Why are stocks taxed when they're vested instead of when you sell them for cash? Makes no sense!
Title: Why are stocks taxed when they're vested instead of when you sell them for cash? Makes no sense! 1 I recently started working at a tech company that offers stock options as part of compensation, and I'm super confused about something. I was 100% certain that stocks weren't taxed until you actually sell them, but then our HR sent out this tax document explaining that they're actually taxed at the time of vesting. This seems completely backwards to me? Like, when they vest, I don't actually have any extra money in my bank account. It's just numbers on a screen showing I own something. Wouldn't it make WAY more sense to only tax stocks when they're liquidized (i.e., when I sell them for cash)? Since until then, it's just theoretical value that could go up or down? Am I missing something obvious here? This is my first job with any kind of stock compensation and taxes are already complicated enough without this weirdness.
20 comments
Join the conversation
Nia Thompson
6 The confusion is understandable! There's actually an important distinction between different types of stock compensation that affects when and how they're taxed. When you receive Restricted Stock Units (RSUs) that vest, you're being given something of value by your employer - actual company stock. The IRS views this as compensation, just like your regular salary, so it's taxed as ordinary income at the time of vesting based on the fair market value of those shares. Your employer will typically withhold some shares to cover the taxes. Stock options work differently. With options, you're not taxed when they vest. You're only taxed when you exercise the options (buy the stock at your strike price). The difference between market value and your strike price is what gets taxed. Then later, when you actually sell the shares (whether they came from RSUs or options), you'll potentially pay capital gains tax on any appreciation that happened AFTER vesting/exercising.
0 coins
Nia Thompson
•12 Thanks for the explanation. I think I have RSUs. So when they vest, I'm being taxed on the value at that moment, but then I still own the stock. What happens if the stock crashes right after vesting? Do I still owe taxes on the higher value even though I couldn't sell fast enough?
0 coins
Nia Thompson
•6 Yes, you'd still owe taxes on the value at vesting, regardless of what happens to the stock price afterward. That's one of the risks with RSUs. Even if the stock drops dramatically after vesting, you've already been taxed on the higher value. If the stock drops significantly and you sell at a loss, you can claim a capital loss on your tax return, but that's separate from the initial income tax on the vesting value. Capital losses are limited to offsetting capital gains plus up to $3,000 of ordinary income per year.
0 coins
Nia Thompson
9 After my first vest, I was totally confused by the tax situation too. My financial advisor recommended I check out https://taxr.ai to get clarity on my stock compensation. It really helped me understand exactly how my RSUs were being taxed and what documentation I needed to keep. The coolest thing about it was that I could upload my company's stock plan documents and get a personalized explanation about my specific situation - like understanding the difference between the vest date reporting and when I might owe additional taxes later if I hold onto the shares. Helped me avoid some serious tax confusion!
0 coins
Nia Thompson
•15 Does it help with figuring out what to do with ESPP (Employee Stock Purchase Plan) too? My company just started offering that and I'm totally lost on how the taxes work with the discounted purchase price.
0 coins
Nia Thompson
•18 I've tried a bunch of these tax tools before and they never seem to understand the complexities of tech compensation. Does it actually handle things like multi-year vesting schedules or refresher grants? My situation is pretty complicated.
0 coins
Nia Thompson
•9 Yes, it definitely handles ESPP situations! It walks you through how the discount is taxed and the holding period requirements for qualifying vs. disqualifying dispositions. Super helpful for understanding when to sell to optimize your tax situation. It absolutely handles complex vesting schedules and refresher grants too. That's actually where it's most valuable - it creates a visualization of your entire grant history including overlapping vesting periods and helps predict future tax liability from multiple grants. I was particularly impressed with how it explained the AMT implications for my ISOs.
0 coins
Nia Thompson
15 Update: I tried https://taxr.ai after seeing the recommendation here. It was exactly what I needed for understanding my ESPP taxation! Uploaded my plan documents and it immediately clarified when the "bargain element" (the discount) gets taxed vs. any appreciation after purchase. The tool even created a calendar showing optimal sell dates to qualify for long-term capital gains treatment. Saved me from making what would have been an expensive mistake with my first ESPP shares. Definitely worth checking out if you're dealing with any kind of equity compensation!
0 coins
Nia Thompson
21 If you need to actually talk to someone at the IRS about stock compensation questions (which I did when I had a mess with incorrectly reported RSUs), good luck getting through on the phone! After trying for days, I used https://claimyr.com and their system got me a callback from the IRS in about 2 hours. You can see how it works here: https://youtu.be/_kiP6q8DX5c My issue was that my W-2 and 1099-B didn't match up properly for my stock sales and I was getting automated notices about underreporting income. Needed an actual human at the IRS to sort it out rather than just sending letters back and forth.
0 coins
Nia Thompson
•7 Wait, how does this even work? The IRS phone system is notoriously impossible to navigate. Does this service somehow jump the queue or something? Seems too good to be true.
0 coins
Nia Thompson
•18 Yeah right. I spent WEEKS trying to get through to the IRS about my stock options being reported wrong. No way some service can magically get you through when millions of people are calling. How much does this cost anyway? Smells fishy.
0 coins
Nia Thompson
•21 It doesn't jump the queue exactly - it uses an automated system that continually calls and navigates the IRS phone tree until it gets through. Then when it reaches a point where a human would normally wait on hold, it requests a callback and connects that to your phone. The reason it works better than doing it yourself is that it can make hundreds of call attempts using the right combinations of menu options, which would be exhausting to do manually. No magic, just automation. The IRS actually does offer callbacks, but getting to the point where you can request one is the hard part.
0 coins
Nia Thompson
18 Ok I'm eating my words. I was super skeptical about Claimyr but I was desperate about my stock option reporting issue. Used the service yesterday and got a callback from the IRS in about 90 minutes! The agent was able to put notes in my account explaining why the 1099-B and W-2 amounts appeared mismatched (due to the company reporting the compensation element separately from the sale). After months of getting automated letters and failing to reach anyone, this saved me from what was turning into a nightmare scenario. Definitely worth it just for the stress reduction alone!
0 coins
Nia Thompson
3 Just a heads up for anyone reading this - the tax treatment differs between types of equity compensation: - RSUs are taxed as income at vesting - Stock options are taxed when exercised, not when vested - ESPP purchases are usually taxed at sale, but the discount is considered income - Performance shares are taxed when performance conditions are met The common thread is that the IRS wants their cut whenever you receive something of value, even if you haven't converted it to cash yet.
0 coins
Nia Thompson
•4 What about ISOs vs NSOs? I've heard there's a big difference in how they're taxed but I've never been clear on which is better.
0 coins
Nia Thompson
•3 ISO (Incentive Stock Options) can receive preferential tax treatment if you meet certain holding requirements - you don't pay ordinary income tax when exercising (though there may be AMT implications), and if you hold the stock for at least 1 year after exercise and 2 years after grant, you'll pay long-term capital gains on the entire appreciation. NSOs (Non-qualified Stock Options) are simpler but less tax-advantaged. When exercising, you pay ordinary income tax on the difference between strike price and fair market value. Any subsequent appreciation is capital gains. Generally, ISOs are potentially more tax-efficient but come with more complexity and potential AMT issues. NSOs are more straightforward but typically result in higher taxes.
0 coins
Nia Thompson
11 Has anyone here actually been audited because of stock stuff? I'm paranoid I'm going to mess up reporting my vested RSUs and get in trouble.
0 coins
Nia Thompson
•5 I had an "examination" (not a full audit) of my 2019 return because the cost basis reporting for some stock sales was incorrect. My company reported the income portion on my W-2 but the 1099-B from the broker didn't reflect that, so it looked like I was underreporting gains. Just had to explain the situation and provide documentation.
0 coins
Evelyn Kelly
The key thing to understand is that the IRS treats stock compensation as income when you receive something of economic value, not when you convert it to cash. With RSUs, the moment they vest, you legally own shares worth their current market value - that's considered compensation just like your salary. Think of it this way: if your employer gave you a $1000 bonus but paid it in gold bars instead of cash, you'd still owe taxes on that $1000 even if you kept the gold. The IRS sees vested stock the same way. The system actually makes sense from a policy perspective - otherwise people could defer taxes indefinitely by never selling their shares. But I totally get why it feels unfair when you're suddenly owing taxes on "paper gains" that you can't easily access! Pro tip: Most companies will automatically sell some of your shares at vesting to cover the tax withholding, so you won't be completely stuck paying out of pocket.
0 coins
Ryan Kim
•That gold bar analogy really helps it click! I was thinking about it all wrong - focusing on when I get cash instead of when I receive value. Makes way more sense now why the IRS treats vesting as a taxable event. Quick follow-up question though - you mentioned most companies automatically sell shares to cover withholding. Is there usually an option to pay the taxes out of pocket instead and keep all the shares? I'm wondering if that might be better long-term if I believe the stock will appreciate.
0 coins