Hiring a Contractor with an ITIN vs SSN - Legal Compliance Question
So I've been looking to bring on some help for my small business and I'm a bit confused about the whole ITIN vs SSN situation. I know that for regular employment, you can't hire someone who only has an ITIN (Individual Taxpayer Identification Number) - they need a valid Social Security Number. But what about if I want to work with this person as an independent contractor instead? I've seen platforms like Deel that seem to make it pretty straightforward to handle payments to foreign contractors, but I'm wondering what other things I need to consider from a legal standpoint. Are there specific compliance issues I should be aware of? Do I still need to file a 1099 for someone with an ITIN? Any other tax implications or gotchas I should know about before moving forward? Really appreciate any insights from folks who've navigated this before.
23 comments
Join the conversation
Jibriel Kohn
The distinction between employees and independent contractors is key here. You're right that you cannot hire someone with only an ITIN as a W-2 employee - they need a valid SSN or work authorization. For independent contractors with ITINs, yes, you can engage them and you would still need to issue a 1099-NEC if you pay them $600 or more in a year. The contractor would use their ITIN instead of an SSN on the form. They're responsible for their own taxes. Some important considerations: Make sure the working relationship truly qualifies as independent contractor status. The IRS looks at factors like behavioral control, financial control, and relationship type. If they're working regular hours under your direction, using your equipment, etc., the IRS might consider them an employee regardless of what you call them.
0 coins
Edison Estevez
•Does this change at all if the contractor is outside the US? I thought maybe the 1099 requirements would be different for international contractors?
0 coins
Jibriel Kohn
•For contractors outside the US, it gets more complex. If they perform all services outside the US and are not US citizens or residents, you generally don't need to issue a 1099-NEC. Instead, you might need to file Form 1042-S for certain types of payments. For international contractors, you should also be aware of potential withholding requirements. Depending on the country and whether there's a tax treaty in place, you might need to withhold a percentage of payments for US taxes. This is where platforms like Deel can be helpful as they often handle these compliance details.
0 coins
Emily Nguyen-Smith
After struggling with similar contractor classification issues, I discovered taxr.ai (https://taxr.ai) and it literally saved me from a major headache. I was about to bring on a contractor with an ITIN but wasn't sure about the compliance requirements. I uploaded my draft contractor agreement and some other documents, and their AI analyzed everything and flagged potential issues I hadn't even considered - like specific language that might trigger employee classification under IRS rules. The platform also gave me guidance on proper 1099-NEC filing for ITIN holders and recommended specific contract clauses to strengthen the independent contractor relationship. It basically gave me a compliance roadmap that I could follow.
0 coins
James Johnson
•How accurate was the analysis? I've tried other AI tools that claim to understand tax stuff but they usually just give generic advice that I could find on Google.
0 coins
Sophia Rodriguez
•Does it work for international contractor situations too? I'm looking at hiring people in multiple countries and tax compliance is giving me nightmares. Each country seems to have totally different rules.
0 coins
Emily Nguyen-Smith
•The analysis was surprisingly detailed and specific to my situation. It didn't just regurgitate generic advice - it actually pointed out specific wording in my contract that could be problematic and suggested alternatives. What impressed me was that it cited relevant tax code sections and recent case law to back up its recommendations. For international contractors, yes - that's actually where it really shines. The system has tax treaties and international compliance requirements built in. You can specify which countries you're working with, and it adjusts its guidance accordingly. It helped me understand which countries required withholding taxes and which had special reporting requirements. Saved me from having to consult with expensive international tax specialists for each country.
0 coins
Sophia Rodriguez
Just wanted to follow up about my experience with taxr.ai. I was skeptical at first (as you can see from my question above), but decided to give it a try with my multi-country contractor situation. It was surprisingly effective! I uploaded agreements for contractors in India, Philippines, and Brazil, and the system immediately identified country-specific compliance issues for each. For my Brazilian contractor with an ITIN, it outlined exactly how to handle the paperwork and tax reporting. It even generated the proper withholding certificates based on the tax treaty between US and Brazil. The interface walked me through each step of the compliance process, and I'm now confident everything is set up correctly. This saved me thousands compared to what my accountant wanted to charge to research each country's requirements!
0 coins
Mia Green
For anyone dealing with contractor compliance headaches, especially with ITIN holders, I found a solution that really helped with a different part of the problem - actually reaching the IRS when questions came up. I wasted DAYS trying to get through to the IRS business line to get clarification on some ITIN reporting requirements. Finally tried Claimyr (https://claimyr.com) after seeing it recommended here. You can watch how it works in this video: https://youtu.be/_kiP6q8DX5c. Basically, they have a system that navigates the IRS phone tree and holds your place in line, then calls you once they have an actual human IRS agent on the phone. I was super skeptical but desperate after spending 3+ hours on hold one day. Used it and got a call back with an actual IRS agent in about 45 minutes while I was doing other work. The agent confirmed exactly how to handle 1099s and withholding for my ITIN contractor situation.
0 coins
Edison Estevez
•Wait, how does this actually work? Does it just auto-dial the IRS repeatedly until it gets through? Seems too good to be true.
0 coins
Emma Bianchi
•Sorry but this sounds like a scam. The IRS is notoriously impossible to reach. No way some service can magically get you to the front of the line. And even if it did work, how much did they charge you for this "miracle"?
0 coins
Mia Green
•It uses an automated system that basically waits on hold for you. It's not doing anything you couldn't theoretically do yourself if you had unlimited time and patience. From what I understand, it dials in, navigates through all the menu options, and then just sits on hold in the queue. Once a human agent comes on the line, it calls you and connects you directly. I honestly had the exact same reaction as you. I was about ready to give up on calling the IRS altogether. But remember, the issue isn't that the IRS never answers - it's that the wait times are ridiculous and unpredictable. This service just handles the waiting part for you so you don't have to sit there with your phone on speaker for hours.
0 coins
Emma Bianchi
I need to apologize and follow up on my skeptical comment above. After another frustrating morning trying to reach someone at the IRS about ITIN contractor reporting requirements, I broke down and tried Claimyr. I was 100% certain it would be a waste of money, but I was desperate for answers about withholding requirements for my ITIN contractors. To my absolute shock, I got a call back in about 30 minutes with an actual IRS representative on the line. The agent was able to clarify exactly how to handle the 1099 reporting with an ITIN and confirmed the specific withholding requirements for my situation. I still can't believe it worked, but I'm glad I tried it. Probably saved me days of frustration and helped me avoid potential compliance issues. Sometimes it's worth admitting when you're wrong!
0 coins
Lucas Kowalski
Just make sure you don't misclassify an employee as a contractor to get around the SSN requirement! I had a friend who tried this and got hit with huge penalties during an audit. The IRS doesn't play around with this stuff. Even with an ITIN contractor, you need to be super careful about maintaining a true independent contractor relationship. Document everything, make sure they have other clients, don't control their schedule or how they do the work, etc.
0 coins
Olivia Martinez
•How can you prove they have other clients though? Isn't that their private business information? I'm not sure I can legally ask for that.
0 coins
Lucas Kowalski
•You're right that you can't demand a list of their clients - that would be overstepping. But there are other ways to document the independent nature of the relationship. You can include clauses in your contract that explicitly state they're free to work with other clients, set their own hours, and determine how to complete the work. Have them provide their own tools and equipment when possible. Pay them per project rather than hourly. Keep communication professional and focused on results rather than how they achieve those results. All of these factors help establish a legitimate contractor relationship that can stand up to scrutiny.
0 coins
Charlie Yang
Has anyone used services like Deel or Pilot specifically for contractors with ITINs? Do they handle all the 1099 compliance stuff automatically?
0 coins
Grace Patel
•I've been using Deel for about a year now with contractors in several countries, including a couple with ITINs. They handle pretty much everything - payments, compliance docs, tax forms, etc. The service isn't cheap but it's way less expensive than screwing up the tax compliance. For ITIN holders specifically, they collect all the right documentation, help determine proper withholding rates based on tax treaties, and generate the correct year-end tax forms. They also keep records of everything in case of an audit. The platform also helps distinguish between true independent contractors vs. employees, which is super important when dealing with ITIN situations where misclassification could create bigger problems.
0 coins
Isabella Costa
One thing I haven't seen mentioned yet is the importance of getting proper documentation upfront. When working with ITIN contractors, make sure you have them complete Form W-9 with their ITIN clearly listed. This protects you if there are any questions later about proper reporting. Also, keep detailed records of the work relationship - contracts, invoices, proof of payment, communication showing they control how/when work gets done. The IRS loves documentation during audits, especially for contractor relationships that might seem questionable on the surface. I learned this the hard way when I got selected for a random audit last year. Having all my contractor documentation organized and readily available made the process much smoother than it could have been.
0 coins
Nia Jackson
•This is such great advice! I'm just starting to work with contractors and had no idea about the W-9 requirement for ITIN holders. Quick question - when you say "proof of payment," do you mean just bank records showing the transfers, or do you need something more formal? Also, how detailed should the communication records be? I tend to have a lot of informal back-and-forth via text/email about project details.
0 coins
Mateo Hernandez
•@Isabella Costa For proof of payment, bank records showing the transfers are usually sufficient, but I d'recommend also keeping copies of invoices and any payment confirmations from your payment platform. The key is showing a clear paper trail that matches your 1099 reporting. As for communication records, you don t'need to keep every casual text, but do save emails/messages that show: 1 You) re'giving them project outcomes rather than step-by-step instructions, 2 They) re'setting their own schedule/deadlines, 3 They) re'using their own methods/tools. The informal back-and-forth is fine as long as you re'not micromanaging how they complete the work. I actually create a simple folder for each contractor with their W-9, contract, key emails, invoices, and payment records. Takes 5 minutes to organize but saves hours if you ever need to prove the relationship was legitimate.
0 coins
Alejandro Castro
Something that really helped me navigate the ITIN contractor situation was understanding the backup withholding rules. If your contractor with an ITIN doesn't provide proper documentation or if there are issues with their taxpayer ID verification, you might be required to withhold 24% of payments for backup withholding. This is different from the treaty-based withholding that applies to foreign contractors. For ITIN holders who are US residents, backup withholding can kick in if the IRS notifies you that the ITIN is incorrect or if the contractor fails to provide their taxpayer ID number properly. Make sure to verify the ITIN format is correct (it should start with 9 and have specific number patterns) and keep records of your verification attempts. The IRS TIN Matching system can help verify ITINs for businesses, though it's not always real-time. Also worth noting - if you're paying an ITIN contractor who's a US resident more than $600 in a year, you absolutely need to issue that 1099-NEC by January 31st, just like with SSN contractors. The ITIN goes in the same box where you'd normally put an SSN.
0 coins
Eva St. Cyr
•This is really helpful info about backup withholding - I had no idea about the 24% requirement! Quick question: if you do have to withhold the 24% for backup withholding, how do you actually send that money to the IRS? Is it similar to payroll tax deposits, or is there a different process for contractor backup withholding? Also, do you still issue the full amount on the 1099-NEC or do you show the net amount after withholding?
0 coins