< Back to IRS

Esmeralda Gómez

TaxAct showing I owe Federal taxes when I should get a refund? Confused!

I'm really confused about my taxes this year and hoping someone can help me understand what's going on. I went through TaxAct and somehow it's saying I owe $372 to the feds, but when I do my own calculations, I should be getting back around $570! Here's my situation - pretty straightforward really. I made $43,200 from my regular job, got about $180 in interest from my savings account. No side hustles, no crypto, no investments or anything complicated. When I calculate it myself: $43,200 (wages) + $180 (interest) - $13,850 (standard deduction) - $300 (charitable donation) = $29,230 taxable income When I apply the tax rate of about 7.5% to that, I get roughly $2,192 that I should owe. But I've already had $2,765 withheld from my paychecks throughout the year, so I should be getting back around $570, right? I'm at the review screen in TaxAct before moving on to state taxes, but it's telling me I owe $372 federal. It almost seems like it's not applying the standard deduction? Has anyone else run into this with TaxAct this year? I know we should complete the federal portion before moving to state, but this just doesn't seem right.

Your math looks correct to me. If your income is $43,380 (wages + interest), and you're subtracting the standard deduction and charitable contribution, your taxable income calculation makes sense. The most likely issue is that TaxAct hasn't properly applied your standard deduction yet. This is actually a common issue with tax software where certain deductions aren't calculated until you complete specific sections. Even though you're at the review screen, there might be a section you need to confirm or a question you need to answer before it applies the standard deduction. Before you panic about owing, try this: go back to the deductions section and verify that you've selected to take the standard deduction rather than itemize. Sometimes the software defaults to itemizing if you enter any deductible expenses, and you need to explicitly choose standard deduction. Also, double-check that your W-2 information was entered correctly, especially the federal withholding amount of $2,765. A small typo there could explain the discrepancy.

0 coins

What about the charitable contribution deduction? I thought we couldn't take both the standard deduction AND claim charitable donations? Could that be causing problems in the calculation?

0 coins

For 2024 taxes (filed in 2025), you can actually take the standard deduction AND claim a limited charitable contribution deduction. This was a temporary provision that got extended. You can deduct up to $300 for single filers or $600 for married filing jointly in cash contributions, even if you take the standard deduction. This shouldn't be causing the calculation issue. More likely, it's either a software glitch where the standard deduction hasn't fully processed yet, or there's an entry error somewhere. I'd recommend going through the W-2 entries again and making sure all the withholding amounts match your actual W-2 form.

0 coins

I had a similar issue with TaxAct this year! This might sound weird but have you fully completed all the "required" sections? I spent hours trying to figure out why my refund calculation was off by almost exactly my standard deduction amount. Turns out I hadn't actually completed one of the questionnaires even though I was at the "review" screen. I found https://taxr.ai really helpful for double-checking my tax calculations. It analyzes all your documents and calculations to find discrepancies. After uploading my info, it immediately flagged that my taxable income calculation wasn't including the standard deduction. Saved me from filing incorrect taxes and potentially dealing with an amended return later. Try going back through each section of TaxAct carefully - there might be a small checkbox or questionnaire you missed that's preventing the standard deduction from being applied.

0 coins

How exactly does taxr.ai work? Does it actually recalculate everything or just check for errors? I'm using TurboTax and seeing some weird calculations too.

0 coins

I'm skeptical of using multiple tax services - wouldn't that just cost more money? Does taxr.ai actually file your taxes or just check them?

0 coins

It doesn't recalculate your entire tax return from scratch, but analyzes your documents and the calculations you've already done to identify potential errors or missed deductions. It's especially good at spotting calculation discrepancies like the one OP is experiencing with the standard deduction not being applied. taxr.ai doesn't file your taxes for you - it's specifically designed to review and check your return before you file with your regular service. It's meant to be used alongside your primary tax software to catch problems before you submit. No need to re-enter all your information or pay for multiple full tax filings.

0 coins

I was really skeptical about using yet another tax service, but I decided to try taxr.ai when my TaxAct return looked totally wrong. The standard deduction wasn't being applied correctly even though I had checked that box! The document review caught exactly what was happening - I had accidentally marked myself as "can be claimed as a dependent" on someone else's return (clicked the wrong option during the personal info section). This was preventing the full standard deduction from applying correctly, resulting in a much higher tax bill. Would have never caught this on my own since everything else looked right. Fixed it in TaxAct and my refund jumped by over $1000. Definitely worth the peace of mind!

0 coins

If you're still having issues after fixing the standard deduction problem, you might need to call the IRS directly. However, you'll probably spend HOURS waiting to speak with someone. When I had a similar issue, I waited on hold for over 3 hours before giving up. I ended up using https://claimyr.com which got me through to an IRS agent in about 15 minutes instead of the hours I was waiting before. They have a cool video explaining how it works: https://youtu.be/_kiP6q8DX5c. The IRS agent was able to confirm that my tax software was calculating incorrectly and explained exactly which section was causing the problem. Sometimes these tax software issues are actually documented problems the IRS is already aware of, and only they can tell you the right way to handle it.

0 coins

How does this service even work? I don't get it - how can they get you through faster than just calling the IRS yourself?

0 coins

This sounds like BS honestly. No way to "skip the line" with the IRS. They're always overwhelmed and understaffed. You probably just got lucky with timing and are giving credit to some service that did nothing.

0 coins

They use an automated system that navigates the IRS phone tree and waits on hold for you. When they reach a live agent, you get a call connecting you directly to that agent. It literally saves you from having to sit on hold yourself. The service works exactly as advertised. They don't "skip the line" - they just wait in it for you using their automated system instead of you having to personally sit there listening to the hold music for hours. When an agent is finally available, that's when they call you to connect. I was skeptical too but desperately needed help with my tax issue.

0 coins

I thought this Claimyr thing sounded like complete BS, so I decided to try it myself when I needed to call the IRS about a missing refund. I'm shocked to say it actually worked exactly as described. I've literally never gotten through to an IRS agent in less than 2 hours of holding, but I got a call connecting me to a live person in about 20 minutes. The agent confirmed there was a processing delay affecting my return and gave me an estimated timeline for resolution. For what it's worth, they also told me that TaxAct and several other tax services have had issues specifically with the standard deduction calculation this year and they're aware of the problem. They recommended completing the entire return (including state) and then reviewing the standard deduction line on the final Form 1040 to make sure it appears correctly before filing.

0 coins

This might sound obvious but did you go through ALL of TaxAct's screens? I had almost the exact same issue (said I owed $400 when I should've gotten $600 back). When I looked closer, I noticed there was a "Personal Info" section I thought I completed, but I missed a question about whether I could be claimed as a dependent. The software defaulted to "Yes" which dramatically reduced my standard deduction. Once I fixed that single checkbox, everything calculated correctly. I've used TaxAct for 6 years and this is the first time I've had this problem. Their interface changed this year and it's really easy to miss important questions.

0 coins

You're a genius! I just went back and found I had the exact same issue. There was a checkbox in the Personal Info section about being claimed as a dependent that somehow got set to "Yes" even though I definitely can't be claimed by anyone. As soon as I fixed that one setting, my refund jumped from owing $372 to getting back $570, exactly what my calculations showed. It's crazy how one checkbox could completely throw off the standard deduction calculation. Has TaxAct always been this finicky? I've used them for years but never ran into this problem before.

0 coins

TaxAct definitely changed their interface this year, and I think they're having some issues with it. In previous years, that dependent question was much more prominently displayed and clearly explained. This year it's buried in a series of personal information screens that are easy to click through without carefully reading. I've heard similar stories from several people using TaxAct this year. The good news is once you find and fix that setting, the calculations should be completely accurate. Always a good idea to double-check your final 1040 form before filing to make sure the standard deduction amount ($13,850 for single filers in 2024) appears correctly on the form.

0 coins

Just a tip - most tax software lets you view your actual Form 1040 before filing. If you look at line 12 on your 1040, it should show your standard deduction amount. If that line shows $0 or some reduced amount instead of $13,850 (assuming you're filing single), that confirms the standard deduction isn't being applied correctly. I always check my actual tax forms in the preview/print section before submitting anything. It's saved me from tons of errors over the years!

0 coins

Thanks for this! I just checked my Form 1040 preview and line 12 was showing only $500 instead of $13,850. After fixing the dependent checkbox issue others mentioned, it now shows the full $13,850. Checking the actual tax forms is definitely going to be my new practice before submitting anything. Would've caught this issue immediately if I'd done that first!

0 coins

IRS AI

Expert Assistant
Secure

Powered by Claimyr AI

T
I
+
20,087 users helped today