How do non-refundable tax credits work with income tax already withheld by employer in Canada?

Hi everyone, I'm trying to wrap my head around how the Canadian tax system handles non-refundable tax credits when my employer has already withheld income tax from my paychecks. Here's my situation - I've calculated that my total tax obligation for the year would be around $5,800, and looking at my pay stubs, my employer has already withheld exactly that amount throughout the year. The confusing part is that I have about $3,700 in non-refundable tax credits that I can claim this year (disability amount, medical expenses, etc.). What I'm wondering is: does this mean my actual tax owing gets reduced to $2,100 ($5,800 - $3,700), and I'll get a refund of $3,700 since my employer already withheld the full $5,800? Or does the CRA handle this differently? I'm pretty confused about how these non-refundable credits actually work in practice when tax has already been withheld from my paychecks. Any insight would be really appreciated!

0 coins

18 comments

Kylo Ren

•8M

The way non-refundable tax credits work in Canada is that they reduce the amount of tax you owe, but as the name suggests, they can only reduce your tax owing to zero (not below zero to create a refund). In your example, your tax obligation is $5,800 and you have $3,700 in non-refundable credits. This means your actual tax owing is reduced to $2,100. Since your employer already withheld $5,800, you would receive a refund of $3,700 (the difference between what was withheld and what you actually owe after applying the credits). Think of it this way: the withholding from your employer is based on your income without considering these credits. When you file your taxes, the CRA calculates your actual tax owing after applying all eligible credits, then compares that to what was already withheld to determine if you get a refund or owe more.

0 coins

Kylo Ren

•8M

The term "non-refundable" refers to the credit itself, not your overall tax situation. What it means is that these credits can only reduce your tax owing to zero - they can't create a refund by themselves. The refund you're getting is simply because your employer withheld more tax than you ended up owing after applying your credits. The withholding is essentially a pre-payment of your taxes based on your income level, but without accounting for credits you might claim when filing. When your actual tax bill (after credits) is less than what was withheld, you get the difference back as a refund.

0 coins

Jason Brewer

•8M

Just wanted to share my experience with a similar situation. I was struggling with figuring out my taxes with all these credits and found this tool called taxr.ai (https://taxr.ai) that was actually super helpful for understanding how these credits work with withholdings. I uploaded my T4 and other documents, and it explained exactly how my non-refundable credits would apply against the tax I had already paid through employer withholdings. It breaks everything down in plain language instead of CRA jargon. Really helped me understand why I was getting a refund even with "non-refundable" credits.

0 coins

Jason Brewer

•8M

It doesn't file your taxes for you - it's more of an analyzer that helps you understand what's happening with your tax situation. It explains how different parts of your taxes work together, which helped me figure out what I was doing wrong with my credits. For self-employment income, yes it definitely handles that. I actually have some freelance work alongside my main job, and it showed me how my self-employment deductions affected my overall tax picture, including how they interact with those non-refundable credits. Really cleared things up for me.

0 coins

Liam Cortez

•8M

Just wanted to follow up - I checked out taxr.ai after seeing it mentioned here and it was exactly what I needed! I was super confused about how my non-refundable credits were applied when my employer had already withheld taxes, but it walked me through the whole process. It helped me identify about $1,200 in additional credits I wasn't claiming properly before. The explanations were really clear about the difference between withholdings and actual tax owing after credits. Now I understand why they're called "non-refundable" even though I'm getting money back from withholdings!

0 coins

Savannah Vin

•8M

If you're having trouble contacting the CRA to get specific answers about your tax credits, I'd recommend Claimyr (https://claimyr.com). I spent DAYS trying to get through to the CRA about a similar non-refundable tax credit issue, but kept getting disconnected or waiting for hours. Claimyr got me connected to an actual CRA agent in under 15 minutes! You can see how it works in this video: https://youtu.be/_kiP6q8DX5c. The agent was able to explain exactly how my non-refundable credits would be applied against my withholdings and confirmed I was calculating my refund correctly.

0 coins

Savannah Vin

•8M

It uses a system that continuously redials the CRA using multiple lines until it gets through, then transfers the call to you once there's a connection. It's basically doing the waiting and redialing for you, which is why it works faster than doing it yourself. I was skeptical too, but after wasting 3 hours myself trying to get through with no success, it was worth trying. They don't put you in the same queue - they actually get you connected with an agent who's ready to help, then transfer you over. Saved me an entire day of frustration.

0 coins

Makayla Shoemaker

•8M

Well I stand corrected about Claimyr. I tried it yesterday after posting my skeptical comment because I was desperate to talk to the CRA about my non-refundable credits situation. Got connected in about 11 minutes which is honestly unbelievable considering I tried for 2 days on my own. The CRA agent confirmed exactly what others here said - my non-refundable credits reduced my tax owing from $4,200 to $1,800, but since my employer withheld $4,500, I'll get a $2,700 refund. The withholding is separate from how the credits are applied, which finally makes sense to me now.

0 coins

Christian Bierman

•8M

One thing to remember is that if your non-refundable credits exceed your tax payable, you don't get to carry forward the unused portion (with a few exceptions like tuition credits). This is different from refundable credits like GST/HST credits that can actually generate a refund regardless of your tax owing. For example, if your tax owing is $5,800 but you have $7,000 in non-refundable credits, your tax is reduced to $0, but you "lose" the extra $1,200 in credits. This is why they're called "non-refundable" - they can't generate a refund by themselves.

0 coins

Christian Bierman

•8M

That's exactly right. If your tax payable is $5,800 and you have $7,000 in non-refundable credits, you can only use $5,800 of those credits to reduce your tax to zero. The remaining $1,200 in credits is essentially "wasted" (except for specific credits like tuition amounts that can be carried forward). Since your employer withheld $5,800, you would get all of that back as a refund, but not the extra $1,200 in unused credits. That's the key difference between non-refundable and refundable credits - the latter would give you the full value regardless of your tax owing.

0 coins