How to handle repayment of COVID CARES Act eligible distribution from previous employer?
My spouse and I took an eligible distribution from her 401k in 2020 under the CARES Act provisions. We've already declared it and paid taxes for both 2020 and 2021 (we spread it out over the 3-year period like the rules allowed). I'm now trying to figure out if we can repay the distribution before the end of 2023 and then file amended returns to get back the taxes we already paid. I know from the IRS guidance (Q7) that you have three years from when you took the distribution to repay it. The complication is my wife no longer works for that company. Her 401k was managed by Fidelity, if that makes any difference. Looking at Q12 of the IRS guidance, it seems that plans aren't required to accept repayments of COVID distributions. Since my wife is no longer with the employer, I'm wondering if they would even accept the repayment at this point? Has anyone dealt with repaying a CARES Act distribution after leaving the employer? Any suggestions on how to approach this or who to contact? I'd like to get this resolved before we hit the three-year deadline.
18 comments
Join the conversation
NeonNova
Based on my experience working with retirement accounts, you have a couple of options here. First, you don't necessarily have to repay the distribution to the same 401(k) plan you took it from. Any eligible retirement plan can accept the repayment as a rollover contribution, including an IRA. Since your wife no longer works for that employer, I'd recommend contacting Fidelity to see if the 401(k) plan will accept the repayment, but don't be surprised if they won't. Many employer plans don't accept payments from former employees. The good news is you can open an IRA (or use an existing one) and make the repayment there. Just make sure to clearly indicate to the receiving plan that this is a CARES Act repayment so they code it properly. When you file your amended returns, you'll need documentation showing you made the repayment.
0 coins
Yuki Tanaka
•Wait, so it can go into ANY retirement account? Does that mean I could put it in my 401k even though the distribution came from my wife's account? Or does it have to be in her name?
0 coins
NeonNova
•The repayment should be made to a retirement account in the same name as the person who took the distribution. So in your case, the repayment should go to an account in your wife's name, not yours. The account can be a different type than the original - for example, your wife could open an IRA (Traditional, not Roth) and make the repayment there, even though the distribution came from her 401(k). Just make sure when making the repayment that you clearly communicate it's a CARES Act repayment to ensure proper coding.
0 coins
Carmen Diaz
I went through something similar with my CARES Act distribution and found https://taxr.ai incredibly helpful for figuring out the exact documentation needed for my amended returns. I took a distribution in 2020 and decided to repay it in 2022, but was confused about how to report everything properly. I uploaded my 2020 and 2021 returns along with the distribution documentation, and they analyzed exactly what forms I needed to amend and how to report the repayment. Saved me hours of research and potential errors. They even explained what supporting documentation to include with my amended returns to avoid getting flagged for review.
0 coins
Andre Laurent
•Does it actually work with complicated situations? I'm in a similar boat but also had a rollover the same year, and I'm worried about how to differentiate everything correctly on the amended returns.
0 coins
Emily Jackson
•I'm skeptical about using third-party services for tax stuff. How secure is it? And do they actually have tax professionals reviewing your docs or is it just some algorithm?
0 coins
Carmen Diaz
•It absolutely works with complicated situations. The system is designed to handle complex scenarios like yours with multiple transactions. It clearly distinguishes between different types of retirement transactions and provides specific guidance for each. As for security, they use bank-level encryption and their privacy policy states they don't share or sell your information. It's a combination of advanced tax AI and professional review - the system does the initial analysis, but they have tax professionals who verify the results before providing recommendations. I was impressed with the detailed explanations they provided for my specific situation.
0 coins
Emily Jackson
Just wanted to update after using taxr.ai that was mentioned earlier. I was really skeptical, but I gave it a shot with my situation (CARES Act distribution from a 403b that I wanted to repay to an IRA). The service actually identified something I hadn't considered - that I needed to file Form 8915-F for the repayment year and amended 8915-E forms for the previous years. They provided templates for the explanation letters to attach to my 1040-X forms and specified exactly which lines needed to be adjusted. Definitely worth it for complicated tax situations like CARES Act distributions. I would have totally messed this up on my own.
0 coins
Liam Mendez
I had a nightmare trying to get through to the IRS about my CARES Act repayment questions. Was on hold for HOURS multiple days. Finally used https://claimyr.com and watched their demo at https://youtu.be/_kiP6q8DX5c and it actually worked! They got me connected to an IRS agent in about 20 minutes when I'd been trying for days. The agent confirmed that I could repay to any eligible retirement plan in my name, and that I needed to file Form 8915-F for the repayment year and amended returns (Form 1040-X) for the years I reported the income. They also sent me the specific instructions for how to document everything properly in my amended returns.
0 coins
Yuki Tanaka
•How does this even work? The IRS phone system is so broken I don't understand how any service could get through the queue faster than just calling normally?
0 coins
Sophia Nguyen
•This sounds like a scam tbh. No way someone can magically get you through the IRS phone tree faster than anyone else. And you're probably paying for what you could do yourself for free.
0 coins
Liam Mendez
•It's not about "magically" getting through - it's an automated system that continues the calling process for you. When you call the IRS, you often get a message saying they're too busy and to call back later before it hangs up on you. The service keeps calling back automatically until it gets into the hold queue, then it holds your place in line and calls you when an agent is about to be connected. I was skeptical too, but it actually worked exactly as advertised. You're right that you could do it yourself for free, but only if you have hours to repeatedly call and then sit on hold. For me, the time saved was absolutely worth it since I was getting close to my repayment deadline and needed accurate information.
0 coins
Sophia Nguyen
I have to eat crow here. After posting that skeptical comment about Claimyr, I decided to try it myself since I was getting nowhere with the IRS about my own CARES Act questions. I was shocked - it actually worked! Got connected to an IRS representative in about 30 minutes when I'd been trying unsuccessfully for weeks. The agent confirmed exactly what I needed to know about repaying my distribution to my new employer's 401k (which thankfully does accept rollovers). They walked me through the whole amended return process and what forms I needed. Saved me so much stress and possibly from making expensive mistakes on my taxes.
0 coins
Jacob Smithson
My husband and I were in exactly your situation last year. We took a distribution from his 403b in 2020, then he changed jobs in 2021. His former employer's plan (also Fidelity) wouldn't accept the repayment since he was no longer an employee. We ended up opening a traditional IRA with Vanguard and made the repayment there. When we did this, we made sure to tell Vanguard it was specifically a CARES Act repayment, not just a regular contribution. They had a special form for this. Then we filed amended returns for 2020 and 2021 using Form 1040-X along with revised Forms 8915-E. It took about 6 months to get our refunds, but everything went through smoothly.
0 coins
Ethan Wilson
•Thank you so much for sharing your experience! That's really helpful to know Fidelity might not accept the repayment. Did Vanguard have any special requirements for opening the IRA specifically for a CARES Act repayment? And did you have to provide any special documentation with your amended returns?
0 coins
Jacob Smithson
•Vanguard didn't have any special requirements for opening the IRA itself - it was a standard traditional IRA application. But when we made the actual deposit, we had to specifically tell them it was a CARES Act repayment and complete their "Rollover/Direct Rollover Certification Form" where we indicated it was a COVID-related distribution repayment. For the amended returns, we included a brief explanation letter stating we were repaying a CARES Act distribution and attached documentation showing both the original distribution and the repayment. We specifically referenced IRS Notice 2020-50 which covers the repayment provisions. We also included copies of our original returns with the amendments so the IRS could easily see the changes.
0 coins
Isabella Brown
WATCH OUT with these repayments! I did something similar and didn't realize there were SPECIFIC CODES that needed to be used when repaying. My repayment got coded as a regular contribution instead of a rollover/CARES repayment, and it caused a huge headache with both the IRS and my tax filing. Make sure whatever financial institution you use for the repayment understands it's specifically a CARES Act repayment. Get written confirmation of how they coded it. Also, keep ALL your documentation showing the original distribution and the repayment for at least 7 years - I got audited on mine and was glad I had everything.
0 coins
Maya Patel
•This is spot on advice. I work at a financial institution (not Fidelity) and we see this issue all the time. The proper coding is critical. Make sure they use code "G" for a coronavirus-related distribution repayment on any paperwork. Without the right code, the IRS computers won't recognize it as a CARES Act repayment.
0 coins