NYSDOL asked me for reason for separation unemployment claim - what do I put?
So I'm going through the initial claim filing on the NYSDOL unemployment portal and I got stuck on the section asking for the reason for separation. My situation is a little complicated and I'm not sure which category actually fits. I was working as a project coordinator at a mid-sized logistics company for about two and a half years. At the start of this year they eliminated my entire department and gave us all 30 days notice. I technically signed a separation agreement but I didn't resign - they just ended the position entirely. The dropdown options in the portal are confusing me because there's 'layoff', 'position eliminated', 'lack of work', and a few others and I genuinely don't know which one NYSDOL considers the right one for my situation. I'm worried that if I pick the wrong category I'll trigger some kind of adjudication flag on my claim and delay everything. Has anyone dealt with something similar when filing? Does the specific wording I choose actually matter that much, or is NYSDOL going to verify the details with my employer anyway?
70 comments

Sofia Gomez
The separation reason genuinely does matter more than people think. My department got cut last spring and I second-guessed myself on that exact same screen for probably 20 minutes. What I ended up learning is that 'position eliminated' and 'layoff due to lack of work' are both employer-initiated separations, so either one is going to work in your favor eligibility-wise. The key thing NYSDOL is trying to establish is whether you left voluntarily or were separated through no fault of your own. Since your whole department was cut and you got written notice, you're firmly in that second bucket. NYSDOL does cross-reference with your employer so the category you pick just needs to be in the right general territory - they're not going to deny you because you chose 'lack of work' instead of 'position eliminated' when both describe the same thing.
0 coins
Dylan Evans
AuthorMy biggest fear was exactly that - picking one that looked like a voluntary quit. That makes me feel a lot better. I'll go with 'position eliminated' since that's literally what happened.
0 coins
StormChaser
This matches what I went through. When NYSDOL verified with my old employer, what mattered was that the employer confirmed it was their decision to end the job, not mine. The specific dropdown label was secondary.
0 coins
Dmitry Petrov
Accurate info here. The employer response to NYSDOL's separation questionnaire carries a lot of weight in how the claim gets processed, especially when the category is ambiguous.
0 coins
Ava Williams
I went through this last year after my company did a round of layoffs and honestly the reason for separation section tripped me up too. What I didn't realize at first is that if you signed a severance agreement or separation agreement, NYSDOL sometimes treats that differently depending on what was in it. Some of those agreements have clauses about not filing for unemployment or waiving certain rights - worth double checking yours before you submit the claim. That said, signing an agreement alone doesn't disqualify you in New York, especially when the layoff was the employer's call.
0 coins
Dylan Evans
AuthorMine had a standard release of claims against the employer but nothing about unemployment benefits specifically. I checked after reading your comment and I think I'm fine.
0 coins
Miguel Castro
Severance agreements and UI eligibility tripped me up too when I first filed. In New York, signing a severance agreement doesn't waive your right to claim unemployment as long as you weren't the one who initiated the separation. The release language is usually about civil claims, not state benefits.
0 coins
Zainab Ibrahim
Yeah the severance thing is a common misconception. I've seen people not even bother filing because they thought the agreement meant they couldn't. NYSDOL doesn't care that you got severance - they care why the job ended.
0 coins
Connor O'Neill
While you're sorting out the separation category, if you need to actually reach NYSDOL to ask someone about how to classify your situation before submitting, the hold times are brutal right now. I spent three hours on hold twice and never got through. What finally worked for me was Claimyr - it waits on hold with NYSDOL for you so you end up talking directly to a live agent. Saved me a whole day of frustration. Their site is claimyr.com and there's a video showing how it works at https://youtu.be/Rdqa1gKtxuE. For something like a separation category question, being able to actually talk to an NYSDOL rep before you submit is worth it.
0 coins
Dylan Evans
AuthorThree hours and still nothing - that's exactly what I was dreading. I might actually use this before I submit, since I want someone at NYSDOL to confirm the category before I lock it in.
0 coins
LunarEclipse
I used Claimyr a few weeks ago when my claim status went weird after I reported part-time hours. Got to speak with an agent and had the issue sorted the same day. Way better than refreshing my account page and guessing.
0 coins
Yara Khalil
Wait so you just end up on the phone with an actual NYSDOL person? That alone sounds worth it. I've been trying to get through for two weeks about an adjudication hold on my claim.
0 coins
Keisha Brown
My layoff paperwork said 'reduction in force' and I wasn't sure if that was the same as a standard layoff for NYSDOL purposes. Ended up picking 'layoff - lack of work' and my claim went through without adjudication. I think as long as you're consistent - pick one category and make sure the narrative you write in the explanation box matches it - NYSDOL isn't going to split hairs over it when the employer confirms they cut the position.
0 coins
Dylan Evans
AuthorThe explanation box is what I keep forgetting exists. I should probably write a couple sentences there clarifying that the whole department was eliminated, not just my role individually.
0 coins
Paolo Esposito
The explanation box matters a lot actually. A brief factual sentence or two in there can prevent an adjudication hold because it gives NYSDOL enough context to verify without having to investigate further. Keep it factual, no emotion, just what happened.
0 coins
Amina Toure
I left my explanation box blank the first time I filed and my claim sat in adjudication for almost three weeks. Second time I filed a few years later I wrote two sentences and it was approved in four days. No way to know for sure but I think the explanation made the difference.
0 coins
Oliver Weber
Okay here's something that actually messed up my claim that I want people to know about. When I was laid off my manager verbally told me I could 'resign in lieu of termination' to make it look better on my record, and I did it. What I didn't understand is that NYSDOL sees that as a voluntary quit, which is completely different from being laid off, and my claim was disqualified. I had to appeal and show documentation that the layoff was happening regardless. It took months. If your situation is truly a department elimination with written notice, you're in a much cleaner spot than I was - just make sure you're selecting the involuntary category and not anything that sounds like you chose to leave.
0 coins
Dylan Evans
AuthorThat's genuinely alarming. I did not resign in any form - I received written notice from HR that the department was being shut down. So I should be clearly on the involuntary side.
0 coins
Sofia Gomez
The 'resign in lieu' situation is unfortunately more common than people realize and NYSDOL does not look past the word 'resignation' easily without documentation proving it was coerced or inevitable. OP's situation with written department elimination notice is very different and much cleaner.
0 coins
Ava Williams
Yeah what happened to you is basically the worst version of that scenario. Employers sometimes suggest it without telling people it affects their UI claim. Glad you eventually got it sorted through the appeal.
0 coins
Dmitry Petrov
New York unemployment law is pretty clear that a resignation under duress or when termination is inevitable can still be treated as an employer-initiated separation - but you have to be able to prove the circumstances, which is exactly what the appeal process ended up requiring in your case.
0 coins
FireflyDreams
Does it matter what industry you were in when you pick the reason for separation? I work in construction and layoffs there are super seasonal and I always just pick 'lack of work' but someone told me that's only for construction and that might not apply to other fields the same way?
0 coins
Sofia Gomez
The 'lack of work' category gets used across industries in New York, it's not exclusive to construction. The seasonal layoff situation in construction does have its own nuances around standby status and return-to-work expectations, but the base separation reason of lack of work applies broadly.
0 coins
Keisha Brown
I'm in tech and used 'lack of work' for my layoff and it went through fine. It's really just the umbrella term for when the employer doesn't have work for you anymore, whatever the industry.
0 coins
FireflyDreams
Okay that clears it up. I was overthinking it.
0 coins
Natasha Kuznetsova
My former coworker filed the same week I did after our company downsized and she picked 'discharged/fired' instead of 'layoff' because she misread the options. Her claim got flagged for adjudication immediately because NYSDOL has to investigate firings for misconduct. She ended up having to call in and correct it which took forever. Triple check that you're not accidentally clicking something in the 'discharge' or 'fired' category when what you mean is a layoff or elimination.
0 coins
Dylan Evans
AuthorI can absolutely see myself misreading that on a stressful day of filing. I'm going to take a screenshot of the screen before I submit so I have a record of what I selected.
0 coins
Miguel Castro
The screenshot idea is smart. I do that for every major step of my claims now - reason for separation, weekly certification answers, everything. It's saved me twice when NYSDOL's records didn't match what I thought I submitted.
0 coins
Amina Toure
Your coworker's situation is exactly why the explanation box matters too. Even if she'd picked the wrong dropdown, a clear note in the explanation saying 'this was a company-wide layoff' would have signaled to whoever reviewed it that the category might be wrong.
0 coins
Javier Morales
I had a terrible time getting any clarity on this when I filed. Spent days trying to reach NYSDOL to ask about my separation category before submitting. What helped me eventually was Claimyr - I ended up speaking with a live NYSDOL agent and she walked me through exactly which category fit my situation. For anyone who actually wants a human at NYSDOL to review their specific scenario before they click submit, that's the route I'd take.
0 coins
Yara Khalil
My claim has been in adjudication for going on five weeks and I've been trying to reach someone the whole time. Might try Claimyr just to finally get a person on the line.
0 coins
Zainab Ibrahim
Talking to an actual NYSDOL rep about separation categories before filing is underrated. The online resources don't cover every scenario and the difference between a smooth approval and a weeks-long adjudication hold often comes down to how the initial claim is coded.
0 coins
Dylan Evans
AuthorI ended up reaching an NYSDOL agent through Claimyr before I submitted my claim, based on this thread's suggestions. She confirmed 'position eliminated' was the right category for my situation and also told me what to put in the explanation box. Worth every bit of time it saved.
0 coins
Paolo Esposito
The part about signing a separation agreement is worth its own conversation. I signed one that included a 60-day notice period as part of a WARN Act situation and I wasn't sure whether the 60 days of continued employment changed anything about my separation date for NYSDOL purposes. Turns out the separation date for UI filing is your actual last day of work, not the date the layoff was announced. Took me a while to find that answer.
0 coins
Dmitry Petrov
WARN Act situations add a layer of complexity because of the advance notice requirements. The key rule in New York is that your base period and benefit rate calculations use your actual wages up to your last day worked, and your filing date should be close to that last day - not the announcement date.
0 coins
Ava Williams
I didn't even know WARN Act was relevant to UI timing. That's the kind of thing that would definitely trip someone up during initial filing if they assumed the announcement date was what mattered.
0 coins
Keisha Brown
The timing of when you file also matters because waiting too long after your last day can affect your benefit year start date and potentially shift which quarters count toward your base period. File as soon as you can after separation.
0 coins
StormChaser
My HR department actually handed out a little sheet with their company's preferred language for the reason for separation when they laid us off. It said to list it as 'lack of work - position eliminated' and to reference the department closure letter if NYSDOL requested documentation. I thought that was weirdly proactive but it made filing so much simpler. If you still have contact with your former HR, it might be worth asking them what language they're using when they respond to NYSDOL's employer verification.
0 coins
Dylan Evans
AuthorMy HR contact is actually still reachable during the transition period. I'm going to email her today and ask exactly that. Great suggestion.
0 coins
Natasha Kuznetsova
The employer verification response from HR is basically the other half of your claim. When NYSDOL contacts them, whatever HR writes needs to match what you filed. If your HR is proactively aligned on the language, that's about as smooth as it gets.
0 coins
Oliver Weber
I wish my old HR had done that. The miscommunication between what I filed and what my employer submitted is part of what complicated my adjudication.
0 coins
Amina Toure
My claim ended up in a weird middle zone where the company listed the reason as 'mutual agreement' with NYSDOL but I had listed it as 'position eliminated.' The mismatch caused a 6-week adjudication delay. NYSDOL sent me a questionnaire asking me to explain the discrepancy and I had to gather emails and meeting notes to prove the conversation about 'mutual agreement' was essentially them telling me my role was gone and asking me to sign off. The adjudication examiner ultimately sided with me but it was exhausting.
0 coins
Miguel Castro
Mutual' agreement is one of those terms employers use to soften a layoff but NYSDOL reads it differently 'than position' eliminated. If the employer uses that language and you'don t, it triggers a review almost everytime.
0 coins
Paolo Esposito
Documentation like the emails and meeting notes you saved is exactly what gets adjudication resolved in your favor. Claimants who have nothing in writing to support their version of events have a much harder time even when they're being completely honest.
0 coins
Sofia Gomez
What you went through is a good argument for aligning with HR before you file, the way another commenter mentioned. Even a quick email exchange confirming the language your former employer plans to use with NYSDOL can prevent exactly this kind of mismatch.
0 coins
Emma Anderson
After weeks of being unable to get through on the phone, I found out from a coworker who was laid off at the same time as me that she had used Claimyr to reach NYSDOL and actually spoke to an agent about her adjudication status. I tried it and had the same experience - sat on hold so long every other time, then with Claimyr an agent picked up and I could finally ask my questions about the separation reason directly. Completely changed how I dealt with the rest of my claim.
0 coins
Yara Khalil
My phone has sat on speaker for literal hours trying to reach NYSDOL. Hearing that Claimyr actually got you to an agent makes me want to try it this week.
0 coins
Zainab Ibrahim
The separation reason question specifically benefits from talking to an actual NYSDOL person because the written guidance online doesn't cover every scenario. Having an agent confirm you're using the right category before you lock in the claim is so much better than guessing and hoping.
0 coins
FireflyDreams
I've been dealing with the same hold time nightmare. Going to look into this for my current claim issue.
0 coins
Dmitry Petrov
There's also a documentation angle here that people overlook during initial filing. Whatever you have in writing from your employer - the department closure announcement, the HR letter, the separation agreement itself - you should keep all of it in one place. NYSDOL may not ask for it immediately but if adjudication does happen, having that documentation organized means you can respond to any questionnaire or hearing quickly. I keep a folder with every piece of paper from every separation I've ever had.
0 coins
StormChaser
The folder system is exactly right. My HR closure letter had the specific language 'position eliminated as a result of departmental restructuring' and quoting that verbatim in my adjudication questionnaire response matched what NYSDOL received from the employer and resolved the review quickly.
0 coins
Dylan Evans
AuthorI've got the written department closure notice, the signed separation agreement, and a couple of emails from HR. Going to scan them all tonight and keep a digital folder.
0 coins
Natasha Kuznetsova
Physical documentation for unemployment claims is underrated. People assume NYSDOL has everything they need internally but claimants often have to supply evidence the system doesn't automatically hold.
0 coins
Zainab Ibrahim
Another angle on this whole question: the reason for separation also affects what NYSDOL calls your 'availability requirements' going forward. When you're separated because of a layoff or elimination, you're considered fully available for work and subject to the standard job search requirements - three documented job search activities per week. If your separation was coded as something that required adjudication, those requirements could be temporarily different during the review. Getting the initial category right keeps your weekly certification process straightforward from day one.
0 coins
Dylan Evans
AuthorI hadn't even thought about how the separation category affects the ongoing weekly certification process. That's an important downstream consequence of getting the initial filing right.
0 coins
Miguel Castro
The job search activities requirement is non-negotiable once you're approved. Three per week, documented, and NYSDOL does audit them. Claimants sometimes slack on documentation thinking it's just a formality and then get hit with an overpayment demand later.
0 coins
Ava Williams
This is why the initial filing matters so much - it sets the terms for everything that follows. A clean separation category with no adjudication flag means you go straight into the standard weekly claim cycle without interruption.
0 coins
Yara Khalil
I was laid off in January and my separation reason was actually contested by my employer who claimed I'd resigned. I had not. NYSDOL sent me a form asking for my account of events and I submitted it with a timeline and supporting emails. The adjudication took about five weeks but I won. The whole process was nerve-wracking and I could not reach anyone by phone for most of it. I wish I had known about better ways to reach NYSDOL earlier in the process.
0 coins
Amina Toure
Five weeks of adjudication while your employer was actively contesting your claim sounds incredibly stressful. The fact that you won with documentation shows the process can work but it definitely takes a toll.
0 coins
Oliver Weber
Employer-contested separations are the hardest version of this situation. NYSDOL has to do a full investigation when the two accounts don't match, which means every day of adjudication is another day without benefits.
0 coins
Keisha Brown
Your experience is a good reminder that even when you do everything right on the initial filing, an employer can file a protest that triggers adjudication. Having all your documentation ready from the start means you're prepared to respond immediately instead of scrambling.
0 coins
Miguel Castro
My first unemployment claim years ago, I had no idea what adjudication even was. I thought my claim was denied when it went into that status. I ended up not filing my weekly certifications during the adjudication period because I assumed there was no point. Big mistake - when my claim was approved I had no certifications on file for those weeks and had to go back and do a manual correction process with NYSDOL that took months. Keep filing your weekly certifications even if your claim status shows adjudication.
0 coins
Dylan Evans
AuthorThis is critical information I would not have thought about. I'm going to set a reminder for myself to certify every week regardless of what the status screen says.
0 coins
Paolo Esposito
The 'keep certifying during adjudication' rule is one of the most important and least communicated things about the NYSDOL claim process. Stopping certifications during adjudication creates a secondary problem that can be harder to fix than the original adjudication.
0 coins
Sofia Gomez
NYSDOL explicitly states you should continue weekly certifications during adjudication but that guidance is buried in their FAQ and most first-time claimants never see it. It should be on the homepage.
0 coins
Dmitry Petrov
Even if you can't get through by phone during adjudication, your weekly certifications should still be submitted through your Unemployment Services account online. The online system stays open for certifications regardless of your claim status.
0 coins
LunarEclipse
My whole claim process felt impossible to navigate until I actually reached a person at NYSDOL. I'd had my claim sitting with a weird adjudication note for three weeks and couldn't get any explanation from the online portal. Used Claimyr and ended up on the phone with an agent who explained exactly what the hold was about and what I needed to submit to resolve it. For something as confusing as the reason for separation flagging your claim, being able to ask a real person makes a completely different kind of difference.
0 coins
Yara Khalil
Three weeks with no explanation from the portal is exactly where I've been. Good to know there's a path to actually reaching someone.
0 coins
Ava Williams
The online portal is useful for basic status updates but it doesn't tell you why something is flagged or what specifically needs to happen next. That information lives with the agents and you need to get to one to find it out.
0 coins
StormChaser
The separation reason question being resolved with a live agent before submission rather than after an adjudication flag is so much more efficient. Prevention is a lot less painful than the fix.
0 coins