How do I stop unemployment benefits with NYSDOL?
So I accepted a full-time job offer last week and I start Monday. I've been collecting unemployment since February and honestly wasn't sure what the proper steps were to stop receiving benefits once I got work again. I already filed my weekly certification for the week ending before my start date and reported my job offer on it. But now I'm wondering - do I need to do anything else to officially close my claim, or does it just stop automatically when I stop certifying? I don't want to end up with an overpayment situation because I didn't handle the closing process correctly. Also my new salary is way higher than my UI benefit amount so there's no point in partial claims or anything like that. Anyone who's dealt with ending their NYSDOL claim properly please help me understand the process!
69 comments

Isla Fischer
Your situation is one I went through myself about six months ago. When you get a full-time job and your earnings exceed your weekly benefit amount, you just stop certifying - there's no formal 'close your claim' button you need to push on the NYSDOL portal. The claim sort of goes dormant on its own. The important thing is that on your weekly certification for any week where you actually worked at the new job, you report those earnings accurately. NYSDOL will calculate whether you're owed anything or nothing based on what you report. If your salary is well above your WBA (weekly benefit amount), you'll just get $0 and after a few weeks of not certifying the claim becomes inactive. You did the right thing by reporting the job offer on your last certification.
0 coins
Logan Chiang
AuthorMy plan is to just not certify starting this week since I'll be working full time. Should I report my actual first-week earnings on the certification for that week or just stop entirely?
0 coins
Isla Fischer
File that first-week certification and report your earnings for whatever days you worked, even if it's a partial week. That way NYSDOL has an accurate record and you won't have any loose ends on the claim. After that, just let it sit.
0 coins
Miles Hammonds
Agreed with this - I did exactly the same when I landed my current job. Filed the week I started, reported earnings, got $0, and never filed again. No issues, no overpayment notice, nothing.
0 coins
Ruby Blake
Reaching NYSDOL to ask a question like this directly is something I'd actually recommend doing, just to have it on record that you informed them of employment. I know calling them feels pointless because the hold times are insane - I was on hold for over two hours before I even got a busy signal last spring. What ended up working for me was using Claimyr (claimyr.com) - it waits on hold with NYSDOL for you so you end up talking to a live agent without sitting by the phone yourself. There's a demo at https://youtu.be/Rdqa1gKtxuE if you want to see how it works. I used it to officially note my return to work on my NYSDOL claim and the agent walked me through exactly what I needed to do to wrap things up cleanly.
0 coins
Logan Chiang
AuthorTwo hours and still a busy signal?? That's brutal. I'll check out the video, I want to make sure everything is officially squared away before my first paycheck hits.
0 coins
Micah Franklin
I had a similar nightmare trying to get through to NYSDOL on a different issue - spent most of a morning redialing and never got an agent. Good tip.
0 coins
Ella Harper
Honestly just not certifying should be enough but if OP wants peace of mind having it documented from an agent isn't a bad idea
0 coins
PrinceJoe
The way NYSDOL handles this is pretty straightforward once you know it. Your claim has a benefit year (usually 52 weeks from when you opened it) and within that year your remaining balance just sits there. You don't need to close anything. What you do need to do is make sure you're not certifying for any week where you're working full time and earning more than your WBA. If you accidentally certify for a week without reporting all your earnings, that's where overpayments happen. Since you said you already reported the job offer on your last certification, you're in good shape. I'd also keep any documentation of your hire date, offer letter, start date, etc., just in case NYSDOL ever asks down the road.
0 coins
Logan Chiang
AuthorMy offer letter is definitely saved. So to be clear - if I work my first full week at the new job and don't certify at all for that week, I won't get flagged or penalized for 'missing' a certification?
0 coins
PrinceJoe
You're totally fine not certifying. Missing a certification isn't a violation - only certifying with false information is. The system isn't going to penalize you for stopping because you're employed. That's literally what unemployment is designed for, it ends when you work.
0 coins
Brooklyn Knight
This is what I wish someone had explained to me when I went back to work. I was terrified I'd get in trouble for just stopping and it turned out to be totally fine.
0 coins
Owen Devar
My experience ending my NYSDOL claim last year was pretty smooth but I will say - double-check your Unemployment Services account after a few weeks to confirm no certifications were submitted that you didn't do. I know that sounds paranoid but someone else had access to my login at some point (I think I'd shared my computer) and an extra certification went through that I didn't file. Caused a whole mess with an overpayment notice. Not saying that'll happen to you but it's worth logging in every couple weeks to verify your claim history.
0 coins
Logan Chiang
AuthorOh wow I hadn't even thought about that. I'll change my password and check my account history.
0 coins
Daniel Rivera
That is genuinely scary. My ex knew my NYSDOL login and I hadn't thought to change it after we broke up. Changing it right now actually.
0 coins
Owen Devar
Yeah it's one of those things nobody thinks about until something goes wrong. The account history section in Unemployment Services shows every certification and payment so it's easy to spot anything weird.
0 coins
Sophie Footman
Changing passwords on government accounts regularly is just good practice anyway. NYSDOL, ID.me, all of it.
0 coins
Connor Rupert
Wait I'm confused about something - if you don't officially close your NYSDOL claim and it just sits there, can you reopen it if you lose the new job? Like within the same benefit year? I always thought you had to start over from scratch every time.
0 coins
Isla Fischer
Your claim stays open for the full benefit year (12 months from when you first filed). If you lose the new job during that period you can resume certifying - you'd just log in and start filing weekly certifications again, assuming you still have a remaining balance. You don't refile from scratch unless your benefit year has expired. This is actually a good reason NOT to try to 'close' your claim - keeping it dormant means you have that safety net available.
0 coins
Connor Rupert
My mind is kind of blown that NYSDOL works that way. I always assumed it closed the moment you got hired. That's actually really reassuring to know.
0 coins
PrinceJoe
Exactly right. The claim is tied to your benefit year, not your employment status. Lots of people don't realize this and panic-call NYSDOL trying to officially close things. Just stop certifying and you're done.
0 coins
Molly Hansen
I went through this exact thing three months ago and want to add one wrinkle nobody's mentioned - if you have a direct deposit set up with NYSDOL and you stop certifying, the payments obviously stop too. But I noticed my bank still showed the NYSDOL direct deposit account as active on my end. Nothing comes in unless you certify but I just want to flag that the banking connection doesn't automatically disappear. I eventually removed NYSDOL as a payee on my bank account just for cleanliness but that's optional.
0 coins
Logan Chiang
AuthorThat's a good detail, thank you. I'll probably leave it connected just in case I ever need to use the claim again this year, but good to know nothing magically deposits on its own.
0 coins
Molly Hansen
Yeah definitely leave it if you think you might need the claim again. I only removed it because my benefit year was almost up and I knew I wouldn't be reopening it.
0 coins
Brady Clean
Tried to get this same question answered by NYSDOL directly a few months back when I returned to work. Their phone lines are honestly the worst - I tried four times in one day and the longest I stayed on hold was 90 minutes before the line just dropped. Eventually someone in a different forum mentioned Claimyr and I figured I'd try it. Without sitting on hold myself I ended up talking to an actual NYSDOL agent and she confirmed everything people are saying here - just stop certifying, report your final week's earnings accurately, and the claim goes dormant. Hearing it from an agent directly put my mind at ease.
0 coins
Logan Chiang
AuthorDropped after 90 minutes is infuriating. Good to hear the agent confirmed the same thing everyone here is saying though - it makes me more confident just stopping certifications is the right move.
0 coins
Skylar Neal
My experience with NYSDOL phone lines is exactly the same, every single time. Never get through without being on hold forever and usually something goes wrong before I reach anyone.
0 coins
Miles Hammonds
NYSDOL phone is just genuinely bad. Good for you for finding a way through.
0 coins
Micah Franklin
An agent confirming it is basically the gold standard for NYSDOL stuff. Everything else is forum speculation, which is helpful but not official.
0 coins
Vincent Bimbach
There's one more thing worth knowing about stopping certifications - your job search record. While you were on UI you were required to record 3 job search activities per week in your NYSDOL account. Once you're employed and no longer certifying, you don't have to keep logging those. But I'd recommend keeping the records you already have for at least a few months in case there's any review of your claim. Just a folder with screenshots or emails from your job search activities during the period you were collecting. NYSDOL can audit past claim weeks and you want to be covered.
0 coins
Logan Chiang
AuthorI actually kept pretty good records of my job search activities the whole time I was collecting. Emails I sent, LinkedIn applications, all saved. Good reminder to hold onto those.
0 coins
Connor Rupert
I never knew they could audit past weeks after you stop collecting. How far back can they go?
0 coins
Vincent Bimbach
NYSDOL can go back through your entire benefit year and potentially further if there's suspected fraud. For honest claimants who just made a reporting error it's usually limited to the benefit year, but keeping documentation for a year after your claim ends is a safe approach.
0 coins
Kelsey Chin
My coworker just went through this and she asked me to post on her behalf (she doesn't have an account here). She said she made the mistake of certifying for a week where she had already worked three full days at her new job and forgot to include one day's earnings when she filled out the certification. She got an overpayment notice about two months later asking for $340 back. She paid it without appealing because honestly it was her mistake. The takeaway is just be really careful when you file that last (or near-last) certification to include ALL earnings from any day you worked that week, even if it's just a partial day or a training day.
0 coins
Logan Chiang
Author$340 overpayment from one missed day of earnings - that's a good cautionary tale. I'll be very careful to include every single hour of my first week when I file that last certification.
0 coins
Kelsey Chin
She said the notice was actually really stressful even though the amount was manageable. NYSDOL's overpayment letters are worded pretty harshly and she thought she was going to have to go to a hearing.
0 coins
Owen Devar
Those overpayment letters are genuinely alarming to receive. The tone makes you feel like you committed fraud even when it was an honest mistake. NYSDOL should really work on their communication style.
0 coins
Sophie Footman
Agreed, the letters are designed to scare people into paying immediately. If you ever genuinely disagree with an overpayment determination, the appeal process exists for a reason.
0 coins
Daniel Rivera
I want to ask about partial claims while you're wrapping this up - OP said their salary is higher than their WBA so partials don't apply, but for anyone reading this who took a job that pays LESS than their weekly benefit amount, stopping cold might not be the right move. You can actually still file a partial claim for weeks where your earnings don't exceed your WBA. NYSDOL will calculate your reduced benefit based on your earnings. I did this for about six weeks when I took a part-time job while looking for something better.
0 coins
Logan Chiang
AuthorMine definitely won't apply since the new salary is well above what I was getting in UI benefits, but this is a helpful note for anyone else reading this thread in a different situation.
0 coins
Connor Rupert
My part-time situation earlier this year was confusing for exactly this reason. I didn't realize I could keep filing partial claims and left money on the table for a few weeks before someone told me.
0 coins
Daniel Rivera
Yeah it's one of the things NYSDOL doesn't exactly advertise clearly. Partial claims are legitimate and you're entitled to them when your earnings are below your WBA.
0 coins
Brooklyn Knight
My last thought on this - when I went back to work I sent a message through my Unemployment Services account inbox just saying I had accepted employment and would be stopping certifications as of a specific date. Never got a formal response but I figured it created a paper trail. Might be overkill but it took me two minutes and I felt better having done it.
0 coins
Logan Chiang
AuthorTwo minutes for peace of mind sounds worth it. I'll do the same thing after I file my final week's certification.
0 coins
Isla Fischer
Not overkill at all, actually smart. The inbox message creates a timestamped record in your account that you proactively reported your employment situation. Unlikely you'd ever need it but costs you nothing.
0 coins
Norah Quay
My situation earlier this year involved something similar - I went back to work but my new employer didn't report my start date to the state right away (apparently they were slow with new hire reporting). A few weeks after I stopped certifying I got a letter asking me to verify my employment because they couldn't confirm it in the system. Had to get in touch with NYSDOL to sort it out. I tried calling multiple times and couldn't get through - waited over an hour twice with no answer. Used Claimyr to eventually reach a live agent and she helped me submit my W-2 information and verify my start date over the phone. Got a confirmation letter within a week. I'd say if you ever get a letter from NYSDOL questioning your employment status, don't just ignore it - actually talk to an agent and get it documented.
0 coins
Logan Chiang
AuthorNew hire reporting delays from employers sounds like something that could blindside anyone. Good to know there's a path to resolving it even when NYSDOL's phone lines are impossible.
0 coins
Skylar Neal
Employer new hire reporting timelines are inconsistent and it really does cause problems. I've seen people get overpayment notices because their employer reported their start date three weeks late and NYSDOL was paying them benefits they technically weren't entitled to after the hire date.
0 coins
Norah Quay
My employer in that case was about two weeks late reporting. Wasn't a huge issue but it caused enough confusion that I needed to talk to someone at NYSDOL directly to clear it up. The agent was actually really helpful once I got through.
0 coins
Ella Harper
For the love of everything please do not call NYSDOL unless you absolutely have to. The phone system is a black hole. I've had three different experiences trying to reach them over two years and each one was worse than the last. The last time I tried I was on hold for 47 minutes, got transferred, and was immediately disconnected. If you can resolve your issue through the Unemployment Services portal online, do that every single time. The inbox messages aren't fast but they're better than fighting the phone system.
0 coins
Logan Chiang
AuthorBased on everything people are saying here about NYSDOL's phone situation, I'm very glad my situation seems simple enough to handle just by stopping certifications and sending an inbox message.
0 coins
Ella Harper
Yours is about as clean as it gets. Just file that last week accurately, send the message, and you're done. No reason to ever touch the phone line for this.
0 coins
Micah Franklin
47 minutes then immediate disconnect is a NYSDOL signature move. I've experienced it multiple times. The portal really is the better option when it works for your issue.
0 coins
Leo McDonald
My brother went through the return-to-work process last spring and had a ton of anxiety about whether he'd done everything right when stopping his NYSDOL claim. He kept checking his account expecting something to go wrong. After a few weeks of nothing happening he decided to just call and confirm with an agent. He had been complaining about not being able to get through on the phone and I pointed him toward Claimyr - said he ended up speaking to an NYSDOL agent who confirmed his claim was simply inactive and there were no outstanding issues. He said just hearing that officially put everything to rest. Sometimes you just need that verbal confirmation even when logically you know you're fine.
0 coins
Logan Chiang
AuthorHonestly that's probably where I'll end up too. Knowing me I'll be checking my account every other day for a month waiting for something bad to appear. Having an agent say 'yes you're fine' would probably be the only thing that settles my nerves completely.
0 coins
Brooklyn Knight
I did the same thing - absolutely unnecessary anxiety spiral about my claim after I returned to work. Everything was fine but I genuinely could not stop worrying until I had spoken to someone.
0 coins
Vincent Bimbach
The anxiety is real and weirdly common. The uncertainty of dealing with NYSDOL makes people nervous even when they've done everything correctly.
0 coins
Skylar Neal
There's also the question of your 1099-G at tax time - I'll mention this because it tripped me up my first year collecting UI. At the end of the year NYSDOL will mail you (or make available in your Unemployment Services account) a 1099-G form showing the total unemployment benefits you received that year. That income is taxable. When you stop collecting mid-year you'll still get a 1099-G for whatever you received. Make sure your tax person knows you had UI income, especially if you didn't elect to have federal taxes withheld from your benefits. Caused me a surprise tax bill one year because I forgot to mention it.
0 coins
Logan Chiang
AuthorI actually did have taxes withheld from my benefits throughout the claim, so hopefully that reduces the surprise factor. But I'll definitely flag the 1099-G for my accountant.
0 coins
Skylar Neal
Having withholding done during the claim is the smart move. I didn't do that the first time and owed a chunk in April. The 1099-G will show the gross benefits and the taxes withheld separately so your accountant will know exactly what to do with it.
0 coins
Daniel Rivera
The 1099-G availability in Unemployment Services is usually around January or February - just log in and look in the documents section rather than waiting for paper mail.
0 coins
Miles Hammonds
My claim experience ending was different from most people here - I accepted freelance work rather than a traditional W-2 job, so I had to report earnings differently on my certifications. The gross income approach for self-employment on NYSDOL certifications confused me for a while. If anyone ends up in a similar situation where the new work is freelance or 1099, I'd really recommend looking at the NYSDOL guidelines specifically for self-employment income reporting because it's calculated differently than regular employment earnings.
0 coins
Logan Chiang
AuthorMine is a straightforward W-2 salaried position so I think I'm in the simpler category. But flagging this for anyone else who might be reading with a freelance situation.
0 coins
Miles Hammonds
Yeah W-2 is definitely cleaner. Self-employment income reporting on NYSDOL claims is its own topic and the rules aren't as obvious from the certification questions.
0 coins
Connor Rupert
My sister does freelance work and she had no idea her income needed to be reported to NYSDOL during the weeks she was collecting. She'd been treating it like her UI was just separate. Turned into a problem.
0 coins
Sophie Footman
Finishing up your NYSDOL claim is honestly a lot easier than opening one was. All the stressful stuff - proving eligibility, waiting through adjudication, setting up direct deposit, getting your job search requirements in order - that was all at the beginning. Stopping is basically just: report your last earnings honestly, don't file again, and you're done. I know it feels like there should be some official conclusion to it but there really isn't.
0 coins
Logan Chiang
AuthorThat's a surprisingly comforting way to put it. The opening process was stressful and I guess I was expecting the closing to be equally complicated. Good to hear it's just... stopping.
0 coins
Sophie Footman
My first instinct when I returned to work was also that I was missing some critical step. Turns out there wasn't one. The system is confusing on the front end but pretty quiet on the back end when things are going normally.
0 coins
Micah Franklin
Agreed. NYSDOL makes the beginning painful and the end almost suspiciously simple. After weeks of adjudication anxiety just being done with it felt almost too easy.
0 coins