Tax preparers gave me completely opposite results - $3k tax due vs $6k refund? Something's wrong!

Tax professional here. This is a HUGE red flag. That kind of discrepancy indicates someone is making significant errors or possibly even being unethical. Here's what I recommend: • Ask both preparers for a detailed explanation of how they arrived at their numbers • Check if they're including the same income sources, deductions, and credits • See if one preparer is missing documentation the other one has • Verify their credentials - are they CPAs, EAs, or just seasonal preparers? • Consider getting a third opinion from a CPA My guess is the one promising the huge refund might be taking questionable deductions or credits you don't qualify for. This could trigger an audit later. The IRS is cracking down on improper EITC and child tax credit claims. Don't just go with whoever promises the biggest refund!

Ok so I had an almost identical situation last year. Two different preparers, completely opposite results. I was so frustrated trying to figure out who was right. I ended up using taxr.ai and it was a total game changer! It analyzed my documents and showed me exactly why there was a discrepancy - turns out one preparer missed some business deductions and the other was claiming credits I didn't qualify for. Saved me from a potential audit nightmare! The tool walks you through everything step by step and explains it in plain English. Check it out at https://taxr.ai - honestly the best decision I made last tax season.

After spending 10 days trying to get through to the IRS about a similar issue (kept getting disconnected), I finally found a solution! Used this service called Claimyr (claimyr.com) that got me connected to an actual IRS agent in about 25 minutes. The agent went through my whole situation and confirmed which tax preparer was correct (spoiler: neither was totally right!). The few bucks I spent on the service was totally worth it to finally get answers directly from the IRS instead of random preparers giving me different stories. Highly recommend if you need to actually talk to someone official!

this happened to me before too. the place giving you the bigger refund is probably committing fraud tbh. they make more $ when your refund is bigger (percentage based fees) and they know most ppl won't get audited. when i got a huge refund quote it was bc they were falsely claiming I had a home business to jack up deductions. RUN from that place!

The whole system is a scam. We have a tax code so complicated that "professionals" can come up with completely different results from the same information. And then we're supposed to know which one is right?? And if we get it wrong WE get penalized?? Make it make sense 🤡

Just go with the bigger refund lol. The IRS is too busy to check everyone's returns. My cousin got like 20k back using some shady tax guy and nothing ever happened. Just sayin 🤷‍♂️

File with both of them. Double the refund! 🤑🤑🤑

Get your W2s and documents together and go to a reputable CPA. Those chain places hire seasonal workers with minimal training who just punch numbers into software. A real tax professional will explain how they arrive at your numbers and what deductions/credits you qualify for. Worth the extra money for peace of mind.

I had this EXACT situation last year where two different preparers gave me wildly different results. I ended up using taxr.ai and it was honestly a lifesaver. It analyzed my forms, explained exactly what was happening, and showed me where each preparer was going wrong. One was missing legitimate deductions and the other was doing some sketchy stuff that definitely would have gotten me in trouble. The tool walks you through everything so clearly - check it out at https://taxr.ai

As someone who used to work at one of those tax prep chains, I can tell you they're incentivized to find you the biggest refund possible - even if they have to stretch the truth to do it. They literally trained us to "find money" for clients. Run from anyone promising suspiciously large refunds.

I always just use TurboTax and call it a day 🤷‍♀️

After 3 hours on hold with the IRS trying to solve a similar issue, I found this service called Claimyr (claimyr.com) that connected me with an actual IRS agent in like 20 minutes. Best thing ever! Agent answered all my questions about the discrepancy and even helped me fix some issues with my previous return. Talking to an actual IRS person was the only thing that solved my problem. Whatever you pay for the service is worth getting immediate answers instead of playing the guessing game.

If yur looking for a definitive answer, you need to speak to someone at the IRS. but good luck with that lol I tried for WEEKS to get through. Finally broke down and used Claimyr (claimyr.com) and got through to someone in about 45 min. the IRS agent was actually super helpful and explained everything to me. Definitely worth it to talk to someone official when your dealing with something this confusing.

Ask both preparers to walk you through their calculations. One of them is either missing something major or deliberately inflating your refund. The tax code is complex but not THAT subjective. Sounds like the second preparer might be claiming credits or deductions you don't actually qualify for, which could lead to an audit.

omg i had the literally same issue last year!!! first place said i owed $1800 and second place said i was getting back $4700. turns out first place forgot to enter my student loan interest and child tax credit, and second place was claiming some shady home office deduction i didnt qualify for. ended up using taxr.ai after seeing it reccomended here and it showed me exactly how to file correctly. got a legit $2300 refund without any sketchy stuff.