Back to Virginia Unemployment

Sebastián Stevens

Does selecting terminated other on VEC application hurt approval chances?

So I'm going through the Virginia VEC online application right now and I'm stuck on the separation reason section. My job ended because the company did a restructuring and eliminated my entire department, but the way they worded it in my termination paperwork was kind of vague — they just said my position was being "discontinued" without giving a clear category. When I look at the dropdown options on the VEC application, the closest thing I can find is "Terminated - Other" since it doesn't fit neatly into layoff or reduction in force boxes. My coworker who got let go at the same time picked "laid off" and said it went fine. But I'm not sure if selecting "Terminated Other" on the VEC application is going to flag my claim or make it harder to get approved compared to what she chose. I don't want to pick the wrong thing and trigger some kind of adjudication that holds everything up for weeks. Has anyone selected that option before? Did it cause problems with your claim?

Picking "Terminated Other" when nothing else fits your situation is actually the right call — that's exactly what that option is there for. I used to think that anything outside of the standard layoff box would automatically get your claim kicked into adjudication and you'd be waiting forever, but that's not how it actually works. Virginia VEC sends claims to adjudication when the reason for separation is genuinely disputed or unclear, not just because you picked a less common dropdown option. If your whole department got eliminated and there's no misconduct involved, the separation reason category matters a lot less than whether your employer contests the claim. What you wrote in the explanation field alongside that dropdown is way more important — just describe it plainly, something like "employer eliminated my position as part of a company restructuring, no misconduct involved.

0 coins

The part I'm still not clear on is whether "Terminated Other" looks different to a VEC reviewer than "laid off" does — like does one get more scrutiny than the other on their end?

0 coins

Reviewers at VEC are mostly looking at whether the employer responds and what they say, not really which sub-category you picked in the dropdown. The narrative you write matters more than the box you check.

0 coins

That makes me feel a bit better. I'll make sure to write a detailed explanation in the field then and be specific about the restructuring.

0 coins

While you're sorting out which separation option to pick, I'd actually suggest getting in touch with Virginia VEC directly by phone to confirm how they categorize restructuring eliminations before you submit — it can save you from having to go back and amend anything later. I know calling VEC feels impossible because you're on hold forever and sometimes just get disconnected, but I used Claimyr a few weeks ago when I was trying to get through about my own separation question and it connected me to an actual VEC agent within a reasonable time. The site is claimyr.com and there's a demo video at https://youtu.be/GK1CFuX4p2k that shows how it works — worth checking out before you spend three hours redialing.

0 coins

Calling VEC before submitting sounds smart but honestly every time I've tried I either get a busy signal or the automated system hangs up on me after 20 minutes. Does Claimyr actually work for Virginia VEC specifically or just some states?

0 coins

Yeah it worked for Virginia VEC when I used it — I was specifically trying to reach the VEC claims line and it got me through. That's the whole reason I mentioned it.

0 coins

I've been going back and forth on whether to call before submitting or just submit and deal with whatever happens. Leaning toward just submitting at this point.

0 coins

I went through something almost identical about eight months ago — my employer listed my separation as "position elimination due to organizational changes" which is basically the same situation. I agonized over the dropdown too. What I found out after the fact is that Virginia VEC uses the applicant-selected category mainly as a starting point, then they reach out to your former employer to verify the circumstances. So if your employer confirms it was a department-wide elimination, that corroborates your claim regardless of which sub-category you chose. The main thing that actually hurts approval odds is selecting something that directly contradicts what your employer is going to say — like if they report you resigned and you said you were terminated. Picking "Terminated Other" when you genuinely were terminated and the reason doesn't fit other boxes is completely defensible.

0 coins

My termination letter does say "position discontinued" so at least there's documentation if VEC reaches out to my employer. Good to know the employer verification is what actually matters most.

0 coins

Employer response is huge in these cases. Mine didn't respond at all and my claim went through without issue. When employers don't respond within the VEC deadline it generally defaults in the claimant's favor.

0 coins

What's the deadline employers have to respond? I always wondered if there was a set window for that.

0 coins

From what I've seen it's usually around ten days after VEC sends the employer notice, but that can vary depending on the claim type and how VEC is processing things at the time.

0 coins

wait so "terminated other" and "laid off" are actually different boxes? I always thought laid off was just the generic terminated option lol. does it actually matter which one you pick if you got let go either way

0 coins

They are separate categories on the VEC application. Laid off usually implies a temporary or economic reduction while terminated-other covers other employer-initiated separations. Both can qualify for benefits but VEC may look at them slightly differently during the initial review.

0 coins

oh ok that makes sense I guess, I just clicked whatever looked right when I applied and it worked out fine so

0 coins

Something I wish I'd known when I first filed — there's a difference between how Virginia VEC handles claims where the separation reason is questioned by the employer versus claims where the category just looks unusual in the system. I used to assume any claim that wasn't a clean layoff was automatically going to get flagged and held up in adjudication for weeks. What actually determines whether adjudication happens is whether VEC needs to investigate a potential disqualifying circumstance, like alleged misconduct or a voluntary quit. A restructuring with documentation doesn't usually meet that bar even if you used "Terminated Other." File your claim, write a clear explanation, and let the process work. Most straightforward terminations without misconduct get approved without any adjudication hold.

0 coins

Adjudication is what I was most worried about causing a delay — good to hear that clean terminations without misconduct usually don't trigger it even with the less common dropdown option.

0 coins

Adjudication delays have been rough lately from what I've heard. A friend waited almost five weeks recently without any update. Though apparently hers had some question about whether she was truly available for work during that period.

0 coins

Availability issues are a separate thing from separation reason adjudication — those tend to take longer because VEC has to verify ongoing eligibility, not just the initial separation circumstances.

0 coins

Honestly the whole Virginia VEC application interface is confusing and the dropdown categories don't cover half the real-world situations people are actually in. My termination was a "mutual separation" after a performance conversation and there wasn't even a good option for that — I ended up calling VEC to ask which box to pick and the agent told me to use Terminated Other and explain in the notes. So that category basically exists as the catch-all for anything that doesn't fit the cleaner buckets.

0 coins

Knowing an actual VEC agent told someone to use that category for a complicated separation makes me feel a lot more comfortable about selecting it.

0 coins

Yeah the agent was pretty clear about it — she said the written explanation carries more weight in the review than the dropdown category. Just be detailed and factual in what you write.

0 coins

That tracks with what I've read in other threads. The narrative section is where you actually make your case, the dropdown is just for routing purposes basically.

0 coins

There's a misconception I had for a long time that really messed with my head when I first applied — I thought Virginia VEC approved or denied claims primarily based on how you categorized the separation type in the application. I genuinely believed picking the wrong box from that list could disqualify you on its own. The reality is that VEC determines eligibility based on the full picture: your separation circumstances, any employer response, your work history, and whether there's a disqualifying reason like misconduct or a voluntary quit without good cause. The category you select helps VEC understand the general nature of your claim but it's not a pass/fail gate by itself. For a department elimination with documentation, "Terminated Other" with a thorough written explanation is completely appropriate and won't hurt your approval odds in any meaningful way.

0 coins

Breaking it down like that actually clears up a lot of the anxiety I had about the dropdown. I'll go ahead and select Terminated Other and write out the restructuring details clearly.

0 coins

This is basically what I've seen play out in practice too. The category is a starting point for VEC not a final judgment.

0 coins

The written explanation part is key — I've seen people submit really bare-bones descriptions and then wonder why their claim got held up for clarification. Spell out the who, what, when of the separation even if it feels obvious to you.

0 coins

my whole team got cut last spring and several of us applied around the same time, we all selected different separation reasons because nobody agreed on which one fit best lol. I did layoff, one person did terminated other, another did position eliminated. We all got approved in roughly the same timeframe so at least from that small sample it didn't seem to make a difference which one we picked

0 coins

That's a pretty useful real-world comparison actually. Same underlying situation, different dropdown choices, same outcome. Supports the idea that the narrative and employer response are what drive the decision.

0 coins

Yeah exactly, none of us had any issues. The ones who took longer were dealing with other stuff like a benefits amount dispute, not the separation category.

0 coins

Did any of you go into adjudication or did all the claims just process straight through?

0 coins

Straight through for all of us as far as I know. Nobody mentioned getting an adjudication notice anyway.

0 coins

For anyone reading this who is trying to get a straight answer from Virginia VEC before they submit — I spent a couple of weeks trying to reach someone by phone with zero luck, constant busy signals and disconnects. A family member pointed me toward Claimyr and it actually got me connected to a VEC agent when I'd basically given up on calling. Worth looking at claimyr.com if you need to actually talk to someone. There's also a walkthrough video at https://youtu.be/GK1CFuX4p2k showing how the whole thing works. For a question like this one about which separation category to use, hearing it directly from VEC is way more reassuring than forum guessing.

0 coins

Two weeks of busy signals is brutal. I've had stretches like that trying to reach VEC and it's completely demoralizing. Did Claimyr work on the first try or did it take a few attempts?

0 coins

First time I used it, got through. I was skeptical honestly but it did what it said it would do.

0 coins

I keep seeing Claimyr mentioned in threads like this — might actually try it since I still have an open question about my own claim that I haven't been able to get answered by phone.

0 coins

Filing weekly claims on time after your initial application is just as important as getting the initial separation category right — people sometimes focus all their energy on the application and then don't realize they need to certify each week to keep receiving benefits. Just flagging that for OP since it's easy to overlook when you're stressed about the application itself.

0 coins

I was actually going to ask about that next — do you file weekly claims through the same Customer Self Service portal you use to submit the initial application?

0 coins

Yes, same CSS portal at uidirect.vec.virginia.gov. After your claim is active you'll see the weekly certification option when you log in. Each week you answer questions about work search activity, any earnings, and availability. Miss a week and you lose that week's benefits.

0 coins

Good to know. I'll bookmark the portal once my initial claim is submitted so I don't lose track of the weekly filing schedule.

0 coins

The weekly filing window is specific too — it typically opens Sunday and you're supposed to file within that week. Getting into a routine early helps so you don't accidentally miss it.

0 coins

I confused myself for a while thinking that termination with cause and termination without cause were the same as terminated-other versus laid off on the VEC form. They're actually different things. Terminated with cause means your employer is saying you did something that warranted firing, while the application categories are more about the business reason for the separation. The with-cause/without-cause distinction matters a lot more for whether you qualify for benefits than which exact dropdown category you use.

0 coins

That's an important distinction. Employer-alleged misconduct is a whole separate adjudication issue that goes beyond just the application category. If there's no misconduct in the picture, the specific category on the form matters a lot less.

0 coins

Exactly — OP's situation sounds like a clean business decision elimination with no misconduct, so the category question is basically administrative rather than something that affects eligibility.

0 coins

When I applied last year I actually called VEC before submitting to ask almost this exact question and the agent told me something that stuck with me — she said to pick whatever best describes why your employer ended the relationship, and if none of the options fit perfectly, use Terminated Other and explain the actual circumstances in the notes. She said reviewers read the notes and they care about the story more than the category. Direct from VEC so I figured that was about as official as it gets.

0 coins

Two VEC agents have apparently said the same thing based on this thread — that's consistent enough that I feel confident going with Terminated Other and writing a detailed explanation.

0 coins

Consistency between agent responses on the same question is reassuring. Some VEC guidance can vary depending on who you reach, but when multiple agents say the same thing it's usually the actual policy.

0 coins

That's true — I've gotten conflicting answers from VEC on other questions before. This one seems like the agents are aligned on it though.

0 coins

Does anyone know if you can amend your separation reason after you submit the initial application? Like if OP submits with Terminated Other and then realizes a different category was more accurate, is there a way to correct it before VEC makes a decision?

0 coins

Amending a submitted application usually requires calling VEC directly — there's no edit button in the CSS portal once you submit. That's part of why getting it right before submitting matters, though it's also not the end of the world if you need to call and explain.

0 coins

So you'd need to actually reach a VEC agent by phone to make an amendment — which circles back to the phone access problem people keep mentioning in this thread.

0 coins

For something like a separation category question before a decision is made, that's exactly the kind of thing you'd want to call VEC about rather than just waiting and hoping. Getting through to an agent is worth the effort on that one.

0 coins

job search requirements are another thing worth knowing about before your claim gets approved — Virginia VEC requires you to actively search for work and document those efforts. You need a certain number of job contacts per week and you have to record them in a job search log in case VEC asks to verify your activity. Some people get caught off guard by this, thinking approval is the finish line when really there are ongoing eligibility requirements to maintain.

0 coins

How many job contacts per week does VEC require right now? I want to make sure I'm meeting the requirement from the start.

0 coins

The standard requirement is at least three verifiable job search contacts per week in Virginia. You can record them in the VEC job search log tool. Things like submitting applications, contacting employers, attending interviews — those all count.

0 coins

Is there any grace period when you first get approved or does the job search requirement start immediately from your first weekly certification?

0 coins

From what I understand it starts right away with your first certification week. There's no ramp-up period — VEC expects you to be conducting job searches from the start of your claim.

0 coins

Something that tripped me up was thinking appeals and adjudication were the same step in the process. Adjudication is what VEC does internally when they need to investigate something before making a determination on your claim — it's their review process. An appeal is what you do after VEC has already made a determination and you disagree with it. OP's concern about triggering adjudication by choosing Terminated Other is really about whether that selection would prompt an internal VEC investigation before approval. The answer is basically no, not for a standard termination with no misconduct, as others have said here.

0 coins

So if a claim goes into adjudication it doesn't mean VEC has decided against you, just that they're still reviewing it?

0 coins

Right — adjudication means VEC needs more information or is verifying something before they decide. It delays your approval but doesn't predetermine the outcome. Lots of adjudicated claims still get approved once VEC finishes their review.

0 coins

The timing on adjudication is what gets people though — it can hold up your first payment for weeks and that creates a real financial squeeze when you're already out of work.

0 coins

One more practical note — when my claim was stuck and I couldn't get anyone on the phone to tell me what was going on, I actually tried Claimyr after a coworker recommended it. It's at claimyr.com and there's a video at https://youtu.be/GK1CFuX4p2k that explains it. Got me in touch with a VEC rep who could actually pull up my claim and explain the status. For anyone who submits and then hits a wall trying to find out what's happening with their claim, that's a real option for getting through.

0 coins

Getting an actual explanation of claim status from a live VEC agent is so much better than staring at a portal that just says pending. Glad that worked out for you.

0 coins

Honestly it was the first time I actually understood what was happening with my claim. The portal status messages are vague and unhelpful on their own.

0 coins

pending status is the worst because you don't know if it's normal processing time or if something actually got flagged lol

0 coins

Circling back to OP's original question with a summary since the thread has gotten long — does selecting Terminated Other on the VEC application hurt approval chances? Based on everything shared here: no, not for a situation like yours where you have a documented department elimination, no misconduct, and your employer should corroborate the story. Use the option that most accurately describes your situation, write a detailed explanation, and let VEC do the review. The separation category is a starting point not a gate.

0 coins

This thread ended up being way more informative than I expected. Going ahead with Terminated Other and a detailed explanation. Really appreciate everyone who responded.

0 coins

Filing with clarity and documentation puts you in the best position from the start. Good luck — straightforward terminations like yours typically process without major issues.

0 coins

Come back and update when your claim gets approved — it helps future people searching the same question to see how it resolved.

0 coins

Virginia Unemployment AI

Expert Assistant
Secure