Back to New York Unemployment

NightOwl42

Can per diem employees collect unemployment in NY? NYSDOL rules explained

I've been working as a per diem hospital aide for the past two years — no guaranteed hours, no set schedule, just available when they need me and off the books when they don't. Last month the facility basically stopped calling me in altogether. I've had maybe four shifts since mid-February and I'm burning through savings fast. Someone at work mentioned I might be able to file for unemployment but I honestly have no idea if per diem workers even qualify. Like, I was never technically laid off because I was never technically employed full-time? My W-2 shows earnings but my employment status is complicated. Has anyone been in this situation with NYSDOL? Can per diem employees collect unemployment or is that just not how it works for people like us?

The per diem situation confused me too when I first stopped getting shifts — I thought because I didn't have a regular schedule I had no claim to anything. What I eventually learned is that NYSDOL looks at your base period wages, not your employment classification. If you earned enough in wages during the base period (generally the first four of the last five completed calendar quarters), you can file a UI claim regardless of whether you were called full-time, part-time, or per diem. The fact that your W-2 shows reportable wages is actually a good sign. File and let NYSDOL assess your eligibility — the worst they say is no.

0 coins

The base period thing — my hours were pretty inconsistent across those quarters. Some months I had a lot of shifts, some months almost nothing. Does that hurt my claim or does NYSDOL just total everything up regardless?

0 coins

They total it up. The dollar amount matters more than how evenly distributed the shifts were. There's also an alternate base period if the standard one doesn't meet the threshold, so even patchy work history can sometimes qualify.

0 coins

My pay was sporadic too and I still qualified. Filed last spring, got approved within two weeks. Don't let the irregular schedule thing discourage you from even trying.

0 coins

Reaching NYSDOL to ask specific questions about per diem eligibility was a nightmare for me — I'd sit on hold for over an hour and then the line would just drop. A coworker pointed me toward Claimyr (claimyr.com) and there's a demo video at https://youtu.be/Rdqa1gKtxuE that shows how it works — basically it waits on hold with NYSDOL so you end up on the phone with a live agent without having to sit there yourself. I used it to get a straight answer about my own irregular schedule situation and the agent walked me through exactly what documentation I'd need.

0 coins

That dropped-line problem is exactly what I've been dealing with. I'll check out that video, thanks.

0 coins

The hold times at NYSDOL have been brutal lately. Good to know there are options besides just hitting redial fifty times.

0 coins

I was skeptical about anything that promises to get you through to a government agency faster but sounds like it actually delivers. Might try it myself, still waiting on an adjudication issue from six weeks ago.

0 coins

I used to think per diem meant you were essentially an independent contractor and therefore ineligible for unemployment — that's what my supervisor actually told me and I believed her for way too long. The reality is different. Per diem is a scheduling arrangement, not a tax or legal classification that automatically disqualifies you. If your employer was withholding taxes from your paycheck and issuing W-2s, you were an employee, full stop. NYSDOL cares about the employer-employee relationship, not what your manager called your status.

0 coins

She actually told you that? That's wild. I wonder if my facility has been banking on people not knowing their rights.

0 coins

Honestly, yes. And it's not just healthcare. Per diem workers in education, social services, all kinds of fields get told the same thing. The W-2 is your strongest evidence that you were an employee and not a contractor.

0 coins

The contractor vs employee distinction is huge. I've seen people get denied because they were actually 1099 workers misclassified, but if you have W-2 income you're in a much stronger position than you might think.

0 coins

There's also the question of what NYSDOL considers a 'lack of work' for per diem folks. I was worried they'd say I wasn't technically laid off since I never got a formal termination notice. But when I filed, the reason I selected was 'reduction in hours / lack of work' and that was completely valid — my employer confirmed I just hadn't been scheduled. NYSDOL accepted it without an adjudication issue.

0 coins

Okay that's reassuring. I didn't get any notice either, calls just stopped coming. Didn't know there was a category for that.

0 coins

There is, and it's the right one for per diem situations where you weren't fired, you just stopped being called in. The important thing is to be accurate when you describe the reason for your reduced hours.

0 coins

Same thing here. I described it as 'work has been unavailable' and that matched what my employer said when NYSDOL reached out to them. No adjudication, approved in about ten days.

0 coins

I was in almost the exact same situation — per diem home health aide, shifts dried up over the winter. Filed my claim and it went into adjudication because my employer initially told NYSDOL I was still 'available for work' as a per diem employee. Had to call in and explain that being available on paper means nothing if no shifts are being offered. The adjudicator agreed and approved my claim. So even if you hit a snag, don't give up.

0 coins

How long did your adjudication take? That's the part I'm most nervous about.

0 coins

Mine took about three weeks from when I filed. Not fun waiting but it did resolve in my favor once I had a chance to explain the situation.

0 coins

Adjudication timelines vary a lot but three to four weeks seems common for per diem situations where the employer challenges or the reason for separation is ambiguous. Document everything in the meantime.

0 coins

Adjudication scared me too before I went through it. It's essentially just NYSDOL verifying the facts. As long as the facts support your claim, it usually works out.

0 coins

My situation went into adjudication and I could not get a human being on the phone to find out what was happening. I tried for two full weeks, calling at 8am, calling at lunch, calling right before close. Eventually I tried Claimyr and that's how I finally got an agent on the line — first time I'd actually spoken to a person at NYSDOL in over a month. The agent told me my adjudication was done and my claim had already been approved, it just hadn't shown up in my account yet. Would've kept worrying for nothing if I hadn't gotten through.

0 coins

Two weeks of trying and nothing — that's my biggest fear with this process. At least knowing Claimyr is an option helps.

0 coins

The gap between a decision being made and it appearing in your Unemployment Services account is real and annoying. Sometimes calling in is the only way to know where you actually stand.

0 coins

I had the same experience — my account showed 'pending' for days after the adjudication was apparently already resolved. Speaking to an agent was the only way I got a straight answer.

0 coins

This is why phone access matters so much. The online portal is useful but it lags behind what the agents actually see.

0 coins

There's one more thing per diem workers should know when filing — the weekly claim certification. Even after you're approved, you still have to certify every week that you were able and available for work, that you actively looked for work, and that you reported any earnings. Per diem workers sometimes forget to report the occasional shift they pick up and that can create an overpayment issue down the road. Report every dollar earned, even if it's just one shift that week.

0 coins

What counts as a job search activity for NYSDOL purposes? I've been applying but I'm not sure what I need to document.

0 coins

NYSDOL requires three job search activities per week. That includes submitting applications, attending job fairs, using employment agency services, or completing skills training. Keep a log with dates, employer names, positions applied for, and how you applied. They can audit this.

0 coins

The job search log requirement trips a lot of people up. I keep a simple spreadsheet and it's saved me a couple of times when NYSDOL wanted to verify I was meeting the requirement.

0 coins

What about per diem workers who are still picking up occasional shifts — can you still file? I'm in that boat right now, getting maybe one shift every two weeks. I've heard people say you can't file if you're still technically employed but that doesn't sound right to me.

0 coins

The still-technically-employed concern stopped me from filing for weeks longer than I should have waited. You can receive partial unemployment benefits in New York while still working reduced hours. NYSDOL has a formula — they deduct a portion of your weekly earnings from your benefit rate but you can still receive something. The key is reporting every shift honestly.

0 coins

Partial UI is very real and very useful. The break-even point where you earn too much to get any benefit is higher than most people expect. Worth filing and letting NYSDOL calculate it.

0 coins

I collected partial benefits for three months while still picking up occasional per diem work. You just have to certify accurately each week about what you earned. NYSDOL handles the math.

0 coins

My employer tried to say I was ineligible because I had 'voluntarily accepted' per diem status when I was hired. NYSDOL's adjudicator didn't buy it — agreeing to per diem scheduling when you take a job doesn't mean you've waived your right to unemployment when the work dries up. I ended up getting an agent on the line through Claimyr to ask exactly what documentation would counter my employer's argument. The agent explained what employer responses typically look like in the system and what I could submit to push back.

0 coins

The 'you chose this' argument from employers — that's exactly the kind of thing I was worried about. Good to know NYSDOL sees through it.

0 coins

Employers fight claims all the time and they don't always win. NYSDOL weighs both sides and the fact that you agreed to per diem scheduling is not the same as agreeing to forfeit benefits.

0 coins

Employer pushback is common in per diem cases. The key is that benefit eligibility is set by statute, not by whatever agreement you signed when you were hired. NYSDOL applies the law, not your employment contract.

0 coins

I was told by an HR person at my facility that per diem workers don't get unemployment 'because that's not how per diem works.' I filed anyway and was approved in about 12 days. HR people are not NYSDOL adjudicators and what they say about your eligibility means nothing. File and let the actual agency make the call.

0 coins

That's honestly such a relief to hear. I've had almost this exact conversation with HR and walked away feeling like there was no point in trying.

0 coins

HR's job is to protect the company, not inform you of your rights. Never take eligibility advice from your employer.

0 coins

This comes up over and over. HR, supervisors, even payroll staff say things about unemployment eligibility that are just wrong. File regardless of what they tell you.

0 coins

Timing matters too — in New York you're supposed to file in the first week you're out of work or significantly underemployed. NYSDOL generally doesn't pay benefits for weeks before you file, so every week you wait is a week of potential benefits you won't get. I waited three weeks after my hours dropped because I wasn't sure I qualified, and I never recovered those weeks.

0 coins

I've already been light on shifts for about six weeks. Is there any way to get benefits for that period retroactively?

0 coins

Typically no — NYSDOL starts the benefit year from your filing date, not from when your hours actually dropped. There are very limited exceptions but they're hard to qualify for. File today if you haven't already.

0 coins

The same thing happened to me, waited too long out of uncertainty. Ended up leaving about a month of benefits on the table. The lesson is to file as soon as your situation changes, not after you've made peace with it.

0 coins

The online filing system at labor.ny.gov is actually pretty smooth for per diem situations. When it asks about your reason for separation, you pick 'reduction in hours' and then describe the per diem situation in the text field. I found being specific — mentioning exact dates shifts stopped coming and what my average hours had been — helped avoid extra scrutiny.

0 coins

Do I need to have exact numbers or is an estimate okay? I didn't keep perfect records of every shift.

0 coins

Be as accurate as you can but don't let imperfect records stop you from filing. NYSDOL also contacts your employer for wage records. Your W-2 and any pay stubs you have will fill in a lot of the gaps.

0 coins

Paystubs, even digital ones from your employer's HR portal, are great supporting documentation. If you can download your pay history do it before you lose access.

0 coins

I went through a period thinking I had to be in standby status to file as an on-call worker. Standby is actually a specific program where your employer certifies you'll be recalled within a set number of weeks — it exempts you from the job search requirement during that period. Per diem workers whose facilities have stopped scheduling them are usually just filing regular unemployment, not standby, because there's no formal recall date. The two paths are different.

0 coins

My facility never mentioned anything about recalling me, it was more like the calls just quietly stopped. Sounds like regular UI is the right path.

0 coins

Right. Standby requires the employer to actively participate and guarantee a recall. If your employer isn't offering that, you're in the standard UI track, which is what most per diem workers end up filing.

0 coins

I confused these two for a while too. Standard UI with job search requirements was actually fine for me — the job search activities weren't that hard to document and I ended up finding better work while collecting.

0 coins

For anyone still unsure whether their wages meet the threshold: New York's current minimum to establish a valid UI claim requires you to have wages in at least two quarters of your base period, with total base period wages at least 1.5 times your high-quarter wages, and your high-quarter wages need to meet a minimum threshold set by NYSDOL each year. Per diem workers with inconsistent schedules sometimes fall short, but many don't. If you don't qualify under the standard base period NYSDOL automatically checks an alternate base period using more recent wages.

0 coins

The alternate base period — does NYSDOL check that automatically or do I have to request it?

0 coins

NYSDOL checks it automatically if you don't qualify under the standard base period. You don't have to do anything extra. They'll apply whichever period results in a valid claim, if one exists.

0 coins

This saved my claim. My standard base period wages were too low but the alternate base period included a quarter where I'd worked a lot and I qualified. I didn't even know that happened until I got my approval notice.

0 coins

Automatic checks like this are one of the few things NYSDOL does that actually helps claimants without them having to know to ask. Good to flag this for people who might assume they don't qualify.

0 coins

Weeks of zero income are stressful enough without spending hours trying to reach NYSDOL on the phone. My whole first week of trying to get answers about my per diem claim was just hold music and disconnections. I ended up working through the online resources pretty heavily — the NYSDOL FAQ page actually has a decent section on reduced hours and varied schedules that answered a lot of my questions without needing to talk to anyone.

0 coins

I hadn't thought to check the FAQ section specifically for reduced hours. I'll look there first before trying to get through on the phone.

0 coins

It's not a perfect substitute for talking to an agent when you have a complicated specific question, but for general eligibility stuff it covers more ground than you'd expect.

0 coins

After my claim was approved I got confused about whether I had to keep certifying weekly even during weeks when I picked up a shift or two. The answer is yes — you certify every single week of your benefit year, even weeks with earnings. Missing a certification for a week means you don't get paid for that week. There's no way to go back and certify retroactively after the window closes.

0 coins

How long is the certification window? Like when does it open and close each week?

0 coins

NYSDOL opens your certification for the previous week on Monday and closes it Sunday night, I believe. I always did mine Sunday evening to make sure I didn't forget. The system sends reminders but don't depend on them.

0 coins

The certification window is important. I missed one week early on and just lost that week's benefit entirely. No appeals process for missing the window, it's just gone.

0 coins

Setting a weekly phone reminder for Sunday afternoon fixed this problem for me completely. Sounds basic but it works.

0 coins

To bring it back to your original question — yes, per diem employees in New York can and do collect unemployment. The core requirements are the same as for any other worker: earned enough wages during your base period, your hours dropped through no fault of your own, and you're able and available for new work. Per diem status doesn't disqualify you. The scheduling arrangement is just that — a scheduling arrangement. NYSDOL looks at the substance of your employment relationship, not the label your employer used.

0 coins

Appreciate you summing it up so clearly. I'm going to file this week. Even if it goes into adjudication I feel a lot more prepared for what that process looks like now.

0 coins

Filing sooner is better than waiting. Good luck — based on what you've described it sounds like you have a solid claim.

0 coins

You've got this. The forum will still be here if you hit any snags along the way.

0 coins

Related posts

New York Unemployment AI

Expert Assistant
Secure