Back to Washington Unemployment

Zoe Papanikolaou

Unemployment overpayment after skipping identity verification appeal no response - Washington ESD help

So I'm in a genuinely bizarre situation and I need to figure out what my options are. Back in the spring I was filing weekly claims and there was a point where Washington ESD flagged my account for identity verification through ID.me. I saw the notification but honestly I panicked about it - I'd heard stories about people's accounts getting locked during ID.me and I just kept filing my weekly claims without completing the verification step thinking maybe it would just... resolve itself? It didn't. Fast forward a few months and I got hit with an overpayment notice for roughly $6,800 covering about 11 weeks of benefits. ESD is saying the payments during that unverified period are now considered invalid because I never completed the verification they required. I filed an appeal right away - sent it in writing, certified mail, the whole thing. That was going on 7 weeks ago now. My online account still shows the overpayment balance with no updates, no hearing scheduled, no correspondence from them at all. I've tried calling the main ESD line probably 15 times. Got through twice - once I was on hold for 47 minutes and then it disconnected me. The second time I actually spoke to someone who told me my appeal was 'in the system' but couldn't tell me anything about timeline or status. I sent two follow-up messages through the online portal and nothing. My worry is that while I'm waiting in this appeal limbo, the overpayment is somehow accruing interest or they're going to refer it to collections without warning me. Can anyone who's dealt with an overpayment appeal in this situation tell me what the actual process looks like from here? Am I just stuck waiting indefinitely?

Your certified mail approach was the right call - having proof of when you filed matters a lot here. The thing about your specific situation that actually works somewhat in your favor is the timeline of when ESD sent the ID.me notice versus when they actually flagged the payments. If they let those weekly claims process for weeks after the verification request without stopping them, that's worth raising in your appeal because it goes to whether the overpayment is really your fault or partly an administrative issue on their end. The formal term for that kind of argument is 'without fault' and it can affect whether they waive the overpayment entirely rather than just setting up a repayment plan.

0 coins

Went back through my account history and you're right - they kept processing my weekly claims for almost 6 weeks after the initial ID.me notification. I didn't even realize they had that much documentation of the lag time. That does feel like it strengthens the argument that I wasn't the only one dropping the ball here.

0 coins

This without fault argument is real, I used something similar when I had an adjudication issue. The key is documenting the specific dates when ESD sent notices versus when payments went out - if there's a big gap that's meaningful.

0 coins

wait does the without fault thing mean they cancel the whole amount or just reduce it? asking bc im in a similar spot

0 coins

Seven weeks with zero update on an appeal is unfortunately pretty normal for Washington ESD right now - their hearings office is backed up. But the collections concern you raised is legitimate. While an appeal is pending, ESD is supposed to hold collection activity, but that only works if your appeal was properly received and logged. The fact that one agent confirmed it's 'in the system' is something, but you really need written confirmation. The overpayment doesn't accrue interest in the traditional sense while appealing but there can be offsets against future benefits.

0 coins

Dug out my certified mail receipt and the tracking shows it was delivered to their appeals office. I didn't get any written acknowledgment from them though which is what worries me - just that one verbal confirmation from the phone agent.

0 coins

ESD is notoriously bad at sending acknowledgment letters for appeals. I filed one last year and never got a confirmation letter but my appeal was still processed. The delivery confirmation from certified mail is actually sufficient proof.

0 coins

the collections hold during appeal is real but its not automatic in every case i think it depends on how the overpayment was classified

0 coins

After spending three weeks trying to get through to anyone at ESD about my own overpayment situation I finally tried Claimyr and it was the first time I actually reached a live agent without sitting on hold for hours. You can check it out at claimyr.com - there's a video demo at https://youtu.be/7DieNd3C7zQ that shows how it works. For your situation specifically you need to talk to someone who can pull up your appeal record and confirm in writing that collection is actually on hold - that's not something you can resolve through the portal alone.

0 coins

Bookmarked the video - honestly at this point I'll try anything. The portal messages just sit there with no response and the phone situation has been exhausting.

0 coins

I was skeptical about stuff like this but a friend used it when her adjudication was stuck and she said it was the only way she got an actual answer about her claim status. Might be worth a shot given how long you've been waiting.

0 coins

does it work for appeals specifically or just regular claim issues

0 coins

It just gets you through to an ESD agent - what you ask them about is up to you. Appeals, claim status, adjudication, overpayments, whatever you need to discuss.

0 coins

The identity verification piece of your situation is actually pretty significant. ESD's position when they issue overpayments related to ID.me failures is usually that benefits paid during an unverified period are considered 'improperly paid' rather than fraudulently obtained, which is an important distinction. For your appeal, you'll want to specifically address that you did receive the notification but that you encountered confusion about the process - that framing matters because it positions this as a good faith issue rather than willful avoidance.

0 coins

That framing distinction actually helps me think about how I wrote my appeal letter. I was pretty direct about saying I saw the notice but didn't complete it, which I think is better than trying to claim I never saw it - that would have been dishonest and probably contradicted by their records anyway.

0 coins

Honesty in the appeal is definitely the right call. ESD can see exactly when you logged in and what notifications were visible to your account. Anyone who tries to claim they never saw something that's clearly in the account activity log is going to have a bad time at the hearing.

0 coins

what happens at the actual hearing though, is it like a real court thing or more informal

0 coins

ok so i went through almost the exact same thing last fall - ID.me notice, kept filing anyway, got slammed with an overpayment demand for like $5,200. What I found out the hard way is that the appeals process for overpayments has two distinct stages and most people don't know about the first one. There's an administrative review that happens before the actual OAH hearing, and sometimes cases get resolved at that stage without ever going to a full hearing. No one explained this to me until I was already scheduled for the OAH.

0 coins

Two stages - I genuinely did not know that. Did your case get resolved at the administrative review or did it go all the way to OAH?

0 coins

Mine went all the way to the OAH hearing but they did reduce the overpayment amount at the administrative review stage. So even that partial step was worth something.

0 coins

This is accurate. The administrative review is basically ESD reviewing their own decision before it goes to an independent hearing officer. Some people skip requesting it because they don't know it exists but it can actually be faster.

0 coins

Something that might help while you're waiting - the Office of Administrative Hearings has a separate contact from the main ESD line, and you can reach out to them directly to check on your hearing status once an appeal has been filed. A lot of people spend all their energy trying to reach ESD when for the appeals tracking piece, OAH is actually the right place to call.

0 coins

Looked up the OAH contact information and realized I had been calling the main ESD number this whole time. Going to try the OAH line tomorrow - appreciate the redirect.

0 coins

OAH is way easier to reach than the main ESD line in my experience. They also have an online case lookup for some claim types which is worth checking first.

0 coins

seconded on this, OAH was responsive when i had my appeal and ESD proper was completely unreachable

0 coins

The interest question you asked is one I had to research when I was in a similar spot. Washington ESD doesn't charge interest on overpayment balances the way a credit card would, but if the overpayment goes uncollected for a long time and gets referred to the Department of Revenue for collection, there can be fees and penalties added at that stage. While your appeal is pending that referral shouldn't happen, but the operative word is 'shouldn't' - ESD's systems don't always communicate perfectly with each other.

0 coins

The Department of Revenue referral is exactly what I've been afraid of. Good to know it shouldn't happen during appeal but I'm now even more motivated to get confirmation that my appeal is properly logged and the hold is in place.

0 coins

If ESD ever does wrongly refer something to DOR while an appeal is pending, that's actually a strong basis for a complaint and they typically unwind it pretty quickly when you can show you have an active appeal on file.

0 coins

has anyone had ESD mess up and send something to DOR while an appeal was open? wondering if thats actually a real risk

0 coins

My sister dealt with an overpayment appeal for almost four months with radio silence and ended up using Claimyr to finally get through to an ESD agent who could actually access her appeal file. She said the agent she reached was able to send her an internal status note which gave her something in writing. The site is claimyr.com if you want to look into it - getting that written confirmation of your appeal status and the collection hold seems like the most urgent thing right now.

0 coins

Four months - that's honestly terrifying but also kind of reassuring that it's survivable. Written confirmation is definitely the goal at this point, not even a resolution just proof of where things stand.

0 coins

written confirmation is huge, even just an email from an agent stating the appeal is logged and collection is on hold changes your whole position if anything weird happens later

0 coins

Filing an appeal in writing via certified mail was smart but there's one more step a lot of people miss. When you filed, did you also upload the appeal to your ESD online account portal as a document? A lot of claimants do one or the other but not both, and ESD recommends doing both so there are two records. If you only sent physical mail, worth uploading a copy now with a note about the original filing date.

0 coins

Genuinely did not upload it to the portal. Doing that right now while reading this. Is it too late for that to be useful even though it was 7 weeks ago?

0 coins

Not too late at all - upload it with a document title that includes the original mailing date. It just adds a secondary record and shows you're engaged with the process.

0 coins

Yeah the portal upload as backup is good practice for literally everything you send ESD. Physical mail is proof of sending, portal upload is proof they have it in your digital file.

0 coins

ok this might be a dumb question but does it matter that the overpayment was because of the identity verification thing specifically versus like some other reason? like do they treat ID.me related overpayments differently than say if you forgot to report earnings

0 coins

Not a dumb question at all. Your particular situation with the ID.me timing actually does have its own nuance. If your income and eligibility were otherwise valid during those weeks - meaning you were unemployed, meeting job search requirements, all that - then the only issue was the verification step itself. That's a different situation than an overpayment where the underlying eligibility was wrong. ESD can in theory reinstate those benefits if the verification is eventually completed, though that process is complicated.

0 coins

This is an important point. Some people in this situation have been able to complete the ID.me verification retroactively and have the overpayment reclassified. It doesn't always work but it's worth asking about explicitly in your appeal or when you reach an agent.

0 coins

oh interesting so the verification completion could actually be part of the solution not just the appeal process itself

0 coins

Not to pile on but I want to mention the job search requirement angle too. During the period you were filing without completing verification, were you maintaining your job search log? If you get to a hearing and you have solid documentation that you were actually eligible during those weeks - actively job searching, available for work, the whole thing - that strengthens the without fault argument considerably.

0 coins

My job search log from that period is actually really thorough - I was applying to multiple positions a week and kept everything documented in a spreadsheet. Pulling that together as supplemental evidence for the appeal hearing sounds like a smart move.

0 coins

Exactly. At the hearing the question is partly about what the technical violation was but also whether you were actually eligible otherwise. Strong job search records make the case that the only issue was an administrative step, not actual ineligibility.

0 coins

wait you have to prove job search activity going back months? thats stressful i never thought about keeping records for that long

0 coins

seven weeks with no word is SO frustrating, i waited almost that long for an adjudication decision on a completely different issue and i swear the lack of communication is the worst part, not even the actual outcome just not knowing

0 coins

Not knowing is genuinely the hardest part. If they told me it would take 6 more months I could plan around that. The uncertainty makes everything harder.

0 coins

The not-knowing is deliberate though is the thing - ESD's system just doesn't have good notification infrastructure so appeals fall into a black hole until something happens. It's a real failure of the system.

0 coins

Something worth knowing about the actual OAH hearing if it gets that far - hearings for overpayment appeals are usually done by phone, not in person. You'll get a letter with the date and time and a phone number to call. The hearing officer will ask you to explain your side, ESD will have a representative, and you can present documents. It's less formal than a courtroom but more structured than a casual conversation. Preparing your timeline in writing beforehand makes a huge difference.

0 coins

Preparing a written timeline is something I can start now regardless of when the hearing is scheduled. Having the ID.me notification date, the weeks benefits processed, the overpayment notice date, appeal filing date all laid out clearly seems like a smart approach.

0 coins

Phone hearings move faster than you expect and having your documents in front of you organized is essential. I've seen people lose hearings they should have won just because they couldn't quickly reference the right date or amount when asked.

0 coins

is there any benefit to getting a lawyer for the OAH hearing or is that overkill for an overpayment appeal

0 coins

On the lawyer question someone asked - you don't need one but you can bring representation. For overpayment appeals, there are legal aid organizations in Washington that help with ESD hearings at no cost if you meet income guidelines. Northwest Justice Project is one that handles these. Given $6,800 is at stake it might be worth at least a consultation.

0 coins

Northwest Justice Project - adding that to my list of things to look into. At $6,800 even a free consultation to make sure I'm approaching this correctly seems worth pursuing.

0 coins

Northwest Justice Project is legit, they helped someone in my family with an ESD appeal. They're stretched thin so contact them early rather than waiting until you have a hearing date.

0 coins

didnt know legal aid covered ESD stuff thats actually really useful information

0 coins

The claimyr.com tool kept coming up when I was dealing with my own ESD situation and I finally tried it after weeks of failed calls. Got through to an agent who was able to actually read me the status notes on my claim from their internal system - stuff that wasn't visible in my online portal at all. For your situation with the appeal, there's apparently an internal notes field that agents can see which shows appeal processing stages, and that's information you can't get any other way except by talking to someone. Video demo is at https://youtu.be/7DieNd3C7zQ if you want to see how it works first.

0 coins

Internal notes that aren't visible in the portal is exactly the kind of thing I've been missing. The portal just shows the overpayment balance with no status updates at all, so there might be a lot happening that I simply can't see from my end.

0 coins

Agents having access to information the portal doesn't show is actually a common source of confusion - claimants think nothing is happening because the portal doesn't update, but there can be review activity that only shows internally.

0 coins

ugh this explains why my portal was showing nothing for weeks and then suddenly a decision appeared with no warning

0 coins

Going back to the without fault argument that was raised early in the thread - the specific piece that matters for your situation is whether completing the ID.me verification now, retroactively, would change ESD's position. Some people have successfully argued that the overpayment should be waived rather than repaid when they can show they were otherwise fully eligible and the only failure was the verification step. This is different from just having the overpayment reduced in a payment plan.

0 coins

Waiver versus repayment plan is a distinction I hadn't fully understood. Waiver would obviously be the ideal outcome here if I was otherwise eligible. Is that something to request specifically in writing to ESD before the hearing or is it part of the hearing itself?

0 coins

You can request waiver consideration as part of your appeal - actually frame it in those terms explicitly. If it's not already in your original appeal letter, you can submit a supplemental statement before your hearing date adding that you're requesting waiver consideration based on your otherwise valid eligibility during the period.

0 coins

Supplemental statements are allowed up to a certain point before the hearing date, usually within a few days, so there's time to add this to your record even now.

0 coins

I noticed nobody mentioned the possibility of requesting an expedited review if financial hardship is a factor. When I was stuck in overpayment limbo I finally got Claimyr and reached an agent who explained that if you can demonstrate the overpayment demand is causing financial hardship, you can request that the appeal be expedited in the queue. It doesn't always work but it moved mine up. The agent I spoke with also flagged that my collection hold was actually not properly noted on my account and fixed it on the spot - exactly the kind of thing you can't discover without talking to someone.

0 coins

Financial hardship expedited review - that's something I could genuinely document. The uncertainty about $6,800 has absolutely affected my ability to plan financially. I didn't know that was a lever I could pull.

0 coins

The hardship expedite request is real. It's not guaranteed but it creates a paper trail showing you proactively engaged rather than just waiting, which also helps if anything goes sideways later.

0 coins

and the fact that collection holds can not be properly noted is alarming but also important to know - another reason to actually get a human on the phone to verify rather than trusting the portal

0 coins

kinda scared now bc i got an ID.me notice a couple weeks ago and was putting it off because i wasnt sure how to do it and now reading this thread im realizing i should probably just do it immediately before i end up in this situation

0 coins

Please go complete it - I'm living proof that putting it off is not a strategy. The ID.me process is clunky but it only takes 15-30 minutes and it's infinitely better than dealing with the aftermath.

0 coins

ID.me verification is definitely something to do immediately when ESD requests it. The process can have technical hiccups so do it on a desktop if possible and have your ID documents ready. Don't put it off.

0 coins

set aside an hour and do it on a weekday during daylight hours, some of the ID.me verification paths work better then, the system can be buggy late at night

0 coins

following this thread bc my situation is different but also involves an overpayment and i feel like im learning more here than from anything ESD has actually communicated to me directly which is kind of embarrassing for them

0 coins

ESD's claimant communication has always been pretty weak honestly. Important information gets buried in letters written in bureaucratic language or just never sent at all. Forums like this are where people actually learn what's happening.

0 coins

same, I've figured out more about how my own claim works from other people's posts than from anything ESD ever told me

0 coins

Final thought on your situation - when you do eventually get to your hearing or reach an agent who can discuss the substance, make sure you specifically ask about the difference between a formal waiver determination and an informal payment plan offer. ESD sometimes tries to resolve things by offering affordable repayment terms, which sounds good but it means you're accepting you owe the money. Waiver is a separate determination that could eliminate the balance entirely if the without fault standard is met.

0 coins

This distinction is exactly the kind of thing I would have stumbled into if I hadn't been doing this research. Accepting a repayment plan without first pursuing waiver would be a significant mistake if waiver is actually available to me. Really glad that's clear before I talk to anyone.

0 coins

Exactly right. If an agent offers you a repayment arrangement before your hearing, you're not obligated to accept it. You can acknowledge the conversation and say you're continuing with your appeal before making any decisions about repayment.

0 coins

This is worth repeating clearly - accepting any repayment terms before the appeal is decided can be interpreted as admitting the debt is valid. Keep the appeal process moving and don't let anyone pressure you into a repayment arrangement before you've had the waiver question addressed.

0 coins

Washington Unemployment AI

Expert Assistant
Secure