Back to New York Unemployment

Fatima Al-Maktoum

Confused about calendar quarters for unemployment - NYSDOL base period explained

I've been going back and forth trying to figure out why my benefit amount came out so much lower than I expected. Filed about six weeks ago after getting laid off from my warehouse job in March 2025, and my weekly benefit rate was way below what I thought it should be based on what I earned last year. When I finally got someone to explain it to me, they mentioned something about 'calendar quarters' and a 'base period' and I honestly had no idea what they were talking about. I've been digging through the NYSDOL website and I think I sort of understand it now but I'm still fuzzy on some details. From what I can tell, they don't just look at your most recent paycheck or even your most recent few months - they go back further and use some specific set of quarters to calculate your benefit rate. But which quarters exactly? And is there any way to get them to use different quarters if the standard ones work out badly for you? My highest-earning period was actually the second half of last year and I'm worried that's getting left out somehow. I know I can appeal stuff but I'm not sure if benefit amount calculations are something you can even challenge. Anyone dealt with this before?

Which quarters did they actually use on your monetary determination letter? That letter should list out exactly which four quarters they pulled your wages from - did you get one of those in your Unemployment Services account or by mail?

0 coins

I did get that letter but honestly it was confusing to read. It showed wages by quarter but I wasn't sure if the quarters listed were the ones they used or just all my recent quarters for reference.

0 coins

The ones they actually used to calculate your benefit rate will be in a row labeled something like 'base period wages' - the other rows are usually just showing what else was on record. If the quarters covering roughly July through December 2024 aren't in that base period row, that could explain the lower rate you're seeing.

0 coins

Calling NYSDOL to ask them to walk through your monetary determination is honestly the move here. I was in a similar spot a while back and kept getting nowhere online, so I ended up using Claimyr - it waits on hold with NYSDOL for you so you actually get a live agent on the line without sitting there yourself for hours. claimyr.com is the site and there's a demo video at https://youtu.be/Rdqa1gKtxuE if you want to see how it works first. I ended up talking to an agent who explained exactly which quarters were in my base period and walked me through why my rate was what it was.

0 coins

Hours on hold is exactly what I've been dealing with - tried three times this week and gave up each time. I'll check that out, thanks.

0 coins

Did the agent you reached actually have the authority to change anything or just explain it?

0 coins

The agent I spoke with couldn't change the base period on the spot but they filed a note flagging my account for review and told me exactly what form to submit for an alternate base period request. That alone saved me probably two more weeks of going in circles.

0 coins

Here's the thing most people don't realize when they're staring at that determination letter - the standard base period NYSDOL uses isn't your most recent work. Ask yourself: what were you doing between January and March 2025, the quarter right before you filed? Chances are those wages aren't included. The way New York sets it up, they go back one full quarter before the quarter you filed in, then count back four quarters from there. So if you filed in spring 2025, your base period is probably the four quarters of 2024 but NOT early 2025. That's the piece that trips everybody up.

0 coins

Wait so my wages from January through March 2025 aren't counted at all? That was actually one of my higher-earning stretches because I had a lot of overtime.

0 coins

Exactly - that's the lag quarter gap. Those wages exist on record but they're outside the standard base period window. This is specifically why the alternate base period option exists, which I'd really push you to ask about.

0 coins

This happened to me too and I didn't know there was an alternate option until it was almost too late to request it. How long does someone have to request the alternate?

0 coins

ugh the quarter thing confused me SO much when I filed. I kept thinking they'd use my w2 from last year and that would be that but nope, it's way more specific than that

0 coins

like they're slicing your work history into these three-month chunks and then picking which chunks matter and I just did not understand why my number was so low until someone explained the lag

0 coins

Same exact experience here. I actually thought I did something wrong when my rate came back low.

0 coins

Ask your NYSDOL rep what would change if they ran your claim under the alternate base period - that's the question that gets you real information fast. The reason it matters: if the most recent completed quarter before your filing date has significantly higher wages than what's in your standard base period, New York does allow a recalculation using a shifted four-quarter window that includes that more recent quarter. It's not automatic though, you have to specifically request it and explain why the standard period shortchanges your actual earning history.

0 coins

How do I even bring this up - is there a specific form or do I just call and ask?

0 coins

There's a form but honestly calling is faster because the rep can tell you on the spot whether the alternate base period would actually result in a higher benefit rate before you go through the paperwork. If it wouldn't help you, there's no point filing the form.

0 coins

Does requesting the alternate base period reset any of your other claim information or just the benefit rate calculation?

0 coins

I'm probably missing something but I thought a 'quarter' for unemployment purposes was just January-March, April-June, July-September, October-December - is that right or do they use different cutoffs than the regular calendar?

0 coins

You're right, it's the standard calendar year quarters - nothing fancy. The confusion is usually not about where the quarters fall but about WHICH four quarters they pick and why the most recent one gets skipped.

0 coins

oh okay that makes more sense. So it's not like a rolling 12 months from your last day of work, it's based on actual Jan/Apr/Jul/Oct start dates?

0 coins

Exactly right. Everything snaps to those four fixed start dates, which is why the quarter you file IN doesn't count and neither does the one right before it under the standard method.

0 coins

NYSDOL never explains ANY of this when you first file and then people are shocked when their rate is lower than expected. I've filed twice and both times I had to figure out the base period stuff entirely on my own because nothing in the initial process explains that your most recent wages might not count.

0 coins

That's exactly where I am right now. The initial confirmation just said my claim was processing, nothing about which wages they were looking at.

0 coins

And then the monetary determination letter arrives and it's written in this dense language that assumes you already know what a base period is. It shouldn't be this hard.

0 coins

To be fair the NYSDOL website does have a page explaining base periods but you have to know to look for it - it's not linked anywhere in the standard filing flow.

0 coins

Went through almost this exact situation about four months ago - my standard base period totally missed a stretch where I'd picked up a second job and my wages were significantly higher than my normal rate. I tried the NYSDOL phone line probably six or seven times over two weeks and either got disconnected or sat on hold until I had to give up. Eventually tried Claimyr and got an actual agent on the line that same day. The agent confirmed my alternate base period calculation would bump my weekly benefit by almost $80 and told me exactly what I needed to submit.

0 coins

$80 a week difference is huge over the life of a claim. Did the alternate base period request take long to process after you submitted it?

0 coins

Took about nine days from when I submitted the form to when my account updated with the new rate. Way faster than I expected honestly.

0 coins

Were your benefits delayed while they recalculated, or did you keep getting paid at the original rate in the meantime?

0 coins

They kept paying at the original rate during the review and then issued an adjustment for the difference once the new rate was approved. I didn't have a gap in payments which I was really worried about.

0 coins

Is the alternate base period automatically considered or do you have to know to ask for it? Because I feel like most people filing don't even know this option exists.

0 coins

You have to ask - it's not automatic. NYSDOL runs the standard base period calculation first and that's what your initial determination reflects. If you don't know to request the alternate, you just get the standard rate and that's that.

0 coins

That feels like a significant thing to leave out of the process. A lot of people are probably leaving money on the table.

0 coins

Completely agree. Especially people who had a strong earnings year recently but filed at a time when those wages fall outside the standard window.

0 coins

My situation was a little different but related - I had a gap in employment mid-year before coming back to work, and I wasn't sure which quarters would even have wages to count. Ended up with this patchwork of partial quarters and I couldn't figure out how they'd handle a quarter where I earned almost nothing.

0 coins

Quarters with low or zero wages still get included in the base period - they just drag your average down. That's actually another scenario where the alternate base period might help, depending on when your gap fell relative to when you filed.

0 coins

I didn't end up pursuing it but I wish I had looked into it more. My rate was low enough that I had to pick up gig work while still on UI, which created a whole other set of reporting questions.

0 coins

Does anyone know if there's a minimum amount you have to have earned in a quarter for it to count toward your benefit calculation? I had one quarter where I only worked part of it.

0 coins

There is a minimum - New York requires a certain threshold in wages in at least two of the four base period quarters, and there's also a total wage floor across the base period as a whole. If a quarter is very low it may not count as a qualifying quarter even though it's still in the base period window. Worth asking NYSDOL to show you the qualifying wage breakdown on your determination.

0 coins

That's what I was afraid of - I think one of my quarters might have been below whatever the threshold is because I took medical leave partway through.

0 coins

Medical leave wages still count if you were paid during that time - it's not about whether you were actively working, it's about wages paid. If you were on unpaid leave that quarter is probably the issue.

0 coins

I keep seeing people say to call NYSDOL but every time I try I spend 45 minutes to an hour on hold and then it either drops or I get told to try another day because of high volume. Is there a better time to call or is it just always like this?

0 coins

early tuesday or wednesday morning before 9am was the advice I got and it did seem slightly better but still not great

0 coins

Tried every time of day at this point and nothing was consistently better for me. I ended up using Claimyr because I genuinely couldn't afford to block off a whole morning just hoping to get through - the whole point is it handles the hold for you so I eventually had an agent on the line without all the waiting. I never would have gotten my base period question answered otherwise because I was running out of patience entirely.

0 coins

What happens if you disagree with their base period calculation after you've requested the alternate and that also doesn't go your way? Is there a formal appeal process or are you just stuck?

0 coins

There is a formal appeal - your monetary determination letter includes instructions for appealing the wage calculation if you believe wages were reported incorrectly or not counted properly. The appeal goes to a Board of Review process and you'd want any employer wage records you have to back up your position.

0 coins

Has anyone actually gone through that appeals process for a monetary determination? Wondering how long it takes.

0 coins

I've heard of it taking anywhere from six weeks to a few months depending on how backed up the appeals board is. It's worth pursuing if the difference is significant but you're not going to get a quick answer.

0 coins

Does switching jobs mid-year affect which quarters count? Like if I had wages at two different employers in the same quarter do both sets of wages get combined?

0 coins

Both employers' wages get combined for each quarter - NYSDOL pulls wage records from all your employers during the base period. The only time this gets complicated is if an employer failed to report your wages, which does happen.

0 coins

What do you do if you think an employer didn't report your wages correctly? That would mess up the whole calculation.

0 coins

You'd need to provide your own pay stubs or W-2 showing those wages and submit them to NYSDOL to have the records corrected. It can delay things but they will adjust if you have documentation.

0 coins

Tried to get this explained to me over the phone three times and kept getting either disconnected or someone who clearly just wanted to get off the call without actually answering my question. Eventually used Claimyr and the agent I ended up speaking with was patient, pulled up my specific determination, and went through each quarter line by line with me. Actually understood my own claim for the first time after that call.

0 coins

Going through it line by line is exactly what I need. I can read the determination letter but I don't have the context to know what I'm reading.

0 coins

The agent even told me which of my quarters had the highest wages and explained why my alternate base period request would or wouldn't help in my specific case. Having that before filing the form saved me from submitting something that wasn't going to do anything.

0 coins

How far back does NYSDOL even have wage data for? Like if I had a weird employment history five years ago would that ever show up?

0 coins

For unemployment purposes they're only looking at roughly the last 18 months of wages - the standard base period goes back five quarters before your filing quarter, so anything beyond that isn't in play for benefit calculation.

0 coins

Okay that's actually reassuring. I had some complicated tax stuff from a few years back and I was worried it might interfere somehow.

0 coins

My neighbor filed at the same time I did with similar wages and got a noticeably higher weekly rate than me. We were comparing notes and trying to figure out why. Could it just be the quarterly distribution of our wages?

0 coins

Yes, distribution across quarters matters a lot. If your neighbor's wages were more evenly spread across the four base period quarters while yours were concentrated in fewer quarters, that can produce different rates even with similar total annual earnings. The formula isn't just total wages divided by weeks - there's a highest-quarter calculation involved too.

0 coins

So someone who had one really high quarter and three lower ones might actually come out ahead of someone with the same total but more even distribution?

0 coins

Depending on how the formula interacts with the caps and minimums, yes that can happen. It's not entirely intuitive which pattern produces a better outcome until you run the actual numbers.

0 coins

This system is complicated enough that I genuinely think most people would benefit from talking to an agent just to understand what they're entitled to, not just to fix problems.

0 coins

wait so the quarter you're filing in literally doesn't count at all? Like if I file in april my whole january-march 2025 earnings just disappear?

0 coins

Under the standard method, yes - the quarter you file in plus the one right before it are both outside the base period. That's why someone who had high earnings right before filing might get a surprisingly low rate.

0 coins

that is wild. I've told so many people to just file whenever and I had no idea timing could actually affect your rate

0 coins

I wish someone had told me this before I filed. I filed the week after my last day of work and looking back I'm not sure if that was the best timing or not.

0 coins

My situation involves self-employment income mixed in with regular W-2 wages and I genuinely don't know how that gets handled in the base period calculation.

0 coins

Self-employment income generally isn't counted toward your unemployment wage base because it doesn't have UI contributions taken out of it - only your W-2 wages from covered employers factor into the base period calculation. If a significant chunk of what you earned was self-employment income, that would explain a lower benefit rate.

0 coins

That explains a lot actually. I had about six months of freelance work mixed in and I think I was mentally counting all of it as wages for this purpose.

0 coins

This comes up a lot with people who do side work or who transitioned between employment types. The unemployment system is really built around traditional employer-employee relationships and anything outside that just doesn't count for benefit rate purposes.

0 coins

Coming back to update everyone - I called this morning and after getting through, an agent walked me through my specific base period quarters and confirmed that my January-March 2025 wages weren't included in the standard calculation. She filed the alternate base period request right on the call and said I should see an updated determination within about two weeks. Really glad I pushed on this instead of just accepting the original rate.

0 coins

How much of a difference is the alternate base period likely to make for you?

0 coins

She estimated it would bring my weekly rate up by somewhere between $60 and $90 depending on how the recalculation lands. Over a 26-week claim that's real money.

0 coins

Updates like this are so helpful to see - glad you got an actual answer instead of just being brushed off.

0 coins

This is the update I needed to see. Going to look at my own determination letter again with fresh eyes after reading this whole thread.

0 coins

Related posts

New York Unemployment AI

Expert Assistant
Secure