Back to New York Unemployment

Amara Eze

How to stop collecting unemployment - NYSDOL process explained

I got a new job offer last week and I start in about 10 days. I've been on unemployment for about 3 months after getting laid off from my retail management position, and honestly I'm relieved to be moving on - but now I'm confused about the actual process for how to stop collecting unemployment through NYSDOL. Do I just... stop filing my weekly claims? Do I need to call someone? Is there a form I have to submit? I reported the job offer on my last weekly certification but I don't know what happens next. I don't want to accidentally keep receiving payments I'm not entitled to and end up with an overpayment situation down the road. Anyone been through this recently?

Week 11 for me when I stopped, so I know exactly what you're going through. The short answer is that you don't need to call NYSDOL or fill out any special form to stop collecting. When you stop certifying for your weekly claims, the payments stop automatically. The key thing is what you report during your final weeks - specifically the week you start working, you need to certify for that week and report your earnings. NYSDOL calculates your partial benefit for that week based on how much you earned, and in most cases your benefit amount gets reduced based on the formula they use. After that week, you just don't file anymore and your claim goes dormant. It won't be closed permanently - it stays open for a year from your benefit year start date in case you lose the new job and need to reopen it.

0 coins

Amara Eze

Author

The benefit year staying open part - does that mean I'm still technically 'on unemployment' even after I stop filing? I want to make sure my new employer doesn't see anything weird on background checks or anything like that.

0 coins

Your new employer won't see anything about your UI claim on a background check, that's not how those work. The open benefit year just means the account exists in NYSDOL's system in case you need it again. You're not 'collecting' unless you're actively certifying and receiving payments.

0 coins

This is accurate. I've reopened a claim twice after going back to work and both times it was much faster than the original filing because the info was already in the system.

0 coins

My start date was a Monday so my reporting situation was pretty clean, but if yours falls mid-week it gets a little more complicated. For the week that contains your first day of work, you report all the hours and wages from that week when you certify. NYSDOL uses a formula where they disregard the first $504 of earnings and then reduce your benefit dollar for dollar after that. So depending on your weekly benefit rate and what you earn that first partial week, you might still get a small payment or nothing at all. Either way, once you stop certifying you're done.

0 coins

Amara Eze

Author

My start date is a Thursday so I'll have a partial week. I'm salaried so I'm not sure how to report earnings for just two days of a weekly salary - like do I divide by 5 or report what I actually received in my first paycheck?

0 coins

You'd report what you actually earned for those days worked, not what you get paid - so yes, divide the weekly salary by the number of work days and multiply by days actually worked that week. NYSDOL goes by when you earned it, not when it hits your bank account.

0 coins

I think I messed this up when I went back to work last year and had to sort it out later. Report the earned amount for the days worked, not the paycheck date. Learned that the hard way.

0 coins

About three weeks into my own return-to-work situation I had a reporting question that I couldn't find answered anywhere online, and calling NYSDOL was an exercise in frustration - I sat on hold for over two hours one morning and the line just went silent and disconnected. A friend told me about Claimyr (claimyr.com) - it waits on hold with NYSDOL for you so you end up talking directly to a live agent without burning your whole morning. There's a video showing how it works at https://youtu.be/Rdqa1gKtxuE. I used it when I had my partial week earnings question and got my answer the same day. For something like a return-to-work reporting question where you really want a straight answer from NYSDOL directly, it was worth it.

0 coins

Amara Eze

Author

Two hours and then it just cut off? That's genuinely awful. My question about the partial week salary calculation is exactly the kind of thing I'd want to confirm directly with NYSDOL rather than guessing.

0 coins

I've heard about Claimyr from a few people now. The hold times at NYSDOL have been brutal lately - my neighbor spent three mornings trying before she got through to anyone.

0 coins

NYSDOL's phone situation has been rough for over a year. Anything that gets you to an actual human is worth trying at this point.

0 coins

My benefit year ended in February so I went through all this recently. Something people don't realize is that the week you start work isn't necessarily your last week to certify - if you work part-time hours or earn under a certain threshold that week, you should still certify even after starting the job, because you might be entitled to a partial benefit. The cutoff is basically if your earnings exceed your weekly benefit amount plus the $504 disregard. If you're full-time from day one at a decent salary, you'll likely get nothing for that partial first week, but it's still worth certifying just to be official about it.

0 coins

Amara Eze

Author

The 'certify even after starting' thing is what I was unsure about. So I should file for the week I start even if I expect to earn more than my benefit amount that week?

0 coins

Yes, absolutely certify for that week. If you don't file and you were technically entitled to even a partial payment, that could cause a discrepancy in your claim record. Just file, report accurately, get a zero or a small payment, then you're clean.

0 coins

Agreed - I always tell people to certify through the week they're sure they've crossed the earnings threshold rather than just stopping abruptly. The administrative trail it leaves is worth it.

0 coins

My sister-in-law skipped filing for her last partial week and got a letter from NYSDOL months later asking about the gap. Wasn't a big deal but required her to call in and explain. Just file the week.

0 coins

Week 7 when I stopped my last claim and I want to flag something nobody else has mentioned yet - make sure your direct deposit or debit card situation is squared away before your final payment processes. I had a bank account change right at the same time I stopped collecting and there was a small payment that bounced around in the system for weeks. If you're on the Key2Benefits card just leave it active for a few months after you stop in case a late payment or adjustment shows up.

0 coins

Amara Eze

Author

I'm on direct deposit to my regular bank account so I think I'm okay there. Good point though - I hadn't considered that a payment could process after I think I'm done.

0 coins

Exactly. The final week's payment sometimes takes an extra few days longer than your usual payment schedule, so don't panic if you're expecting it and it doesn't show up on the normal day.

0 coins

I'm actually in kind of the opposite situation and reading this thread nervously. I've been on UI for 5 months and got a job offer but then the company rescinded it three days later. I went back to certifying but now I'm in adjudication because there was a gap in my certifications when I thought I was stopping. Does this happen to anyone else? I'm terrified I messed up my claim by assuming I was done.

0 coins

Your adjudication situation from the certification gap is probably a standard 'able and available' review for those weeks you didn't file. You should be able to call NYSDOL and explain that you had a job offer that was rescinded - that's a documented situation they deal with. Document everything about the rescinded offer if you can.

0 coins

The rescinded offer - I only have an email saying the position was 'no longer available' and not a formal rescission letter. Is that enough documentation for NYSDOL?

0 coins

An email works as documentation. NYSDOL adjudicators look at the totality of circumstances. Save that email and any other correspondence about the job offer.

0 coins

My claim hit adjudication for a similar reason a while back - job offer accepted, then it fell through - and I really needed to talk to someone at NYSDOL to explain the situation. I used Claimyr to get through to an agent after spending two days trying on my own. Ended up with the adjudication resolved within a week after that call.

0 coins

My termination was in December so I've been through a full cycle with NYSDOL and want to add something for OP - when you reopen a claim if you ever need to, they'll ask if you have any earnings or employment to report since your last certification. Be ready to have your new employer's information handy including their FEIN if you have it, because they verify employment when you reopen. Not a big deal, just something to know.

0 coins

Amara Eze

Author

The FEIN thing is interesting - I would not have known to find that. Where do I even get that number?

0 coins

Your W-2 or any official tax document from your employer has it. You can also sometimes find it on your offer letter or employment paperwork. If you're reopening a claim in the future, your first paystub will definitely have it.

0 coins

I reopened a claim once and I didn't have the FEIN and they just moved on without it - I think it's helpful but not always required depending on the agent.

0 coins

NOBODY tells you this stuff when you first sign up for unemployment - the whole stopping process is just as confusing as starting. I spent 45 minutes on the NYSDOL website when I got my new job trying to find a 'close my claim' button that doesn't exist. The system really does just expect you to stop certifying. Would have saved me so much stress if someone had explained this upfront.

0 coins

I spent probably an hour looking for the same thing. At one point I was convinced I needed to submit a formal letter to NYSDOL to close the claim.

0 coins

Exactly - it feels wrong to just... stop. Like you're leaving something unfinished. But that's really how it works.

0 coins

The NYSDOL website could genuinely use a 'returning to work' guidance page that walks through this. The information exists but it's scattered across multiple FAQ sections.

0 coins

My situation when I went back to work was a bit unusual because I started a new job while I still had an open issue on my claim from a previous employer contesting my separation. I kept getting letters about it even after I stopped collecting. If you have anything like that pending - an employer appeal, an adjudication issue, anything unresolved - stopping your certifications doesn't make those go away. You still have to deal with them even after you're employed again.

0 coins

Amara Eze

Author

My separation was pretty clean - straightforward layoff due to position elimination with no contest from my employer. So hopefully I don't have to worry about that angle.

0 coins

Position eliminations are usually the cleanest exits from unemployment too. No employer contest, no misconduct review. You're in a good spot.

0 coins

Employer appeals can come even months after the fact if they decide to contest something retroactively. Not trying to scare OP but keep any documentation of your layoff just in case.

0 coins

Fifth week of my job search when I found this thread and it's genuinely useful. I wanted to ask - if I do part-time work while still unemployed and searching for full-time, at what point does stopping make sense vs. continuing to certify? Like if I pick up 15 hours a week of gig work is that different from starting a full-time job for the purpose of stopping?

0 coins

Your 15 hours of gig work per week - what you'd earn from that matters more than the hours. If your weekly gig earnings stay low enough that you're still eligible for a partial benefit after the disregard calculation, you can and should keep certifying. The question of when to stop is really about when your earnings consistently eliminate your benefit entitlement, not just about hours.

0 coins

That makes more sense than what I thought. I assumed it was more of a binary 'working or not working' situation rather than an earnings-based calculation.

0 coins

Lots of people assume that. The partial benefits system exists specifically for situations like yours - underemployment, gig work, etc. Keep certifying until you consistently have no benefit remaining.

0 coins

My phone saga trying to get a question answered about my return-to-work week took three full mornings before I accepted that the hold times were just not manageable for me. A person in another forum suggested Claimyr and I ended up speaking to a NYSDOL agent within the same afternoon I tried it. The question I had was specifically about how to report a signing bonus - whether it counted as earnings for my first certification week. Turns out it does, and it has to be reported the week you receive it not when you earned it, which is different from regular wages.

0 coins

Amara Eze

Author

The signing bonus timing thing is really useful to know - I don't have one but that's exactly the kind of edge case detail that would trip someone up.

0 coins

Three mornings is brutal. I've had similar luck with NYSDOL's phones - you just sit there and eventually either get through or get cut off.

0 coins

Signing bonus counting as earnings for that week makes sense in retrospect but I never would have guessed it. Good info.

0 coins

My layoff was in a completely different industry than OP but the return-to-work reporting process is universal. The main things to remember across any situation: certify for every week up through the last week you have any potential eligibility, report earnings in the week they were earned not when you get paid (except for certain lump sums as someone above mentioned), and keep your Unemployment Services account login accessible for at least a year because letters and determinations sometimes show up well after you've stopped collecting.

0 coins

Amara Eze

Author

The letters showing up after stopping is something I'd have completely forgotten about. I should make sure my email and address on file with NYSDOL are current before I stop.

0 coins

That's a really good point - update your contact info in Unemployment Services before your last certification so any subsequent correspondence reaches you.

0 coins

I got an overpayment notice about four months after I stopped claiming - addressed to my old apartment because I moved and forgot to update NYSDOL. Nightmare to sort out.

0 coins

My claim experience was really different from most people here because I was on standby status for most of my UI period, which meant I didn't have to do job searches. When I finally was called back to full-time work by my employer, I wasn't sure if 'returning from standby' had a different process than stopping a regular claim. It doesn't - you still just stop certifying after reporting the return to work. But I called my union hall first assuming there was something special to do and they were as confused as I was.

0 coins

Standby status confuses a lot of people. My understanding is it's really just a modified version of the regular claim and the exit process is the same.

0 coins

Yeah that's exactly it. The only difference is that during standby you weren't required to do the three job search activities per week, but on the way out it's identical.

0 coins

My former coworker asked me this exact question two months ago when she got rehired by our old company. The thing she was most worried about was whether stopping unemployment would affect her eligibility if the company laid her off again. It won't - each UI claim is evaluated on its own based on your base period wages. Using your benefits fully, partially, or not at all in a given benefit year doesn't penalize you for future claims.

0 coins

Amara Eze

Author

That's something I hadn't even thought to wonder about. Good to know starting a job doesn't somehow mark you as a 'repeat claimer' in a negative way.

0 coins

You'd be surprised how many people think there's some kind of strike system. There isn't. NYSDOL looks at your wages in the base period, your separation reason, and your availability - not your claim history in terms of how often you've filed.

0 coins

I've filed three times over my career and each one was evaluated totally fresh. The system isn't punitive about multiple claims.

0 coins

About 8 weeks into collecting when I got a temp position that might go permanent - my situation was weird because I didn't know if it was actually full-time employment or not. The agency said it was 'full-time temporary' but I wasn't sure how to categorize it on my certification. I reported the earnings and hours accurately and let NYSDOL sort it out. The partial benefit I got for that first week was lower than I expected but everything was correct. Report accurately and let the system do the math is my advice.

0 coins

Amara Eze

Author

Report accurately and let the system do the' math is probably the most useful thing'I ve read in this whole thread honestly. I keep trying to figure out the formula in advance but maybe I should just file correctly and see whathappens.

0 coins

The formula has enough variables that pre-calculating it rarely matches what NYSDOL actually computes. Report your earnings and hours truthfully and the payment will be whatever it is.

0 coins

This is correct advice. The disregard calculation and benefit rate computation involve rounding and some steps that are hard to replicate manually. File accurately, the system handles it.

0 coins

Eleven months into my benefit year before I stopped and I want to validate what others said about not needing to do anything formal. I was so convinced there had to be an official cancellation process that I called the NYSDOL number three times trying to ask how to officially close my claim. Each time I got through, the agent told me the same thing: just stop certifying. There is no cancel button, there is no form, there is no call required. You just stop.

0 coins

Amara Eze

Author

You got through three times?! That in itself seems like a miracle based on what people are saying about hold times.

0 coins

The first time I called very early - like 7:58am - and got through in about 25 minutes. The other two were much longer waits. It was months apart so the luck varied a lot.

0 coins

7:58am noted. I always try around 10am and wonder why I wait forever.

0 coins

My return-to-work was complicated because I took a job in a different state - I had a NYSDOL claim and moved to start a position out of state. I was worried about whether I needed to do anything different. The answer was still just 'stop certifying' but I did want to make sure my final week was properly reported before the move. If you're doing anything cross-state or unusual, that might actually be worth a call to confirm, but for a standard in-state rehire situation OP described, the process is what everyone here says.

0 coins

Amara Eze

Author

Mine is a straightforward in-state situation so sounds like I'm definitely in the simpler category. Good context for anyone in a more complicated situation though.

0 coins

Cross-state situations get more complex fast. For you this really should just be: certify for your start week, report earnings accurately, then stop. That's the whole process.

0 coins

My benefit amount was lower than expected from the start of my claim so I always paid close attention to the weekly payment details. When I went back to work I noticed my final payment processed about 4 business days after I expected it - normal variation apparently. The Unemployment Services portal shows the payment status so you can track if you're waiting on a final payment to clear before you fully stop monitoring.

0 coins

Amara Eze

Author

The portal tracking is a good reminder - I keep forgetting I can check payment status there rather than just waiting to see if money shows up.

0 coins

The payment history section in Unemployment Services shows every transaction including pending ones. Useful for confirming your final payment came through correctly.

0 coins

I track everything through that portal too. Having a record of every weekly payment is also useful if anything ever comes into question later - better than trying to piece it together from bank statements.

0 coins

My first attempt at understanding the return-to-work reporting process went through Claimyr after a full day of failed attempts to get NYSDOL on the phone myself. The agent I ended up speaking with was actually pretty thorough - walked me through exactly how to handle the certification for my first week back including the partial day situation. Having that direct confirmation from NYSDOL before I filed gave me a lot more confidence than trying to interpret the website on my own.

0 coins

A full day of failed attempts sounds about right for NYSDOL phones lately. Getting direct confirmation is probably worth it for peace of mind even if the online info is technically there.

0 coins

Amara Eze

Author

Direct confirmation is exactly what appeals to me. I can read all the forum posts I want but hearing it from an actual NYSDOL agent feels more definitive.

0 coins

The website has the information but it's written in a way that creates as many questions as it answers sometimes. An actual agent who can respond to your specific situation is different.

0 coins

Related posts

New York Unemployment AI

Expert Assistant
Secure