Back to New York Unemployment

Sofia Rodriguez

NYSDOL unemployment overpayment forgiveness - is it actually possible?

So I got a letter from NYSDOL last month saying I owe back $4,800 in unemployment benefits from claims I filed about two years ago. The letter says there was an 'overpayment determination' and they want repayment within 30 days. I honestly don't know how this happened - I reported my part-time hours every single week when I filed my weekly certifications and I never tried to hide anything. What's killing me is there's zero explanation of WHY they think I was overpaid. Just a dollar amount and a repayment deadline. I've been trying to reach someone at NYSDOL for two weeks now - the phone lines are impossible and I haven't gotten any response through my Unemployment Services portal messages either. My main question is: does unemployment overpayment forgiveness actually exist in New York? Like can NYSDOL actually waive or reduce what I supposedly owe? I've seen people mention it online but I can't find clear info anywhere. And if it does exist, how do you even apply for it? Do I need to appeal first or is a waiver request a separate thing?

Your situation with that $4,800 demand is exactly what I went through last year, so let me share what I found out. First - yes, overpayment forgiveness (technically called a 'waiver' in NY) does exist, but it's not automatic and NYSDOL doesn't advertise it much. You have to specifically request it and show that repaying would cause you financial hardship AND that the overpayment wasn't your fault. The tricky part is you really need to talk to an actual NYSDOL agent to understand what triggered your overpayment determination before you decide whether to appeal the determination itself or request a waiver - because those are two completely different paths. I spent weeks trying to get through on the phone with no luck until I tried Claimyr (claimyr.com) - it basically waits on hold with NYSDOL so you don't have to, and I ended up speaking directly with a live agent who pulled up my file and explained everything. There's a demo at https://youtu.be/Rdqa1gKtxuE if you want to see how it works before trying it. That conversation changed everything for me because I finally understood what I was actually dealing with.

0 coins

My portal account still shows the overpayment balance with no breakdown at all, so I genuinely don't even know what weeks they're disputing. That's what makes this so hard - I can't defend myself against something I don't understand. I'll look into Claimyr because getting through to someone who can actually pull up my file sounds like the first real step here.

0 coins

The waiver vs. appeal distinction you mentioned is huge and most people don't realize it. My sister-in-law made the mistake of only filing an appeal when she should have done both simultaneously - when the appeal was denied she had no waiver request pending and suddenly owed the full amount with no recourse.

0 coins

I didn't know NY even had overpayment waivers. I just assumed if NYSDOL said you owed money you just... owed it. This is actually useful information.

0 coins

The timeline on your overpayment matters more than you might think. Your specific determination date affects whether you're still within the window to appeal the underlying decision - in NY you typically have 30 days from the mailed date on the determination notice to file an appeal. If you're close to or past that, the waiver route becomes your primary option. For the waiver itself, NYSDOL looks at two things: whether you spent the money in good faith (meaning you had no reason to know it wasn't rightfully yours) and whether paying it back would create genuine financial hardship. If both are true, there's a real chance at forgiveness. The form you want is the Request for Waiver of Overpayment - ask for it specifically when you reach an agent.

0 coins

Checked my determination letter again and the mailed date is exactly 23 days ago, so I'm still inside the 30-day appeal window. Does filing an appeal pause the repayment deadline, or do they expect payment while the appeal is pending?

0 coins

Appeals do typically pause collection activity while they're being processed in NY - at least that's how it worked when my husband went through this. But you should confirm that with NYSDOL directly because I've seen people say different things about whether interest or penalties accumulate during the appeal period.

0 coins

You're still inside the window, so definitely file that appeal ASAP even if you end up pursuing the waiver. Filing an appeal costs you nothing and preserves your options. You can always withdraw it later if the waiver works out.

0 coins

I went through an overpayment situation two years ago and what nobody tells you upfront is that the reason CODE on your determination letter matters enormously. There are different categories - fraud overpayments, non-fraud overpayments, employer-reported discrepancies, and so on. Waivers are generally only available for NON-FRAUD overpayments. If NYSDOL coded yours as fraud-related, the waiver path is basically closed and you're looking at an appeal or repayment plan as your only options. Check your letter carefully for any language about 'willful misrepresentation' or 'fraud' - if those words appear, that's a different and more serious situation than what this thread has been discussing.

0 coins

Went back through every line of that letter and there's no mention of fraud or willful misrepresentation anywhere. It just says 'overpayment of benefits' with the amount. So it sounds like I may be in the non-fraud category which is at least some relief.

0 coins

That's actually a significant thing to know - non-fraud overpayments have way more options available. NYSDOL treats fraud cases completely differently and the consequences are much more serious. The fact that your letter doesn't use that language is genuinely good news for your situation.

0 coins

My overpayment letter also didn't say fraud but when I finally talked to an agent they told me it was flagged as a 'potential fraud review' internally which wasn't reflected in the letter at all. So I'd still recommend getting on the phone with NYSDOL to confirm the actual coding on your account, not just what the letter says.

0 coins

okay so I had an overpayment from 2022 and I want to share what actually happened with mine bc I think it might help people here. Mine was about $3,200 and it happened because my former employer reported my separation date differently than I did - they said I quit a week before I actually did which made it look like I collected UI for a week I technically wasn't eligible for and then everything after that got questioned too. I filed an appeal AND a waiver request at the same time (filed them the same day). The appeal took like 4 months to get scheduled for a hearing. The waiver request got reviewed faster. I ended up getting a partial waiver - they knocked like $2,100 off and I had to pay back about $1,100 on a payment plan. So it's not all or nothing, partial waivers happen too.

0 coins

The employer-reported separation date discrepancy is actually making me wonder if something similar happened with me. I did have a complicated end to my last job - there was a period where I was technically still on the books but not actually working. That could absolutely have created the kind of confusion you're describing.

0 coins

Partial waivers are a thing I had no idea about. Everyone talks about it like it's binary - either they forgive the whole thing or you owe everything. Knowing partial forgiveness exists actually makes this less terrifying.

0 coins

the employer separation date issue is SO common and so unfair bc you have no control over what your former employer reports to NYSDOL and you don't even know what they said until the problem has already happened to you

0 coins

There's a financial hardship component to the waiver that people don't always prepare for properly. NYSDOL will look at your current income, monthly expenses, assets, and overall financial picture when evaluating a hardship claim. You'll want to gather documentation - recent pay stubs or proof of current income (or lack of it), bank statements, monthly bills, rent or mortgage statements, that kind of thing. The standard NYSDOL uses is roughly whether repaying the overpayment would leave you unable to meet basic living expenses. So if you're currently employed and doing okay financially, the hardship argument gets harder to make. But if you're still struggling or the amount is large relative to your income, document that thoroughly.

0 coins

My current situation is definitely not great - I'm working but it's part-time and I'm still essentially living paycheck to paycheck. So I think the hardship argument is legitimate in my case, I just need to actually document it properly like you're describing.

0 coins

They asked my husband to submit like three months of bank statements plus a monthly budget worksheet when he applied for the waiver. So gather more documentation than you think you'll need because they can always request more and it delays everything.

0 coins

i got denied on the hardship part even though i thought my situation was pretty tight. the appeals officer said my monthly income was 'above the threshold for demonstrated hardship' even though it really didn't feel that way to me. so make sure you document EVERYTHING including medical expenses, childcare, any extra costs that aren't obvious

0 coins

My overpayment was $6,400 and I went back and forth with NYSDOL for months getting nowhere. The portal messaging system basically goes into a black hole - I'd send messages and get automated acknowledgments and then nothing for weeks. What finally moved things for me was actually getting a live agent on the phone. I used Claimyr to get through the hold wait and ended up talking to someone who had actual authority to look at my account and tell me what documentation I needed to submit for my waiver. That conversation gave me a clear checklist of what to send and where to send it.

0 coins

The portal messaging black hole is exactly what I've been experiencing - automated acknowledgment and then silence. I'm increasingly convinced that actually talking to someone is the only way to get real information about my specific case.

0 coins

I had the same portal message experience - sent four messages over six weeks and got nothing useful back. Some things with NYSDOL genuinely require a phone conversation with a human being who can see your whole account.

0 coins

after my experience i always tell people to do both - send the portal message AND try to get through on the phone. the portal message creates a paper trail which can be useful, but the actual information comes from phone calls

0 coins

six thousand dollars is a terrifying amount to owe back. glad you found a way to get through to someone who could actually help

0 coins

I want to add some context about what happens if you don't respond to the overpayment notice within the timeframe. NYSDOL has the ability to intercept your state tax refund, offset future UI benefits, and in some cases refer the debt to a collection agency. They can also intercept federal payments under certain programs. So while it feels overwhelming, not responding is definitely the worst option - even sending a letter saying you're requesting a waiver or appealing buys you some time and shows you're engaging with the process.

0 coins

Tax refund interception is something I hadn't even thought about - I was planning to use my refund to cover some bills this year. That's another reason I need to get this resolved or at least have a formal process underway before tax season.

0 coins

they also can garnish wages in some situations from what i understand??? like if it goes to collections it becomes a whole different and much worse problem. dealing with it directly through NYSDOL while you still can is definitely the right move

0 coins

the offset of future UI benefits is the one that got me - I didn't know about it and ended up in a situation where I needed UI again later and they just took it out of my new claim automatically. it was jarring to see my weekly payment reduced with no warning

0 coins

The key thing in your situation is that you're still within the appeal window and you haven't ignored the notice - you're actively trying to resolve it. NYSDOL generally treats responsive claimants much better than ones who go silent. Document everything you're doing to try to reach them, including failed call attempts, portal messages sent, etc.

0 coins

Does the overpayment forgiveness waiver thing apply to people who already set up a repayment plan? Because my situation is that NYSDOL basically pressured me into agreeing to a repayment plan like two months ago and I've been making monthly payments but it's really straining my budget. Can I still apply for a waiver even though I technically already agreed to pay it back?

0 coins

Your agreement to a repayment plan doesn't necessarily waive your right to request forgiveness - it's worth asking NYSDOL directly whether a waiver application can still be submitted. The fact that you've been making payments might actually work in your favor as evidence of good faith.

0 coins

This is actually a nuanced question that probably needs a direct answer from NYSDOL rather than forum speculation. The repayment plan agreement language matters - some agreements have clauses about waiving further challenges. I'd strongly recommend getting that agreement reviewed.

0 coins

I honestly just agreed to it because I was scared and didn't know I had other options. I wish I'd found this thread two months ago before I signed anything.

0 coins

The waiver request process - once you know what you're doing - is actually pretty manageable. You fill out the financial disclosure form, attach your supporting documents, write a brief statement explaining why you believe the overpayment wasn't your fault and why repayment causes hardship, and submit it to the NYSDOL address listed on your determination letter. Keep copies of absolutely everything. The review can take anywhere from 6 to 16 weeks depending on their backlog. During that time, collection activity is typically suspended though you should confirm that in writing when you submit. I know someone who used Claimyr to get through to an agent specifically to get written confirmation that his waiver submission had been received and that collection was paused - that peace of mind was worth a lot to him.

0 coins

The 6 to 16 week range is wide but at least it's a known window. I'm going to get the waiver documentation together this week and also try to get an agent on the phone to confirm receipt and status of everything.

0 coins

The 'confirm in writing' point is so important. I've heard too many stories of people who submitted things to NYSDOL and got no confirmation and then the collection activity continued anyway because apparently the submission got lost or misrouted.

0 coins

Submitting via certified mail with return receipt requested for anything important to NYSDOL is something I always recommend. It's not foolproof but it gives you dated proof of delivery which can matter a lot if there are later disputes about whether and when you responded.

0 coins

i didn't know you could get confirmation that collection is paused during waiver review. i just assumed they'd keep trying to collect regardless

0 coins

wait I'm confused about something in this thread - are people saying you can appeal AND request a waiver at the same time? I thought an appeal was for when you disagree with the determination entirely and a waiver is for when you agree you were overpaid but want forgiveness. Are those really two separate things you can file simultaneously?

0 coins

Yes, they're genuinely separate processes and yes, you can file both. An appeal says 'I don't think I was overpaid at all, let's have this reviewed.' A waiver says 'even if I was overpaid, I shouldn't have to repay it due to good faith and hardship.' Filing both hedges your bets - if the appeal succeeds, great. If not, the waiver is already in process.

0 coins

Okay that makes so much more sense. I've been lurking on this thread trying to figure out my own situation and I was under the impression it was one or the other. I'm going to file both.

0 coins

the dual-filing strategy is legitimately the advice most people wish they'd gotten earlier. you lose nothing by filing both and you preserve all your options

0 coins

My overpayment experience taught me that the initial determination letter is often vague on purpose - like NYSDOL sends the basic demand letter first and you have to request the detailed breakdown. There's something called a 'computation sheet' or 'detailed overpayment calculation' that shows exactly which weeks they're claiming you were overpaid and by how much. You can request this specifically. Once I got that document I realized NYSDOL had used my employer's reported earnings for a week where I had already self-reported the same earnings - they essentially counted the same income twice. That error was the entire basis of my overpayment and it got corrected once I had the actual numbers to work with.

0 coins

Requesting the detailed calculation breakdown is something I'm definitely going to do first thing. If they doubled-counted income the way you're describing, that could explain my situation entirely - especially given the complicated reporting period I had at the end of my last job.

0 coins

The double-counting issue is more common than NYSDOL would probably like to admit. The system gets employer wage reports AND claimant self-reporting and those two data sources don't always reconcile cleanly, especially for jobs that ended mid-week or had irregular hours.

0 coins

I had a similar double-counting issue but it took me four months to discover it because I didn't know I could request the detailed calculation. I just assumed NYSDOL's numbers were correct. Turns out they weren't.

0 coins

The hearing process, if you end up at that stage after appealing, is less intimidating than it sounds. It's typically done by phone with an Administrative Law Judge - you get to present your side, submit documents as evidence, and the ALJ can call in your former employer as well. I was terrified going into mine but the ALJ was pretty neutral and actually helpful in guiding what documents mattered. If you're at the hearing stage, free legal aid organizations sometimes assist with UI appeals specifically. The Legal Aid Society and other nonprofits in NY do this. Worth looking into before your hearing date.

0 coins

Knowing that free legal help exists for UI appeals is genuinely helpful - I hadn't thought to look for that. I'll research legal aid options in my area in case the waiver doesn't work out and I end up at the hearing stage.

0 coins

the ALJ hearings being by phone makes them so much less scary. I had visions of having to show up somewhere and argue in person. phone hearings are still stressful but way more manageable.

0 coins

Legal aid orgs that specialize in UI cases know NYSDOL procedures really well and often catch procedural errors that average claimants would miss. If you can get one, do it.

0 coins

I want to circle back to the problem of actually reaching NYSDOL when you have an urgent overpayment situation. I tried calling for three weeks - mornings, afternoons, end of day - and kept hitting busy signals or getting disconnected after long waits. I eventually used Claimyr and finally got a live NYSDOL agent on the line after the hold was handled for me. The agent I spoke with walked me through my account and explained exactly what triggered the overpayment flag and what my options were. That information would have taken me months to piece together on my own.

0 coins

Three weeks of busy signals sounds absolutely miserable. What time of day did you usually try before you used Claimyr? I'm still trying the manual route and wondering if there's a magic window.

0 coins

My attempts were mostly mid-morning which apparently is one of the busiest times. People online say very early - like right when lines open - is better, but I tried that a few times too with the same result. Some weeks NYSDOL volume is just high regardless of timing.

0 coins

i've heard tuesday and wednesday are marginally better than monday but honestly my experience is that NYSDOL phone lines are just hard no matter what

0 coins

the fact that getting basic information about your own claim requires this much effort is genuinely one of the most frustrating things about the unemployment system. it shouldn't be this hard to find out why you supposedly owe thousands of dollars

0 coins

Has anyone had success with NYSDOL reducing an overpayment to zero through the waiver? Like full forgiveness? Or is partial reduction more typical? I'm in a similar situation (owe about $5,500) and trying to calibrate my expectations before I go through all of this.

0 coins

My partial waiver knocked off about two-thirds of mine so I'd say significant reduction is definitely possible. Full forgiveness probably depends a lot on how clearly you can demonstrate both good faith AND genuine financial hardship - if both factors are really strong, full waivers do happen.

0 coins

Full waivers happen when the case is really clear-cut - the claimant genuinely didn't know the overpayment was happening, spent the money on normal living expenses, and would genuinely suffer serious hardship repaying. The stronger both prongs are, the better the outcome.

0 coins

For your $5,500 situation, I'd document financial hardship very thoroughly. The larger the amount, the more important it is to have strong documentation because NYSDOL will look more carefully at bigger waiver requests.

0 coins

Something I want to flag for the original poster - when you file your waiver request and your appeal, make sure the contact information on your NYSDOL account is current and you're checking your Unemployment Services portal frequently. NYSDOL will send determination notices and hearing notices through the portal and by mail, and missing a notice because you weren't checking can result in a default decision against you. Hearing notices sometimes give you as little as 10 days to respond or confirm, so you really need to be on top of that account during this whole process.

0 coins

Went through my portal settings just now and my address and email were actually outdated from when I moved last year. Updated everything. Really glad you mentioned this because a missed hearing notice due to wrong contact info would have been devastating.

0 coins

The portal notification settings are something most people set up once when they first file and never check again. I had to help my brother-in-law update his because he'd moved twice since his original claim and all his notices were going to old addresses.

0 coins

NYSDOL sending important legal notices that have 10-day response windows to potentially outdated contact info is such a design flaw. they should require claimants to verify contact info before sending something that time-sensitive

0 coins

The job search requirements are separate from overpayment issues but I want to mention one thing that caused overpayments for a lot of people - during certain periods NYSDOL temporarily waived the job search requirement and then later determined that some claimants who certified they were meeting requirements actually weren't because the guidance changed and nobody was clear on what applied when. If your overpayment corresponds to a period with unusual requirements, that context could help your case.

0 coins

My overpayment period is from about two years ago - so that could potentially be relevant to my situation. I'll mention this when I talk to an agent.

0 coins

The job search certification issue affected a surprising number of people and NYSDOL has handled those cases inconsistently. If that's what triggered yours, it's worth specifically raising that context in your appeal or waiver statement.

0 coins

For people in this thread who are earlier in the process - if you're currently filing weekly claims and you get any notice that something is under review or that your employer reported something different from what you reported, respond to it immediately. Don't wait. The overpayment issue usually starts as a flag that sits unresolved and balloons into a demand letter months later. Catching it at the flag stage is so much easier than dealing with a formal overpayment determination.

0 coins

I wish I had read something like this two years ago. My flag sat unresolved for eight months while I kept filing because I didn't understand what it meant. By the time I got the demand letter it was a huge amount.

0 coins

how do you even know if there's a flag on your account? is it visible somewhere in the portal or do you only find out when you get a letter

0 coins

There's usually something in your portal - either a message, a note in your claim status, or sometimes a questionnaire that gets sent. But honestly it's not always obvious which is part of the problem. If your claim status ever changes or you see anything unexpected, that's the time to call NYSDOL and ask what it means.

0 coins

i just want to say to the original poster - you're doing the right thing by asking questions and not just panicking or ignoring the letter. I ignored my first notice for two weeks because I couldn't believe it was real and that delay made everything harder. the people in this thread have given you a really solid roadmap. appeal within your window, request the detailed calculation, file a waiver, document your hardship, and get an actual human on the phone who can see your account.

0 coins

Reading through everything in this thread has honestly calmed me down significantly. When I first got that letter I felt completely blindsided and like I had no options. Now I have a clear list of steps and I know there are real paths forward here. Thank you everyone.

0 coins

good luck with everything - hope the waiver comes through for you

0 coins

update us when you have news - threads like this are more useful when we know how they actually turned out

0 coins

Related posts

New York Unemployment AI

Expert Assistant
Secure