Unemployment second deputy determination overpayment after appeal - do I need to appeal again?
So I'm in this weird limbo situation and genuinely can't figure out what step I'm supposed to take next. Quick background: I was laid off from my warehouse supervisor job back in January, filed my claim, everything seemed fine for about six weeks. Then out of nowhere I got hit with a disqualification notice. I appealed it, went through the whole hearing process, and the appeals examiner actually ruled in my favor on the original issue. But here's where it gets confusing. About two weeks after I won that appeal, I got a NEW letter from Virginia VEC - this one is called a 'Second Deputy Determination' and it says I owe back $4,800 in benefits because of something related to my separation from my employer. The letter looks totally different from the first determination I appealed. I honestly don't know if this is connected to the original appeal I won, if the employer disputed something new, or if Virginia VEC is essentially trying to come after me again on a different basis. My question is basically: unemployment second deputy determination overpayment after appeal do i need to appeal again, or does my previous win somehow cover this? I've been filing my weekly claims throughout all of this but I'm terrified they're going to start garnishing my future payments. Has anyone dealt with a second determination coming out AFTER they already won an appeal on the same claim?
73 comments

Ella Russell
Week 11 of my own claim saga here, so I've been through some loops with Virginia VEC. First thing I want to say is - yes, a Second Deputy Determination is absolutely a separate document and it requires its own appeal if you disagree with it. The fact that you won your first appeal does NOT automatically protect you from a new determination. Each determination Virginia VEC issues is essentially its own legal finding, and each one has its own 30-day appeal window starting from the date on that letter. Now separately - and I know you're asking about the legal process - but if you need to actually TALK to someone at Virginia VEC to understand what triggered this second determination before you decide how to appeal it, I cannot stress enough how hard it is to get through by phone normally. I used a service called Claimyr (claimyr.com) that basically handles the hold queue for you and calls you back when an actual agent is on the line. There's a demo video at https://youtu.be/GK1CFuX4p2k that shows how it works. I used it specifically to ask about a determination letter and the agent was able to tell me exactly which employer report triggered it. That context made my appeal way more focused.
0 coins
Mohammed Khan
The letter dated two weeks after my hearing decision is sitting right here on my desk and I'm reading the same kind of confusion this person is feeling. So each determination really does start its own 30-day clock? I always assumed winning an appeal kind of reset everything under that claim.
0 coins
Aaliyah Reed
AuthorMine arrived on a Tuesday and I've been staring at it ever since. I didn't realize they could essentially issue a brand new finding after I already won. That's really helpful context. I'm going to look at the date on this letter and count my days carefully.
0 coins
Gavin King
My folder of VEC paperwork now has four separate determination letters across two claims and yeah, confirming what you said - each one is standalone. I actually had one situation where I won appeal #1 and then got hit with determination #3 on the same underlying employment situation. Completely separate process each time.
0 coins
Nathan Kim
Just got to week 8 of adjudication on my own claim so this thread is hitting close to home. The thing people don't realize about Second Deputy Determinations specifically is that Virginia VEC can issue them when NEW information comes in - usually from the employer - that wasn't part of the original determination. So your employer may have submitted additional payroll records, separation paperwork, or a formal protest AFTER your first appeal concluded. VEC then has to issue a fresh ruling on that new information. Your win on appeal #1 covered appeal #1's specific findings. This new $4,800 figure likely comes from a completely separate factual basis that the examiner in your first hearing never even looked at.
0 coins
Aaliyah Reed
AuthorReading through the letter again after seeing your comment - it does reference a different document number than my original determination. The basis listed is 'unreported earnings during benefit weeks 3 through 7' which was NOT what my first appeal was about at all. So these really are two separate things.
0 coins
Eleanor Foster
My determination last spring had almost identical language about 'unreported earnings during specific benefit weeks' and that one came directly from my former employer submitting wage records to VEC. If that's what triggered yours, your defense is basically showing that those earnings WERE reported on your weekly claims, or that the wages they're counting were from a different period than VEC thinks.
0 coins
Lucas Turner
Three different claims filed over five years here. Employer-submitted wage data causing second determinations is extremely common, especially in warehouse and logistics work where overtime and bonuses can look like unreported income to the system if the timing doesn't match up perfectly.
0 coins
Kai Rivera
Finishing up my own appeal paperwork tonight so your question is very relevant to me. Here's the practical answer on the appeal question: yes, you need to file a new appeal specifically responding to the Second Deputy Determination. When you file, write clearly on the appeal form that this is in response to Determination #[whatever number is on that letter], not your previous determination. Virginia VEC needs you to identify the specific document you're contesting. If you just file a general appeal or reference your old case number, there's a real risk it gets attached to the wrong file.
0 coins
Aaliyah Reed
AuthorThat detail about the specific determination number is something I definitely would have missed. I was going to write a general statement about the whole situation. So I need to make sure the form clearly references the new document number, not my old appeal case?
0 coins
Anna Stewart
My appeal from last fall got delayed by almost three weeks because I didn't clearly identify which determination I was responding to and they had to manually sort it out. Very much worth being specific from the start.
0 coins
Layla Sanders
The CSS portal (uidirect.vec.virginia.gov) has a section where you can file appeals directly and it asks you to enter the determination ID number. Filing through there at least forces you to put the right number in before you can submit.
0 coins
Morgan Washington
Just opened my mailbox and found my OWN overpayment notice today so I'm reading everything in this thread very carefully. Had a friend go through almost this exact same double-determination situation about four months ago. She was really lost on what had triggered the second notice and couldn't get anyone at VEC on the phone for days - standard story. She tried Claimyr and got connected to an agent who actually pulled up her employer's submission history and walked her through exactly what wages they had reported. Turned out the employer had submitted a corrected W-2 that conflicted with what she'd certified on her weekly claims. She was able to file her appeal with that specific information instead of just writing a vague response. Made a big difference in how her hearing went.
0 coins
Aaliyah Reed
AuthorGlad your friend got it sorted out. I'm now genuinely wondering if my employer submitted something corrected as well because the weeks they're flagging were weeks where I had some part-time hours I did report - but maybe their records show different numbers than what I entered.
0 coins
Kaylee Cook
Employer-side data corrections are really common after formal appeals, almost like the employer's response to losing the first round. I've seen this pattern mentioned on this forum before.
0 coins
Oliver Alexander
My former employer submitted 'corrected' separation paperwork after my first appeal too. It felt retaliatory even if it probably wasn't. The key is documenting everything you have from that period - pay stubs, your weekly claim confirmation numbers, all of it.
0 coins
Lara Woods
About 60 days into dealing with an overpayment from a previous claim cycle, so I feel this deeply. Something important nobody has mentioned yet: when you file your appeal on the Second Deputy Determination, you typically have the option to request a waiver of the overpayment amount alongside the appeal. These are two separate requests you can make simultaneously. The waiver is basically you saying 'even if the overpayment finding is correct, I should not have to repay it because I was acting in good faith and repayment would cause financial hardship.' Some people skip the waiver request thinking the appeal will just fix everything, but if your appeal doesn't fully succeed, having that waiver on file can protect you.
0 coins
Aaliyah Reed
AuthorThis is the first I'm hearing about a waiver option being filed at the same time as the appeal. Can you do that through the CSS portal or does the waiver have to be a separate paper form?
0 coins
Lara Woods
My paperwork showed both options available through the portal but I'd strongly recommend calling VEC to confirm before you rely on that for your specific determination type. The overpayment waiver process can differ based on whether the original overpayment was classified as fraud-related or non-fraud.
0 coins
Adrian Hughes
Non-fraud overpayment waivers are genuinely worth pursuing in Virginia. The standard is financial hardship plus good faith, and if you were certifying honestly, you have a real argument on the good faith prong.
0 coins
Molly Chambers
Got a letter last week that's similar in some ways so I've been researching this exact area. One thing I want to flag: the 30-day appeal window is strict in Virginia. I've seen people on this forum who waited even 32 or 33 days and got their appeals rejected as untimely. If your letter has a specific date on it, count from THAT date, not from when you received it in the mail. VEC uses the issue date, not the received date, as the start of the clock. If you're close to that deadline, file first and add details later - you can supplement your appeal statement after initial filing.
0 coins
Aaliyah Reed
AuthorCounting backward from today - I think I have about 19 days left based on the issue date on the letter. So I have some time but not a lot. I appreciate the warning about the issue date vs. received date, that's exactly the kind of thing I would have assumed wrong.
0 coins
Mohammed Khan
Filing even a basic placeholder appeal before the deadline and then strengthening your written argument is totally valid. The important thing is getting something submitted before day 30.
0 coins
Ian Armstrong
My appeal hearing resulted in a continued overpayment but a reduced amount after I submitted detailed documentation about the specific weeks in question. Even if you don't fully win, a well-documented appeal can sometimes reduce the dollar amount they claim you owe. And for getting help understanding the determination before you write your appeal statement - Claimyr worked well for me when I needed to actually speak to someone at VEC rather than just submitting through the portal blind. Got through in about 45 minutes versus the multiple days of calling I'd done before that.
0 coins
Eli Butler
Day 47 of my adjudication process and I stumbled onto this thread while looking for answers to my own situation. Quick clarifying question for anyone who knows: if the Second Deputy Determination is specifically about unreported earnings, does Virginia VEC always require an in-person or phone hearing, or can some of these be resolved with just written documentation? I'm asking because scheduling a hearing is really difficult with my current work schedule.
0 coins
Nathan Kim
Based on my experience with VEC hearings, you can request a telephone hearing rather than in-person. The appeals process gives you the option when you file. For earnings-based disputes specifically, written documentation (pay stubs, weekly claim confirmations, bank deposits) is essential regardless of whether the hearing is phone or in-person.
0 coins
Kai Rivera
My phone hearing last year was just as thorough as an in-person would have been. The examiner asked detailed questions about specific weeks and had all the employer-submitted data in front of them. Come prepared with organized documentation for each week in dispute.
0 coins
Marcus Patterson
Just passed the six-week mark on a determination dispute and reading this thread has been genuinely useful. Something I want to add about the overpayment specifically: even while your appeal is pending, VEC may start withholding a portion of your ongoing weekly benefits to offset the alleged overpayment. You can request a stay of collection while your appeal is in process. It's not automatic - you have to ask for it. If you're still filing weekly claims and depending on that money, that stay request is worth submitting alongside your appeal.
0 coins
Aaliyah Reed
AuthorWait, they can start withholding even before the appeal is resolved? That feels like it should be illegal but I've seen weird things from VEC. I'm absolutely going to look into the stay of collection request right now.
0 coins
Marcus Patterson
My notification letter actually mentioned this possibility in the small print on page 2. Worth reading every page of that determination letter carefully because sometimes procedural options are buried in the boilerplate.
0 coins
Eleanor Foster
This happened to my cousin - about 25% of her weekly benefits were being withheld during her pending appeal. The stay request stopped it. Keep copies of everything you submit for that request.
0 coins
Lucas Turner
Virginia's rules on benefit withholding during appeals are actually somewhat claimant-friendly compared to some situations I've read about. The stay option is real and VEC does honor it in most non-fraud cases.
0 coins
Anna Stewart
Somewhere around week 14 of fighting my own claim issues, so I've got opinions. Something I haven't seen mentioned: if the weeks flagged in your Second Deputy Determination are weeks where you DID certify earnings on your weekly claim, pull your certification history from the CSS portal immediately. Print or screenshot every single weekly certification from those weeks. The CSS portal keeps a record of what you reported and when. If VEC's overpayment calculation is based on earnings that you actually DID report, that certification history is your strongest evidence.
0 coins
Aaliyah Reed
AuthorMy CSS portal shows all my past weekly certifications - I just checked and weeks 3 through 7 do show that I reported part-time earnings. I entered dollar amounts on those certifications. So the question is why their system is showing a discrepancy with what my employer reported.
0 coins
Anna Stewart
Those screenshots are your evidence. The discrepancy might be a timing issue - like you reported gross wages but the employer reported net, or the pay period dates don't align with the benefit weeks exactly. Bring that explanation to your hearing.
0 coins
Gavin King
Gross vs. net wage reporting is a surprisingly common source of these discrepancies. VEC wants gross wages for the week you worked, but sometimes employers report what was actually paid out in that period which is different.
0 coins
Kaylee Cook
Three weeks since I got my own determination letter so I'm actively in this process. Quick point about documentation: start gathering your pay stubs from the employer for those exact weeks NOW, before you even file your appeal. If your former employer is being uncooperative or if you don't have copies, you can request employment records directly. Having those in hand before the hearing rather than scrambling for them at the last minute makes a real difference in how organized your appeal statement can be.
0 coins
Aaliyah Reed
AuthorFortunately I kept all my pay stubs from that job. I've got physical copies for every pay period during the weeks in question. So I should have the documentation to show what my gross earnings actually were for those benefit weeks.
0 coins
Adrian Hughes
Physical pay stubs plus your digital weekly certification screenshots together create a really clear paper trail. When you present them side by side at a hearing, the examiner can see exactly what you reported and why it matches your stubs even if it differs from what the employer submitted to VEC.
0 coins
Oliver Alexander
Partway through my second appeal on the same underlying claim and I want to offer some honest perspective: the fact that you won your first appeal does help you in one specific way even though it doesn't cover the new determination. It establishes that you were credible and that VEC found in your favor on the previous facts. When the same examiner (or a different one) looks at your second appeal, your track record of being truthful in your first appeal can support your credibility on the new one. It's not a legal argument but examiners are human and patterns matter.
0 coins
Aaliyah Reed
AuthorThat's actually a really interesting point I hadn't considered at all. I'm not sure if the same examiner handles both but the idea that my previous successful appeal shows I was being straight with them is something I can at least reference in my written statement.
0 coins
Molly Chambers
Referencing the prior appeal outcome in your written statement is completely appropriate. Something like 'as was established in Determination Appeal [case number] dated [date], I have consistently and accurately reported my earnings throughout my claim period' sets that context clearly.
0 coins
Mohammed Khan
In my eighth week trying to get a straight answer from VEC on anything, so solidarity. I want to revisit the original question one more time for clarity because I've seen people answer pieces of it but not the whole thing: 1) Yes you need to appeal again, 2) The appeal is on the new Second Deputy Determination only - your old appeal case is closed and separate, 3) You have 30 days from the issue date on the new letter, 4) You can request a waiver of overpayment at the same time, 5) You can request a stay of collection to protect your ongoing benefits. That's the full checklist from what I've gathered reading this whole thread.
0 coins
Aaliyah Reed
AuthorThis summary is exactly what I needed. I'm going to screenshot this comment. So to confirm: file appeal on new determination, reference its specific document number, include waiver request, include stay of collection request, attach my weekly certification screenshots and pay stubs, and do it before the 30-day window closes. That's my action plan.
0 coins
Layla Sanders
My checklist from going through this myself matches that pretty closely. One addition: request a telephone hearing at the time of filing so you don't get defaulted into an in-person hearing date that might not work with your schedule.
0 coins
Eli Butler
Following this thread to the end because my situation might go this direction soon. Really clear summary - appreciate someone putting it all together like that.
0 coins
Lydia Bailey
Just starting week 5 of dealing with an overpayment notice myself so everything in this thread is relevant. I've been in the same boat with not being able to get through to VEC by phone - it was genuinely making my situation worse because I couldn't get answers before my deadline. I ended up using Claimyr (claimyr.com) last week. There's a walkthrough at https://youtu.be/GK1CFuX4p2k that shows how it works. The main thing I wanted from the call was to have an agent confirm that my appeal had been received and was in the system, because the CSS portal wasn't updating. Got through, confirmed, got the case number for my appeal, and felt a lot less like I was just screaming into the void.
0 coins
Aaliyah Reed
AuthorConfirming that my appeal was actually received is exactly the kind of thing I'd want to verify. The portal has been pretty unreliable about showing status updates throughout my whole claim. Good to know there's a way to get a live confirmation.
0 coins
Nathan Kim
The CSS portal update delays are a known frustration. Sometimes documents you've submitted don't show as received for 3-5 business days even when VEC has them. Getting verbal confirmation from an agent creates a record (get the agent's name and time of call if you can) that you can reference if something gets disputed later.
0 coins
Adrian Hughes
Dealing with my third VEC issue in two years so I'll add one practical thing: take detailed notes during your appeal hearing. Write down or type as the examiner speaks, including what documents they reference and any case numbers or exhibit numbers they mention. After the hearing, write up a summary of what was discussed while it's fresh. If the determination on this appeal also goes against you, you'll have a record for any further appeals, and in Virginia you can appeal all the way to Circuit Court in some situations.
0 coins
Aaliyah Reed
AuthorI hadn't even thought about what happens if this second appeal also goes against me. Circuit Court is a real option? That feels extreme for $4,800 but good to know the process doesn't dead-end at the appeals examiner level.
0 coins
Adrian Hughes
It is a real option. Practically speaking, most people don't go to Circuit Court for overpayment disputes unless the amount is substantial, but for $4,800 some people do consider it especially if they have solid documentation. At minimum knowing the process continues beyond the hearing level takes some of the pressure off.
0 coins
Oliver Alexander
The legal appeal option also sometimes motivates VEC to revisit their position when you mention it in correspondence. Worth knowing even if you don't end up needing it.
0 coins
Eleanor Foster
My appeal examiner issued a decision three weeks ago and I'm still waiting to see if it sticks, so I understand the limbo feeling. One thing worth mentioning: when VEC issues a Second Deputy Determination, they're supposed to send a copy to your former employer as well. That means your employer now also has 30 days to respond or participate in the appeal process. This isn't necessarily bad for you, but it means your employer might show up at your hearing with their own documentation. Going in prepared with your own organized evidence is even more important when the employer is likely to participate.
0 coins
Aaliyah Reed
AuthorI had no idea the employer would also receive a copy and have standing to participate. That changes how I'm thinking about this. The whole reason this feels like a second bite at the apple for them is probably because they ARE actively disputing my claim still.
0 coins
Eleanor Foster
Former employers, especially in warehouse and logistics, often have HR or legal staff who handle these routinely. Coming to your hearing with organized documentation levels the playing field significantly.
0 coins
Mohammed Khan
Knowing the employer will likely participate is actually useful information because you can mentally prepare for a more adversarial hearing rather than just an administrative review.
0 coins
Layla Sanders
Currently at the 'waiting for hearing date' phase of my own appeal so I know this stage well. Practical tip on scheduling: appeal hearings in Virginia are usually scheduled 3-6 weeks after you file. Use that time productively. Create a document with a week-by-week breakdown of every benefit week in dispute - dates of the week, what you reported on your weekly claim, what your pay stub shows for those dates, and any explanatory notes about timing differences. Having it organized by week rather than by document type makes it much easier to walk through during a hearing.
0 coins
Aaliyah Reed
AuthorOrganizing by week is a much better structure than what I was planning (which was just dumping all the documents in chronological order). I'll restructure my evidence file that way.
0 coins
Anna Stewart
My examiner specifically appreciated when I presented a week-by-week table during my hearing. It made it really clear which weeks were in dispute and what the specific earnings were for each one. Examiners deal with a huge volume of cases and anything that makes their job easier tends to work in your favor.
0 coins
Lucas Turner
Watching week 9 tick by on my pending adjudication while following this thread. Something nobody has brought up: if you do get a repayment demand while your appeal is pending and you don't have the stay of collection in place, don't just ignore the payment notices. Contact VEC in writing to note that you have an active appeal on the determination. Otherwise, non-response to repayment notices can sometimes be interpreted as acknowledgment of the debt or lead to additional collection actions even during the appeal process.
0 coins
Aaliyah Reed
AuthorSo even with an appeal filed I should still be sending something in writing about the repayment notices? That feels like a lot of parallel paperwork but I understand why you'd do it.
0 coins
Lucas Turner
It's essentially a CYA move. The stay of collection request is the cleaner solution, but if that's still processing, a written response saying 'I have filed Appeal [reference number] on this determination and am contesting this overpayment finding' protects you from any suggestion that you're ignoring it.
0 coins
Molly Chambers
Keep copies of everything you send to VEC and note the method (certified mail, portal message, etc.) and date. Building a paper trail of your responsiveness is part of showing good faith for the waiver argument as well.
0 coins
Gavin King
My situation two months ago was almost identical to what OP is describing - won appeal #1, got blindsided by a second determination. What I'll tell you is that when I filed my second appeal, I explicitly stated in my appeal letter that the weeks in question had been subject to a prior determination appeal and referenced the outcome. The examiner at my second hearing actually pulled the transcript from my first hearing and it helped establish context. I don't know if that made the difference but I won the second appeal too. The specifics of my case were different but the approach of connecting the two proceedings was something my second examiner engaged with directly.
0 coins
Aaliyah Reed
AuthorKnowing someone got through a second determination appeal on a similar situation and won is genuinely encouraging. I'm going to reference my first appeal outcome in my written statement the way you described.
0 coins
Gavin King
Just make sure you have the case number and date of that first appeal decision ready to cite. VEC should have it in your file but having it in your written statement ensures the examiner finds it.
0 coins
Kaylee Cook
Cross-referencing prior appeal outcomes in your statement shows you understand the procedural history of your own claim. That kind of organized self-advocacy tends to be received well compared to just reacting emotionally to the new determination.
0 coins
Adrian Hughes
Examiners have discretion in how they evaluate credibility and context. Using the record of your first appeal appropriately - not in a 'you already ruled for me so give me a break' way but as factual evidence of your consistent reporting behavior - is a legitimate and smart approach.
0 coins
Kai Rivera
Wrapping up my second week post-hearing while waiting on the written decision. Last thought from me: after you've filed your appeal on the Second Deputy Determination and gotten your hearing scheduled, the most important thing you can do is prepare as if you're presenting a case to someone who knows nothing about your situation. Don't assume the examiner remembers anything from the first appeal or has read your file. Walk them through your whole factual story, week by week, with documentation for each claim. The examiners I've encountered have been genuinely fair when presented with organized, specific evidence. The process is frustrating but it does work when you engage it seriously.
0 coins
Aaliyah Reed
AuthorThat reframe of 'present as if they know nothing' is really helpful. I was going to assume a lot of continuity from the first appeal that apparently doesn't exist. I'll build my presentation from scratch for the specific facts in this new determination.
0 coins
Lara Woods
Came to this thread looking for answers on my own situation and ended up getting a pretty complete picture of how to handle a second determination. OP's situation is exactly the kind of thing that's hard to find information on - the 'what happens after the appeal wins but new issues emerge' scenario.
0 coins
Eli Butler
Bookmarked this thread. The collective knowledge here is more useful than anything on the official VEC website, which basically just tells you to read your determination letter.
0 coins