How do business owners file for unemployment in New York? NYSDOL explained
I shut down my small landscaping business back in February after losing three major contracts back to back. I had been running it as a sole proprietor for about six years, paying into the system the whole time — or so I thought. When I went to file for unemployment through NYSDOL, I hit a wall immediately. The online system kept rejecting my information and I couldn't figure out if I even qualify since I technically employed myself. My situation is a little complicated because I did have W-2 income from a part-time job at a hardware store while running the business, so I'm not purely self-employed. Has anyone else been through this? I genuinely don't know if business owners can even collect UI benefits in New York or what the process looks like when your income was mixed. I've been going in circles on the NYSDOL website for days and can't find a clear answer specific to my situation.
70 comments

Dmitry Petrov
My landscaping side gig and a retail job situation was almost identical to yours last year. What I found out is that it really comes down to whether you had W-2 wages reported to New York State — not your self-employment income. NYSDOL bases your benefit rate on wages that were actually taxed through payroll, so your hardware store income is what matters most here. The self-employment piece on its own doesn't count toward your base period wages. When I went through the process, my UI claim got approved solely based on my W-2 employment, and my sole proprietor income was essentially ignored for calculating benefits. File using the standard online claim at labor.ny.gov and list only your W-2 employer when asked about your work history. You'll likely qualify based on that alone.
0 coins
Sofia Gutierrez
AuthorThat actually makes a lot of sense. I was overthinking it and trying to figure out how to list the business separately. So I should just focus on the hardware store wages when I file the initial claim?
0 coins
StarSurfer
Echoing what was said above — the base period wages from your W-2 job are what NYSDOL plugs into their formula. Your self-employment history won't help or hurt the calculation itself, though you do need to disclose that you were also self-employed during that period.
0 coins
Ava Martinez
Worth noting that if the landscaping business had any employees you paid W-2 wages to, that gets more complicated — but as a sole proprietor with no employees, you're in the cleaner situation here.
0 coins
Miguel Castro
Reaching NYSDOL by phone about a mixed-income situation like yours is genuinely difficult because the hold times are brutal. I burned through almost two full days trying to get a live agent. A friend told me to try Claimyr — what it does is wait on hold with NYSDOL for you, so you actually end up speaking with a live agent instead of sitting there for hours. You can check it out at claimyr.com and there's a video showing how it works at https://youtu.be/Rdqa1gKtxuE. Got my questions about sole proprietor filing answered in one conversation with an agent, which would have taken me weeks to figure out from the website alone.
0 coins
Zainab Abdulrahman
I'm not sure the hold times are quite that bad every day — early mornings can sometimes be shorter. Though I'll admit I've had some really rough stretches too where I gave up after two hours.
0 coins
Sofia Gutierrez
AuthorTwo days is insane. I tried calling once and hung up after 90 minutes. I'll look into that option because I really do need to talk to someone who can look at my specific situation.
0 coins
Connor Byrne
The phone situation at NYSDOL has been rough for a while now. Mixed-income claims are exactly the type where you need a human to walk you through it rather than guessing from the website.
0 coins
Yara Elias
My accountant actually flagged this for me when I closed my LLC two years ago — the business structure matters a lot for how NYSDOL views your eligibility. A sole proprietor is different from someone who had their business set up as an S-Corp and paid themselves a salary through it. If you were an S-Corp owner paying yourself W-2 wages through the business, those wages absolutely count toward your UI base period just like any other employer would. Sole proprietors who only took draws — no payroll, no W-2 from the business — are the ones who end up relying entirely on other employment income.
0 coins
Sofia Gutierrez
AuthorMine was straight sole proprietor, so no payroll, no W-2 from the business side. Everything from the landscaping was just reported on Schedule C. Good to know the structure makes such a difference.
0 coins
QuantumQuasar
My situation involved an LLC taxed as an S-Corp and I did pay myself a salary, so I was able to include those wages when I filed my UI claim. NYSDOL accepted them without any issues.
0 coins
Keisha Jackson
This is a detail I never would have known on my own. I always assumed all self-employed people were just shut out of the system entirely.
0 coins
Paolo Moretti
NYSDOL adjudication flagged my claim for review when I listed both my business and my W-2 job in the work history section. They wanted documentation showing the business actually ceased operations — not just slowed down. I had to send in my business dissolution paperwork, my final tax return, and a letter explaining the circumstances. The process took about five weeks before my claim got cleared. If you're in a similar mixed situation, get your documentation together before you file so you're not scrambling when NYSDOL asks for it.
0 coins
Sofia Gutierrez
AuthorFive weeks is a long time. What kind of documentation did they specifically ask for about the business closing? I have my final contracts and bank statements but nothing official like a dissolution filing since sole proprietors don't always do that formally.
0 coins
Dmitry Petrov
For a sole proprietor, official dissolution paperwork may not exist the same way it does for an LLC or corporation. In my experience, NYSDOL accepted a signed statement explaining the closure along with tax records showing the business income dropped off.
0 coins
Amina Diop
They asked me for similar things — final invoices, proof that my business activity stopped. A statement with dates and a brief explanation seemed to satisfy the adjudicator in my case.
0 coins
Oliver Weber
The adjudication process for mixed-income claims is definitely slower than a standard W-2 only claim. It's not necessarily a red flag if your claim goes into review — it just takes longer when the picture is more complicated.
0 coins
Natasha Romanova
I tried to file for UI when my food truck business collapsed and honestly the whole experience was a nightmare. I didn't have any W-2 job on the side so I had zero base period wages in the system and I got denied outright. The agent told me that without documented payroll wages reported to New York, there was nothing to base a benefit calculation on. I wish someone had warned me before I spent three weeks thinking I had a claim. If you don't have that W-2 job in your background you might be out of luck with regular UI.
0 coins
Sofia Gutierrez
AuthorThat's a tough situation. At least you found out through an agent rather than just getting a form rejection with no explanation.
0 coins
StarSurfer
Purely self-employed individuals without W-2 wages in their base period can't collect regular UI in New York — that's the fundamental rule. The W-2 from the hardware store is really the whole ballgame for the original poster's claim.
0 coins
Zainab Abdulrahman
I know people who had the same experience as the food truck situation above. No W-2 income means no regular UI, which feels unfair but that's how the law is written here.
0 coins
NebulaNinja
After reading about the hold time situation in this thread, I want to say that Claimyr actually worked for me when I was trying to get my adjudication issue sorted out on a mixed-income claim. I'd already spent two mornings listening to hold music and getting nowhere. Used Claimyr and ended up talking to a live NYSDOL agent that same afternoon. The agent walked me through exactly what documentation I needed to submit and my claim cleared within two weeks after that.
0 coins
Sofia Gutierrez
AuthorThis is making me more confident I should try it. Getting a straight answer from an agent in one conversation beats weeks of guessing.
0 coins
Javier Gomez
My experience with NYSDOL phone lines is that you can sit on hold for two hours and then get a disconnection right at the end. It's genuinely demoralizing. Good to hear there are ways around that.
0 coins
Yara Elias
The difference between talking to an agent versus trying to interpret the NYSDOL website on your own for a complicated case really can't be overstated. Some situations just need a human to look at them.
0 coins
Ava Martinez
My base period calculation caught me off guard when I filed after closing my business — I had assumed NYSDOL would look at my most recent earnings but they actually use wages from the first four of the last five completed calendar quarters. If your W-2 hours at the hardware store were limited or seasonal, that might affect your weekly benefit rate even if you technically qualify. It's worth calculating what your base period wages look like before you file so you have a realistic expectation of what your weekly benefit amount might be.
0 coins
Sofia Gutierrez
AuthorI worked at the hardware store part-time throughout the whole period so hopefully the base period wages are solid. I'll add up the quarters before I file.
0 coins
QuantumQuasar
My benefit amount was lower than I expected because I had a gap in my W-2 employment during one of the base period quarters. The formula can produce some surprising results.
0 coins
Keisha Jackson
I had no idea NYSDOL used that specific lookback window. I always assumed it was just your most recent year of income.
0 coins
Emma Wilson
There's a part of this nobody really spells out clearly — when you're running your own business and you close it, NYSDOL will ask whether you left your work voluntarily or were laid off. As a business owner, the closure of your own business is treated differently than being fired or laid off by an employer. You need to be ready to explain that the business closed due to circumstances beyond your control, not that you just decided to stop. The adjudicator may ask follow-up questions about why the business failed and whether you had other options. The more documentation you have showing the external causes — lost contracts, reduced revenue — the better your position.
0 coins
Sofia Gutierrez
AuthorThis is something I hadn't really thought about framing properly. I did lose the contracts suddenly and the revenue just wasn't there to continue. I have emails from the clients terminating our agreements which should help show it wasn't a voluntary decision.
0 coins
Dmitry Petrov
Those client termination emails are exactly the kind of thing to hold onto. In my case I submitted similar documentation and it helped the adjudicator understand that the closure wasn't a choice I made lightly.
0 coins
Amina Diop
The voluntary separation question tripped me up initially too. The key is showing that you exhausted reasonable options before closing rather than just walking away when things got hard.
0 coins
Oliver Weber
Adjudicators dealing with business closure cases have seen a wide range of situations. Clear documentation of the external factors makes their job easier and your approval more likely.
0 coins
Zainab Abdulrahman
I called NYSDOL four separate times trying to understand my eligibility as a part-time employee who also freelanced on the side. Every time I either got disconnected after a long wait or got a different answer from whoever picked up. The inconsistency was really frustrating — one agent said my freelance income would be counted, another said it wouldn't, and a third said it depended on how I reported it. Eventually got a consistent answer in writing by submitting a question through my Unemployment Services account message center, which created a paper trail.
0 coins
Sofia Gutierrez
AuthorThe inconsistent answers thing is concerning. I'd rather have something in writing too if possible.
0 coins
Connor Byrne
Submitting through the message center in your Unemployment Services account is underrated for exactly this reason — you get a written response that you can reference later if there's ever a dispute about what you were told.
0 coins
Javier Gomez
I got three different answers from three different agents too on a pretty basic question. It shook my confidence in the whole process honestly.
0 coins
Malik Thomas
My neighbor went through a business closure situation and was absolutely stuck getting anyone at NYSDOL to explain the process to him. He ended up using Claimyr after weeks of failed attempts to reach someone, and he finally talked to an agent who could actually look at his claim and answer his specific questions. His claim got approved about three weeks after that conversation. He said the difference was night and day compared to navigating the website alone.
0 coins
Sofia Gutierrez
AuthorThree weeks from agent conversation to approval sounds reasonable for a complicated case. I'm going to look into this seriously.
0 coins
StarSurfer
Having an agent who can actually pull up your claim and see the specifics changes the conversation completely. Generic website guidance only gets you so far with unusual situations.
0 coins
Isabella Oliveira
There's also a job search requirement that kicks in once your claim is approved and you start certifying weekly — even as a former business owner, you're expected to be actively looking for employment. NYSDOL requires three work search activities per week and you need to log them in your Unemployment Services account. Some former business owners I've talked to were surprised by this because they assumed they could just be working on starting a new venture instead. Looking into starting another business does not satisfy the work search requirement.
0 coins
Sofia Gutierrez
AuthorI had planned on doing some consulting work while figuring out my next move. I need to make sure I understand what counts as an approved work search activity versus what doesn't.
0 coins
Dmitry Petrov
Consulting or freelancing while collecting UI gets into territory where you have to report any earnings during the week you do the work, not when you get paid. Any income above a small threshold reduces your weekly benefit for that week.
0 coins
QuantumQuasar
My situation after closing my business was similar — I was doing occasional odd jobs and had to report every dollar. The reporting system through Unemployment Services is pretty straightforward once you understand how it works.
0 coins
Amina Diop
The work search requirement caught me off guard too. Three activities a week sounds manageable but you need to actually log them or you risk losing your benefits for that week.
0 coins
Javier Gomez
My claim sat in adjudication for six weeks after I closed my small cleaning business and filed for UI. During those six weeks I kept certifying my weekly claims because I was told that if you stop certifying while in adjudication you lose those weeks entirely even if you eventually get approved. That was the most stressful part — filing week after week with no income coming in and no idea if any of it would ever be approved. Eventually everything came through and I got the back weeks deposited all at once.
0 coins
Sofia Gutierrez
AuthorSix weeks is a long time to be in limbo. And the advice to keep certifying during adjudication is really important — I wouldn't have thought to keep doing that if the claim was showing as pending.
0 coins
Emma Wilson
Keeping up with weekly certifications during adjudication is critical and a lot of people don't know to do it. You're right that skipping weeks means those weeks are gone even if the underlying claim eventually gets approved.
0 coins
Keisha Jackson
I stopped certifying for two weeks during my adjudication because I assumed there was no point. I lost those two weeks permanently. Don't make that mistake.
0 coins
Oliver Weber
My adjudication was triggered specifically because I listed self-employment income on my tax returns during my base period — NYSDOL wanted to verify that I was available for work and not still running a business during the weeks I was claiming. The concept of being 'able and available' for work is something they take seriously for former business owners. Even after your business closes, if you're still doing any work related to it — finalizing accounts, completing remaining contracts — you need to report those activities and any income honestly.
0 coins
Sofia Gutierrez
AuthorI still have a couple of outstanding invoices from before the closure that I might collect on. I'll need to report those payments when they come in even though the work was done before I filed.
0 coins
Ava Martinez
Reporting money received during a claim week is what matters for NYSDOL purposes, not when the work was performed. So yes, those outstanding invoices becoming payments would need to be reported in the week they arrive.
0 coins
Zainab Abdulrahman
The 'able and available' standard is one of those things that sounds simple but gets complicated when you have an ongoing business wind-down happening at the same time as your claim.
0 coins
StarSurfer
My first week after filing I realized I had no idea what the base period wage threshold was to even qualify — I kept second-guessing whether my part-time income was enough. In New York, you need to have earned wages in at least two of your base period calendar quarters, and your total base period wages need to meet a minimum that's tied to your highest quarter earnings. It's not a simple flat dollar amount. The NYSDOL website has a benefits calculator where you can plug in your quarterly wages and get an estimate before you even file.
0 coins
Sofia Gutierrez
AuthorI'll use that calculator before I submit anything. It would be good to know going in whether my part-time wages are even enough to qualify.
0 coins
Connor Byrne
The benefits calculator on the NYSDOL site gave me a pretty accurate estimate of my weekly amount. It's not perfect but it's close enough to be useful for planning.
0 coins
Keisha Jackson
My whole experience with this process made me realize how few resources exist specifically for former business owners navigating unemployment. Most of the guides assume you were a straight W-2 employee who got laid off — the second you introduce self-employment into the picture, everything gets more complicated and the official guidance gets vague. I ended up piecing together information from forums like this one, a conversation with a legal aid organization, and eventually talking to an actual NYSDOL agent. It took all three to feel confident about what I was doing.
0 coins
Sofia Gutierrez
AuthorThat's exactly where I am right now — piecing things together from multiple sources because no single one covers the full picture for someone in my situation.
0 coins
Natasha Romanova
Agreed completely. The official NYSDOL guidance reads like it was written for someone whose situation has no complications whatsoever. Anything outside the standard W-2 layoff scenario and you're kind of on your own.
0 coins
Paolo Moretti
Legal aid organizations that specialize in employment law can be genuinely useful here. Some offer free consultations and they know the NYSDOL process well enough to give specific guidance.
0 coins
Amina Diop
My approval finally came through after what felt like forever and the first thing I did was figure out what my job search log needed to look like going forward. NYSDOL considers a lot of different things as qualifying work search activities — submitting applications, attending career fairs, using the services at a New York State Career Center, reaching out to employers even without a posted opening. I found that mixing a couple of job applications with one Career Center activity per week kept my log easy to complete and varied.
0 coins
Sofia Gutierrez
AuthorThe Career Center option is interesting. I didn't realize those services could count toward the work search requirement.
0 coins
Dmitry Petrov
New York State Career Centers offer resume help, job search assistance, and employer connections that all qualify as work search activities. Some people get most of their weekly requirements met just from Career Center visits and workshops.
0 coins
QuantumQuasar
My weekly routine became two online applications and one Career Center resource use. It was manageable once I had a system and I never had a week flagged for insufficient work search.
0 coins
Connor Byrne
My biggest fear when I started the process was that disclosing the business closure would somehow disqualify me automatically. But the NYSDOL adjudicator who reviewed my claim treated the business closure the same way they'd treat a layoff — they just needed to establish that I wasn't still operating and that the closure was genuine. Full honest disclosure of everything actually worked in my favor because there were no surprises later in the process.
0 coins
Sofia Gutierrez
AuthorThat's reassuring. I've been worried that mentioning the business at all would create problems, but it sounds like transparency is actually the right approach.
0 coins
Oliver Weber
Transparency is always the safer path with NYSDOL. Inconsistencies between what you report and what shows up in your wage records or tax history are what trigger deeper reviews and longer adjudication periods.
0 coins
Emma Wilson
Trying to downplay or omit the business aspect of your work history tends to create more problems than it solves. The adjudicators have seen enough cases like this that honest answers move things along faster.
0 coins
Miguel Castro
An agent I spoke with after using Claimyr told me almost the same thing — they'd rather work with a complicated honest case than sort out inconsistencies later. Straightforward disclosure even when the situation is messy is the right move.
0 coins