Social Security Disability benefit DECREASED at Full Retirement Age - why is my husband's payment going down?
My husband has been on SSDI for about 7 years and receives approximately $2,000 per month. Yesterday, we got this bewildering letter from Social Security saying that when he reaches his Full Retirement Age next month, his benefit will DROP to around $1,535! I'm completely confused - I thought SSDI automatically converts to retirement benefits at exactly the same amount when you reach FRA. How can they possibly REDUCE his payment? It almost seems like they're stripping away all the cost of living adjustments he's received over the years. Has anyone experienced this? What's going on here? Should we appeal this decision or is this actually normal procedure I wasn't aware of?
19 comments


Ryan Andre
This definitely sounds wrong. When SSDI converts to retirement at FRA, the amount should stay exactly the same - it's essentially just an administrative change on their end. The only time I've seen amounts change is when there were previous overpayments being recouped or if he was receiving some additional benefits that had age limits. Did the letter explain any reason for the reduction?
0 coins
Nora Bennett
•The letter just states that the benefit amount will change when he converts from disability to retirement. No explanation about WHY it's being reduced! That's what has me so confused and worried. We definitely don't have any overpayment situation that I know of. Should we try calling SSA directly? I've heard it's nearly impossible to get through to them these days.
0 coins
Lauren Zeb
my uncle had something like this happen!!! turned out he was getting some extra disability thing that stops at retirement age. check if the disability payment had some kinda special addition to it maybe??
0 coins
Nora Bennett
•Thank you! Do you remember what that 'extra disability thing' was called? I'm wondering if there's some terminology I should be looking for when I review his paperwork.
0 coins
Daniel Washington
There are a few possible explanations for this confusing situation: 1. Worker's Compensation Offset: If your husband received Worker's Comp in addition to SSDI, there may have been an offset that ends at FRA. 2. Disability Freeze: During disability, SSA doesn't count low/no-earning years toward benefit calculations (called a "disability freeze"). When converting to retirement, they sometimes recalculate without this protection. 3. Early Retirement: If he took early retirement benefits before going on disability, the reduction factor might be reapplied at FRA. 4. Special Disability Benefits: Some forms of disability include supplemental payments that terminate at retirement age. I strongly recommend requesting an appointment with your local SSA office to get a detailed explanation. Ask specifically for a "BPQY" (Benefits Planning Query) which breaks down all components of his benefit calculation.
0 coins
Nora Bennett
•Thank you so much for these detailed possibilities! My husband did receive Worker's Comp about 8 years ago, but that ended before his disability began. I've never heard of the "disability freeze" concept - that's really interesting and could explain it. We'll definitely request that BPQY report. Is that something we can get online through his my Social Security account or do we need to call/visit an office?
0 coins
Aurora Lacasse
Wow that is cRaZy they would just cut benefits like that when someone is already struggling! The system is totally rigged against disabled people. My cousin had her benefits cut completely when she turned 62 and they said she had to reapply for retirement! She went 3 months with NO income at all. This government is a JOKE!
0 coins
Anthony Young
•That's not how the system works. Benefits don't just get cut off at 62 - your cousin likely encountered a different issue. SSDI automatically converts to retirement at FRA with no reapplication needed. The situation described by OP is unusual and needs investigation, but spreading misinformation doesn't help anyone navigate an already complex system.
0 coins
Charlotte White
Have you been on my Social security website to check his benefit estimates? Sometimes the letters have errors. I'd look online first then call if the numbers still don't match up.
0 coins
Nora Bennett
•That's a good idea. I just checked his online account and it shows the same reduced amount for future benefits. So it doesn't appear to be a letter error. So confusing!
0 coins
Admin_Masters
If you need to speak with someone at Social Security about this reduction (which you absolutely should), try using Claimyr.com to help get through to an agent quickly. I was having a similar issue with benefit calculations last month and spent days trying to reach someone. After using their service, I got through to an SSA rep in less than 20 minutes. They have a demo video at https://youtu.be/Z-BRbJw3puU showing how it works. Saved me hours of frustration and the agent was able to explain my benefit calculation in detail.
0 coins
Nora Bennett
•Thank you for the suggestion! I've never heard of this service before. Did they explain everything clearly when you got through? I'm worried about trying to understand all the technical details over the phone.
0 coins
Admin_Masters
•Yes, the SSA representative I spoke with went through my entire benefit calculation line by line. I actually took notes during the call. Make sure you have all your husband's SSA paperwork in front of you when you call, especially his most recent SSDI award letter and the new letter showing the reduction. Ask them to explain each component of the calculation and why it's changing.
0 coins
Ryan Andre
After thinking about your situation more, I recalled another possibility: if your husband took reduced retirement benefits first and then later qualified for SSDI, his disability benefit would have included both his reduced retirement benefit PLUS an additional amount to bring it up to the full disability rate. When he reaches FRA, the additional amount stops, and he goes back to just his reduced retirement amount. This scenario would explain the significant drop. Did he by chance apply for early retirement before being approved for disability?
0 coins
Nora Bennett
•YES! That's exactly what happened! He took early retirement at 62 and then about 9 months later was approved for SSDI. So they increased his payment at that point. I had completely forgotten about that sequence of events. That explains why it's dropping back down now. Thank you so much for helping me figure this out!
0 coins
Anthony Young
Glad you figured it out! This is a perfect example of why it's important to understand how the original benefit was calculated. When someone takes early retirement and then qualifies for SSDI, they receive their reduced retirement benefit plus an additional amount to reach the full disability benefit level. At FRA, they return to their original reduced retirement amount plus any COLAs. For others reading this thread: this is why claiming strategy and timing matters so much with Social Security benefits. Taking early retirement can have long-term impacts even if you later qualify for disability.
0 coins
Lauren Zeb
•wait so does that mean if u think u might get disability later you should NEVER take early retirement?? this is so confusing!!!
0 coins
Anthony Young
•Generally, if you think you might qualify for disability, it's better to apply for SSDI first rather than taking early retirement. However, each situation is unique based on your health, financial needs, and work history. The key takeaway is that these decisions can have long-term impacts on your benefit amounts.
0 coins
Noland Curtis
•@Lauren Zeb It s'definitely a complex situation! The general rule is that if you re'considering disability benefits, it s'usually better to apply for SSDI before taking early retirement. But like Anthony said, every case is different. If you re'dealing with a serious health condition and need income immediately, sometimes early retirement might be the only option while you wait for a disability decision which (can take months or even years .)The important thing is to understand the long-term implications before making the choice. You might want to consult with a Social Security disability attorney if you re'facing this decision - many offer free consultations.
0 coins