Can minors file for unemployment in NY? NYSDOL rules explained
My 17-year-old has been working part-time at a grocery store for about a year and a half, legitimately on the payroll with taxes withheld and everything. The store is downsizing and let him go last week. He's devastated, honestly, because he was really proud of that job and saving up for college. Someone at school told him he might be able to file for unemployment but neither of us can find a clear answer about whether NYSDOL even allows minors to file. We've looked at the labor.ny.gov site and it's not exactly written in plain language. Has anyone actually been through this or know what the rules are? He meets the base period wage requirements as far as we can tell from the numbers, so it's not a matter of earnings. It's specifically the age thing we're unsure about.
80 comments

Mateusius Townsend
My nephew was 16 when he got laid off from a restaurant job a couple years back and we went through almost exactly this. The thing that surprised us was there's no minimum age written into the NY unemployment insurance law itself — the eligibility rules focus on wages earned, reason for separation, and whether you're able and available to work. If your son was a legitimate W-2 employee with taxes withheld, he was likely covered under UI the same as any adult worker. The base period earnings requirement is what trips most people up, not age. We ended up filing online through the NYSDOL Unemployment Services portal and it went through without issue.
0 coins
Demi Hall
AuthorThat's genuinely the first concrete answer I've found anywhere. So NYSDOL doesn't actually have an age floor written into the statute? That's wild, I assumed there was some cutoff like 18.
0 coins
Kara Yoshida
My experience matches this too. The NY UI law is tied to employment status and earnings, not age. If the employer was taking out FICA and state taxes, that minor was treated as a regular employee and the UI coverage follows from that.
0 coins
Philip Cowan
Worth pointing out that school attendance can complicate the 'able and available' requirement for a minor. If he's in school full time, NYSDOL might question whether he's genuinely available for full-time work, which is one of the ongoing eligibility criteria.
0 coins
Caesar Grant
I've been through the NYSDOL phone lines enough times to know they're almost impossible to reach when you actually need a human answer on something specific like this. If you need to talk to an agent directly — which I'd honestly recommend for a situation with this many variables — I had good luck using Claimyr (claimyr.com). It waits on hold with NYSDOL so you end up on the phone with a live agent yourself. There's a video showing how it works at https://youtu.be/Rdqa1gKtxuE. For a question like whether a minor's claim will process without flags, talking to an actual agent beats guessing based on forum posts.
0 coins
Demi Hall
AuthorHadn't heard of that before. The couple times I tried calling NYSDOL I sat on hold for over an hour and then the line dropped. Getting a live agent would be huge for this.
0 coins
Lena Schultz
The phone situation at NYSDOL is genuinely terrible, especially for anything that falls outside the standard scenario. A minor filing is unusual enough that an agent can probably save you a lot of back-and-forth.
0 coins
Gemma Andrews
I tried calling NYSDOL four times last month on a different issue and got nowhere. Ended up just submitting a message through my Unemployment Services account and waiting days for a reply. Live agent access sounds way better for something time-sensitive.
0 coins
Pedro Sawyer
My daughter filed when she was 17 and the system didn't reject her based on age at any point in the process. The online filing portal on labor.ny.gov asks for your SSN, employment history, and separation reason — there's no age verification step or age-based block that we encountered. She did have to certify she was able and available for work and actively seeking employment, same as any adult claimant.
0 coins
Demi Hall
AuthorThe active job search piece is what I keep coming back to. He's a junior in high school so his availability during school hours is obviously limited. I wonder how NYSDOL views that.
0 coins
Mateusius Townsend
That availability question came up for my nephew too. His claim was approved, but the case worker noted his school schedule in the file. He was expected to be available for work outside school hours and on weekends, and that satisfied the requirement. It's not a black-and-white disqualifier, more of a nuance they evaluate.
0 coins
Mae Bennett
The 'able and available' standard doesn't require you to be available 24/7, it's more about whether you're genuinely in the labor market. Part-time availability can satisfy it in some cases. I'd document his availability carefully in the weekly certifications.
0 coins
Beatrice Marshall
What people are saying here is basically right but let me add some context from actually reading through the NY Labor Law. Section 527 covers disqualifications and there is nothing in there that bars a person from collecting based solely on age. The eligibility requirements in Article 18 center on the base period (the first four of the last five completed calendar quarters), sufficient wages in that base period, job loss through no fault of your own, and ongoing able-and-available status. A 17-year-old who meets all those conditions is eligible. The school schedule thing is real but manageable — NYSDOL generally accepts that someone in school can still be 'available' if they're seeking work in the hours they're not in class.
0 coins
Demi Hall
AuthorThe base period math is something I tried to figure out from his pay stubs. He started in early 2024 so depending on when exactly the quarters cut off, it might be close. Is there a tool on the NYSDOL site to estimate whether he hits the threshold?
0 coins
Beatrice Marshall
There's no official calculator on the NYSDOL site but the basic rule is you need to have earned wages in at least two of the four base period quarters, and your total base period wages need to be at least 1.5 times your highest quarter wages. There's also a minimum weekly benefit floor. For a part-time grocery store job at minimum wage or close to it over 18 months, he likely clears the threshold but it depends on his exact hours and pay rate.
0 coins
Kara Yoshida
The alternative base period is also an option if the standard one doesn't work out — that uses the last four completed quarters instead, which might capture more of his earnings depending on timing.
0 coins
Melina Haruko
i didn't even know minors could have wages withheld for UI purposes?? i thought that was only for adults. does the employer have to do anything special when hiring someone under 18 or is it just automatic
0 coins
Mateusius Townsend
Employers pay FUTA and SUTA on wages paid to employees regardless of age in most cases. There are some exemptions for things like family businesses where a child works for a parent, but a standard retail or service job has UI taxes withheld the same way for a 15-year-old as for a 40-year-old.
0 coins
Melina Haruko
ohh ok so if the grocery store was a regular employer they would have been paying into UI on his wages the whole time
0 coins
Pedro Sawyer
Exactly. His W-2 at the end of the year should show state wages, and that's what NYSDOL uses. The taxes were being paid in whether anyone realized it or not.
0 coins
Dallas Villalobos
NOBODY AT NYSDOL CAN GIVE YOU A STRAIGHT ANSWER ON ANYTHING. I went through this with a family member's claim last year and every agent said something slightly different. One told us minors couldn't collect, another said they absolutely could but had extra requirements, and a third acted like it was the first time anyone had ever asked. The online information is vague on purpose I think. If you do manage to get through to someone, write down their name and the date because if they give you wrong info and you act on it, you at least have something to reference.
0 coins
Lena Schultz
The inconsistency between agents is a real problem. The underlying law is what governs, not what any individual agent says, but when you're trying to file and something seems unusual, contradictory agent advice is incredibly frustrating.
0 coins
Demi Hall
AuthorThis is exactly why I wanted to find people who had actually done it rather than relying on the official line. Though I will try to reach a live agent for the actual filing questions.
0 coins
Dallas Villalobos
Document everything. If you do get an agent who says something definitive, ask them to note it in the claim file. It won't always help but it's better than nothing.
0 coins
Philip Cowan
The job search requirements are worth understanding before you start weekly certifications. During each week he certifies, he'll need to have made the required number of job search contacts — currently three per week in NY — and log them in his NY.gov account. For a minor in school, employers need to be ones where he's genuinely eligible to work given his age and school schedule. Putting down applications to full-time adult jobs he couldn't actually take might raise flags later.
0 coins
Demi Hall
AuthorThree contacts per week — does that include online applications through Indeed or similar sites, or does it have to be direct employer contact?
0 coins
Philip Cowan
Online applications through job boards count as valid job search contacts. You just need to record the employer name, the method of contact, the position, and the date. The portal has a form for entering these each week.
0 coins
Caesar Grant
There's also a job search waiver option sometimes called 'standby' status, but that requires a recall date from a former employer. Since his store is permanently downsizing rather than doing a temporary layoff, standby probably isn't applicable here.
0 coins
Reina Salazar
Went through a messy situation last year trying to reach NYSDOL about a minor family member's claim and kept hitting dead ends by phone. Eventually tried Claimyr and it did what nothing else managed — it sits on hold with NYSDOL so I ended up actually talking to a live agent instead of waiting forever and getting dropped. The agent confirmed the minor was eligible and walked us through what documentation to have ready for the file. For something this specific, that conversation was worth more than anything I read online.
0 coins
Demi Hall
AuthorThe documentation piece is what I hadn't thought about. What did they say you'd need to have ready?
0 coins
Reina Salazar
The agent mentioned his SSN, the employer's FEIN (which should be on the W-2), dates of employment, reason for separation, and earnings history. The online filing pulls a lot of this automatically but it helps to have it in front of you in case anything needs to be entered manually.
0 coins
Gemma Andrews
Having the FEIN from the W-2 ready is good advice for anyone filing. The system usually finds the employer by name but if there's any ambiguity, that number resolves it fast.
0 coins
Kara Yoshida
My younger brother filed at 17 after a retail job ended and the claim actually processed faster than mine did as an adult, which surprised me. No adjudication hold, no special flags. The system treated him exactly like any other claimant. His weekly benefit amount was low because his part-time wages were low, but it was something — helped cover his phone bill and car insurance while he looked for another job.
0 coins
Demi Hall
AuthorThat's genuinely encouraging. I think we've both been assuming there would be some automatic roadblock because of his age and it sounds like that's just not how the system works.
0 coins
Pedro Sawyer
The benefit amount is calculated as a percentage of your average weekly wage during the base period, so part-time teen wages do mean a lower weekly benefit. But lower isn't zero, and for a teenager without major bills it can still be meaningful.
0 coins
Beatrice Marshall
The minimum weekly benefit amount in NY is set by statute and updated periodically. If his calculated benefit comes out below the minimum, he'd receive the minimum floor amount instead. His claim is worth filing just to see what comes out.
0 coins
Lena Schultz
There's one scenario that could complicate things that nobody's mentioned yet. If he's under 18 and his parents claim him as a dependent on taxes, that doesn't affect UI eligibility at all — the two systems don't talk to each other. But if the grocery store was a family business or if any family member had an ownership stake in it, there are specific exclusions in the NY UI law for family employment. Standard corporate or franchise grocery store, no issue. Corner store owned by a relative, potentially a problem.
0 coins
Demi Hall
AuthorIt's a large regional chain, nothing family-connected. So that exclusion wouldn't apply.
0 coins
Lena Schultz
Then you're clear on that front. Chain retail employment is as standard as it gets for UI purposes.
0 coins
Mateusius Townsend
The family employment exclusion catches people off guard sometimes. Good call flagging it even if it doesn't apply here.
0 coins
Saanvi Krishnaswami
My kid had a job at 16 and when it ended I honestly just assumed she couldn't collect because she was a minor. Nobody told me otherwise. She worked almost a full year at that job and I found out months later she might have been eligible the whole time. If you're reading this thread and your minor child recently lost a job, the window to file matters — NYSDOL generally has a one-year limit on how far back claims can be retroactively applied, and even within that there are complications. File promptly if you think they're eligible. I also want to say Claimyr actually helped me figure out the retroactive question because I ended up talking to an actual NYSDOL agent through it after months of not being able to reach anyone.
0 coins
Demi Hall
AuthorThe retroactive piece is a real concern, we've already been sitting on this for about a week since his last day. I'll prioritize getting the application submitted this week.
0 coins
Saanvi Krishnaswami
A week is completely fine, you have time. The retroactive issue matters more if someone waits months without knowing they were eligible. File the claim with his actual last day of work as the start date.
0 coins
Caesar Grant
The effective date of the claim is usually the Sunday of the week you file, not the date of separation. So filing this week would typically make the claim effective as of last Sunday. Getting it in sooner rather than later captures more weeks.
0 coins
Mae Bennett
Two things about the weekly certification process that tripped us up when my sibling filed as a teen. First, the system asks whether you were 'able to work and available for work' during each week. If he had a school exam week where he genuinely couldn't take a job if offered, the honest answer might affect his payment for that week. Second, the job search activity section gets reviewed — NYSDOL does audit these, and contacts that don't hold up under scrutiny can trigger an overpayment determination later. Keep records of every application, screenshot confirmations where possible.
0 coins
Demi Hall
AuthorThe audit risk on job search logs is something I didn't know about. How thorough are those audits typically — spot checks or systematic review?
0 coins
Mae Bennett
From what I understand it's more spot-check than systematic for regular claims, but if anything else on the claim draws attention, the job search log gets looked at more carefully. The safest approach is accurate documentation of real contacts.
0 coins
Philip Cowan
Overpayment notices are really hard to fight once they're issued. Accurate weekly certifications from the start are worth the extra five minutes every week. If he's genuinely not available a particular week, it's better to report that honestly than to have an overpayment clawed back later.
0 coins
Demi Lagos
My first week trying to understand the NYSDOL system for my teenage son, I spent three hours on hold across two separate calls and got nowhere. Someone in a different forum mentioned Claimyr — it basically waits on hold with NYSDOL so you end up speaking to a live agent without burning your whole afternoon. We got through to someone who answered the minor eligibility question directly, explained the base period calculation for his specific earnings, and noted in the file that the claim should not be flagged based on age alone. Worth it for anyone dealing with NYSDOL on a less common situation.
0 coins
Demi Hall
AuthorThree hours across two calls and still nothing — that's brutal. I appreciate the tip, especially since this situation is unusual enough that I'd rather have an agent on record saying how they're handling it.
0 coins
Dallas Villalobos
NYSDOL phone access is a whole problem on its own separate from whatever your actual claim issue is. You can have a completely valid claim and still fight for weeks just to get a human on the line to explain something simple.
0 coins
Lena Schultz
For anything that deviates from the most standard scenario, an agent conversation where you can ask follow-up questions in real time is genuinely more useful than navigating the website.
0 coins
Gemma Andrews
The portal setup itself is worth walking through before you file. His NY.gov ID account needs to exist first — if he doesn't have one, that's the first step, and verifying identity for someone under 18 can sometimes be a minor extra step. Once the NY.gov ID is set up, you access Unemployment Services through it. The filing itself is pretty straightforward once you're in.
0 coins
Demi Hall
AuthorHe actually already has a NY.gov ID from when his school district required it for something. So that step should be skipped.
0 coins
Gemma Andrews
That makes it even simpler then. Log into NY.gov with his existing credentials and look for the Unemployment Insurance option under Unemployment Services. The filing interview takes about 20-30 minutes if you have his employment info handy.
0 coins
Pedro Sawyer
Having the employer's address and phone number ready also helps since the system asks for that as part of the separation details.
0 coins
Beatrice Marshall
After reading everything in this thread, the summary for anyone who lands here from a search: NY unemployment law does not set a minimum age for claimants. A minor who was legally employed, earned wages in covered employment, lost the job through no fault of their own, and is able and available for work meets the same eligibility criteria as an adult. School schedules can intersect with the 'available for work' requirement but do not automatically disqualify a student. File promptly, certify accurately, and document job searches carefully.
0 coins
Demi Hall
AuthorThis is a genuinely useful summary. I'm going to screenshot this and walk through each point with him before we file.
0 coins
Kara Yoshida
The 'no fault' criterion is straightforward here since the store initiated the layoff, not him. That piece is clean, which makes the whole claim stronger from the start.
0 coins
Mateusius Townsend
The documentation habit for job search is the one that most people let slip and then regret. Instilling it from week one of the claim makes the rest of the process much less stressful.
0 coins
Caesar Grant
There's also the question of what happens if the claim goes to adjudication. If NYSDOL has questions about the separation — like if the employer contests anything or if there's ambiguity in the reason given — the claim gets held for review. During adjudication the claimant typically gets a questionnaire to complete and may be asked to provide additional information. Responding promptly to any adjudication requests matters a lot; delays in responding can stall the claim significantly.
0 coins
Demi Hall
AuthorHow would we know if it went to adjudication? Does the portal show that status?
0 coins
Caesar Grant
Yes, the Unemployment Services account shows the claim status and will reflect adjudication if that's where it ends up. You can also see any pending issues or questionnaires through the same portal. Checking it regularly after filing is a good habit.
0 coins
Reina Salazar
The employer response window is one of the things that can trigger adjudication — if the former employer disputes the reason for separation, that kicks off the review process. For a straightforward store downsizing layoff, the employer should confirm that without contest, which keeps things cleaner.
0 coins
Melina Haruko
does he get to keep collecting if he finds another part time job or does that cancel everything
0 coins
Beatrice Marshall
Partial UI benefits are a real thing in NY. If he earns wages in a week he's certifying, he reports those earnings during certification. NYSDOL subtracts a portion of those earnings from his weekly benefit rather than eliminating the benefit entirely. There's a formula — earnings above a small disregard amount reduce the benefit dollar for dollar above a threshold. So part-time work doesn't have to end the claim, it just reduces the weekly payment proportionally.
0 coins
Mae Bennett
The key is reporting every dollar earned in the week it was earned, not when it was paid. Getting that wrong is what leads to overpayment issues later.
0 coins
Melina Haruko
ok thats actually really good to know bc i assumed getting any job at all would just end it completely
0 coins
Dallas Villalobos
I want to go back to the employer piece for a second because it matters. The grocery store downsizing — did they give him any paperwork when he was let go? A lot of employers are legally supposed to provide information about UI eligibility at separation in NY. If they gave him anything mentioning unemployment, that documentation is useful to have on hand, and if they didn't, that's worth knowing too since it doesn't affect his right to file but it's part of the picture.
0 coins
Demi Hall
AuthorThey gave him a final pay stub and a generic separation letter saying his position was eliminated as part of a store restructuring. No mention of unemployment benefits in either document.
0 coins
Dallas Villalobos
The separation letter describing the layoff as restructuring is actually useful documentation to have. If the employer tries to characterize the separation differently later, that letter supports his account of what happened.
0 coins
Lena Schultz
Employers are supposed to provide a record of employment or separation notice in NY but many don't do this comprehensively. The letter you have is better than nothing — keep a copy somewhere accessible for the life of the claim.
0 coins
Pedro Sawyer
My experience was that the first weekly certification after filing felt confusing because the timing is a bit counterintuitive. You file the initial claim, and then you have to certify for each week retroactively going back to the effective date of the claim. If his effective date ends up being last Sunday, he'll need to certify for that week (and potentially prior weeks depending on how the system populates) before any payments release. The portal shows which weeks need certification.
0 coins
Demi Hall
AuthorThe retroactive certification piece is new information for me. So even if we file this week, we still need to go back and certify for last week before anything gets paid out?
0 coins
Pedro Sawyer
Exactly. The initial claim sets up the account and the effective date, but the actual payments only release after each week is certified as a week in which you were able, available, and job searching. It's a bit of a lag but it makes sense once you see how the system is structured.
0 coins
Kara Yoshida
Payments also don't release on the first certified week due to the NY waiting week — the first week of a valid claim is an unpaid 'waiting week' by statute. So the first actual payment usually corresponds to the second certified week.
0 coins
Philip Cowan
The appeal process is worth understanding even before you need it. If NYSDOL denies the claim for any reason — whether it's a question about availability, base period wages, or anything else — there's a formal appeal process. The denial letter specifies the reason and gives a window to appeal, typically 30 days. The appeal goes to an Administrative Law Judge and both the claimant and employer can participate. For a case like this where the law is on the claimant's side, a denial based on age or availability might actually be worth appealing.
0 coins
Demi Hall
AuthorI hadn't thought about what happens if it's just denied outright. Good to know there's a formal path to challenge that.
0 coins
Beatrice Marshall
Appeals for straightforward cases can actually go reasonably well because the ALJ looks at the law, not just what the initial determiner decided. If the denial reason is shaky, an appeal sometimes resolves it quickly.
0 coins
Mateusius Townsend
Keeping copies of everything filed, every communication, and every certification from the beginning is what makes an appeal possible if you need one. Without records, you're trying to reconstruct a timeline from memory.
0 coins