NYS Department of Labor unemployment requirements for employers - need help understanding how unemployment works for employers
I just started my own small business in Brooklyn and hired my first employee last month. I'm trying to figure out all the NYS Department of Labor requirements for unemployment insurance. I know I need to pay into the system but I'm confused about the rates, when I need to register, and what happens if my employee files for unemployment benefits. Can someone explain how unemployment works for employers in New York? I don't want to mess this up and get hit with penalties.
13 comments
Join the conversation
Lucas Schmidt
You need to register with NYS Department of Labor for unemployment insurance as soon as you have employees. The base rate for new employers is usually around 4.1% but it varies based on your industry. You'll pay this on wages up to the taxable wage base which is $12,300 for 2025. Once you have a claims history, your rate will be adjusted based on how many former employees file for benefits.
0 coins
Eloise Kendrick
•Thanks! Do I register online or do I need to mail forms? And when exactly do I need to pay - is it quarterly?
0 coins
Freya Collins
Yes you register online through the NYS Department of Labor employer portal. The payments are quarterly and you'll also need to file wage reports showing what you paid each employee. If someone files for unemployment, NYS Department of Labor will send you a notice asking if you want to contest the claim. You have 10 days to respond if you think they were fired for misconduct or quit without good cause.
0 coins
Eloise Kendrick
•What counts as misconduct? Like if someone is chronically late or doesn't do their job properly?
0 coins
Freya Collins
•Chronic lateness can be misconduct if you documented it and gave warnings. Not meeting performance standards is trickier - it has to be willful misconduct, not just inability to do the job. Keep good records of any disciplinary actions.
0 coins
LongPeri
just went through this last year when i had to lay someone off. the nys department of labor will investigate if you contest a claim and they'll look at your documentation. if the person gets benefits and you think they shouldn't have, you can appeal but honestly it's a lot of paperwork
0 coins
Oscar O'Neil
Wait I'm confused about something related to this. If I have to pay unemployment insurance, does that mean I'm guaranteeing my employees will get benefits if I fire them? What if I can't afford to keep someone and have to let them go for business reasons?
0 coins
Lucas Schmidt
•Layoffs due to lack of work usually qualify for unemployment benefits. That's exactly what the system is for. Your unemployment tax rate will go up if you have claims against your account, but you're not directly paying the benefits - that comes from the overall unemployment trust fund.
0 coins
Sara Hellquiem
The system is honestly frustrating for small business owners. I've been dealing with NYS Department of Labor for years and their employer website is terrible. When I need to reach someone about a claim or have questions about my account, I usually end up on hold forever. Recently discovered a service called Claimyr that can actually get through to NYS Department of Labor agents for you - check out claimyr.com and they have a demo video at https://youtu.be/qyftW-mnTNI. Makes dealing with the bureaucracy much easier.
0 coins
Eloise Kendrick
•That sounds helpful, I'll check it out. Do they handle employer issues too or just claimant stuff?
0 coins
Charlee Coleman
One thing to remember is that your unemployment insurance rate will change over time based on your experience rating. If you have a lot of former employees filing claims, your rate goes up. If you have few claims, it goes down. So there's an incentive to be careful about hiring and to document any performance issues properly in case you need to contest a claim later.
0 coins
Omar Mahmoud
As someone who just went through setting up unemployment insurance for my small business, I'd recommend calling NYS Department of Labor directly to confirm your industry classification - that affects your initial rate. Also make sure you understand the difference between independent contractors and employees because misclassifying workers can lead to big penalties. The quarterly reporting deadlines are strict so set up reminders. One more tip: even if you only have one employee now, start keeping detailed personnel files from day one including job descriptions, performance reviews, and any disciplinary actions. You'll thank yourself later if you ever need to contest a claim.
0 coins
Justin Evans
•This is really helpful advice! I'm also a new small business owner and had no idea about the industry classification affecting the rate. When you called NYS Department of Labor, were you able to get through easily or did you have to wait on hold for a long time? I'm dreading having to call government agencies but it sounds like it's necessary to get this right from the start.
0 coins