What to say to unemployment when fired - NYSDOL tips
So I got let go from my job at a distribution warehouse last month and I'm trying to figure out how to handle my unemployment claim properly. My supervisor said it was 'performance-related' but honestly the whole situation was murky - I missed a couple of targets during a stretch where our team was understaffed and I was covering two roles. HR gave me a termination letter that just says 'separated for performance reasons' with nothing more specific than that. I filed my UI claim online through the NYSDOL Unemployment Services portal and now I'm worried about what I should say when they ask me about the circumstances of my separation. I don't want to accidentally say something that gets me disqualified but I also don't want to lie. Has anyone been through something like this where the reason for being fired is kind of vague? Do I need to get a lawyer involved or can I handle the NYSDOL phone interview on my own?
76 comments

Anastasia Sokolov
Fired for performance vs. misconduct - that distinction matters a lot to NYSDOL. Performance-based separations (not meeting quotas, low productivity numbers, skill gaps) are generally NOT disqualifying in New York. Misconduct is what disqualifies you, and NYSDOL defines that pretty specifically as deliberate rule violations, theft, harassment - stuff like that. Missing targets because you were stretched thin covering two people's work? That's going to read as performance to any reasonable adjudicator. When they ask you during your phone interview, just tell the truth clearly: you were terminated, the letter says performance, and you believe the circumstances were largely outside your control because of understaffing. Don't oversell the story, don't add dramatic details. Just factual and calm.
0 coins
Diego Rojas
AuthorMy termination letter doesn't actually go into any detail about what the performance issue was - will that hurt me? Like should I be trying to get more documentation from HR before the interview?
0 coins
Anastasia Sokolov
The letter alone is usually enough to establish the reason. If HR gave you anything in writing about expectations or the targets you were supposed to hit, keep those too. But a vague termination letter actually tends to work in a claimant's favor during adjudication because the burden shifts to your former employer to prove misconduct.
0 coins
Sean O'Donnell
Agreed on the burden of proof point. Former employers have to actually demonstrate misconduct to NYSDOL, not just say 'we fired them for performance.' Vague documentation usually means the employer won't be able to make that case.
0 coins
Zara Ahmed
Genuinely confused here - does NYSDOL actually call you for an interview after you file? I filed last week and I haven't heard anything, my claim just says 'processing.' Did I miss something?
0 coins
Anastasia Sokolov
Not every claim triggers a phone interview. If there's a potential issue - like your employer contests the reason for separation - then NYSDOL may schedule an adjudication interview with both you and your employer. If your claim processes clean, you might just get approved without any interview at all.
0 coins
Zara Ahmed
Oh okay that makes way more sense. I was panicking thinking I missed a call or something. My claim status hasn't changed in 5 days which is making me nervous.
0 coins
StarStrider
Five days is nothing, mine sat at processing for almost two weeks before anything moved. Try not to spiral yet.
0 coins
Luca Esposito
Okay so reaching NYSDOL by phone is genuinely one of the more painful experiences I've had dealing with any government agency. I spent three days trying to get through to ask a simple question about my adjudication interview and kept hitting the same busy signal wall. Someone in another thread mentioned Claimyr - basically it waits on hold with NYSDOL so you don't have to, and you end up on the phone with a live agent. I was skeptical but tried it and actually got to talk to someone within the same day. If you need to reach someone before your interview, worth checking out claimyr.com - there's also a video at https://youtu.be/Rdqa1gKtxuE that shows how it works.
0 coins
Diego Rojas
AuthorThree days of busy signals sounds like my worst nightmare honestly. I've been dreading having to call them. Did the agent you spoke to actually help clarify what you needed to say during the interview?
0 coins
Luca Esposito
They walked me through exactly what documentation I should have ready and what kinds of questions to expect. Knowing what was coming made the actual interview way less stressful.
0 coins
Nia Thompson
Busy signals for days is NOT an exaggeration, I tried to reach NYSDOL nine times in one morning and got through zero of them. The hold situation is brutal.
0 coins
Sean O'Donnell
The phone lines are genuinely terrible, especially on Mondays and right after holidays. Mornings mid-week are your best shot if you're going to try without any help.
0 coins
Mateo Rodriguez
My situation last year was similar - fired after a 'performance improvement plan' that I thought I was actually meeting. NYSDOL still approved my claim because my employer couldn't document specific misconduct. The key thing I learned: in your interview, do NOT volunteer extra information beyond what they ask. Answer the question asked, then stop. People get themselves in trouble by over-explaining and accidentally introducing issues the adjudicator wasn't even looking for.
0 coins
Diego Rojas
AuthorMy instinct is definitely to over-explain because I'm nervous. That's really useful to hear - just answer what's asked and don't fill silences.
0 coins
Mateo Rodriguez
Exactly. Silences feel awkward but the interviewer isn't trying to trick you. They're just doing a job. Stick to the facts of your situation and you'll be fine.
0 coins
Aisha Abdullah
This is solid advice. I told my adjudicator way more than necessary and I think it actually delayed my claim while they dug into details I brought up myself.
0 coins
Ethan Wilson
wait so if ur employer just SAYS you were fired for performance can they switch it to misconduct later?? like after you already filed??
0 coins
Anastasia Sokolov
Employers can submit their version of events to NYSDOL during the adjudication process, but they can't just change the documented reason arbitrarily. Whatever they put in writing at the time of termination matters a lot. If the termination letter says performance, that's what NYSDOL is working from unless the employer provides substantial evidence of something else.
0 coins
Ethan Wilson
ok good bc my old job has been really shady and i wouldn't put it past them to try something like that
0 coins
Sean O'Donnell
If your former employer does contest the reason and NYSDOL decides against you initially, you have the right to appeal within 30 days of the determination letter. That appeal goes to an Administrative Law Judge hearing and you can present your side fully there.
0 coins
NeonNova
30 days to appeal - I actually almost missed that window because nobody told me and I didn't read the determination letter carefully enough. Ended up filing my appeal on day 28. If anyone reading this gets a determination you disagree with, read the date on that letter the same day you get it and mark your calendar immediately.
0 coins
Diego Rojas
AuthorDay 28 - that's cutting it incredibly close. I'll definitely keep that in mind if things don't go my way initially.
0 coins
NeonNova
My hands were literally shaking filling out the appeal form. The letter was sitting in a pile of mail for ten days before I even opened it. Learned my lesson.
0 coins
Yuki Tanaka
Appeals are way more winnable than people think too. I went through one last spring - my initial claim got denied after my employer called it misconduct, but at the ALJ hearing I could actually present documentation and explain the full context. Got approved on appeal.
0 coins
Carmen Diaz
For the actual phone interview itself - I work in HR now (not the HR that fired you, obviously) so I see this from both sides. Employers are asked specific questions by NYSDOL too. They need to establish: was there a policy that was violated, did the employee know about it, was it willful. Performance issues almost never meet that standard. Being bad at a job or slow or missing targets is not the same as deliberate policy violation. Your situation sounds very much like straightforward performance which is not a disqualifying reason in New York.
0 coins
Diego Rojas
AuthorHearing it from someone who's been on the HR side is really reassuring actually. I was scared my employer would just be able to say whatever and I'd be stuck.
0 coins
Carmen Diaz
Employers overestimate their ability to deny claims. NYSDOL adjudicators hear these situations constantly and they're pretty good at identifying when an employer is stretching the definition of misconduct.
0 coins
Zara Ahmed
I had no idea employers also had to answer specific structured questions. I assumed it was just them writing a paragraph saying whatever they wanted.
0 coins
Carmen Diaz
Nope, there's a whole questionnaire process. They have to provide dates, specific policy language, documentation of warnings. If they can't back it up, the claim typically gets approved.
0 coins
Nia Thompson
NYSDOL phone situation deserves its own complaint thread honestly. I spent probably 6 hours total across multiple days just trying to ask whether my adjudication interview was rescheduled. SIX HOURS. Got disconnected twice after long waits. This is people's rent money being held up and the phone system is an absolute disaster.
0 coins
StarStrider
Six hours is brutal and unfortunately not unusual. The Monday after a long weekend is somehow even worse.
0 coins
Nia Thompson
Mine was the week after a holiday Monday and it felt like every person in New York was calling at the same time. I eventually got through but only by calling very early on a Thursday.
0 coins
Ethan Wilson
i gave up calling entirely and just kept refreshing my claim status page obsessively which is probably not healthy
0 coins
Andre Laurent
Tried Claimyr when I was dealing with my own claim last winter and needed to talk to someone urgently about a document they said was missing. Claimyr sat on hold for me and I ended up speaking to a NYSDOL agent that afternoon. For anyone who needs to get information clarified before an adjudication interview especially, that kind of access to an actual human being at NYSDOL is worth a lot.
0 coins
Diego Rojas
AuthorThat's exactly my situation - I want to clarify a few things before my interview and I can't figure out what to look up versus what actually requires talking to someone.
0 coins
Andre Laurent
The things worth calling about: interview timing, whether both parties are scheduled for the same call, what documentation they already have on file. Those are hard to figure out from the portal alone.
0 coins
Aisha Abdullah
My adjudication dragged on partly because there was a document submission issue I didn't know about for weeks. Having access to a live agent to catch those things early would have saved me a lot of stress.
0 coins
Sean O'Donnell
Documentation you should have ready before any NYSDOL interview about your separation: your termination letter, any performance review documents from the past year, records of any communication about your workload situation (emails showing you were covering two roles would be gold), and your pay stubs or records showing dates of employment. You probably won't need to submit all of it but having it organized means you're not scrambling.
0 coins
Diego Rojas
AuthorThose emails about covering two roles - I do actually have some of those. I didn't even think about those as potentially relevant to my claim.
0 coins
Sean O'Donnell
Those could be important if your employer contests and tries to frame the performance issue as your fault. Showing you were operating under unusual circumstances without additional compensation or adjusted expectations directly undermines a misconduct argument.
0 coins
NeonNova
Also any texts or messages from supervisors acknowledging the understaffing. Even casual messages help establish the context.
0 coins
Diego Rojas
AuthorGoing through my messages now. There are definitely some from my manager that essentially admit they needed me to cover the gap because they hadn't filled the other role yet.
0 coins
StarStrider
My first unemployment claim years ago I panicked and told the adjudicator I 'kind of understood why they let me go' because I wanted to seem reasonable and not difficult. That phrasing nearly tanked my claim because the adjudicator noted it as me partially accepting fault. Don't try to be diplomatic or make your employer sound reasonable - just describe the facts neutrally.
0 coins
Diego Rojas
AuthorThat's such a specific trap and I could absolutely see myself falling into it. I'm the kind of person who tries to be fair to everyone even when it hurts me.
0 coins
StarStrider
Fairness to your former employer is their lawyer's job, not yours. NYSDOL isn't asking you to be a neutral observer, they're asking what happened to you.
0 coins
Mateo Rodriguez
Describing facts neutrally is exactly right. 'I was told my performance did not meet expectations and I was terminated' is complete and accurate. You don't need to editorialize in either direction.
0 coins
Aisha Abdullah
Does being fired affect how many weeks of UI benefits you can get? I always assumed if you were fired you got fewer weeks or a reduced amount or something.
0 coins
Anastasia Sokolov
Being fired for performance doesn't reduce your benefit amount or duration in New York. Your weekly benefit rate is calculated from your base period wages and the number of weeks you can claim depends on that calculation too. The only way termination affects your claim is if you're disqualified entirely for misconduct - in that case you get nothing, not a reduced amount.
0 coins
Aisha Abdullah
Okay so it's basically all or nothing - either you qualify fully or you're disqualified. I had completely the wrong mental model of this.
0 coins
Sean O'Donnell
That's a really common misconception actually. New York UI is not graduated based on how or why you left - it's tied to your wage history.
0 coins
Yuki Tanaka
My adjudication interview last year ended up being pretty short actually - maybe 20 minutes. The interviewer asked me to describe in my own words why I was separated, whether I received any warnings, whether I was aware of any policies I violated, and whether I had anything else to add. That was basically it. I think people expect it to feel like a cross-examination and it's really much more low-key than that.
0 coins
Diego Rojas
Author20 minutes is way shorter than I was imagining. I think I've been building this up in my head as this incredibly high-stakes interrogation.
0 coins
Yuki Tanaka
It did feel high-stakes in the moment because the money matters, but the interviewer was professional and not adversarial at all. I'd used Claimyr to get through to NYSDOL beforehand to verify my interview was actually scheduled correctly, which helped me walk in knowing I hadn't missed any steps.
0 coins
StarStrider
Knowing your paperwork is in order going in makes a huge difference psychologically. Half the anxiety is 'did I accidentally mess something up without realizing it.
0 coins
Emily Jackson
Weekly certifications - don't forget those exist. While your adjudication is pending you should still be submitting your weekly claim certifications through the portal. Some people stop because they think 'why bother while it's being reviewed' but those weeks only get paid out if you certified for them. Miss them and you lose those payments even if your claim is ultimately approved.
0 coins
Diego Rojas
AuthorI had no idea that was even a thing. I certified my first week but then assumed I should wait until the adjudication was done. Going to certify right now.
0 coins
Emily Jackson
Certify every week without exception. If the system prevents you from certifying for some reason, document that by keeping screenshots. You can sometimes get missed weeks reinstated but it requires contacting NYSDOL and explaining what happened.
0 coins
Zara Ahmed
Wait, I didn't certify last week because I had a freelance thing that paid me and I didn't know if I should report it or just not certify. Did I mess up?
0 coins
Anastasia Sokolov
You need to certify and report the freelance earnings - partial earnings get factored into your weekly payment amount but don't disqualify you. Not certifying means that week is just gone. Try certifying for the missed week if the portal still allows it and report what you earned.
0 coins
Nia Thompson
The online portal doesn't tell you ANYTHING useful about why your claim is in adjudication or what's actually holding it up. You can sit there refreshing it for weeks and it'll just say 'pending' with zero explanation. At least if you can get a human on the phone they can actually tell you what document is missing or what question they need answered. That access to information is what makes actually reaching someone so valuable.
0 coins
Diego Rojas
AuthorThe portal opacity is honestly one of the most stressful parts of this whole process. You just sit and wait and have no idea if everything is fine or if something is quietly going wrong.
0 coins
Nia Thompson
Mine had a document submission problem that I found out about only when I finally got through to someone by phone after two weeks of 'pending.' If I'd known earlier I could have fixed it on day two.
0 coins
Ethan Wilson
same energy with mine, it's been pending for 11 days and i can't tell if that's normal or a problem. the portal is basically useless for status info
0 coins
Liam Mendez
got fired last month too, different industry but similar vibe - they said 'not a good fit' on my paperwork which is basically meaningless. filed, certified, got approved three weeks later with no interview at all. sometimes it just works out without all the drama
0 coins
Diego Rojas
AuthorNot a good' fit is such a nothing phrase and hearing it went smooth for you is reassuring. Mine 'says' performance which feels more specific but maybe'that s also vague enough to befine.
0 coins
Liam Mendez
performance without specific violations sounds identical to my situation honestly. i think they write those things to cover themselves legally without really saying anything
0 coins
Mateo Rodriguez
Not a good' fit is actually language that tends to work very well for claimants because it signals no policy violation 'occurred.' Performance is similar - both are essentially employers 'saying we preferred someone' else in bureaucraticlanguage.
0 coins
NeonNova
My whole thing fell apart initially because I accidentally described the termination as 'partly my fault' in the initial written questionnaire - same trap as the person above but I did it in writing before I even knew there was going to be an interview. If I had to do it over, I would write 'I was notified by my employer that I was being terminated for performance reasons' and nothing else in that box.
0 coins
Diego Rojas
AuthorThe written questionnaire is the initial claim filing, right? I already submitted that but I described things pretty similarly to how I'd say them to a friend. Hoping that wasn't too conversational.
0 coins
NeonNova
Conversational isn't a problem, self-incriminating is. As long as you didn't use language that implies deliberate wrongdoing you're probably fine. 'I tried my best but missed some targets' is very different from 'I see why they had a problem with my work.
0 coins
Sean O'Donnell
The written portion establishes the factual frame but the adjudication interview is where the real details get explored anyway. One imperfect sentence in the initial filing won't sink you if you're consistent and clear in the interview.
0 coins
Zara Ahmed
is there any way to find out what your former employer actually said to NYSDOL about why they fired you? like can you request that information?
0 coins
Anastasia Sokolov
You can request your claim file through a FOIL (Freedom of Information Law) request to NYSDOL, which would include the employer's submitted information. It's not instant and probably not worth doing before your adjudication interview since you won't get it in time, but if you end up appealing a denial it becomes very valuable to know exactly what your employer said.
0 coins
Zara Ahmed
That's good to know for appeal situations. I guess for the interview itself I just need to tell my side clearly and trust the process.
0 coins
Carmen Diaz
At the ALJ appeal stage you're actually entitled to see the information the employer submitted as part of your hearing preparation. So if it gets that far, you won't be flying blind.
0 coins