How to appeal ESD disqualification for not looking for work while furloughed
Got hit with a disqualification notice last week and I'm still kind of in shock. Some background: I was furloughed from my warehouse job back in January, fully expecting to be called back within a few weeks. My supervisor actually told me not to bother job searching because they'd have us back before March. So I filed my weekly claims, answered the job search questions honestly saying I was on standby, but I never got approved for standby status through ESD. I just assumed my situation was obvious enough that it wouldn't matter. Fast forward to now — ESD reviewed my claim and disqualified me for failing to meet job search requirements during the furlough period. They say I needed to be applying to at least three jobs per week the whole time. The notice showed I was receiving benefits for about 11 weeks without documented job search activity, and now they're saying I may also owe back some of what I was paid. I genuinely didn't know standby had to be formally requested and approved before you could skip the job search requirement. My employer never told me and nobody at ESD ever flagged it while I was filing. Has anyone actually appealed one of these disqualifications and won? What documentation do I even need to put together? I have emails from my supervisor saying I'd be called back, would that help at all?
68 comments

Kelsey Hawkins
30 days from the mailing date on that notice — that's the window you have to file your appeal before ESD treats the disqualification as final. A lot of people miss this because they spend the first two weeks panicking and then realize they're almost out of time. The appeal goes through the Office of Administrative Hearings, not back to ESD directly. You fill out the appeal form on the ESD website or you can mail/fax it, but honestly submitting online through your eServices account is the fastest way to get it documented with a timestamp. For your specific situation, the supervisor emails are genuinely useful. What you're trying to show at the hearing is that you had a reasonable belief you were on a temporary layoff with a definite return date — that's a different factual picture than someone who just didn't bother looking. The hearing examiner will want to see the timeline: when the furlough started, what you were told, and any written communication confirming the recall expectation. Pull together anything you have — texts, emails, even a written statement from your supervisor if they're willing.
0 coins
Harper Collins
AuthorChecked my notice just now and the mailing date is showing February 14th, so I'm cutting it close. Filing through eServices tonight. Do I need to have all my documentation uploaded at the time I submit the appeal or can I add it later before the actual hearing?
0 coins
Dylan Fisher
You can add documentation after you file — the hearing itself usually gets scheduled several weeks out and they give you a deadline to submit evidence before that date. File first, gather everything second.
0 coins
Edwards Hugo
wait does faxing actually still work for ESD lol i thought that was like a 2003 thing
0 coins
Gianna Scott
Claimyr got me through to an actual ESD agent in under an hour when I was dealing with my own disqualification last year. The regular phone line was giving me busy signals or disconnecting after 45 minutes on hold basically every time I tried. With Claimyr at claimyr.com they handle the hold queue and call you back when an agent is on the line — there's a demo video at https://youtu.be/7DieNd3C7zQ that shows how it works. Worth it just to get a real person to explain exactly what triggered the disqualification on your account before your hearing, because sometimes the ESD rep can tell you things about your file that aren't spelled out in the notice letter.
0 coins
Harper Collins
AuthorMy cousin mentioned something like this existed. The notice I got is pretty vague about which specific weeks triggered it — knowing that before the hearing would actually help me a lot.
0 coins
Alfredo Lugo
second this, talking to an agent before your hearing is underrated. they can sometimes tell you if there are notes in the system about your claim that you wouldn't otherwise know about
0 coins
Sydney Torres
does the agent have any power to actually reverse the disqualification or are they just informational at that point
0 coins
Kaitlyn Jenkins
The standby status piece is really the crux of your appeal argument. Formal standby through ESD means your employer actually files paperwork with ESD certifying the layoff is temporary and the recall date — it's not something the claimant can just self-declare. When that's properly set up, ESD waives the weekly job search requirement automatically. What happened to you happens a lot: employer tells workers informally 'don't worry about it' but never completes the standby application on their end. If you can get your former employer to submit a statement or letter confirming they intended it as a temporary furlough with an expected recall date, that corroborates your side of the story even if the formal standby was never filed. It won't automatically fix the technical violation but it goes a long way toward showing you acted in good faith rather than just ignoring the requirement.
0 coins
Harper Collins
AuthorMy employer did eventually call me back, so they're on decent terms with me. I'll reach out and ask if they'd write something up. Is there a specific format ESD wants for that kind of statement or just a letter on company letterhead?
0 coins
Kaitlyn Jenkins
No specific form required — a signed letter on company letterhead stating the furlough dates, the expectation of recall, and confirmation that you were told not to job search is sufficient. The more specific the better, actual dates rather than vague language.
0 coins
Caleb Bell
your employer not filing the standby paperwork is kind of on them and you got the consequences, that's genuinely unfair
0 coins
Danielle Campbell
Three things the hearing examiner is going to focus on: whether you knew or should have known about the job search requirement, whether you took any steps to verify your exemption status, and whether the disqualification period is accurate. On that third one — go through your weekly claim history in eServices and cross-reference which weeks you actually claimed. Sometimes ESD miscounts the weeks in disqualification notices, and catching an error like that can reduce what you potentially owe.
0 coins
Harper Collins
AuthorPulled up my eServices history and the dates on the notice don't quite match what I'm seeing — there are two weeks where I didn't actually claim any benefits but they seem to be included in the disqualification window. Definitely flagging that.
0 coins
Rhett Bowman
good catch on checking the dates, i had an overpayment notice once where they included a week i had already paid back and it took forever to sort out
0 coins
Edwards Hugo
does pointing out their math error make them look at everything more closely though? like could it make things worse
0 coins
Abigail Patel
Filed my appeal for a similar situation eight months ago and won. Furloughed from a restaurant, same story — boss said we'd all be back when things picked up, never told me about formal standby. What actually made the difference at my hearing was a text message chain with my manager that showed the specific dates she told me not to look for work. Screenshots printed out and submitted as exhibits. The hearing examiner specifically cited those texts in the written decision. Also: the OAH hearings are conducted by phone now for most cases. You'll get a notice with the call-in information. Don't miss that call — if you're not on the line when they start, they can rule against you by default.
0 coins
Harper Collins
AuthorText screenshots — I actually have those too, didn't even think of them as evidence. Grabbing those right now.
0 coins
Daniel White
wait they do the hearings by phone?? i thought you had to go in person, that's actually way less stressful
0 coins
Alfredo Lugo
the default ruling thing is real, set three alarms for that call time
0 coins
Nolan Carter
something to know: the burden of proof at these unemployment hearings is on ESD to show you didn't meet the requirements, not on you to prove you did. people go in thinking they have to prove their innocence and that's not exactly how it works. you should absolutely present your evidence but understanding that ESD has to affirmatively establish the disqualification can change how you frame your responses during the hearing.
0 coins
Harper Collins
AuthorNobody told me that before, that actually reframes how I'm thinking about this. So if ESD can't produce documentation that I was notified of the job search requirement during the furlough period, that works in my favor?
0 coins
Nolan Carter
Exactly. If their own records don't show you were informed, that weakens their case. Ask during the hearing whether ESD sent any written communication specifically advising you of the job search requirement during the period in question.
0 coins
Natalia Stone
this is genuinely useful information not enough people know this going into hearings
0 coins
Tasia Synder
Used Claimyr when I needed to get through to ESD about my appeal status — the hold times on the main line were absolutely brutal, like two hours minimum and then getting disconnected. The service calls you back once an agent is available, check out claimyr.com or the walkthrough video at https://youtu.be/7DieNd3C7zQ. For your situation I'd use it specifically to ask an agent to read you the notes on your claim, because there may be flags or comments in your file from when you were filing weekly that could either help or hurt you at the hearing and you want to know about them before you walk in.
0 coins
Caleb Bell
the 'know what's in your file before the hearing' advice is solid regardless of how you get through to them
0 coins
Sydney Torres
is there like a specific thing to say to get them to read you the notes or do they just volunteer that
0 coins
Natalia Stone
never knew you could even ask for that, calling tomorrow
0 coins
Selena Bautista
One thing that tripped me up when I was appealing my own disqualification: ESD may try to introduce your weekly claim certification responses as evidence. When you answer the weekly questions, you're certifying under penalty of perjury. So if you answered that you met job search requirements during weeks you didn't apply anywhere, that becomes part of their evidence. Be prepared to address why you answered the way you did — in your case the honest answer is probably that you misunderstood what the standby exception required.
0 coins
Harper Collins
AuthorGoing back through my old weekly certifications now. Some weeks I marked that I met the job search requirement and others I left it ambiguous — I genuinely wasn't sure what I was supposed to answer given what my employer told me.
0 coins
Selena Bautista
That ambiguity actually helps you a little. Consistent answers either way would look more deliberate. Inconsistency suggests you were uncertain and acting in good faith rather than knowingly falsifying.
0 coins
Mohamed Anderson
this is the kind of nuance you really want to have sorted out before the hearing, not figuring it out on the fly
0 coins
Ellie Perry
Documentation checklist for your appeal packet before the hearing: supervisor's written statement on company letterhead, all text message and email exchanges about the furlough and recall expectation, your eServices weekly claim history printed or saved, the original disqualification notice, and any prior written communication you received from ESD during the claim period. If ESD ever sent you letters or emails during the furlough weeks, include those too — if they never mentioned job search requirements in any of their correspondence, that's a gap in their case.
0 coins
Harper Collins
AuthorSaved this comment. This is the clearest list I've seen anywhere. The ESD correspondence piece is smart — I have zero emails from them during those 11 weeks beyond the standard 'your payment has been processed' notices.
0 coins
Rhett Bowman
those generic payment confirmation emails might actually matter — they knew you were claiming and said nothing about job search, that's a reasonable thing to point to
0 coins
Dylan Fisher
also save or screenshot literally everything before the hearing date in case anything changes in your eServices account
0 coins
Landon Morgan
Claimyr was the only way I actually got through to ESD after my disqualification notice — spent three days trying the regular line and kept hitting 'we cannot take your call at this time.' Go to claimyr.com and check the demo at https://youtu.be/7DieNd3C7zQ if you're not sure how it works. The agent I eventually talked to confirmed that in my file there was a notation that my employer had contacted ESD about standby but never completed the actual form submission, which was crucial context for my hearing. Wouldn't have known that without getting through to someone.
0 coins
Daniel White
your employer started the standby application but didn't finish it?? that's such a specific thing to discover and it completely changes the story
0 coins
Landon Morgan
Right — and the hearing examiner found it very relevant that the employer had initiated the process even if it wasn't completed. It showed the furlough was intended to be a qualifying temporary layoff situation, just with a paperwork failure.
0 coins
Edwards Hugo
ok that's actually a compelling reason to call before the hearing and not just show up hoping for the best
0 coins
Natalia Stone
my coworker won her appeal for almost the exact same thing last year. the key phrase she kept using at the hearing was 'reasonable reliance on employer instruction' — she said her attorney prepped her with that framing and the examiner kept coming back to it in the written decision. don't know if that helps but it stuck with me
0 coins
Kelsey Hawkins
Reasonable' reliance is a recognized legal concept and'it s completely appropriate to use in this context. If a reasonable person in your position would have believed they were exempt based on what their employer told them, that cuts against an intentional violationfinding.
0 coins
Harper Collins
AuthorWriting that phrase down. The examiner in my hearing is going to hear those words multiple times.
0 coins
Caleb Bell
should OP get an actual lawyer for this or is that overkill for a UI appeal
0 coins
Rhett Bowman
something nobody mentioned: after you file the appeal, keep filing your weekly claims every single week while it's pending. Missing weekly claims during an appeal can create a whole separate problem with your benefit year, and if you win the appeal you'll want your continued claims on record for any back pay calculation.
0 coins
Harper Collins
AuthorWas literally about to stop filing because I figured what's the point while everything is frozen — glad I saw this.
0 coins
Alfredo Lugo
this is so important and so easy to forget when you're stressed about the appeal itself
0 coins
Sydney Torres
does ESD actually pay those weekly claims while the appeal is pending or do they just stack up<br>
0 coins
Mohamed Anderson
The overpayment question is separate from the disqualification appeal but they're connected. If you win the disqualification appeal entirely, the overpayment determination typically goes away with it. If you win partially — say the examiner reduces the number of weeks — the overpayment amount gets recalculated. And if you lose, you'll have a separate window to appeal the overpayment itself or request a waiver based on financial hardship. Don't pay anything back until the appeal process is fully exhausted.
0 coins
Harper Collins
AuthorReally needed to hear that last sentence. Got a letter about repayment and panicked, was wondering if I should just start paying to show good faith.
0 coins
Mohamed Anderson
No — paying doesn't help your appeal and it doesn't prevent them from ruling against you. Hold off until there's a final determination or you've explicitly negotiated a repayment plan.
0 coins
Kaitlyn Jenkins
the waiver option for overpayments is underused — if you ultimately do owe something and paying it back would cause genuine financial hardship, the waiver application is worth filing
0 coins
Dylan Fisher
Just want to add: hearing decisions come back in writing, usually within a few weeks of the hearing itself. The written decision will state the specific findings of fact and the legal basis for the ruling. Even if you lose, read it carefully — it tells you exactly what evidence the examiner found persuasive or not persuasive, which is valuable if you decide to pursue a second-level appeal to the Commissioner's Review Office.
0 coins
Harper Collins
AuthorDidn't know there was a second level of appeal above OAH. How long does that process take?
0 coins
Dylan Fisher
Commissioner's Review can take several months — it's a review of the OAH record, not a new hearing. And above that there's Superior Court, though that's rarely worth it unless the amount is very large or there's a clear legal error.
0 coins
Nolan Carter
the OAH hearing is where most people win or lose, putting all your effort there is the right call
0 coins
Caleb Bell
reading this whole thread as someone who just got a disqualification letter yesterday for a totally different reason and I'm spiraling a little. is the OAH process generally fair or is it basically always ruled in ESD's favor
0 coins
Kelsey Hawkins
Claimants win a meaningful percentage of UI appeals at OAH — it's not a rubber stamp for ESD. The hearing examiners are independent administrative judges. Outcomes depend heavily on whether you have documentation and show up prepared.
0 coins
Abigail Patel
Won mine, coworker won hers, the person starting this thread has a solid case. It's not impossible, go in prepared.
0 coins
Caleb Bell
ok that's genuinely reassuring thank you, going to read this whole thread again more carefully
0 coins
Daniel White
one thing i was confused about reading this: is a furlough the same as a layoff for ESD purposes or do they treat it differently
0 coins
Kaitlyn Jenkins
ESD treats a furlough as a temporary layoff — you're still eligible for UI benefits during a furlough. The issue in this thread isn't eligibility for benefits, it's specifically the job search requirement exemption, which requires formal standby status to waive.
0 coins
Daniel White
oh ok so the original problem wasn't that they got benefits they shouldn't have, it's that they got benefits without technically meeting the conditions attached to them
0 coins
Danielle Campbell
Exactly right. Benefits were legitimately payable — the disqualification is about the job search requirement specifically, not furlough eligibility itself. That distinction matters for the appeal argument.
0 coins
Alfredo Lugo
submitted my appeal two weeks ago for a job search disqualification (different circumstances than this thread) and the OAH acknowledged it within about five business days. If you don't get an acknowledgment email within a week of filing, follow up — occasionally submissions get stuck and you don't want to assume it went through.
0 coins
Harper Collins
AuthorFiled mine last night and got an automated confirmation email about an hour later with a case number. Assuming that means it went through successfully.
0 coins
Alfredo Lugo
Case number means you're in the system, that's what you want. Keep that email somewhere safe, that number is how you'll track everything going forward.
0 coins
Sydney Torres
does the case number let you check status online somewhere or do you have to call
0 coins