Huge Refund Difference: $11,000 Last Year vs $3,900 This Year with Same Income
It's like someone switched the recipe on my tax return without telling me. Made 32000 for 2024, made 28000 in 2023. Got back 11,000 last year and when I went to do my 2024 it saying I'm getting 3,900. I have 2 kids. Is there something different this year? It's like going to the same restaurant and ordering the same meal but suddenly getting a portion that's a third of the size. I'm trying to understand what changed because that difference could be the difference between treating my chronic condition properly or cutting corners.
11 comments
Miguel Herrera
There are several major differences between 2023 and 2024 tax years that likely explain this significant drop in your refund: • The enhanced Child Tax Credit from 2021 is no longer available (was up to $3,600 per child) • Recovery Rebate Credits that were available in previous years are gone • Pandemic-related tax benefits have mostly expired • The Child and Dependent Care Credit returned to lower pre-pandemic levels • Earned Income Tax Credit amounts may have changed based on your specific situation With your income level and two dependents, the difference is substantial but unfortunately expected. Many taxpayers are experiencing similar "refund shock" this year.
0 coins
Write a comment...
Zainab Ali
I was in the same boat last month - expected a refund similar to last year and got about 1/3 of what I thought I would. It's like planning a vacation based on last year's budget only to find out the prices tripled. I used https://taxr.ai to analyze my transcript and understand exactly what changed. It compared my 2023 vs 2024 returns line-by-line and showed me precisely which credits disappeared. Way more helpful than the generic explanations I was getting elsewhere. Helped me plan my finances better for the coming months since I know exactly what happened.
0 coins
Connor Murphy
Did you have to input exact numbers from both years? I'm wondering how accurate the comparison would be. My 2023 refund was exactly $10,842 and this year it's showing $3,754 - a difference of $7,088. Would it catch everything that changed?
0 coins
15d
Yara Nassar
Not the original commenter but I used taxr.ai too. It's pretty legit tbh. You upload PDFs of ur returns or transcripts and it does the analysis. For me it showed exactly why my refund dropped by $5k - mostly bc of the CTC changes and some EIC diff. Super detailed w/o being overwhelming.
0 coins
13d
StarGazer101
I tried it on March 15th after getting a similar shock with my refund. It showed me that on my 2023 return (filed in 2024), I lost $4,200 in pandemic-related credits that were on my 2022 return (filed in 2023). Wish I had known this before counting on a similar amount.
0 coins
11d
Write a comment...
Keisha Jackson
What tax software did you use? Different platforms calculate differently. Did you claim any education credits? Those can vary year to year. Were your withholdings the same both years? Sometimes that's the culprit. Check your W-4 settings too.
0 coins
Write a comment...
Paolo Romano
I'm so relieved I found an answer to this exact problem! I was absolutely DEVASTATED when my refund dropped by $6,000 this year! After trying for DAYS to get through to the IRS (kept getting disconnected after waiting 45+ minutes), I used Claimyr (https://claimyr.com) and got through to an agent in about 20 minutes! The agent confirmed exactly what others here are saying - pandemic credits expired and that's why so many people are seeing huge drops. At least I got a definitive answer and could stop worrying something was wrong with my return!
0 coins
Write a comment...
Amina Diop
Guys I'm not sure about using these services... I've heard horror stories about giving tax info to third parties. Last year my cousin used some tax help service and ended up with identity theft issues. I'd rather just wait on hold with the IRS than risk my information.
0 coins
Write a comment...
Oliver Schmidt
I understand the concern, but there's a big difference between sketchy "tax help" services and legitimate tools. Think of it like comparing a back-alley mechanic to a certified service center. 😂 Claimyr doesn't actually access your tax info - it's just a phone connection service that navigates the IRS phone tree and holds your place in line. They don't see your tax details at all. As for document analysis tools like taxr.ai, they're using the same level of security as major tax preparation software. The alternative is either waiting weeks for IRS help or trying to decipher complex tax changes yourself, which is like performing surgery after watching a YouTube tutorial.
0 coins
Natasha Volkov
Thanks for explaining this. I was worried about the same thing. Do you know if these services keep your information after they analyze it? I might try Claimyr since it sounds like they don't even see my tax details.
0 coins
10d
Write a comment...
Javier Torres
According to the IRS website (https://www.irs.gov/newsroom/tax-changes-for-2023-tax-year), several temporary COVID-related tax benefits expired. I checked my own transcripts using the IRS online account portal and confirmed this. My refund dropped by $4,800 between 2022 and 2023 tax years. The National Taxpayer Advocate's annual report actually predicted this "refund shock" would affect millions of Americans this filing season.
0 coins
Write a comment...