Back to New York Unemployment

Aaliyah Reed

Are you unemployed if you are a student? NYSDOL eligibility explained

My situation is a little complicated and I'm hoping someone here has dealt with something similar. I got laid off from my full-time warehouse job in March after the company downsized, and I've been collecting UI benefits since then. About two weeks into my claim, I enrolled in an accelerated logistics certification program at a local community college — it's only four months long and I figured it would help me land something better when I got back out there. Now I'm second-guessing everything. NYSDOL sent me a notice asking me to call in about my "able and available" status, and suddenly I'm wondering if being a student means I'm technically not considered unemployed anymore. I've been doing my three job search activities every week and reporting honestly on my weekly claims. I didn't hide the school thing but I also didn't specifically mention it. Does being enrolled in a short program like this actually affect your UI eligibility in New York? Really stressed about this.

My first move in your position would be to pull up your Unemployment Services account and look for any disqualification language in that notice — NYSDOL usually signals in the letter whether they think there's an "able and available" issue specifically or whether it's a broader eligibility review. The rule in New York is that you have to be ready, willing, and able to accept full-time work right now. If your class schedule would stop you from taking a full-time job offered to you, that's where the problem lives. Short certification programs can go either way depending on how NYSDOL classifies them — if it's vocational retraining, they sometimes approve it, but it's case by case.

0 coins

My schedule is two evenings a week, so I could take a full-time day job no problem. Does that actually matter to them or will they just see "student" and flag it?

0 coins

Your evening schedule actually helps you a lot here. NYSDOL's real concern is whether the school prevents you from working. Two evenings a week? Tell them that explicitly when you talk to them — it usually resolves the able-and-available question pretty fast.

0 coins

They flagged me for the same thing two years ago even though I was only taking one class. The key is saying clearly that you would drop the course if a full-time job came through. That's the magic phrase apparently.

0 coins

Honestly when I got a similar notice I spent three days trying to get through on the phone and kept hitting the busy signal loop. A coworker told me about Claimyr — it basically waits on hold with NYSDOL for you, doing all the holding so you eventually end up talking to a live agent there. The site is claimyr.com and there's a video showing how it works at https://youtu.be/Rdqa1gKtxuE. For something like an able-and-available review you really do need to speak to an actual person, not just leave a message.

0 coins

Thanks, appreciate it. Three days of busy signals sounds like a nightmare — did your situation end up getting resolved once you got through to someone?

0 coins

My situation cleared up in one call once I actually reached an agent. They just needed to hear me explain my availability, didn't even put me in adjudication after that.

0 coins

Phones at NYSDOL are brutal. Hours on hold and then it just disconnects. Might look into this.

0 coins

Student status and unemployment eligibility is one of the most misunderstood things about New York UI. The law doesn't say students can't collect — it says you have to be available for work. Those are two totally different things. Full-time students at four-year schools often do get disqualified because they can't take day shifts, but someone doing a short vocational program two nights a week is in a completely different situation. NYSDOL has approved plenty of people in retraining programs, especially when the training is connected to their former occupation or a related field.

0 coins

Mine is logistics, and my old job was in a warehouse — so there's definitely a connection there. That's actually reassuring to hear.

0 coins

Vocational retraining angle is real. My brother went through a CDL training program while collecting and NYSDOL approved it once he filed a form showing it was job-related. Worth looking into whether there's a formal approval process you can apply for.

0 coins

There is a formal approval route — it's the "approved training" designation from NYSDOL. If you get that, your enrollment is explicitly protected and won't affect your benefits. The OP's situation might qualify given the connection to their previous work.

0 coins

wait so you can collect unemployment AND go to school at the same time?? I always thought that was totally not allowed. I dropped a class last year because I was scared it would mess up my benefits and now im kicking myself

0 coins

Your concern made sense given how confusing the rules are, but yeah — it depends on the schedule and how it affects your availability. Evening or weekend classes usually don't cause problems.

0 coins

ugh that's annoying. would have finished the class by now if I'd known

0 coins

ABLE AND AVAILABLE notices are terrifying, I got one last spring and thought I was about to lose everything. Mine was actually triggered because I mentioned to a career counselor that I was "considering" taking a class and somehow that got flagged. It had nothing to do with actually being enrolled. So sometimes these notices are based on really thin reasons and one phone call clears it up completely.

0 coins

Wow, a career counselor's note triggered yours? That's wild. Did you have to wait long after the call to get a decision?

0 coins

My decision came through in my Unemployment Services account within about five days after the call. They marked it resolved. No back payments missing or anything.

0 coins

Career center interactions generating able-and-available flags is more common than people realize. Some career centers share notes with NYSDOL directly, especially if you mention anything that could suggest you're unavailable for work.

0 coins

The technical answer to your question in the title is: no, being a student does not automatically make you unemployed OR employed in NYSDOL's eyes. Your employment status is based on wages and hours worked, not school. Your BENEFIT eligibility is what school can affect, and only if it limits your availability. Two different things that people mix up constantly.

0 coins

Your distinction between employment status and benefit eligibility actually makes this way clearer in my head. I was confusing the two.

0 coins

Your confusion is incredibly common, happens all the time in these threads. Most people think "student = not unemployed" but that's not how UI law works in New York.

0 coins

Honestly this should be pinned somewhere. So many people panic-drop classes because they don't understand the distinction.

0 coins

I am one of those people lol

0 coins

Three job search activities every week while enrolled and you haven't missed a weekly certification — you're doing everything right. The notice might just be NYSDOL verifying your situation proactively rather than actually planning to cut you off. Some claims get reviewed mid-stream when new information comes in. It doesn't always mean bad news.

0 coins

Fingers crossed that's all it is. The letter wording was vague enough that I couldn't tell if it was routine or serious.

0 coins

Vague letters are frustrating but honestly pretty standard — NYSDOL sends the same templated language for routine checks and actual issues. Speaking to an agent will tell you in five minutes what a letter can't.

0 coins

i went through adjudication for the able and available thing and mine took 6 weeks to resolve. six WEEKS with nothing deposited. Had to borrow money from family. All because I told them I was taking an online course. the system is so broken

0 coins

Six weeks with no payment is terrifying. Did they pay everything back once it was resolved?

0 coins

They did pay the back weeks eventually but the stress during those six weeks was awful. I called every few days and kept getting told it was "in process.

0 coins

My adjudication was similar — the back pay came through in one lump sum but the waiting period is genuinely rough. Hope OP avoids going into full adjudication.

0 coins

My supervisor at a career center used to say that the "approved training" designation is underutilized — a lot of people who would qualify for it don't know to ask. If your program is at a community college and relates to your prior work, you have a good shot at getting it approved, which essentially protects your claim during enrollment instead of leaving it in a gray area.

0 coins

How do you actually apply for the approved training designation? Is there a specific form or do I ask the career center?

0 coins

Your best path is to ask your NYSDOL career center directly — they can review your program and submit the recommendation. You can also ask the community college's financial aid or career services office, some of them have dealt with this before.

0 coins

Approved training applications do go through the career center in most cases. The OP should bring documentation of their program, the course schedule, and their prior employment history to show the connection.

0 coins

After spending an entire morning redialing NYSDOL and getting nowhere, I finally heard about Claimyr from someone in a Facebook group. Ended up talking to an agent at NYSDOL the same afternoon after Claimyr handled all the hold time for me. For anyone with an open able-and-available review, speaking directly to an agent really can make the difference versus waiting for a decision that might go wrong.

0 coins

NYSDOL's phone situation is genuinely awful. Good to know there are options.

0 coins

Okay seriously considering this now. Getting on the phone with an actual person before my adjudication goes any further sounds like the right move.

0 coins

Your instinct is right — the sooner you talk to someone the better. These things can snowball if left unaddressed.

0 coins

From a process standpoint, the able-and-available issue in New York comes down to a pretty simple test that NYSDOL applies: are you ready to accept suitable full-time work immediately if offered? If yes, and your school schedule doesn't interfere with that, you should be fine explaining your situation. The adjudication process, if it goes that far, will ask you to describe your schedule and confirm your availability. Having your class schedule in writing and a statement that you'd leave the program for a full-time job is exactly what they want to see.

0 coins

Written documentation of my schedule — good idea. I'll print that out from the college portal and have it ready.

0 coins

Your college's registrar can also provide an enrollment verification letter that lists your credit hours and meeting times. That's the most official version and sometimes carries more weight.

0 coins

This is solid advice. Having paper documentation ready before the call or any adjudication interview makes the whole thing go faster.

0 coins

My experience with Claimyr sorted out a similar situation. Had a flag on my claim, couldn't get through to anyone, and after using Claimyr I actually had a conversation with an NYSDOL agent who explained exactly what I needed to submit. The hold time was completely out of my hands and I didn't have to sit there waiting.

0 coins

Sitting on hold for hours just to get disconnected is one of the most demoralizing experiences. Sounds like a good option.

0 coins

Heard enough good things in this thread — going to try it this week. Need to get ahead of this before it becomes a bigger problem.

0 coins

Two things that helped me when I had an availability issue on my claim: first, I kept filing my weekly certifications the whole time even when in adjudication — if you stop filing you lose those weeks and they don't pay them back. Second, I documented every job search activity with a screenshot or email confirmation so there was no question about my compliance.

0 coins

Already keeping up with the weekly filings — good to know I should definitely not stop. The documentation tip is great too.

0 coins

Your weekly filings are your lifeline during any review period. Missing even one can complicate the back payment if you're approved.

0 coins

This is really important. NYSDOL can deny back pay for weeks you didn't certify, even if you were otherwise eligible. Keep filing no matter what.

0 coins

Claimyr is the reason I actually got my adjudication resolved before it dragged on for months. Reached a live NYSDOL agent the day I used it, explained my school situation in about ten minutes, and they made a note on my file right then. Didn't get a formal decision for a few more days but the agent told me what to expect.

0 coins

Ten minutes to explain and have it noted on your file sounds so much better than waiting weeks for a letter. That's the kind of outcome I'm hoping for.

0 coins

My case probably would have sat in a queue for weeks otherwise. The difference between having an agent aware of your situation versus just being a number in adjudication is huge.

0 coins

Having a human aware of your specific circumstances really does seem to speed things up. The agents I've spoken to have always been much more helpful than the letters suggest they'll be.

0 coins

New York UI rules have a specific carve-out that many people don't know about — if NYSDOL itself or the Career Center refers you to a training program, your availability requirements are automatically waived for the duration. It's different from self-enrolling like the OP did, but worth knowing for anyone reading this who's considering training.

0 coins

Your point about NYSDOL-referred training is accurate and important. If the OP's career center had any role in pointing them toward this program, that's worth mentioning during the review.

0 coins

Mine was my own decision, the career center didn't suggest it. But I'll mention that I told my career center about it afterward and they seemed supportive.

0 coins

Your career center's support of the program even after the fact could be useful — if they'd endorse it formally as job-related training that could help with the approved training designation application.

0 coins

the whole able and available system seems designed to confuse people into giving up their benefits tbh. like the letters are intentionally vague and you cant get anyone on the phone and then they wonder why adjudication backlogs are so long

0 coins

Absolutely this. The letter I got had three different possible interpretations and nothing that told me what I actually needed to do next.

0 coins

My letter was the same. Had to come to forums like this just to figure out the basics.

0 coins

Worth knowing for future weekly certifications: there's a question on the form that asks whether you were enrolled in school or training during the week. Answer it honestly. NYSDOL isn't trying to trick you with that question — they're using it to route claims to the right review process. Answering no when you are enrolled creates a bigger problem than whatever the original school situation would have been.

0 coins

Had been answering that question honestly every week. Good to know that's the right call even though it triggered the review.

0 coins

Your honest answers actually protect you here — if they check back and your answers match your enrollment records, it shows you weren't hiding anything.

0 coins

wait thats actually a question on the weekly form?? i dont think ive been reading those carefully enough

0 coins

My resolution timeline after the able-and-available review was pretty fast once I had documentation in place. About 10 days from the call to a decision showing up in my Unemployment Services account. The agent told me during the call that it would go to a reviewer but that my explanation sounded consistent with the eligibility rules. That gave me a little peace of mind during the wait.

0 coins

Ten days is totally manageable. The uncertainty is what's killing me more than anything.

0 coins

My biggest advice is just don't sit on it — the longer you wait to respond to that notice the worse the timeline gets. Get on the phone as soon as you can.

0 coins

Final practical point for anyone in this situation: if your able-and-available adjudication results in a disqualification you disagree with, you have 30 days from the mailing date of the determination letter to file an appeal. The appeal goes to an Administrative Law Judge and you can present documentation and testimony. Win rates for people who actually show up with documentation are pretty solid, so don't treat a disqualification as the end of the road.

0 coins

30 days for the appeal — writing that down. Hoping I don't need it but good to know the safety net exists.

0 coins

Appeals are genuinely worth pursuing if you have documentation. The ALJ hearings are less formal than people expect and the judges are used to hearing from pro se claimants.

0 coins

Two people I know won their appeals. Showed up with their schedules printed out and a letter from their employer confirming they were available. Don't give up after a denial.

0 coins

Related posts

New York Unemployment AI

Expert Assistant
Secure