Back to New York Unemployment

Dmitry Ivanov

How do I withdraw unemployment claim with NYSDOL?

So I filed for unemployment about two weeks ago and now I've landed a full-time job starting Monday. My situation changed completely - went from laid off at my logistics company to getting hired at a competitor faster than I expected. The thing is I never certified for any weeks and haven't received any payments at all. I want to make sure I properly withdraw unemployment claim with NYSDOL so it doesn't cause any issues down the line, especially with my new employer doing a background check. Is there an online way to do this or do I have to call? My Unemployment Services account doesn't seem to have an obvious button for withdrawing or canceling. Anyone done this recently?

Your new job starts Monday and you haven't certified yet - honestly you might not even need to do anything formal. If you filed but never certified for any weeks and received zero payments, NYSDOL typically just lets the claim go inactive on its own after you stop certifying. Your new employer's background check won't pull up an unemployment claim you never collected on.

0 coins

Mine was filed literally 11 days ago though - does the inactivity thing kick in that fast or is there a waiting period before it closes out?

0 coins

I heard it takes like 6 months for a claim to go fully inactive, but I could be wrong on that number

0 coins

The 6 months figure sounds about right for the benefit year to expire. But if no payments went out, there's nothing to reconcile - the claim just sits there unused. Your record shows a filing, not a collection.

0 coins

Reaching NYSDOL by phone to confirm this stuff is genuinely brutal - I spent three weeks trying to get someone on the line about my own claim situation. Eventually tried Claimyr (claimyr.com) - what it does is wait on hold with NYSDOL for you so you actually end up talking to a live agent instead of getting disconnected after 45 minutes. There's a video showing how it works at https://youtu.be/Rdqa1gKtxuE. For something like withdrawing or canceling a claim, talking directly to an agent is way cleaner than guessing.

0 coins

Hadn't heard of that before - did you use it specifically for a claim withdrawal situation or something different?

0 coins

Mine was an adjudication issue, but the agent I ended up speaking with handled two separate questions in that same call. They can look up your whole file once you're on with them.

0 coins

Interesting, I've been burning through lunch breaks trying to get through to NYSDOL for weeks. The hold music alone is enough to make you lose your mind.

0 coins

Your logistics background actually matters here - when you filed, did you select any industry-specific options or standby status? Because standby claims sometimes have slightly different procedures when you're re-employed. For a standard layoff claim with no certified weeks and no payments issued, the process is pretty simple: you can either let it lapse or call to formally close it. NYSDOL doesn't penalize you for filing and then getting re-employed quickly.

0 coins

No standby status - it was a straight separation claim. My old company did a standard layoff, nothing complicated about the separation itself.

0 coins

Then you're in the cleanest possible situation. No payments out, no adjudication pending, no standby complications. The claim will effectively go dormant. If you want absolute peace of mind though, calling to confirm closure is not a bad move.

0 coins

Wait does standby work differently for logistics workers specifically or is that just a general comment? Asking because I'm in transportation and trying to understand my own options

0 coins

I actually did this exact thing last year - filed, got a job offer within 10 days, never certified once. I was paranoid about it too. What I did was send a secure message through my Unemployment Services account saying I had returned to full time work and wanted to close my claim. Got a confirmation message back within about a week. The online message system is underused but it does work for straightforward stuff like this.

0 coins

The secure message route sounds way less stressful than sitting on hold. Where exactly in the account do you find that - under the correspondence tab or somewhere else?

0 coins

You go into your account and look for the messaging or correspondence section - it's not super obvious but there's a 'send a message' option in there. Just explain clearly that you returned to work and haven't certified or received any payments.

0 coins

Huh I didn't know you could do it that way. I've been treating phone as the only option for everything NYSDOL-related

0 coins

The secure message thing is real but responses can take a while. I sent one about a totally different issue and waited 12 days for a reply. Still got answered though.

0 coins

My brother went through almost this same scenario about 8 months ago. He filed after a construction layoff, got picked up by another contractor within two weeks, panicked about the open claim. His HR person at the new job told him not to worry about it since no benefits were paid out. He ended up not doing anything formal and had zero issues. Background checks for employment don't typically flag UI claims with no payment history.

0 coins

That's genuinely reassuring to hear. I think the anxiety comes from not knowing what shows up on background checks - glad to hear it's not a red flag.

0 coins

Yeah his new employer did a pretty thorough check too, since it was a licensed contractor situation. Nothing came up related to the unemployment filing. The check is looking for criminal history, employment verification, that kind of thing - not whether you filed a UI claim.

0 coins

Technically some background check companies do pull financial records depending on the type of check though right? Or is that only for like security clearance stuff?

0 coins

Security clearance and certain financial sector jobs are a different animal - those can get deep. Standard employment background checks for logistics or construction are really not going to surface a UI filing with no payments.

0 coins

WAIT. I actually tried to withdraw a claim once and was told by an agent that there's no formal 'withdrawal' process in NYSDOL's system - the claim either stays open until the benefit year ends or you get a determination on it. The agent said as long as I didn't certify and didn't receive money there was nothing to actually close. So all this advice about sending messages to close it might just get you a reply saying they noted your return to work but the claim year just runs its course.

0 coins

Okay so it sounds like 'withdrawal' isn't even really the right word for what I'm trying to do - more like just stopping the process by not certifying?

0 coins

Exactly. The term 'withdraw' isn't something NYSDOL's system technically recognizes the same way a bank withdrawal works. You filed an application, the claim year opens, and if you don't certify it just sits. What you're really doing is choosing not to continue. For your own records you can note your return-to-work date, but there's no button that closes it out permanently.

0 coins

This matches what I was saying earlier - the claim goes inactive. The semantics of 'withdrawal' vs 'letting it lapse' caused a lot of confusion in a thread I saw a few months ago too.

0 coins

Had the same confusion when I re-entered work before my claim got processed. The phone situation with NYSDOL almost broke me - tried for two weeks straight, mornings evenings everywhere. A coworker mentioned Claimyr and I was skeptical but gave it a shot. Ended up actually speaking with a live NYSDOL agent who confirmed in about 90 seconds that my situation needed zero additional steps. Saved me so much anxiety.

0 coins

90 seconds to resolve it once you're on with an agent - that's wild compared to weeks of trying to get through on your own.

0 coins

Does Claimyr work for any NYSDOL question or only specific claim types? Asking because my issue is a bit more complicated - pending adjudication that's been going on 5 weeks.

0 coins

My situation was straightforward but the agent I spoke with seemed knowledgeable about all kinds of claim issues. I'd think an adjudication question is exactly the kind of thing worth getting a live person for.

0 coins

Five weeks in adjudication is rough. I went through 6 weeks and the stress was something else entirely.

0 coins

Is this person sure they even want to fully stop the claim? I ask because if the new job doesn't work out within the benefit year, having the original claim still technically open might be useful. I had a situation where my 'permanent' job ended after 3 months and I had to refile from scratch because I had let my previous claim fully expire without understanding I might have been able to restart certification.

0 coins

Hadn't thought about that angle at all - is there actually a scenario where the original claim stays usable if the new job ends quickly?

0 coins

Your benefit year from that original filing date runs for 52 weeks. If you stopped working again within that year, you could potentially restart certifying on the same claim rather than filing a new one. Worth at least understanding before you do anything to close it.

0 coins

This is a real consideration but it depends heavily on your base period wages and what the weekly benefit amount would be. If you earned significantly more at the new job, a fresh claim after a future layoff might actually give you a higher benefit amount than the old one would.

0 coins

Honestly the whole NYSDOL website makes this more confusing than it needs to be. There's no clear 'I found work' button anywhere obvious. You'd think they'd want to make it easy for people to report re-employment since that's literally the outcome they want.

0 coins

The secure message workaround I mentioned does kind of serve that function even if it's buried. But yeah, a simple 'I returned to work' self-service option on the dashboard would make so much sense.

0 coins

Exactly. Instead it's like you have to either figure out the hidden messaging system or sit on the phone forever just to tell them good news.

0 coins

Transportation system had a 'return to work' field in their union portal that synced with state systems - wish NYSDOL had something that streamlined

0 coins

My claim situation was different from yours but I want to mention for anyone reading who's struggling to reach NYSDOL - Claimyr genuinely changed my experience with this whole process. I had a disqualification issue on a previous claim and getting to an actual agent was the only way to resolve it. The hold situation at NYSDOL is no joke and having something that waits through it for you so you end up talking to a real person is worth knowing about.

0 coins

A disqualification is so much scarier than just withdrawing - how long did resolution take once you got an agent on the line?

0 coins

The agent flagged it for review during the call and I got a determination letter about 8 days later. The call itself took maybe 20 minutes but we went through everything thoroughly.

0 coins

Eight days for a disqualification determination seems pretty fast actually. Mine took 3 weeks and I never even got a clear explanation of why it happened.

0 coins

To bring it back to your actual situation - you have three realistic paths. First, do nothing and let the claim go inactive as you stop certifying. Second, send a secure message through your Unemployment Services account documenting your return to full-time work. Third, phone NYSDOL to get verbal confirmation from an agent that no further action is needed. Any of these is defensible. The first is lowest effort. The third gives you the most direct answer. What you absolutely don't need to do is stress about some penalty for filing and not collecting.

0 coins

This breakdown actually makes the decision feel manageable. I think I'll send the secure message just to have something in writing, and if I don't hear back in a reasonable time I'll try calling.

0 coins

That's a solid approach. Keep a copy of the message you send and note the date. If you're ever asked about the claim later you have documentation that you proactively reported your return to work.

0 coins

This is the kind of clear summary that should be at the top of every NYSDOL FAQ page instead of buried in legal language nobody can parse

0 coins

My HR rep when I started my current job specifically told me not to worry about an open claim with no payments - she said they see it pretty often when candidates get offers while unemployment is processing and it has never once affected a hiring decision on their end. Your new employer is not scrutinizing your unemployment filing history.

0 coins

Coming from an HR perspective that really does put my mind at ease. The background check fear was probably my biggest anxiety about this whole thing.

0 coins

Background checks are mostly looking at criminal records, verifying your employment history matches what you said on your application, sometimes credit for certain roles. UI filings are not on the standard checklist.

0 coins

The employment history verification part is where people get tripped up - like if you listed your dates wrong or forgot a job. That's what actually causes issues, not unemployment claims.

0 coins

I'm kind of in the opposite situation right now and this thread is relevant to me. I withdrew too early from a previous claim years ago thinking I had permanent work, got laid off again 6 weeks later, and had to refile completely. The new claim had a lower benefit amount because my base period wages worked out differently. Really wish someone had told me to just let the original claim sit.

0 coins

This is exactly the scenario I was raising earlier - there are real financial implications to actively closing a claim versus just leaving it open. The benefit year staying live is actually an asset sometimes.

0 coins

This is making me definitely lean toward the 'send a message noting return to work but don't formally try to close anything' approach rather than trying to get the claim shut down entirely.

0 coins

That sounds like the smart play. Report the re-employment so it's on record, but let the claim year run its natural course. Best of both situations.

0 coins

And if the new job works out long term, the whole thing is moot anyway. The claim just expires in the background with no effect on anything.

0 coins

The number of people who don't know that filing unemployment and not collecting has basically zero consequences is probably really high. The stigma around unemployment makes people think even applying was some kind of mark against them. It's an insurance system - filing a claim that you end up not needing is totally fine.

0 coins

The stigma thing is real. I didn't file for weeks after my layoff because I felt weird about it, ended up missing out on benefits I was completely eligible for.

0 coins

So many people do that. The benefits exist specifically for situations like unexpected layoffs - there's nothing to feel bad about filing, let alone filing and then getting re-employed quickly.

0 coins

The 'I found a job before I needed it' situation is probably the best outcome NYSDOL could hope for and yet people are stressed about it

0 coins

Does anyone actually know what gets reported to NYSDOL when you start a new job? Like does the new employer report your hire date automatically or is that something you have to self-report through certification?

0 coins

New employers in New York are required to report new hires to the state - it's called the New Hire Registry. NYSDOL cross-references this. So if you start a new job and keep certifying, that's going to get flagged. This is why stopping certification immediately when you're re-employed matters.

0 coins

Okay so the system does have a way to catch people who keep certifying after returning to work. Good to know the enforcement side exists even if the self-service side is clunky.

0 coins

The new hire reporting is also why I'd argue sending that secure message is worthwhile - you're just getting ahead of information NYSDOL will likely receive anyway from your new employer

0 coins

Related posts

New York Unemployment AI

Expert Assistant
Secure