< Back to Washington Unemployment

Lower-paying job offer - do I have to accept it to keep ESD benefits?

I just got some news that I'm both happy and stressed about. After being on unemployment for 3 months, I finally got a job offer! But here's the problem - it pays only 45% of what my previous position paid ($28/hr vs $62/hr before), and they want me to work 6 days a week instead of 5. I'm really struggling with this decision. If I turn it down, will ESD consider this refusing suitable work? Will my benefits be reduced or cut off completely? I know there's some rule about not having to accept work that's way below your previous wage, but I'm not sure what the threshold is. Has anyone dealt with this situation before? My savings are getting low but I'm afraid taking this job will actually put me further behind financially than staying on unemployment while I search for something more comparable to my previous position.

Caden Nguyen

•

This is a common question, and the answer depends on how long you've been receiving benefits. ESD uses a "tiered suitable work" approach. During the first 10 weeks of unemployment, you're generally not required to accept work that pays less than 90% of your previous wage. After 10 weeks, that drops to 80%, and after 20 weeks, it drops to 70%. Since you've been unemployed for 3 months (about 12-13 weeks), you'd likely fall into that second tier. A job offering only 45% of your previous wage could reasonably be considered not suitable work at this point. If you decline the offer, document exactly why (the significant pay reduction and increased workdays). Report the refusal on your weekly claim and be prepared to explain during adjudication why it wasn't suitable. Keep detailed records of the offer - date, company, position, pay rate, hours, etc.

0 coins

Harper Hill

•

Thank you SO much for this detailed explanation! I had no idea about the tiered approach. So since I'm at the 12-week mark, I shouldn't have to accept anything below 80% of my previous wage? That gives me some relief. I'll definitely document everything like you suggested. I'm still actively applying for jobs in my field that are closer to my previous salary.

0 coins

Avery Flores

•

BE CAREFUL!!! I turned down a job offer last year cuz it was way less than i was making before and ESD cut off my benefits for 8 WEEKS!!! They said I refused "suitable work" and put my account into adjudication. I appealed but still lost. It took FOREVER to get things sorted out and I nearly got evicted while waiting!!

0 coins

Harper Hill

•

Oh no, that's exactly what I'm worried about! Did you explain to them about the pay difference? Did you have any documentation about the job offer? I'm wondering if there were specific details in your case that led to that decision.

0 coins

Avery Flores

•

Yeah I told them but they didnt care. The job was like 35% less pay but they said since I was on benefits for like 6 months already I had to take it. I think its different in the first few weeks vs later on. I didn't have anything in writing tho, just a verbal offer so maybe thats why I lost.

0 coins

Zoe Gonzalez

•

The previous responses are partially correct, but let me clarify exactly how this works according to ESD guidelines: 1. During the first 10 weeks of your claim, suitable work is considered 90% or more of your previous wages 2. Weeks 11-20, suitable work is 80% or more of your previous wages 3. After 20 weeks, suitable work is 70% or more of your previous wages At 45% of your previous wage, you have valid grounds to refuse this offer at your current stage (12 weeks). However, you MUST report the job offer and your refusal on your weekly claim. Be specific about the wage differential and the increased work days. The key is how you document and report this. Don't just decline and say nothing - this will likely trigger a disqualification. Instead, be proactive: 1. Get the job offer in writing if possible 2. Calculate the exact percentage difference in wages 3. Note the change in work schedule (5 days to 6 days) 4. Report the refusal with these specific details 5. Continue your job search activities and document them thoroughly If ESD questions your refusal, you'll need to request an adjudication interview to explain your situation.

0 coins

Harper Hill

•

This is incredibly helpful, thank you! I'll make sure to report everything properly on my weekly claim. The offer came via email, so I do have it in writing with all the details. I'm assuming I should upload that as supporting documentation? Also, do you know if I'll still need to continue with my regular job search activities (3 per week) while this is being sorted out?

0 coins

Zoe Gonzalez

•

Yes, definitely upload the email offer as documentation - that will be crucial evidence. And absolutely continue with your 3 job search activities per week without interruption. Any gap in your job search documentation could create additional issues with your claim. Even while an adjudication is pending, you must meet all other ESD requirements to maintain eligibility.

0 coins

Ashley Adams

•

ive been on unemployment 4 times in my life and the rules change all the time lol. my brother in law just went thru something like this last month and ended up taking the job cuz his benefits were about to run out anyway. but ya know what, he found a better job 3 weeks later! sometimes u just gotta do what u gotta do

0 coins

Harper Hill

•

That's a good point - this doesn't have to be a permanent decision either way. I guess it's about weighing the immediate financial needs against the long-term career impact. Thanks for sharing your brother-in-law's experience!

0 coins

Alexis Robinson

•

When I had issues with my claim last year and needed to speak with an ESD agent about a similar situation, I used Claimyr (claimyr.com) to get through to an agent right away instead of waiting for weeks. They have a video showing how it works: https://youtu.be/7DieNd3C7zQ?si=26TzE_zGms-DODN3 It really helped me get specific answers about my situation rather than guessing about the rules. In your case, I'd suggest speaking directly with an ESD representative to get official guidance on your specific situation before you make a decision. The rules have nuances that might apply to your particular circumstances.

0 coins

Harper Hill

•

I've never heard of this service before! I've been trying to get through to ESD for days with no luck. I'll check out the video - thanks for the suggestion. It would definitely help to get an official answer rather than risking my benefits.

0 coins

Aaron Lee

•

I used this too when my account got flagged for identity verification. Saved me like 2 weeks of stress probably. Worth it just to know exactly where you stand.

0 coins

Chloe Mitchell

•

Have you calculated what your actual take-home would be with this new job versus staying on unemployment? Factor in extra transportation costs for the 6th day, potential childcare issues, etc. Sometimes the numbers aren't what they first appear when you do the full calculation.

0 coins

Harper Hill

•

That's a really good point I hadn't fully considered. With the extra commute day and childcare costs, it might actually be even worse financially than just the raw salary numbers suggest. I'll sit down and make a detailed comparison tonight. Thank you!

0 coins

Zoe Gonzalez

•

One additional point that hasn't been mentioned: If you're receiving UI benefits, you're required to be actively seeking suitable work. Make sure you're documenting ALL your job search activities thoroughly each week (minimum 3 per week). This becomes especially important if you're declining an offer. ESD will want to see that you're making genuine efforts to find work that is suitable for your skills and wage history.

0 coins

Harper Hill

•

I've definitely been keeping detailed records of my job search activities - applying to at least 5 positions each week and attending networking events too. I'm using the ESD job search log to document everything. I really am trying to find appropriate work, not just turning down offers!

0 coins

Aaron Lee

•

ppl forget that state law says a job has to be "suitable" not just any random job!! my case worker told me its not just about wages its also about hours and distance and if it matches ur skills. dont let them bully u into taking something way below ur worth!

0 coins

Caden Nguyen

•

Based on everything in this thread, I think your best approach is to: 1. Document the offer completely 2. Report it accurately on your weekly claim 3. Be prepared to explain specifically why it doesn't meet the 80% threshold at your current stage 4. Try to speak directly with an ESD representative for clarity (using Claimyr or other means to get through) 5. Continue your job search efforts at the same or increased intensity The system is designed to help people find suitable employment, not force them into jobs that represent a major regression in their career or financial stability. Just make sure you follow all the proper procedures so your benefits remain protected.

0 coins

Harper Hill

•

Thank you so much for summarizing everything. I feel much more confident about how to handle this situation now. I'll report everything properly and try to speak with an ESD rep directly to make sure I'm following the correct process.

0 coins

TaxRefund AI

Expert Assistant
Secure

Powered by Claimyr AI

T
I
+
6,865 users helped today