Back to Washington Unemployment

Emma Davis

ESD repayment letter fired for misconduct from first employer how to appeal

Got a repayment letter from Washington ESD last week demanding $4,850 back and I'm completely blindsided. Here's my situation - I was let go from my first job about 8 months ago and my employer listed the reason as 'misconduct' on their end. I genuinely disagreed with that characterization because what happened was I called in sick twice in one week without proper documentation and they terminated me. I still filed for unemployment, got approved, collected benefits for about 14 weeks, then picked up a second job which I'm still working now. Fast forward to now and ESD is saying I was never eligible because of the misconduct determination from that first employer and wants the full $4,850 back. The letter mentions an overpayment and gives me 20 days to respond or appeal. I had no idea the misconduct flag would come back like this months later - when I first filed they just approved me without any apparent issue. I'm a construction worker, so taking time off those two days was actually related to a minor injury (nothing workers comp worthy but definitely real). I didn't document it at the time and didn't think I needed to. Has anyone dealt with appealing a repayment/overpayment letter tied to a misconduct disqualification? Do I even have a chance here, especially since I already spent the benefits? I need to know what documentation to gather and whether the appeal process is worth pursuing.

Misconduct disqualification appeals are absolutely winnable - the threshold Washington ESD uses is actually pretty specific and a lot of employers misclassify terminations. The key distinction is whether your behavior showed 'willful disregard' for your employer's reasonable expectations. Missing work twice with a legitimate injury reason, even undocumented, doesn't automatically clear that bar for misconduct. You can argue that at the appeal hearing.

0 coins

That phrase 'willful disregard' - is that literally in the ESD documents or is that the standard they apply? I want to make sure I'm using the right framing if I write my appeal letter.

0 coins

ESD adjudicators and administrative law judges use it as the practical test. Look up RCW 50.04.294 - Washington's unemployment law defines misconduct and that concept is baked into how they evaluate cases. Your appeal letter doesn't need to quote it but knowing it helps you tell your story correctly.

0 coins

Injury at work even without workers comp documentation still counts as a legitimate reason. I'd get a note from a doctor now even if it's after the fact explaining the nature of what happened to you.

0 coins

20 days goes fast. Before anything else - check the postmark date on that letter, not the date you received it. ESD counts from when they mailed it, so you might have less time than you think to file your appeal.

0 coins

Mine was dated the 14th and I got it on the 18th so I'm already 4 days in. Filing online through the SAW portal - is that how most people do it or should I mail it?

0 coins

Online through your eServices account is fastest and you get a confirmation. Mailing adds risk because USPS delays don't stop the clock for ESD. Go digital if you can.

0 coins

Same thing bit me last year, letter sat in my mailbox over a weekend and I nearly missed the window. Online filing saved me.

0 coins

Reaching an actual ESD agent before you file your appeal is smart because they can tell you exactly what triggered the overpayment determination and whether there's additional documentation they need. Getting through on the phone is brutal though - tried for two weeks straight and kept hitting busy signals or getting disconnected mid-queue. Someone in another thread recommended Claimyr (claimyr.com) and I was skeptical but it actually got me connected to a live ESD agent within the same day. There's a demo at https://youtu.be/7DieNd3C7zQ if you want to see how it works before trying it. Knowing exactly what's in my claim file before I appealed made a huge difference.

0 coins

Two weeks of busy signals sounds like my nightmare. I've called three times already and gotten a 'call volume too high' message and hung up on. Will look into that option seriously.

0 coins

Phone connection to ESD is basically luck-based at this point. Anything that improves those odds is worth knowing about.

0 coins

Claimyr worked for me too when I had an adjudication issue. Got through in a few hours instead of days.

0 coins

Documentation strategy matters a lot here. What you're building is a case that your absences were not willful - gather anything that supports the injury: pharmacy receipts from that week, any texts to a coworker or supervisor mentioning you were hurt, your own work boots or gear if the injury was footwear-related, anything timestamped from that period. You're essentially reconstructing a paper trail after the fact and that's okay.

0 coins

Text messages to my site supervisor actually exist - I told him my back was messed up. Didn't think of that as evidence.

0 coins

Screenshot every single one with timestamps visible. That's potentially your strongest evidence because it shows contemporaneous communication about the injury, not something you're inventing now.

0 coins

Old texts saved my appeal on a totally different issue. Never underestimate what's sitting in your phone.

0 coins

Even a screenshot of a pain reliever purchase on your bank statement from those days could help paint the picture.

0 coins

I thought an overpayment letter meant the decision was already final and there was nothing left to do - held that belief for two months on my own situation before someone finally told me the appeal right survives. The 20-day clock to appeal the overpayment determination is separate from any earlier determination timeline. You still have standing to challenge the underlying misconduct finding even now.

0 coins

Wait - so I'm appealing both the misconduct classification AND the overpayment demand together? Or are those two separate filings?

0 coins

One appeal covers both. When you appeal the overpayment, you're inherently challenging the basis for it which is the misconduct disqualification. The Office of Administrative Hearings (OAH) judge will look at the whole picture.

0 coins

Confirm this - OAH handles these appeals, not ESD internally. That distinction matters because the OAH judge is independent and not part of ESD.

0 coins

Construction industry context matters here. Your employer labeling attendance issues as 'misconduct' rather than just cause without documentation is unfortunately common in trades. But ESD and OAH have seen this before. The burden actually shifts to your former employer at the hearing - they have to prove misconduct, you don't have to prove innocence.

0 coins

My former employer is a mid-size GC and they have HR. I'm worried they'll show up with documentation I don't have.

0 coins

Request your complete claim file from ESD before the hearing. It'll include whatever documentation your employer submitted during the initial claim process. Knowing what they filed tells you exactly what you're responding to.

0 coins

Employer burden of proof is real and many don't bother showing up to OAH hearings at all. Smaller contractors especially. Your GC might send HR but that actually sometimes backfires if they can't articulate the specific policy you violated.

0 coins

The repayment amount itself can sometimes be waived even if the disqualification stands, depending on circumstances. Washington has a provision where if you received benefits in good faith without knowing you were ineligible, a waiver of repayment can be requested. These are two different arguments - fight the misconduct disqualification AND if that fails, request a waiver based on good faith receipt.

0 coins

Good faith waiver - hadn't heard of that at all. Does that require a separate form or is it part of the appeal packet?

0 coins

Separate request process but you can raise it in your appeal statement as well. ESD's website has the waiver request option in eServices. Don't skip this even if you feel confident about the appeal itself.

0 coins

Waiver requests are underused because nobody tells claimants they exist. Important to know.

0 coins

Had an overpayment case last year that dragged on and the hardest part was getting ESD to explain the specific basis for the determination before my hearing. Phone tag for weeks. Eventually used Claimyr to cut through - got an agent who actually pulled up my file and walked me through which employer response triggered the overpayment flag. That prep made my OAH hearing way less stressful. Worth trying at claimyr.com if you're hitting walls on the phone.

0 coins

Knowing the specific employer response that triggered it is exactly what I need. I'll try this before the hearing.

0 coins

Pre-hearing prep by actually talking to ESD is underrated. Most people go in blind.

0 coins

Misconduct cases involving attendance are fact-intensive at the hearing. The judge will want to know: did your employer have a written attendance policy, were you informed of it, and did you violate it knowingly. If the employer never gave you a written policy or never warned you formally, that weakens their misconduct argument significantly.

0 coins

No written policy was ever handed to me. We got a verbal orientation on the job site but nothing signed.

0 coins

That verbal-only policy is a real weakness in their case. At the hearing, simply state that no written attendance policy was provided to you and ask the employer rep to produce one. If they can't, the judge notices.

0 coins

Verbal-only policies in construction are extremely common and extremely weak in OAH hearings. This is good news for your situation.

0 coins

Before my OAH hearing on a similar misconduct/overpayment issue I actually found the Claimyr service helpful just to confirm my hearing date and get some pre-hearing notes from ESD. Site is claimyr.com and there's a video at https://youtu.be/7DieNd3C7zQ - the agent I reached was able to flag that my employer had submitted a late response and that actually changed how my hearing went entirely.

0 coins

Late employer responses being flagged - didn't know ESD tracked that. Good to know going into a hearing.

0 coins

Procedural details like employer response timing can absolutely affect outcomes. Judges pay attention to that stuff.

0 coins

At the OAH hearing itself: dress professionally, bring three copies of everything (one for you, one for the judge, one for the employer rep if they appear), and answer only what's asked. Don't volunteer extra information. If the judge asks why you missed work, say 'back injury' and wait. Don't apologize for not having documentation - just explain what you do have.

0 coins

Three copies is practical advice I wouldn't have thought of. Is the hearing in person or by phone usually?

0 coins

Most OAH unemployment hearings are still conducted by phone. You'll get a notice with dial-in instructions. In-person is available on request but phone is default.

0 coins

Phone hearings are actually less intimidating than in-person in my experience. You can have your notes in front of you which helps.

0 coins

Thought the misconduct from first employer would automatically disqualify any future unemployment claims forever - that's wrong. Misconduct disqualification is specific to the benefit year connected to that job. If you get laid off from your current construction job down the road, you'd file a new claim based on that new separation. The current overpayment fight is about the past claim only.

0 coins

Current job security was actually on my mind. Good to know this doesn't follow me permanently.

0 coins

ESD misconduct flags are claim-specific, not lifetime blacklists. The confusion around this is widespread.

0 coins

Thought all overpayments went to collections immediately if not paid within 30 days - completely wrong assumption I made when I got my first repayment letter years ago. ESD has an installment payment option and also collections don't start until after any appeal is resolved. File your appeal and that clock on collections essentially pauses while the case works through OAH.

0 coins

Collections pause during appeal - that's a huge relief. I was panicking about that timeline on top of everything else.

0 coins

Correct - ESD typically doesn't refer to collections while a timely appeal is pending. Document when you filed your appeal and keep that confirmation.

0 coins

Installment plans also exist for cases where repayment is upheld. It's not all-or-nothing on the payment side.

0 coins

The OAH website has a self-help section specifically for unemployment appeals. It walks through what to expect at the hearing, what evidence format works, and even has a sample statement format. A lot of people don't know this exists but it's genuinely useful prep material.

0 coins

Going there now. Any specific section of the OAH site you'd point me to first?

0 coins

Look for 'Unemployment Insurance Appeals' under the OAH case types section. They have a claimant guide document that's worth reading before you draft your appeal statement.

0 coins

Wrote my appeal statement once in an angry, disorganized way and it hurt me. Second appeal (different issue) I organized it like this: first paragraph states the facts of my separation, second paragraph explains why the misconduct label doesn't fit legally, third paragraph lists my supporting evidence. Judges respond to clear structure.

0 coins

Structure advice is useful. Mine was going to be a wall of text explaining everything chronologically.

0 coins

Chronological can work but lead with your conclusion - 'my separation did not constitute misconduct because' - then build the case. Don't make the judge hunt for your argument.

0 coins

Treating it like a brief rather than a letter is the right instinct. Clear thesis up front.

0 coins

Misconduct threshold in Washington is actually higher than most people assume. ESD isn't supposed to rubber-stamp whatever an employer calls misconduct. Single incidents of attendance without prior documented warnings are routinely overturned on appeal. Your situation with two call-ins and an injury context is not a slam-dunk for the employer.

0 coins

Prior documented warnings - I never received any formal written warnings at all during my time there. Would that be worth stating explicitly in my appeal?

0 coins

Absolutely state it. 'I received no prior written warnings regarding attendance during my employment' is a sentence that should be in your appeal statement.

0 coins

Absence of progressive discipline is a recurring theme in successful misconduct appeals. It matters.

0 coins

My sister went through almost the exact same situation - ESD overpayment after a misconduct disqualification from a retail job. She appealed, employer didn't show up to the OAH hearing, case was decided in her favor entirely. The overpayment was reversed. Not guaranteed but it happens more than people think.

0 coins

Employer no-shows are apparently common from what I'm reading in this thread. Gives me more confidence that appealing is worth it.

0 coins

Even if the employer does show, you're not at a disadvantage. You have the injury context, the supervisor texts, no written policy, no prior warnings. That's a solid factual record.

0 coins

Weekly claims during the period in question - ESD will also look at whether you filed your weekly certifications accurately. If you reported all your job search activities and earnings correctly during those 14 weeks, that also supports the good faith argument for the waiver side of things.

0 coins

Filed every weekly claim accurately, reported the transition to my new job immediately when it started. No gaps or misreporting that I'm aware of.

0 coins

That consistent accurate reporting history genuinely helps. It shows you were engaging with the system in good faith throughout.

0 coins

Pull your weekly certification history from eServices and include a note in your appeal confirming accurate reporting. It's supporting evidence for the good faith narrative.

0 coins

After my own appeal was resolved I learned you can request a payment plan on the overpayment amount proactively - before the appeal decision even comes down. Setting one up doesn't mean you're conceding the debt, it just protects you from any collection action starting. Some people do this as a hedge while the appeal proceeds.

0 coins

Setting up a payment plan as a hedge while fighting the full thing - that's an interesting strategy I hadn't considered.

0 coins

ESD allows you to simultaneously appeal AND set up a repayment arrangement. They're not mutually exclusive and the payment plan can be cancelled if the appeal goes your way.

0 coins

One thing to do immediately regardless of everything else: request your claim file from ESD in writing. You're entitled to it and it will show you exactly what your former employer submitted as their reason for termination. Sometimes employers overstate the case in writing versus what actually happened verbally.

0 coins

Can I request the claim file through eServices or does that require a separate public records request?

0 coins

Public records request to ESD - there's a form on the ESD website. Submit it now because it can take 1-2 weeks to receive and you want it before your hearing, not after.

0 coins

Records request is completely separate from the appeal filing. Do both today if possible.

0 coins

Washington Unemployment AI

Expert Assistant
Secure