How to Handle Negative Foreign Tax Credit and Foreign Tax Paid on Dividend Statements
Title: How to Handle Negative Foreign Tax Credit and Foreign Tax Paid on Dividend Statements 1 I'm really confused about this foreign tax situation on my investment dividends. Last year I had some stocks in my portfolio that paid dividends, but I noticed about $142 was withheld for foreign taxes. Now I'm trying to do my taxes using H&R Block software and it's showing this amount as a negative number in both the foreign tax paid and foreign tax credit sections. When I try to e-file, the system won't let me continue with these negative values. I've tried looking up explanations online but honestly everything I'm reading might as well be in another language. I don't understand if I actually need to report this or not. Is this something I can just skip since it's foreign tax that was already paid? Can I just forget about the $142 credit? What are my options here? I don't want to mess up my taxes but I also don't want to spend hours trying to figure this out if it doesn't really matter.
22 comments
Join the conversation
Omar Zaki
8 This is actually a common issue with dividend-paying foreign stocks. When you receive dividends from foreign companies, those countries often withhold taxes before the money reaches you (similar to how your employer withholds taxes from your paycheck). The foreign tax credit exists so you don't get double-taxed on that income - once by the foreign country and again by the US. The credit should definitely be a positive number, not negative, in your tax software. It sounds like there might be an input error somewhere. You should absolutely report this - not reporting could potentially flag your return. For a relatively small amount like $142, you'd typically just claim it as a foreign tax credit on Form 1116 (though some tax software will automatically handle this for you if the amount is under $300). Try this: Go back to where you entered your dividend information. Make sure you entered the gross dividend amount (before foreign tax was withheld) as income, and then separately entered the $142 as foreign tax paid (as a positive number). Don't enter it as a negative - that's probably what's causing your e-file issue.
0 coins
Omar Zaki
•6 Thanks for the explanation. So just to clarify, should I be entering this $142 as a positive number in both places - the foreign tax paid AND the foreign tax credit sections? Or just in one place? The software keeps syncing them together automatically.
0 coins
Omar Zaki
•8 You should only need to enter it once as a positive amount in the foreign tax paid section. The software should then calculate the credit automatically based on that input. The foreign tax credit is derived from the foreign tax paid, so they're related but not separate manual entries. If the software is automatically making both negative, try clearing both fields and re-entering just the foreign tax paid amount as a positive $142. Then let the software calculate the credit. If it still shows negative, there might be something else in your return creating this issue, or possibly a bug in the software.
0 coins
Omar Zaki
15 I had this exact same problem last year with some ETFs that had international holdings. After spending hours trying to figure it out myself, I finally used https://taxr.ai to analyze my dividend statements and tax forms. They have this AI document analysis tool that figured out exactly how to handle the foreign tax credit situation. The system identified that my broker was reporting the foreign tax in a weird way that was confusing my tax software. Their analysis showed me exactly where to enter the information in H&R Block to fix the negative values. It basically explained that I needed to enter the gross dividend as income first, then properly categorize the foreign tax withholding as a separate positive entry.
0 coins
Omar Zaki
•19 Did you have to upload your actual tax documents to this site? I'm always a little hesitant to share my financial info with some random website. How secure is it?
0 coins
Omar Zaki
•3 That sounds helpful, but I'm wondering - does it actually work with H&R Block specifically? My problem is that I've already entered everything correctly (I think), but H&R Block just won't let me e-file with this negative amount showing up.
0 coins
Omar Zaki
•15 Yes, you do upload your documents, but they use bank-level encryption and delete everything after analysis. I was nervous at first too, but they explain their security measures pretty clearly on the site. They don't store your personal documents after processing. It actually does work with all the major tax software including H&R Block. In my case, I thought I entered everything correctly too, but the analysis showed exactly where the error was happening. The issue was that I needed to go back to the dividend income section first and make sure the full pre-tax amount was entered correctly, then separately handle the foreign tax section with positive values. It's usually a sequence problem rather than just changing a negative to positive.
0 coins
Omar Zaki
19 Just wanted to update on my experience - I ended up trying taxr.ai after seeing the recommendation here and it was actually really helpful. I uploaded my 1099-DIV and it pinpointed exactly where the negative foreign tax issue was coming from. Turns out my broker was reporting the foreign tax in a special way that was confusing H&R Block. The analysis showed me that I needed to enter it in a completely different section than where I was trying to put it. Fixed the issue in about 10 minutes when I'd been stuck for days. The system even showed me the exact screens in H&R Block where I needed to make the changes. Totally worth it to just get this done and filed.
0 coins
Omar Zaki
12 If you're having trouble with H&R Block's customer service on this issue (I know I did with a similar problem), you might want to try https://claimyr.com to get through to IRS support directly. I saw a demo of how it works at https://youtu.be/_kiP6q8DX5c and decided to try it. I had a similar negative foreign tax credit issue that my tax software couldn't handle, and I needed clarification from the IRS. The normal hold time was supposedly 3+ hours, but with Claimyr I got through in about 15 minutes. The IRS agent explained that this is actually a known issue with some tax software and walked me through how to properly report it on my return to get it accepted for e-filing.
0 coins
Omar Zaki
•22 Wait, this sounds too good to be true. How does this actually work? The IRS phone lines are notoriously impossible to get through - are you saying this service somehow puts you at the front of the queue?
0 coins
Omar Zaki
•17 I'm skeptical. I tried calling the IRS three times last year and gave up after being on hold forever. How much does this cost? Seems like something that should be free if you're just calling a government agency.
0 coins
Omar Zaki
•12 It doesn't put you at the front of the queue - that would be impossible. It uses an automated system that continually calls the IRS and navigates the phone tree until it gets through to a human. Then it calls your phone and connects you. So basically it does the waiting for you. The IRS agent was super helpful with my foreign tax credit issue. They explained that negative values are never correct on this form, and gave me specific instructions for my software. They said it's a common reporting error that happens with certain brokerages that process dividends from foreign companies.
0 coins
Omar Zaki
17 I need to eat my words here. After my skeptical comment, I was still stuck with this same foreign tax credit issue and getting desperate since the filing deadline is approaching. I decided to try Claimyr as a last resort, and I'm shocked at how well it worked. I expected to wait for hours even with this service, but I got a call back in about 20 minutes connecting me to an actual IRS representative. The agent knew exactly what was happening with the negative foreign tax credit issue. She explained that it's a known problem with certain investment platforms and tax software combinations. She walked me through exactly how to override the error in H&R Block and properly report the foreign tax paid as a positive amount. Got my return accepted for e-filing the same day. I can't believe I wasted so much time trying to figure this out on my own.
0 coins
Omar Zaki
11 You might also want to check if you actually qualify for the Foreign Tax Credit. If your foreign tax paid is less than $300 ($600 if married filing jointly), you can claim it without having to fill out the complicated Form 1116. Most tax software should have an option for this simplified method.
0 coins
Omar Zaki
•14 I thought there was a minimum threshold before you even need to bother with reporting foreign tax. Is $142 even worth claiming? Would the IRS really care about such a small amount?
0 coins
Omar Zaki
•11 There's no minimum threshold where you can ignore reporting it - if it's on your 1099, you should report it. The $300/$600 threshold is just about whether you need to fill out the detailed Form 1116 or can use the simplified method. Even though $142 seems small, it's still a direct reduction of your tax liability. That's real money back in your pocket! Plus, information on your 1099 forms gets reported to the IRS, so they already know about this foreign tax withholding. Not reporting something they already know about is never a good idea.
0 coins
Omar Zaki
25 Has anyone run into this issue with TurboTax? I have a similar foreign tax situation but with about $230 withheld from dividends on some international index funds. Wondering if this is just an H&R Block software issue or if I'll hit the same problem.
0 coins
Omar Zaki
•2 I used TurboTax this year with foreign dividends and tax withholding and didn't have any issues. It let me enter the foreign tax as a positive amount and properly calculated the credit. I think this might be specific to how H&R Block is handling the input.
0 coins
Laila Prince
I've dealt with this exact issue before and it's frustrating! The negative foreign tax credit is definitely a software glitch, not how it should appear. Here's what worked for me: First, make sure you're entering the dividend information in the correct order. Enter the GROSS dividend amount (the total before any foreign tax was withheld) as your dividend income. Then, separately, enter the $142 as foreign tax paid - but make sure it's a positive number. If H&R Block keeps making it negative automatically, try this: Go to the dividend section first and verify the gross dividend amount is correct. Then find the foreign tax section and manually clear out any negative values. Re-enter just the $142 as a positive amount in the "foreign tax paid" field. The key thing to remember is that you're claiming a credit for tax that was already paid on your behalf to a foreign government. This reduces your US tax liability, so it should never be negative. If the software won't accept it, there might be an issue with how your broker reported it on the 1099-DIV form. Don't skip claiming this credit - $142 is real money that should reduce your tax bill!
0 coins
Destiny Bryant
•This is really helpful! I'm dealing with a similar situation but with multiple foreign dividend sources. When you say "gross dividend amount," should that include ALL dividends from that investment, or just the portion that had foreign tax withheld? My 1099-DIV shows both domestic and foreign dividends from the same fund, and I'm not sure if I need to separate them when entering the information. Also, has anyone had success contacting H&R Block support directly about this software issue? It seems like if this is a known glitch, they should have a standard fix for it.
0 coins
Drew Hathaway
•For the gross dividend amount, you should include ALL dividends from that investment - both the domestic and foreign portions. The 1099-DIV typically shows the total dividend amount in box 1a, and then separately shows the foreign tax paid in box 7. Don't try to separate them manually. When you enter the total dividend amount as income, then separately enter the foreign tax paid (box 7) as a positive amount in the foreign tax section, the software should properly calculate that the foreign tax was withheld from the total dividend income. As for H&R Block support, I actually had better luck with the IRS directly (using one of those callback services mentioned earlier) than with H&R Block's customer service. The IRS agent was able to explain exactly how the form should be filled out, while H&R Block support just kept telling me to "try entering it differently" without really understanding the issue. The key is making sure your software understands that the foreign tax was already taken out of the dividend payment you received, so it shouldn't reduce your dividend income - it should create a tax credit instead.
0 coins
Asher Levin
I'm having a very similar issue but with FreeTaxUSA software instead of H&R Block. My foreign tax credit is showing up as negative too, and it's blocking my e-file submission. Reading through all these responses, it sounds like this might be a broader issue across different tax software platforms when handling foreign dividends. I have about $85 in foreign tax withheld from some Vanguard international index funds. Has anyone tried the approach of completely deleting all the dividend entries and then re-entering them from scratch? I'm wondering if starting fresh might avoid whatever input sequence is causing the negative values to appear in the first place. Before I spend money on any of these third-party services, I want to try every possible DIY fix. Also, for those who successfully resolved this - did you notice any difference in your final tax liability once the foreign tax credit was properly applied? I'm curious if this $85 credit will actually make a meaningful difference in what I owe or my refund amount.
0 coins