Can you get unemployment after a seasonal job ends in NY?
So my situation is probably pretty common but I couldn't find a clear answer anywhere online. I spent the last seven months working for a landscaping company - full time hours, taxes taken out of every check, the whole deal. Season wrapped up two weeks ago and my employer basically said 'see you in spring' and that was that. No layoff paperwork, no final meeting with HR, just done. I went ahead and filed a claim on the NYSDOL Unemployment Services portal because a coworker told me I should, but now I'm second-guessing everything. The thing is, I've heard people say seasonal workers can't collect UI, and I've also heard the opposite. My base period earnings are solid - I made decent money through peak season - but I honestly don't know if the seasonal nature of the job disqualifies me from benefits. Anyone been through this? Did NYSDOL approve your claim after a seasonal job ended or did you get hit with a disqualification?
72 comments

Andre Laurent
I went through almost exactly this two summers back when my resort job ended in October. Filed right away and spent the first three days trying to get someone at NYSDOL on the phone to ask about my specific situation - the hold times were brutal, talking two-plus hours and then getting cut off. A friend told me about Claimyr (claimyr.com) and there's a video demo at https://youtu.be/Rdqa1gKtxuE that shows how it works - basically it waits on hold with NYSDOL for you so you end up talking to a live agent without sitting there yourself. Used it and finally got a rep who walked me through the whole seasonal eligibility question. Turns out the key is whether the layoff was due to lack of work, not the seasonal label itself.
0 coins
Emily Jackson
My first attempt at reaching NYSDOL that month also ended with a disconnected line after 90 minutes. Knowing there's something that handles the hold time for you is genuinely useful - I wish I'd had that option then.
0 coins
Liam Mendez
Wait so the seasonal label doesn't automatically disqualify you? I was told by my supervisor that seasonal workers just don't qualify, full stop. That sounds wrong now that I think about it.
0 coins
Andre Laurent
Your supervisor probably assumed it, a lot of employers say that. The agent I spoke with told me the question NYSDOL actually asks is whether the job ended because there was no more work - same as any other layoff. The word 'seasonal' on your paperwork doesn't block your claim on its own.
0 coins
Sophia Nguyen
My landscaping crew all filed after last season and about half got approved without any issues. The ones who ran into trouble were the guys whose employers coded the separation as 'temporary layoff with definite return date' - that triggered a whole adjudication process. If your employer just said 'see you in spring' verbally but didn't file any official return-to-work paperwork with NYSDOL, you're probably in a cleaner position than you think.
0 coins
Carmen Diaz
AuthorThat detail about the definite return date is making me nervous. My boss definitely said he expects me back but nothing was put in writing. Does a verbal expectation count?
0 coins
Sophia Nguyen
Verbal didn't matter in my crew's cases - what NYSDOL looked at was what the employer reported. If no return date was formally filed, the system treated it as an indefinite separation and benefits went through.
0 coins
Jacob Smithson
My employer told me one thing and reported something completely different to NYSDOL. I found out when I got an adjudication letter asking me to explain the discrepancy. Always worth checking your Unemployment Services account to see what your employer actually submitted.
0 coins
Isabella Brown
My base period situation was similar - I'd worked seasonally for three years at the same ski resort and kept getting told I couldn't collect in the off-season. Finally asked an actual NYSDOL rep about it and learned I'd been leaving money on the table for two years. The earnings requirement doesn't care whether your job was labeled seasonal. If you earned enough in your base period and lost work through no fault of your own, you're in the same pool as everyone else filing.
0 coins
Carmen Diaz
AuthorTwo years of benefits you didn't collect is genuinely painful to hear. I definitely meet the earnings threshold - seven months of full-time work paid well. Good to know the label shouldn't be the deciding factor.
0 coins
Maya Patel
I read somewhere that there's a special seasonal worker exception that lets NYSDOL deny claims automatically but I can never find the actual rule. Does that exist in NY?
0 coins
Isabella Brown
The exception people mix up is for certain agricultural workers covered under separate rules, not standard landscaping employment. Regular W-2 landscaping work goes through the normal UI eligibility process.
0 coins
Aiden Rodríguez
My HR person at a previous job told me the same wrong thing about seasonal workers. It's wild how often employer-side folks don't actually know the rules.
0 coins
Emma Garcia
There's a specific thing about standby status that might apply to your situation and I want to flag it because it changed how my claim worked. When I got laid off from my pool maintenance job in September, NYSDOL put me on standby because my employer indicated I'd return within 45 days. While on standby you still certify weekly but you're not required to do the active job search activities. If your employer is planning to bring you back in spring, ask the rep whether standby makes sense for your claim - it's not automatically applied and you sometimes have to request it.
0 coins
Carmen Diaz
AuthorStandby is something I hadn't even heard of before this thread. So if I'm on standby I still receive benefits but I'm not required to apply to jobs every week?
0 coins
Emma Garcia
Exactly - you still have to certify each week and confirm you're able and available to work, but the weekly job search log requirement is waived while you're in standby status. It's specifically for situations where the return to the same employer is expected.
0 coins
Ava Kim
My standby got denied because my employer listed the return date as 'spring 2024' without an actual date, and NYSDOL said that wasn't specific enough to qualify. Had to do full job search activities the whole time anyway.
0 coins
Liam Mendez
This is confusing me - does standby help or hurt the claim? If you're expected to return, does that mean they might not pay you?
0 coins
Emily Jackson
My claim after a seasonal hotel job took about two weeks to process and then hit adjudication because my employer contested it. The adjudication process felt endless - no updates on the portal, couldn't get anyone on the phone. What finally moved things was getting a live NYSDOL rep to put a note on my file. If you end up stuck in adjudication, the portal alone won't get it resolved quickly.
0 coins
Carmen Diaz
AuthorAdjudication is what I'm most worried about. My employer and I parted on good terms but I have no idea if they'll contest the claim or not.
0 coins
Emily Jackson
Mine contested purely as a reflex - their HR department apparently contests every claim as default policy. Didn't mean anything personal, just added six weeks to my wait time.
0 coins
Ethan Anderson
My adjudication went on for nine weeks before I got a determination letter. Nine weeks with no income and no updates. I'd tell anyone in that situation to do whatever it takes to actually speak with a rep rather than just checking the portal.
0 coins
Layla Mendes
My brother was stuck in a similar waiting situation and that's when he found Claimyr. He said it handled the hold time with NYSDOL so he wasn't glued to his phone all day, and he got to speak with an actual agent who explained exactly where in the process his claim was sitting. Might be worth it if you end up in adjudication limbo with no updates.
0 coins
Carmen Diaz
AuthorAdjudication limbo with no updates is exactly what I'm afraid of. Good to have that option in my back pocket.
0 coins
Lucas Notre-Dame
My experience with long NYSDOL holds made me try every alternative first - early morning calls, the online message center, even mailing a letter. Nothing moved as fast as actually speaking to a rep though.
0 coins
Layla Mendes
My brother said the same thing - the message center never got a response, and speaking to a person was the only thing that created any movement on the file.
0 coins
Aria Park
I've filed four times after seasonal jobs over the past eight years and the process is basically the same every time. File immediately, don't wait to see if the employer calls you back with more work. Each week you delay filing is a week of benefits you can't recover. The portal at labor.ny.gov is where everything happens now - you file, certify weekly, and check your claim status all in one place.
0 coins
Maya Patel
I delayed filing for three weeks thinking my employer might extend the season and I never recovered those weeks. File right away is correct.
0 coins
Carmen Diaz
AuthorAlready filed - did that the same week the job ended based on my coworker's advice. Glad I didn't wait.
0 coins
Aria Park
You did the right thing. Week one is usually a waiting week with no payment anyway, so the sooner you get through that the sooner payments start if you're approved.
0 coins
Noah Ali
My waiting week felt like a trap the first time I went through it. You certify, nothing happens, and you panic thinking something is wrong. It's just normal.
0 coins
Lucas Notre-Dame
After my catering job ended each November for three years I filed every time and got approved every time. The consistent piece was always the same - the NYSDOL rep explained that as long as my employer filed the separation as a layoff due to lack of work, the seasonal nature was just context, not a disqualifier. What would cause problems is if the employer claimed you quit or were terminated for misconduct. Layoff for lack of work is the cleanest path.
0 coins
Carmen Diaz
AuthorLack of work is exactly what it was. Landscaping just stops in winter here. There's no misconduct angle, no quitting - the ground froze and there's nothing to do until spring.
0 coins
Lucas Notre-Dame
Then your situation sounds very textbook eligible. The challenge is just getting through the process without hitting a contested claim or an adjudication snag.
0 coins
Jacob Smithson
My catering employer filed 'lack of work' but then sent a letter to NYSDOL two weeks later adding information about some performance issues. That second letter triggered adjudication even though the original filing was clean. Keep an eye on your account for any employer correspondence.
0 coins
Ava Kim
My first seasonal UI claim I made the mistake of not keeping a weekly job search log because I assumed standby would be automatically applied. It wasn't, and after six weeks I got a notice that my benefits were being reviewed because I hadn't documented any job search activities. Had to appeal and explain the situation. Don't assume standby - ask specifically and get it confirmed in your account.
0 coins
Liam Mendez
So you have to actually apply to jobs every week normally? How many is it now?
0 coins
Ava Kim
My understanding from my last claim is you need three job search activities per week in NY - those can be applying, contacting employers, or attending job fairs, things like that. But confirm with your rep because the requirements can shift.
0 coins
Emma Garcia
My rep confirmed three activities per week when I was on a regular claim last year. And they do audit these - my neighbor got flagged when her log didn't match up with the dates she certified for.
0 coins
Chloe Boulanger
My situation after a farm stand job ended was messy because my employer was a small family operation with no real HR department. They didn't respond to NYSDOL's requests for employer information at all, which pushed my claim into adjudication even though there was nothing disputed. If your employer is similarly small and informal, it might be worth giving them a heads up that NYSDOL may contact them so they respond promptly.
0 coins
Carmen Diaz
AuthorMy landscaping company is about fifteen people - definitely on the smaller side. I hadn't thought about warning them they might get a letter. Good thinking.
0 coins
Chloe Boulanger
My employer was apologetic about it - they just hadn't dealt with unemployment paperwork before and didn't realize not responding would cause problems for me. A quick heads up prevented that issue the next season.
0 coins
Sophia Nguyen
My first employer was the same size and same situation. The adjudication letter looks scary to small business owners who don't deal with it regularly and sometimes they just ignore it thinking it's a problem for the employee to handle.
0 coins
Ethan Anderson
There's another wrinkle I hit that nobody warned me about - my seasonal job was my second job. I had a part-time year-round retail job that I kept. NYSDOL calculated my benefit rate based on total base period earnings but then reduced it every week based on what I was earning at the retail job. I was still getting partial benefits but the calculation confused me for weeks because the amount kept changing depending on my hours.
0 coins
Carmen Diaz
AuthorI'm only working the one job so this probably doesn't apply to me, but good to know for anyone reading who has a second gig going.
0 coins
Ethan Anderson
My retail manager also cut my hours around the same time the season ended so my income dropped from two directions at once. Partial benefits were better than nothing but I wish someone had explained how the reduction formula worked before I started seeing inconsistent payment amounts.
0 coins
Maya Patel
I had no idea you could get partial benefits if you still have some income. I thought it was all or nothing.
0 coins
Isabella Brown
Partial UI is real and genuinely helpful. You report your earnings each week when you certify and the system calculates what you're owed based on a formula. Definitely worth filing even if you have some income coming in from another source.
0 coins
Noah Ali
My seasonal job situation was complicated by the fact that I hadn't worked the previous year due to a gap, so my base period looked thin. The NYSDOL rep explained how the alternate base period works - if your earnings in the standard base period (first four of the last five completed calendar quarters) don't meet the threshold, they can look at the most recent four quarters instead. Worth knowing if your work history has any gaps.
0 coins
Carmen Diaz
AuthorMine should be fine since I worked continuously the whole season, but the alternate base period thing is news to me. Useful to know exists.
0 coins
Noah Ali
My gap was only about five months but it shifted enough of my earnings out of the standard base period that I would have been denied without the alternate calculation. The system checks both automatically but it's good to understand why the numbers might look different than you expect.
0 coins
Aiden Rodríguez
I never knew the alternate base period was a thing until my claim got denied on the first pass and an appeals counselor mentioned it. Got the denial reversed after they applied the alternate base period calculation. That was an unnecessarily long process for something the system should catch automatically.
0 coins
James Martinez
My sister-in-law was in seasonal work for years and always assumed she couldn't file. When she finally tried Claimyr to get through to NYSDOL and ended up talking to a live agent, the rep told her she'd qualified every single prior year and just hadn't filed. She was pretty upset about all the benefits she'd missed. If you're not sure, file and ask - don't assume seasonal means ineligible.
0 coins
Carmen Diaz
AuthorThat's genuinely frustrating to hear on her behalf. I'm glad I at least asked before assuming I didn't qualify.
0 coins
Liam Mendez
My whole crew assumed the same thing for two seasons before someone in the group finally looked it up. It's such a common misconception.
0 coins
James Martinez
My sister-in-law said the agent was actually really helpful once she got through - walked her through what documentation to pull together and explained the base period earnings requirement clearly. It was just the getting through part that had been the obstacle.
0 coins
Jacob Smithson
My NYSDOL claim after a summer camp job is relevant here because the camp tried to argue I was an independent contractor rather than an employee, which would have made me ineligible for UI entirely. I had to show that taxes were withheld from my checks and that I was treated as an employee in every practical sense. If your landscaping company paid you on a W-2, you should be in the clear on that front.
0 coins
Carmen Diaz
AuthorDefinitely W-2 employment - taxes withheld from every paycheck, the whole thing. That was one thing I did check before filing.
0 coins
Jacob Smithson
My camp eventually backed off when I submitted my W-2 and old pay stubs showing withholding. The misclassification argument falls apart fast when the paper trail clearly shows employee status.
0 coins
Emily Jackson
My delivery job tried the same contractor argument. The NYSDOL adjudicator saw through it quickly because the working conditions were clearly employee-like regardless of what the contract said.
0 coins
Aiden Rodríguez
My appeal after a denied seasonal claim taught me something important - the initial denial is not the end. NYSDOL denials can be appealed within 30 days of the determination letter date, and the Board of Labor Appeals actually overturns a lot of initial denials when the claimant shows up prepared with documentation. I was terrified of the hearing but the process was more straightforward than I expected.
0 coins
Carmen Diaz
AuthorI really hope I don't get to that stage but it's reassuring to know the appeal process exists and actually works.
0 coins
Aiden Rodríguez
My hearing was over the phone, lasted about 25 minutes, and I basically just told my side of the story and answered the judge's questions. The intimidating-sounding 'hearing' label made it seem scarier than it was.
0 coins
Ethan Anderson
My appeal also went better than expected. I brought every piece of documentation I had - offer letter, final paycheck, text messages from my employer about the season ending - and the judge said the documentation was thorough. Preparation matters more than anything else.
0 coins
Liam Mendez
After reading this whole thread I went ahead and filed my own claim - I was in the exact same boat as the original poster and had been putting it off because I assumed I'd be denied. The portal was pretty straightforward for the filing part. Now I'm just waiting to see if adjudication gets triggered.
0 coins
Carmen Diaz
AuthorGood luck - we're in the same boat waiting now. Keep checking your Unemployment Services account for any notices that need a response.
0 coins
Liam Mendez
My employer is small like yours and I'm now worried about whether they'll respond to NYSDOL if contacted. Might take the advice from earlier and give them a heads up.
0 coins
Aria Park
My biggest advice for the waiting period is respond to anything NYSDOL sends immediately. Any request for information has a deadline and missing it can pause or end your claim.
0 coins
Maya Patel
My mom worked seasonal retail for seven years and collected UI every off-season. She said it was completely normal and expected in seasonal industries - even some employers remind workers to file when the season ends. I think the misconception that seasonal workers can't collect has just been passed around by employers who don't want their experience ratings affected.
0 coins
Carmen Diaz
AuthorThe employer experience rating piece actually makes a lot of sense as a reason employers would discourage workers from filing. Never thought about it from that angle before.
0 coins
Maya Patel
My mom said one of her supervisors literally told the whole crew not to bother filing because they'd be back in the fall anyway. She filed anyway and got approved with no issues every single time.
0 coins
Lucas Notre-Dame
Employers pay more into the unemployment system when their former workers collect benefits - it raises their experience rating and their tax rate. So yes, some employers absolutely discourage filing for self-interested reasons, not because the workers are actually ineligible.
0 coins