Back to New York Unemployment

Vincent Bimbach

Can I collect unemployment if I get fired? NY situation

So I got let go from my job last Friday and I'm honestly in shock still. I'd been at this company for about 6 years doing warehouse logistics and my supervisor basically said they were 'restructuring' but then the termination paperwork says 'terminated for performance reasons.' I don't even know what performance issues they're talking about - I had good reviews up until like two months ago when we got a new manager. I keep hearing different things from people. My buddy said you can't get unemployment if you get fired, but my sister-in-law said it depends on the reason. I went on the NYSDOL site and it's honestly confusing. I filed a claim already but now I'm worried it's going to get denied. Can I collect unemployment if I get fired in NY? Does the reason they write on the termination paper actually matter? I'm really stressing about this because I have rent due in three weeks.

Your situation - six years at one company and then a vague 'performance' label slapped on the paperwork right after a management change - that's actually a really common setup for a successful unemployment claim. NY doesn't automatically deny UI benefits just because an employer says 'terminated for cause.' What matters is whether the employer can prove you did something that rises to the level of 'misconduct' under NYSDOL's standards. Vague performance complaints that weren't formally documented before your termination often don't meet that bar. File your claim and be honest when they ask about the separation - explain the timeline, the new manager, the reviews. The adjudication process will look at both sides.

0 coins

My termination letter doesn't go into specifics at all, just says performance-related separation. Would that hurt me or help me in adjudication?

0 coins

The vagueness actually tends to work in your favor. NYSDOL adjudicators look for documented warnings, written write-ups, that kind of paper trail. If your employer can't produce records showing you were warned about specific issues, it's hard for them to prove disqualifying misconduct. Keep any emails or reviews you have from before the management change.

0 coins

this is right. my employer just said 'not a good fit' and i still got approved. vague reasons don't hold up well for employers in these hearings

0 coins

I was in almost the exact same spot eight months ago and spent two weeks trying to get someone at NYSDOL on the phone to ask about my adjudication status. Hold times were insane - I'd sit there for an hour and a half and the line would just drop. A coworker told me about Claimyr (claimyr.com) - it waits on hold with NYSDOL for you so you end up talking to a live agent without burning your whole day on hold. There's a video showing how it works at https://youtu.be/Rdqa1gKtxuE. Once I actually got an agent, she explained exactly where my claim stood and what documentation I needed to submit. Huge relief compared to guessing from the website.

0 coins

Two weeks trying to get through sounds like my worst nightmare right now. I'll check that out if my claim goes into adjudication and I need answers fast.

0 coins

Hold times at NYSDOL have been brutal lately. Heard a lot of people mentioning Claimyr recently, might be worth trying if you're stuck.

0 coins

I tried calling first thing in the morning three days in a row and still waited over an hour each time. The hold situation is genuinely terrible right now.

0 coins

The word 'fired' covers a huge range of situations and NY unemployment law treats them very differently. Your case hinges on what you actually did or didn't do at work. The state disqualifies people for what it calls 'misconduct' - but that word has a specific legal meaning. It's not just doing your job imperfectly or clashing with a new boss's style. It means intentional wrongdoing, serious rule violations you knew about, or repeatedly ignoring clear instructions after warnings. A new manager deciding your old work habits don't fit their approach, or reassigning blame for problems that weren't tracked before - that rarely meets the misconduct definition. So yes, you can absolutely collect unemployment if you get fired, as long as the reason doesn't clear that legal bar.

0 coins

That distinction makes a lot of sense. I genuinely didn't violate any rules, there were no warnings in writing, nothing. It really does seem like it came down to the new manager not liking how the previous team operated.

0 coins

Exactly this. I got fired too, employer said 'attendance issues' but I had FMLA-covered absences. NYSDOL sided with me because the employer couldn't show I violated a clear attendance policy I'd been warned about. The documentation piece is huge.

0 coins

wait so if they fire you for being late a few times does that count as misconduct or not?? asking for a situation i know of lol

0 coins

Being late a few times without prior written warnings usually won't qualify as misconduct under NY standards. If the employer never formally documented the tardiness or issued warnings, it's really hard for them to claim it rises to that level.

0 coins

I went through adjudication after getting fired last year and want to share what actually helped me. NYSDOL sends a questionnaire to both you and your former employer after you file. Fill it out completely - don't leave anything blank and don't just say 'see attached.' Write out the full story in the box they give you, especially the timeline of when the new management came in versus when these so-called performance problems appeared. The adjudicator is basically reading two competing versions of events and deciding which one makes sense. Your version needs to be clear and specific.

0 coins

I haven't gotten that questionnaire yet but I'll be ready when it comes. How long did it take to arrive after you filed?

0 coins

Mine came about 10 days after I filed the initial claim. Check both your Unemployment Services portal and your physical mail - mine came by mail even though I expected it online.

0 coins

The questionnaire response is genuinely the most important step in the whole process for fired claimants. Adjudicators make decisions based heavily on those written statements when neither party requests a phone interview.

0 coins

My neighbor just went through this exact thing two months ago - fired after a management change, same murky performance excuse. She was terrified she'd be denied. She got approved after adjudication, about three weeks after filing. The employer apparently didn't respond to NYSDOL's questionnaire at all, which basically defaulted in her favor. Smaller companies especially often don't bother responding.

0 coins

Honestly that's reassuring to hear. My former employer is a mid-sized company so I'm not sure if they'll respond or not.

0 coins

Even if they do respond, without written documentation of warnings it's hard for them to build a case. Your 6-year tenure actually works in your favor too - shows a pattern of acceptable performance.

0 coins

employer not responding happened to my uncle too and he got approved pretty fast. they have like 10 days to respond i think

0 coins

THE SYSTEM IS SO BROKEN THOUGH. I got fired for absolute nonsense after 4 years and had to fight for months. My employer made stuff up in the questionnaire, submitted fake 'documentation' that was clearly backdated, and I still had to go through a whole appeal hearing before finally winning. Don't assume adjudication will be quick or easy. Some employers are willing to lie to avoid paying into the UI system. Keep EVERY email, every text, every document from your time there.

0 coins

That sounds exhausting. I did save my last few performance reviews from before the new manager arrived - at least I have those showing good standing.

0 coins

Those reviews are gold. Seriously, make sure they're saved somewhere outside of any company system you might lose access to. Print them if you have to.

0 coins

The appeal process, while frustrating, does work in legitimate cases. Hearing officers are independent from the initial adjudication and they evaluate evidence carefully. Having those prior reviews is exactly the right kind of documentation.

0 coins

My claim hit a wall during adjudication and I couldn't get a straight answer through the portal or the phone line. After days of busy signals and disconnections, Claimyr is what finally got me talking to an actual NYSDOL agent. The agent told me my employer had submitted a response with an allegation I'd never even heard before - I never would have known to respond to it without that phone call. Got the chance to submit a rebuttal and ended up approved.

0 coins

Wait, you can submit a rebuttal to what an employer says? I had no idea that was even an option.

0 coins

Yes - when I spoke to the agent she told me I could send in additional information before the adjudication decision was finalized. The portal doesn't tell you that. You really need to actually talk to someone sometimes.

0 coins

This is why getting someone on the phone actually matters. The portal shows almost nothing about what's happening behind the scenes with your claim.

0 coins

I had no idea employers could add allegations after the initial filing. That's genuinely concerning. Good to know there's a way to respond.

0 coins

Let me break down the NY unemployment eligibility timeline so you know what to expect. After filing, you'll have a one-week waiting period before benefits can start. If NYSDOL flags your separation as potentially disqualifying, your claim goes into adjudication - this is not a denial, just a review. Adjudication typically runs 2 to 6 weeks in NY right now. If the determination goes against you, you have 30 days from the mailing date to appeal to an administrative law judge. That appeal hearing is a full de novo review - fresh eyes on the evidence. Win the hearing and benefits are paid back to your original filing date.

0 coins

30 days from the mailing date - is that calendar days or business days? I want to make sure I don't miss it if I need to appeal.

0 coins

Calendar days, so count carefully and don't assume weekends or holidays extend it. NYSDOL is strict about that deadline. File the appeal online through your Unemployment Services account as soon as you get a denial - don't wait.

0 coins

i missed my appeal deadline by like 2 days once and they would not budge at all. take the 30 days seriously, it is NOT flexible

0 coins

my coworker got fired last spring and was scared she couldn't get unemployment but she did. they said the employer never proved she actually did anything wrong just kept saying she wasn't meeting 'expectations' without showing what those expectations even were. ny really does look at whether the company followed their own rules before firing you

0 coins

Did she have to do a phone interview with NYSDOL during adjudication or was it all written?

0 coins

i think it was all written. they just asked her to fill out the questionnaire and that was basically it. the whole thing took like 4 weeks before she heard anything

0 coins

written questionnaires are more common than phone interviews now. they usually only do calls if the case is complicated or there are conflicting stories that need to be sorted out verbally

0 coins

Your six years of employment matters more than people realize in these situations. When NYSDOL's adjudicator looks at a long-tenured employee versus a fresh hire, the patterns of behavior mean something different. An isolated incident or a vague performance complaint at the end of a 6-year run, with no documented issues before a management change, reads very differently than the same complaint leveled at someone who'd been there three months. Claimyr actually helped me get the information I needed to understand this - I talked to an agent who walked me through exactly how my tenure was being weighed in my own adjudication.

0 coins

I hadn't thought about tenure being a factor like that but it makes complete sense. Good to know it's not irrelevant.

0 coins

Length of employment signals a lot. If you were truly a performance disaster they would have caught it sooner than 6 years in. That's a strong implicit argument.

0 coins

Are you still certifying weekly claims while adjudication is happening? A lot of people don't realize you're supposed to keep filing even if no money is coming in yet. If you get approved, they pay back all the weeks you certified for - but if you stopped certifying, you lose those weeks permanently.

0 coins

I had no idea I was supposed to keep filing during adjudication! I filed my initial claim but haven't done a weekly certification yet. How do I do that?

0 coins

Log into your Unemployment Services account and look for 'claim weekly benefits' - it shows up each week. You answer questions about whether you worked, earned money, were available for work, and whether you looked for a job that week. It only takes about 5-10 minutes.

0 coins

This is a really important point. Keep those weekly certifications current no matter what. NYSDOL will back-pay the approved weeks but only the ones you actually certified for.

0 coins

Going to do this right now. Thank you for catching that.

0 coins

I want to push back a little on the idea that this is all straightforward. I got fired after 8 years, had great reviews, employer gave a vague reason, and I still got denied at adjudication. My employer had an HR department that knew how to write things up in a way that sounded more serious than it was. I eventually won on appeal but it took 4 months and was incredibly stressful. Don't go in expecting an easy approval - prepare your documentation like you're going to need every bit of it.

0 coins

That's sobering but I appreciate the realistic view. What documentation did you end up presenting at your appeal hearing?

0 coins

I had three years of annual reviews showing 'meets expectations' or better, emails from my previous manager praising specific work, and a timeline I wrote up showing exactly when the new manager arrived and when the complaints started. The hearing officer found the timing suspicious and ruled in my favor.

0 coins

Appeals do add significant time but the hearing process itself is actually pretty fair. Administrative law judges look at patterns and credibility, not just whoever has the most paperwork.

0 coins

For the job search piece - once you're approved and benefits start, NY requires you to do a minimum of three job search activities per week and log them. You need to keep a record of company name, contact info, date, and how you applied. NYSDOL can audit these at any time, and if you can't produce the records, it creates an overpayment problem. Set up a simple spreadsheet from day one.

0 coins

Three activities per week - does that mean three separate job applications, or does it include things like attending a career event?

0 coins

It includes applications, reaching out to employers, networking events, career fairs, online skills courses approved by NYSDOL, and other activities. All three don't have to be direct applications. The NYSDOL website has the full list of what qualifies.

0 coins

yeah i used to just count linkedin messages as one of my activities. as long as you document the contact info and date you should be fine

0 coins

Couldn't get through to NYSDOL on the phone for three days straight trying to find out if my claim was under adjudication or had just fallen through the cracks. A friend who went through this last year pointed me toward Claimyr. Ended up speaking with a real NYSDOL agent that same afternoon and learned my claim had actually been approved two days earlier but the portal just hadn't updated yet. Would have been anxious for another week at least without that conversation.

0 coins

The portal not updating in real time sounds incredibly frustrating. How long had your claim been sitting approved without you knowing?

0 coins

Two full days. The agent told me the approval date and explained why my portal was lagging. She said it's a known system issue and the portal can run a day or two behind actual decisions.

0 coins

ugh that portal lag is real. i thought i was denied for days because nothing updated and then suddenly all the weeks deposited at once

0 coins

The honest answer to your original question - can you collect unemployment if you get fired - is yes, more often than people think. NY's misconduct standard is actually fairly hard for employers to meet unless they have solid written documentation. Vague performance issues, personality clashes with new management, restructuring disguised as termination-for-cause - these rarely succeed as disqualifying reasons. The burden is on your employer to prove misconduct, not on you to prove innocence.

0 coins

Flipping the burden of proof around makes me feel a lot better about this. I've been thinking of it backwards.

0 coins

Most people do think of it backwards because that's how it works in employment generally. For UI purposes though, the employer has to come forward with real proof. If they can't produce it, the tie goes to the claimant.

0 coins

This is correct and worth emphasizing. The adjudicator isn't starting from a presumption that the firing was justified. They're asking: did the employer prove misconduct by their own documented evidence?

0 coins

does anyone know if it matters that he was technically in a probationary period when he got the new manager? like does that change the misconduct standard at all

0 coins

The original poster mentioned being there 6 years total, so there's no probationary situation here. Generally speaking, long-tenured employees outside any probationary period get the standard misconduct analysis regardless of whether a new manager recently took over.

0 coins

Probationary periods are typically only relevant to brand new employees under 6 months or so. At 6 years in, that concept doesn't apply to this situation at all.

0 coins

I want to circle back to the documentation point because it cannot be overstated. Right now, before you lose access to any company email or systems, forward any relevant emails to your personal address. Download any performance reviews, goal-setting documents, project notes. Once your work account is deactivated - which often happens fast - you can't get those back. Courts and administrative hearings have upheld that employees can retain copies of documents related to their own job performance.

0 coins

Already done on the reviews, but I'm going to go back through my work email right now and grab anything else useful.

0 coins

Do it today. I lost access to my work systems within 48 hours of being terminated and had to reconstruct a lot from memory during my appeal. Having the actual documents is so much more convincing.

0 coins

SCREENSHOT EVERYTHING. Even internal messaging apps like Teams or Slack if you can. Those messages can show the actual climate before the firing and sometimes contradict what employers claim in their written statements.

0 coins

Since you mentioned your paperwork says 'performance-related separation' specifically - when NYSDOL contacts your former employer, they'll ask the employer to describe the specific acts or omissions that led to termination. If your employer responds with equally vague language and no documented incidents, the adjudicator doesn't have much to work with. The more specific the employer has to get, the more exposed any weak documentation becomes. Your 6-year record with no prior formal discipline is going to be a contrast they'll have to explain away.

0 coins

My previous manager actually left me a LinkedIn recommendation about four months ago before he moved on. Would something like that be useful to reference?

0 coins

A glowing recommendation from your previous manager dated a few months before termination is excellent context. It doesn't substitute for the formal documentation but it establishes the baseline of how your work was actually perceived before the management change.

0 coins

Screenshots of that recommendation are worth keeping. It's not official documentation but it paints a picture - positive supervisor assessment, then management change, then sudden termination. That timeline tells a story.

0 coins

After adjudication wraps up you'll get a determination letter by mail and in your Unemployment Services portal. Read it carefully the moment it arrives. The letter will state either an approval, a denial with the specific reason, or in some cases a partial decision. If denied, the reason code matters - different disqualification reasons have different appeal paths and timelines. Don't just glance at the outcome and set it aside.

0 coins

Are the reason codes explained on the NYSDOL website or do I need to look them up somewhere else?

0 coins

They're partially explained in the letter itself and more fully on the NYSDOL website under the appeals section. If you get a denial and the code doesn't make sense, calling to ask an agent to explain it is worth the effort.

0 coins

The specific disqualification code also tells you whether you can cure the issue on appeal or whether the appeal requires a full hearing. Some procedural issues can be corrected without a formal hearing before an administrative law judge.

0 coins

Related posts

New York Unemployment AI

Expert Assistant
Secure