letters and they tune it out. just the facts presented clearly

0 coins

Something that might complicate the appeal a little - Washington ESD is going to look at whether you gave the first employer a reason when you turned down the offer. If you just said 'no thanks' with no explanation, that's a weaker position than if you communicated clearly that the wage was below your previous compensation and the commute was unreasonable. Do you remember how that conversation went?

0 coins

I did say something to the recruiter about the commute being too long. I'm not sure I specifically mentioned the wage - I think I just said it wasn't the right fit. Would an email to the recruiter count as documentation?

0 coins

Any communication you have from that time period is worth including. Even if you didn't explicitly say 'the pay is too low,' your offer letter showing the wage differential is evidence of your reasoning. Courts and administrative judges are pretty good at inferring legitimate reasons from documented facts.

0 coins

if you have texts or emails with the recruiter from that time save them now before they disappear from your phone or inbox

0 coins

i kinda wanna push back on the idea that the appeal is a slam dunk here. ESD does take 'refused suitable work' seriously and I've seen people lose appeals with similar facts. not trying to be negative but go in prepared for a fight not assuming you'll win easily. document everything, consider whether you want to get actual legal help for the hearing - there are free legal aid options in washington for unemployment appeals

0 coins

Appreciate the reality check honestly. I've been trying not to get overconfident. What would legal aid look like for something like this - is it an actual attorney or more like a paralegal?

0 coins

actual attorneys in some cases - there are organizations in washington that specifically help people with unemployment appeals at no cost. search for legal aid unemployment washington and you should find options. they can review your case and tell you if it's worth fighting.

0 coins

columbia legal services does unemployment appeal work in washington. worth calling them early because their availability varies

0 coins

Something I want to add about the 'starting new job' piece of your overpayment. When you started your new job and reported earnings on your weekly claim, there's also a question about whether you completed any partial weeks. Your first week at a new job is often a partial week - started on a Monday but didn't work Monday through Sunday of a benefits week. ESD's weekly benefit calculations can get weird around partial work weeks and sometimes generate overpayment flags automatically even when you did everything right. That might be part of what's in your $4,200 figure.

0 coins

I did start on a Monday but the benefits week runs Sunday to Saturday I think, so my first week was actually nearly a full week. But the week before I started I was still filing claims normally - I wonder if something got crossed there.

0 coins

The week before you started is exactly what to look at. If you filed a weekly claim for the week that ended right before you started work, and ESD paid it out after you technically had accepted and were about to start a job, that could be flagged. When did you accept the offer vs when you filed that last claim?

0 coins

the date of acceptance vs date of claim filing is a really important detail to nail down before the appeal. pull up your eServices history and get the exact dates

0 coins

been following this thread and wanted to share that I went through ESD adjudication for refusing suitable work about a year and a half ago. lost at the initial level, won on appeal, then had to fight about whether the repayment was due during the appeal period. the whole process took about four months start to finish. mentally prepare yourself for this taking a while. it's worth fighting but go in knowing it's a process not a quick fix.

0 coins

Four months is longer than I was expecting. That's hard to hear but good to know. Did you have to repay anything while the appeal was pending or did they put it on hold?

0 coins

ESD can put a hold on collection while your appeal is pending but it's not automatic, you have to request it. ask about this when you get through to an agent - it at least takes the immediate financial pressure off while you sort out the legal side.

0 coins

yes the collection hold is a thing, do not forget to ask about it. having them actively try to collect while you're in the middle of an appeal is incredibly stressful and you don't have to deal with that if you ask for the hold

0 coins

have you looked at whether you qualify for a hardship waiver separate from the appeal? like even if the appeal doesn't fully go your way, if repaying $4200 would cause you financial hardship you can apply for a waiver of the overpayment amount. they look at your income, expenses, all that. it doesn't get rid of the disqualification but it can mean you don't actually have to pay it back

0 coins

I didn't realize the waiver was separate from the appeal. So I could fight the disqualification AND separately argue I can't afford to pay it back even if I lose?

0 coins

exactly, two separate tracks. appeal says the overpayment was wrong to begin with. waiver says even if it was technically right, making me pay it back would be a hardship. you can pursue both at the same time

0 coins

the waiver option is real but document your financial situation carefully. ESD looks at your monthly income vs expenses and whether repayment would leave you unable to meet basic needs. be thorough and honest in that documentation

0 coins

Just a practical thing - make sure you're keeping your records organized as you go through this. Create a folder (physical or digital) with: the original overpayment notice, all correspondence with ESD, your offer letters from both jobs, your old pay stubs, your weekly claim confirmation numbers from the period in question, and notes from any phone calls including the date, time, who you spoke with and what they said. If this goes to a hearing those call notes can actually matter.

0 coins

Starting that folder today. The call notes thing is something I never would have thought of - I'll start keeping a log immediately.

0 coins

screenshot your eServices account pages too - the weekly claim history, the payment history, all of it. sometimes things get updated in the system during an appeal process and having the original view documented can be useful

0 coins

also note the date on every piece of paper ESD sends you, the date you received it, and when you responded. timeline documentation has saved people in hearings

0 coins

I want to circle back to something earlier in this thread - the two separate issues in one notice thing. In my experience with ESD you're better off addressing each one explicitly and separately in your appeal letter rather than writing one general appeal. Like, literally label them: Issue 1 - Refusal of Suitable Work, then your argument. Issue 2 - Benefit Payments After New Job Acceptance, then your argument. Appeals reviewers deal with a lot of paperwork and making their job easier by being organized actually helps your case.

0 coins

Formatting the appeal with separate sections for each issue - that's genuinely useful advice. I was going to write it as one narrative but separating it out makes more sense.

0 coins

the narrative approach works for some people but for a two-issue case being structured helps make sure neither issue gets glossed over. you can still tell your story within each section

0 coins

agree with the structured approach. also put your contact information and claim number at the top of every page. sounds basic but appeals offices deal with a lot of paper and your pages can get separated

0 coins

Washington Unemployment AI

Expert Assistant
Secure