Will IRA withdrawals affect my Social Security benefits before full retirement age?
I'm 62 and just started receiving my Social Security retirement benefits last month. My husband reached his full retirement age (67) earlier this year and is also receiving his benefits. We both claimed based on our own work records. We have a financial situation where we need to withdraw about $8,500 from our IRAs in January to cover some unexpected home repairs. We have separate IRA CDs - one in my name and one in his. Since we file taxes jointly, I'm thinking the tax impact would be the same regardless of which account we withdraw from, but I'm worried about the earnings test. Will withdrawing from my IRA count as "income" that could reduce my monthly Social Security payment since I'm still under FRA? Or should we just take it from his account to be safe?
25 comments
Join the conversation
Zara Mirza
IRA withdrawals don't count toward the Social Security earnings test! Only wages from employment or net earnings from self-employment count. You can withdraw from either IRA without affecting your SS benefits. The earnings test only looks at work income, not investment income or distributions.
0 coins
Sean Kelly
•Oh thank you so much! That's a huge relief. I was worried I'd have to calculate some complicated reduction in my benefits if we used my IRA.
0 coins
Luca Russo
The previous commenter is absolutely correct. IRA distributions are NOT counted as earnings for the Social Security annual earnings limit test. However, there's another consideration - Required Minimum Distributions (RMDs). Is your husband already taking RMDs? If he's over 73, he needs to take those anyway, so it might make sense to take additional funds from his IRA first. Just something to consider for your overall retirement planning.
0 coins
Sean Kelly
•He just turned 67 so we don't have to worry about RMDs yet, but that's good to think about for the future! We're still learning all these retirement rules.
0 coins
Nia Harris
my sister said ANY income affects ur benefits if ur under FRA. she had to pay back like $2000 to SS last year when she took money from her 401k. are u SURE ira doesnt count??
0 coins
Luca Russo
•Your sister might be confusing two different issues. The earnings test only counts work income (employment wages or self-employment earnings). However, IRA/401k withdrawals can potentially make more of your Social Security benefits taxable on your income tax return. That's separate from the earnings test and doesn't actually reduce your monthly benefit amount - it's just about how much of your benefit is taxable.
0 coins
GalaxyGazer
I ran into this exact situation last year! Needed to withdraw from either my IRA or my husband's. Called SSA directly to confirm and they verified that IRA withdrawals DO NOT count against the earnings test. Only work income matters for that. But fair warning - trying to get through to SSA on the phone was a nightmare. I spent over 2 hours on hold and got disconnected twice. I ended up using this service called Claimyr (claimyr.com) that got me connected to an agent in under 10 minutes. They have a video showing how it works here: https://youtu.be/Z-BRbJw3puU. Saved me so much frustration!
0 coins
Sean Kelly
•That's really helpful to know! I tried calling SSA last week and gave up after being on hold for 45 minutes. I might try that service if I need to confirm anything else. Did you end up withdrawing from your IRA or your husband's?
0 coins
GalaxyGazer
•We ended up using mine because it had slightly better terms for early withdrawal. But the SSA agent confirmed it wouldn't affect my benefits at all, which was such a relief!
0 coins
Mateo Sanchez
THESE SSA RULES ARE SO CONFUSING!!! My neighbor lost $340 a month because she was "over the limit" but she swears it was from selling stocks not from working!! The whole system is designed to trick seniors!!! They don't want us to understand our own benefits!!
0 coins
Luca Russo
•There must be more to your neighbor's story. Stock sales and IRA distributions definitely don't count for the earnings test. Either she also had work income she's not mentioning, or there was some other adjustment to her benefits for a different reason. The earnings test rules are actually quite straightforward - only work income counts.
0 coins
Aisha Mahmood
When i was deciding which account to withdraw from, i also looked at the tax brackets. If one of you has other income that might push you into a higher bracket, it might be better to take from the other person's IRA. just something else to think about.
0 coins
Sean Kelly
•That's a good point, but since we file jointly I think our tax brackets are combined anyway. We're both pretty much just living on our Social Security now since we retired.
0 coins
Ethan Moore
i had this same question last month! i thought for sure ira withdrawals would count against the earnings test but they definitely don't. one less thing to worry about lol
0 coins
Sean Kelly
•It's such a relief! I've been stressing about this decision for weeks!
0 coins
Zara Mirza
Although IRA withdrawals don't affect the earnings test, just remember they DO count as income for determining if your Social Security benefits are taxable. If your combined income (adjusted gross income + nontaxable interest + half of your Social Security benefits) exceeds $32,000 for joint filers, up to 50% of your benefits may be taxable. Above $44,000, up to 85% may be taxable. So plan accordingly!
0 coins
Sean Kelly
•Thank you for that reminder. We're aware of the taxation thresholds and have been planning our withdrawals to try to minimize the tax impact. It's like a complicated puzzle trying to balance everything!
0 coins
Emily Jackson
Just wanted to add another perspective - since you mentioned you have IRA CDs, make sure to check if there are any early withdrawal penalties from the CD itself (separate from IRA penalties). Some CDs have penalties for early withdrawal even within an IRA. Also, if you're withdrawing before age 59½, don't forget about the 10% early withdrawal penalty on the IRA distribution for tax purposes. But as everyone else confirmed, none of this affects your Social Security earnings test - only actual work income counts for that!
0 coins
Norman Fraser
•Great point about the CD penalties! I hadn't thought about that. We're both over 59½ so we don't have to worry about the 10% penalty, but I'll definitely check with our bank about any CD-specific penalties before we make the withdrawal. Thanks for thinking of that detail!
0 coins
QuantumQuest
One more thing to consider - if you do decide to withdraw from your husband's IRA since he's at full retirement age, you might want to coordinate the timing with any other income you expect this year. Even though the withdrawal won't affect your Social Security benefits directly, spreading out larger withdrawals across tax years can sometimes help manage your overall tax burden. Since you mentioned this is for January, you're already planning well ahead! The peace of mind knowing it won't impact your SS benefits is definitely worth having.
0 coins
Ian Armstrong
•That's really smart advice about timing and spreading withdrawals across tax years! As someone new to navigating all these retirement rules, I appreciate everyone sharing their experiences. It's reassuring to know there are so many knowledgeable people in this community willing to help. The consensus seems clear that IRA withdrawals won't affect the Social Security earnings test, which takes a huge weight off my shoulders. Now I just need to figure out which account makes the most sense from a tax and penalty perspective.
0 coins
Freya Andersen
As a newcomer to this community, I just wanted to say how helpful this thread has been! I'm approaching 62 myself and have been wondering about similar IRA withdrawal questions. It's really reassuring to see so many experienced members confirming that IRA distributions don't count toward the Social Security earnings test - I had been under the impression that ANY income would affect benefits if you claim before full retirement age. The distinction between work income and investment/retirement account income makes sense now. I'll definitely bookmark this thread for reference when I start navigating these decisions myself. Thanks to everyone who shared their knowledge and real-world experiences!
0 coins
Freya Thomsen
•Welcome to the community, Freya! I'm also relatively new here and have found this thread incredibly valuable. Like you, I was confused about what counts as "income" for Social Security purposes before finding this discussion. It's such a relief to learn that retirement account withdrawals are treated differently from work income for the earnings test. This community really seems to have a wealth of practical knowledge from people who've actually been through these situations. Good luck when you reach your decision point - at least now we both know where to come for reliable advice!
0 coins
Kaitlyn Otto
As someone new to this community, I really appreciate how thoroughly everyone has addressed this question! I'm 59 and starting to think about early retirement planning, and this discussion has been incredibly enlightening. The clear distinction between work income (which counts for the earnings test) and IRA distributions (which don't) is so important to understand. I had been operating under the assumption that all income would potentially affect Social Security benefits if claimed early. It's also helpful to see the practical experiences shared - like the challenges with calling SSA directly and the reminder about CD-specific penalties within IRAs. This kind of real-world knowledge from community members who've actually navigated these situations is invaluable. Thanks to everyone for creating such an informative thread that I'm sure will help many people facing similar decisions!
0 coins
Demi Hall
•Welcome to the community, Kaitlyn! I'm also new here and this thread has been such an eye-opener. At 59, you're in a great position to start planning with this knowledge. Like you, I had no idea there was such a clear distinction between work income and retirement account distributions for Social Security purposes. It's fascinating how many misconceptions exist about these rules - even some of the earlier comments in this thread show how easy it is to get confused about what actually counts toward the earnings test. The practical tips from members who've been through this process are worth their weight in gold. I'm bookmarking this entire discussion for when I need to make these decisions myself. It's reassuring to know there's a community of people willing to share their hard-earned knowledge!
0 coins