Back to Washington Unemployment

Cedric Chung

Can I get unemployment if fired for misconduct over lunch breaks - Washington ESD question

So I got terminated two weeks ago and I'm trying to figure out where I stand with unemployment. The whole situation was about lunch breaks - I work in a warehouse and the shift supervisors have been inconsistent about how long we're actually allowed to take. Some days they'd wave us back in after 20 minutes, other days nobody cared if you took 45. I went by what seemed like the actual norm on the floor and apparently that crossed a line after my manager decided to make an example out of me. HR called it 'repeated misconduct' on the termination paperwork. I filed a Washington ESD claim right away because I need the income, but I'm terrified the 'misconduct' label is going to automatically disqualify me. I've been reading about how ESD handles misconduct claims and I genuinely cannot tell if what happened to me counts as the kind of misconduct that blocks benefits or not. The policy enforcement at my workplace was so uneven that I honestly didn't think I was breaking any real rule. Has anyone been through something similar where the reason for firing was listed as misconduct but you still got approved? I have about 14 months of work history there and this came completely out of nowhere for me.

Wait, they seriously put 'misconduct' for lunch break timing? How strict was the written policy on that?

0 coins

Dug out my employee handbook last night - there's a paragraph saying breaks are 30 minutes but there's zero documentation of me ever being warned formally. My supervisor just verbally told me a few times to get back sooner and I thought it was casual conversation, not a formal disciplinary process.

0 coins

That handbook detail matters a LOT actually. No formal write-ups before termination is a huge factor in how ESD evaluates misconduct claims.

0 coins

Okay so when I got fired last year I was completely panicking about reaching ESD to ask about my situation before my adjudication even started. Called for days, couldn't get through. Someone in a different forum mentioned Claimyr and honestly it changed everything for me. You go to claimyr.com, there's a video demo at https://youtu.be/7DieNd3C7zQ that shows exactly how it works - basically it gets you connected to an actual ESD agent instead of you sitting on hold forever. I used it specifically to ask about my misconduct flag before the adjudication decision came down. Turned out I could explain my side before anything was finalized.

0 coins

Just watched the video demo - this is actually what I need right now. My claim shows 'pending adjudication' and I have no idea what's happening with it or if I should be adding anything to my file.

0 coins

Does this work for people whose claims haven't officially entered adjudication yet or only after the flag appears?

0 coins

Mine was already in adjudication when I used it but I've seen people here say they used it just to ask general questions about their claim status too.

0 coins

Here's something I believed for a long time that turned out to be completely wrong - I thought any termination where the employer writes 'misconduct' on the paperwork meant automatic disqualification from UI. Had that idea stuck in my head from something I half-read online. The actual way ESD handles it is that they do their own investigation. The employer's label doesn't decide anything on its own. What ESD looks at is whether you intentionally violated a known policy, whether you had real notice that the behavior was a problem, and whether the employer applied the rule consistently. If your workplace had no consistent enforcement, that's genuinely relevant to their finding.

0 coins

Printed the ESD adjudication criteria off their website after reading this - there's specific language about 'deliberate disregard of the employer's interest' which seems like a high bar compared to just being inconsistently managed.

0 coins

Exactly right. The deliberate disregard standard is key. Confusion caused by inconsistent supervision is a pretty different thing from knowingly ignoring a clear rule.

0 coins

yeah but employers know how to word things to make it sound worse than it was, OP should definitely document everything from their side too

0 coins

This thread is hitting close to home. I went through a misconduct termination dispute with ESD about eight months ago. Mine was over attendance policies, not breaks, but the core issue was the same - inconsistent enforcement. Want to know what actually mattered in my case?

0 coins

Found your older post actually while searching this topic - yes please share whatever helped you.

0 coins

The thing that made the difference was that I had text messages from coworkers describing the same flexible treatment they got. ESD's adjudicator asked me direct questions about whether others were treated differently for the same behavior. Having those texts meant I could answer confidently instead of just saying 'I think so.

0 coins

How did you submit texts as evidence? I always assumed you had to have official documents only.

0 coins

Okay can we back up - what did your termination letter actually say word for word? Because 'repeated misconduct' over breaks sounds like they're claiming a pattern. Did you have any written warnings at all before the final termination?

0 coins

Went back through every email from my manager - there's nothing in writing ever. The two verbal conversations I remember were framed as general team reminders, not individual warnings directed specifically at me.

0 coins

No paper trail of progressive discipline is genuinely a significant factor. ESD tends to look at whether the employer gave the employee a real opportunity to correct the behavior. 'We mentioned it generally to the team' is pretty different from 'we formally warned this specific employee.

0 coins

OP this is good news honestly, the lack of documentation in your favor

0 coins

Ugh I'm going through almost the exact same thing right now except mine was about remote work clock-in procedures and they called it misconduct too. Filed three weeks ago, still pending. This whole process is so stressful when you don't know if you're going to get anything at all.

0 coins

Three weeks pending adjudication - has ESD contacted you at all during that time asking for your side of the story?

0 coins

Got one generic letter saying my claim was under review. Called twice, couldn't get through either time. Starting to think I need to find a better way to actually reach a human there.

0 coins

Worth looking into Claimyr for this - claimyr.com - I used it when my own adjudication was dragging and I needed to actually talk to someone at ESD instead of just waiting. The video at https://youtu.be/7DieNd3C7zQ shows the whole thing. Got connected to an agent who could pull up my specific file and tell me what was actually happening.

0 coins

Just want to flag something I've seen trip people up in misconduct adjudications - make sure you're still filing your weekly claims while this is being reviewed. I didn't for the first two weeks because I assumed there was no point since I was under investigation. Ended up having to call ESD to fix the gap. Actually that's how I found out about Claimyr - claimyr.com has the video demo at https://youtu.be/7DieNd3C7zQ - used it to sort out the backdating issue with an actual agent.

0 coins

Already filed my first two weekly claims actually - someone warned me about this in a different thread. Good to hear it confirmed though.

0 coins

Wait I haven't been filing because I assumed the same thing - that adjudication meant everything was frozen. Need to fix this immediately.

0 coins

Yes file immediately. The weekly claim process runs separately from adjudication. Missing weeks can create an entirely separate issue even if your original claim gets approved.

0 coins

This comes up constantly and it really should be more clearly stated in the ESD materials. So many people stop filing when adjudication starts.

0 coins

I used to think getting fired for misconduct meant you couldn't get unemployment - full stop, end of story. Then a friend who worked in HR explained that there's a real difference between poor performance or policy confusion versus something genuinely intentional and harmful. ESD draws that line themselves rather than just accepting whatever the employer documents. Policy confusion that the employer created through inconsistent enforcement is not the same category as someone who knew the rule, understood it applied to them, and ignored it anyway. Your situation sounds much more like the first thing than the second.

0 coins

This reframing actually helps me think about it more clearly. The supervisors created the ambiguity - I didn't invent it.

0 coins

Is there a way to actually show ESD that the enforcement was inconsistent? Like do they interview other employees or only talk to management?

0 coins

ESD adjudicators contact both the employer and the claimant separately. You'll get a chance to tell your side. When they reach out, be specific - not just 'my supervisors were inconsistent' but 'on this specific date supervisor X told the team 45 minutes was fine, on this date supervisor Y sent us back at 20 minutes.' Specific examples carry more weight than general statements. If you have any coworkers willing to put something in writing, even a simple statement, that can help too.

0 coins

Made a list of specific dates and what happened - going back as far as I can remember. Some of this I actually have in group chat logs with coworkers.

0 coins

Those chat logs could be really valuable. ESD adjudicators do look at evidence claimants submit, it's not just the employer's word.

0 coins

The more specific the better. Adjudicators are deciding based on what they can actually verify, not vibes. Dates, supervisors' names, what was said - all of it matters.

0 coins

Something else worth knowing - Washington ESD's misconduct standard requires that the behavior was harmful to the employer's interests in some meaningful way. Extended lunch breaks in a warehouse where the supervisors themselves weren't enforcing the policy consistently... it's genuinely hard to frame that as serious harm to the employer. If you weren't causing production problems, missing deadlines, or creating safety issues, the harm element of the misconduct definition gets harder for them to establish.

0 coins

Looked at my performance reviews from the past year - all positive, no production complaints, no documented issues with output. This feels relevant.

0 coins

document that too, like get copies of those reviews if you can before the employer controls the narrative

0 coins

Okay can I ask something that might sound dumb - when ESD contacts you during adjudication, is it just one phone call or do they send forms too? I'm trying to understand the process for my own situation.

0 coins

Not dumb at all. It varies. Sometimes it's a questionnaire they mail or send through your eServices account. Sometimes an adjudicator calls. Sometimes both. The key is to respond to absolutely everything they send, as completely as you can, within the deadlines they give you. Missing a response deadline can result in a decision based only on the employer's information.

0 coins

Check your eServices account messages regularly during adjudication. ESD sometimes sends requests there that people miss because they're only watching for mail.

0 coins

Set a reminder on my phone to check eServices daily - good call.

0 coins

EMPLOYERS KNOW HOW TO GAME THIS SYSTEM. They write 'misconduct' because they know it triggers adjudication and they know claimants don't know how to fight it. I went through this twice. Twice. Both times eventually approved after fighting but the stress almost wasn't worth it. Document EVERYTHING. Every conversation. Every inconsistency. Every name and date. Don't let them tell the story without your version being just as detailed.

0 coins

Recording everything I can remember right now while it's still fresh. What was your timeline both times from filing to actual decision?

0 coins

First time was about 6 weeks, second time almost 10. Depends heavily on how complicated the case looks and how backed up ESD is.

0 coins

10 weeks is brutal when you have no income coming in

0 coins

While you're waiting on adjudication, keep your job search activities going and log them properly. I know when you're stressed about whether you'll even get benefits it feels pointless, but if you do get approved you'll need those records current and complete. ESD can audit your job search log going back to your claim start date. Missing entries during the adjudication waiting period has tripped people up. Also worth knowing - I ended up using Claimyr at claimyr.com to get through to ESD when my claim had a different kind of issue, and they were able to actually look at my job search audit question while I was on the phone. Way better than sending messages into a void.

0 coins

Haven't slacked on the job search even while this is unresolved - logging three contacts per week as required.

0 coins

Wait is the job search requirement paused during adjudication or does it run the whole time?

0 coins

It runs the whole time for most claimants. Unless you're approved for standby status, you document your job search every week regardless of claim status.

0 coins

Has ESD reached out to you yet at all? Like have they contacted you asking for your version of events?

0 coins

Nothing yet - it's been 11 days since I filed. Is that normal or should something have happened by now?

0 coins

11 days is not unusual especially right now. Adjudication timelines vary a lot depending on claim volume. The fact that nothing has come yet doesn't mean anything is wrong - it usually just means they haven't gotten to yours in the queue yet.

0 coins

Mine took about 3 weeks before the first contact. Keep checking eServices though because sometimes the notification that something needs your response doesn't come through email reliably.

0 coins

Quick practical thing - when you do hear from ESD, don't go in trying to defend or explain the company's perspective along with your own. Just clearly explain your experience. What you understood the policy to be, why you understood it that way, what supervisors said and when, what you observed others doing without consequence. You're not arguing against your employer, you're giving ESD the full picture they need to apply the actual legal standard.

0 coins

This is a helpful framing shift - explain my experience clearly rather than trying to anticipate and counter their version.

0 coins

Exactly. Adjudicators are pretty experienced at detecting when a claimant is being evasive or over-arguing. Clear factual statements about your own experience are more credible than coming in trying to dismantle the employer's whole case.

0 coins

Update from me since I mentioned my own situation earlier - finally got through to ESD today and found out my claim is waiting on a form response from my employer that they haven't submitted yet. Apparently that's why mine has been sitting. Didn't know employer response timing could hold things up like that.

0 coins

This is useful to know - so the employer's response time is a variable in how long adjudication takes, not just ESD's internal workload?

0 coins

Yes, ESD gives employers a window to respond and if they're slow about it the whole thing sits. It's frustrating but it's part of why timelines vary so much.

0 coins

How did you finally get through? I've been trying to reach ESD about a different issue for days

0 coins

One more thing that might help frame your expectations - misconduct findings for things like attendance and break policies get overturned on appeal pretty regularly, even when ESD initially rules against the claimant. If you get a denial, that's not the end. The appeal process exists and it's worth using. You have 30 days from the date on a denial letter to file an appeal, and appeals are heard by a separate administrative law judge who reviews everything fresh.

0 coins

Good to know there's still a path even if the first decision goes wrong. I'd obviously rather not need it but knowing the option exists helps.

0 coins

Appeals are more successful than people expect. The initial adjudication is often rushed. The appeal hearing is where you can actually present things in full.

0 coins

Is there free help available for appeal hearings? Like do you have to hire a lawyer or is there another option?

0 coins

WorkSource offices can connect you with free assistance for unemployment appeals. Also the Northwest Justice Project does legal help for low-income folks dealing with unemployment appeals specifically.

0 coins

Coming back to check in - OP have you had any updates since your original post? Curious how the adjudication is progressing.

0 coins

Got a questionnaire through my eServices account yesterday - ESD is asking me to describe the incidents, the policies as I understood them, and whether I received formal warnings. Filling it out today. Feels good to finally be doing something active instead of just waiting.

0 coins

That questionnaire is your moment - take your time with it, be specific, and answer every single question they ask fully.

0 coins

Good luck with it. The fact that they're asking for your side is exactly the process working how it should. Give them everything.

0 coins

Washington Unemployment AI

Expert Assistant
Secure