Back to New York Unemployment

Carmen Diaz

Can you collect unemployment as a student in NY? NYSDOL rules explained

So I enrolled in a full-time nursing program at a community college back in January after getting laid off from my hospital admin job where I'd been working for about six years. I figured going back to school would be a smart move while the job market was rough, but then my coworker mentioned I might still qualify for UI benefits since my layoff was legitimate and I'd been contributing to the system the whole time I worked there. When I actually tried to file, the NYSDOL system flagged my claim almost immediately. Something about not being 'able and available' for work because of my school schedule. I honestly didn't even know that was a factor - I thought as long as you were laid off and looking for work you could get benefits. My school schedule is Monday through Thursday, 8am-2pm, with clinicals on some Fridays. Has anyone actually navigated this as a student? I've got a 12-credit course load which apparently is considered full-time by the school. I'm willing to do my job search activities every week and I could genuinely take evening or weekend work in my field, but I don't know how to explain that to NYSDOL. My claim has been sitting in adjudication for almost five weeks now and I haven't heard anything.

My layoff and my enrollment happened at the same time actually, so I fought through almost this exact thing. The key piece NYSDOL cares about is whether your school schedule prevents you from accepting a job if one was offered. If you can honestly say you'd drop or reschedule a class to take a suitable job, that matters a lot. The 'able and available' standard isn't about whether you're in school - it's about whether you'd actually take work if it came up. I had to write a detailed statement explaining I was available for evening and weekend shifts and that my program allowed leaves of absence if I landed employment.

0 coins

My schedule does actually allow flexibility - the nursing program has a leave policy and I've been applying to evening positions at medical offices. Where did you submit that statement? Through the online portal or did you have to send it somewhere else?

0 coins

They usually ask for it during the adjudication interview when an examiner finally contacts you. Keep documenting everything in writing in the meantime.

0 coins

wait does this mean part time students have it easier? my friend is taking like 6 credits and wondered the same thing

0 coins

Five weeks in adjudication with no word is brutal, and trying to reach anyone at NYSDOL by phone is a nightmare on its own. My situation last spring was similar - I discovered Claimyr (claimyr.com) which stays on hold with NYSDOL so you end up talking to a live agent yourself. There's a video showing how it works at https://youtu.be/Rdqa1gKtxuE - it honestly saved me hours of redialing and I actually got to speak with someone who could see exactly where my adjudication was stuck.

0 coins

Tried their number four times this week already, longest I stayed was 2 hours before the line dropped. Will check Claimyr out tonight.

0 coins

same, nysdol phones are impossible rn. took me like 3 weeks just to get a human on the line

0 coins

Does it work for adjudication questions specifically or just general claim stuff? My adjudication has been going on forever and I can't get any info.

0 coins

My call with the agent covered adjudication status directly - the agent pulled up my file and told me exactly what was flagged and what documentation they needed. It was way more useful than waiting for a letter that may or may not come.

0 coins

NYSDOL's able and available requirement trips up a lot of students. The rule basically says you have to be ready to accept full-time work in your usual occupation during the week you're claiming benefits. If your class schedule blocks off most of the standard business day Monday through Friday, examiners tend to find you unavailable. BUT - and this is important - there's a legal exception called the 'approved training' provision under Section 599 of the NY Labor Law. If NYSDOL formally approves your program as approved training, you can collect UI even while in school full time without the able and available issue coming into play.

0 coins

Section 599 - hadn't heard of that before. Would a nursing program qualify? It seems vocational enough but I'm not sure how to apply for that designation.

0 coins

Nursing programs often do qualify because they're vocational and in-demand fields. You'd file a separate application for training approval - look for the 'Request for Training Approval' form on NYSDOL's site. The earlier you file that the better because approval can take weeks and it doesn't always backdate easily.

0 coins

I went through 599 approval for a healthcare IT program two years back. It took about six weeks to get approved but once it came through my benefits resumed without all the able and available headaches. Definitely worth pursuing alongside your adjudication fight.

0 coins

wait so there are literally two completely different paths here? adjudication fighting vs the 599 thing? that seems like nysdol should just tell people this upfront instead of leaving everyone confused

0 coins

My claim got approved last year while I was in a part-time evening program and I honestly think the number of credit hours matters a lot to whoever reviews these. Under 12 credits seems to raise fewer flags automatically. That said, my neighbor was in a full-time program and got benefits approved through Claimyr after she finally reached an agent who walked her through submitting an availability statement. The agent told her she needed to put in writing that she'd accept any shift outside class hours.

0 coins

Part-time seems like the loophole a lot of people use then. I'm locked into full-time because of financial aid requirements though.

0 coins

the credit hour thing is real, i've seen people in this same forum say 11 credits sailed through and 12 or more got flagged instantly

0 coins

Your point about putting availability in writing is key. Verbal statements to phone agents don't get documented the same way a written statement uploaded to your Unemployment Services account does.

0 coins

Went through adjudication as a student and lost the first time because I didn't understand what NYSDOL actually needed from me. My mistake was just saying 'I'm available' without being specific. When I appealed, I brought a letter from my school showing the leave of absence policy, a schedule showing I had open availability after 3pm weekdays and all weekend, AND a log of the jobs I'd applied to that were within those hours. The appeals board reversed the initial denial.

0 coins

Appeal - so even if adjudication comes back as a denial I shouldn't just give up. That's actually reassuring to hear.

0 coins

Absolutely do not give up at denial. The appeals process is where a lot of students actually win because you get to present your full picture rather than whatever the examiner assumed from your claim form.

0 coins

appeals board reversals for students aren't uncommon from what i've read. the initial examiner usually just sees full time school and flags it without digging into the specifics

0 coins

My brother in law tried to collect while doing a full-time program and got denied, never appealed, just assumed it was final. Lost months of benefits he probably would have gotten if he'd fought it. Don't be like him - the 30-day appeal window goes fast and once it closes you've got nothing.

0 coins

The 30-day clock on appeals is strict. Miss it and your options basically disappear. File the appeal first and then gather your documentation while it's pending rather than waiting to have everything perfect before filing.

0 coins

30 days from the date on the determination letter, right? Or 30 days from when I receive it?

0 coins

Date on the letter is what NYSDOL counts from, not when it hits your mailbox. Mail delays can eat into that window so act fast when you see a determination come through.

0 coins

yeah I lost like 4 days once because I waited to open a letter thinking it was just a general notice. always open NYSDOL mail same day

0 coins

The job search log requirement doesn't go away just because you're in school or in adjudication. Three documented job search activities per week still need to happen and need to be entered in your Unemployment Services account for every week you certify. I've seen people win their adjudication fight only to have benefits denied for specific weeks because they didn't keep up the job search log while waiting.

0 coins

Have been keeping up with the three activities per week - applying to evening and weekend positions mostly. Good to know that matters even during adjudication.

0 coins

Your job search log should ideally show positions with hours that fit your stated availability. If you're claiming you're available evenings and weekends, the jobs you log should reflect that or it looks contradictory to an examiner.

0 coins

Claimyr actually helped me sort out a job search documentation issue - got to an agent who explained which job search activity types were acceptable versus which ones wouldn't count toward my weekly requirement. Had no idea contacting a staffing agency counted the same as a direct application.

0 coins

staffing agencies counting is a game changer for evening availability folks because a lot of medical and hospitality staffing agencies specifically work with non-standard hour workers

0 coins

Used Claimyr to finally get through to NYSDOL after my student adjudication dragged past seven weeks. The agent I reached pulled up my entire claim history and told me the examiner had noted my availability statement was missing even though I thought I'd uploaded it. Turns out it went to the wrong section of my account. Would never have known that without actually speaking to someone.

0 coins

Missing document in the wrong section - that's exactly the kind of thing you'd never find out just from staring at your Unemployment Services portal.

0 coins

My portal just showed 'adjudication in progress' with no additional detail for weeks. The agent was the only one who could actually see the notes on my file.

0 coins

ugh this is why the portal is basically useless for understanding whats actually happening with your claim

0 coins

My situation was different but related - I was taking classes before my layoff and kept going after. NYSDOL actually asked during adjudication whether I had been in school while employed. If the answer is yes and your hours and job type haven't changed, that's actually a stronger argument that school doesn't interfere with your ability to work.

0 coins

Mine started after the layoff so I can't use that angle, but it's good context for others reading this thread who were already in school.

0 coins

Even starting school after layoff isn't automatically disqualifying - the examiner just needs to understand your availability situation clearly. The assumption is you're unavailable, and your job is to overcome that assumption with specifics.

0 coins

The 'school before layoff' argument is legitimately one of the stronger ones. Courts and appeals boards have consistently recognized it in NY as evidence that work and school were compatible.

0 coins

Three things helped me when I was in a similar position: First, write out your weekly schedule with every available time block highlighted. Second, get a letter from your program director confirming students can pause enrollment for employment. Third, pull together employer contacts from jobs you've applied to showing they were within your available hours. Having all three ready sped my adjudication resolution up significantly once an examiner actually reached out.

0 coins

Program director letter - hadn't thought of that one. My nursing director is actually pretty supportive, I think she'd write something for me.

0 coins

Make sure the letter specifically mentions the leave of absence or enrollment pause option, not just general support. NYSDOL examiners want to see that there's an actual mechanism for you to take a job, not just that someone vouches for you.

0 coins

This is really practical advice. The employer contact log to show your applied hours match your claimed availability is especially smart.

0 coins

My sister worked nights at a hospital and took daytime classes - NYSDOL flagged her claim too but once she documented her shift history and showed she'd always worked nights, the adjudication resolved in her favor. The key was showing a pattern of actual work that matched what she was claiming she'd do going forward.

0 coins

Pattern of past work is a great point. My six years in hospital admin were all standard daytime hours but I can show I've applied to evening roles since enrolling, which demonstrates I'm willing to shift.

0 coins

showing willingness to shift hours by actually applying to those shifts is way more persuasive than just saying you would. paper trail matters

0 coins

Went through this whole mess two years ago and nobody told me NYSDOL has a specific form for student availability statements. It's not labeled obviously but when I finally got an agent on the phone they walked me through exactly what documentation to upload. The adjudication closed within a week after I uploaded the right stuff.

0 coins

Do you remember what it was called or where to find it? I want to get ahead of this before the examiner contacts me.

0 coins

Honestly I'd just ask the agent directly - they knew exactly what was needed and it varied slightly based on program type. Generic availability letters from students apparently get rejected more often.

0 coins

This is why getting to a live agent is so valuable - the portal and the general NYSDOL guides are vague about student-specific documentation

0 coins

My claim got denied after adjudication as a student and I honestly wanted to just give up. A friend pushed me to appeal and I did, presented my school leave policy and shift availability evidence at the ALJ hearing, and won. The whole process took about four months start to finish but I got all the back weeks paid once the appeal came through.

0 coins

Four months is a long time but getting all the back weeks paid makes it worth fighting. Good to have a realistic timeline in my head.

0 coins

File every weekly certification the whole time even during appeal. If you stop certifying you won't get paid for those weeks even if you win.

0 coins

This is so important - I know people who won appeals but missed weeks of certification during the wait and those weeks were gone forever. Keep certifying no matter what.

0 coins

I think a lot of people conflate the adjudication process with a denial and panic. Adjudication just means someone has to look at your claim manually - it's not a verdict. For student claims, manual review is almost automatic because the system flags anything that could affect availability. Getting flagged is not the same as getting denied.

0 coins

That reframe actually helps my anxiety about this a lot. I've been treating the adjudication flag as if it were already a denial.

0 coins

Your weekly certifications, job search log, and availability documentation all keep building your case during adjudication. Use the time constructively.

0 coins

wish someone had told me this when my claim got flagged, i almost didn't file the second week because i thought i was already disqualified

0 coins

NYSDOL adjudication timelines have been rough lately. Five weeks isn't unusual anymore but it's not a sign anything is specifically wrong with your claim either. The examiner pool is small and the caseload is high. Keeping your certifications current and your contact information updated in your Unemployment Services account is about all you can do proactively.

0 coins

Contact info is updated and I've been certifying weekly. At least that part is in order.

0 coins

Also make sure the phone number on your account is a number you actually answer during business hours. Examiners sometimes reach out by phone and if they can't reach you, the determination may not go your way.

0 coins

The Section 599 approved training route that I mentioned earlier - to be clear, it's a separate process from your adjudication and you can pursue both at the same time. If 599 gets approved, your adjudication issue essentially disappears because approved training students are explicitly exempted from the able and available standard. Talk to your NYSDOL career center about initiating the 599 application.

0 coins

Pursuing both simultaneously makes sense. I'll ask about the career center referral process when I get through to someone.

0 coins

My career center counselor actually initiated the 599 paperwork on my behalf - I didn't even know I could ask them to do that. The counselors at the career center often know more about these edge cases than the phone agents do.

0 coins

Career centers are underused for this stuff. They have direct channels to NYSDOL that most claimants don't have access to on their own.

0 coins

Five weeks and counting with no examiner contact is frustrating but unfortunately common for student cases. Had a similar stretch last year. The portal status staying at 'adjudication in progress' the whole time gives you nothing to go on. When the examiner finally did reach me, they had specific questions about my program's attendance policy and what would happen to my financial aid if I took a full-time job. Be ready to answer those questions concretely.

0 coins

Financial aid and full-time job interaction is something I hadn't fully thought through - good to have an answer ready if they ask.

0 coins

The examiner asked me if taking a 40-hour job would trigger a leave that affected my aid. I had to call my financial aid office after and get a statement from them. That delay cost me another two weeks before my claim resolved.

0 coins

Get the financial aid office statement preemptively if you can - it's the kind of thing that slows adjudication down significantly if the examiner has to wait for you to gather it after they ask.

0 coins

Weekly certification while in adjudication - make sure you're answering the availability questions accurately and consistently. If your answers to 'were you able and available for work' fluctuate week to week without explanation, it creates inconsistencies in your record that an examiner will notice. Answer based on your actual availability during that specific week.

0 coins

Have been answering yes to able and available because I genuinely have been applying to evening and weekend jobs. Just want to make sure that's the right call.

0 coins

Yes is correct if you are genuinely available and actively seeking work within hours you can actually fill. The issue only comes up if you'd realistically turn down any job offered because of school - which it sounds like you wouldn't.

0 coins

consistency in those weekly answers is something examiners specifically look at. any week where you said no to able and available without an approved reason is a week that may not get paid even if you win the overall adjudication

0 coins

Related posts

New York Unemployment AI

Expert Assistant
Secure