Back to IRS

Miguel Diaz

Has anyone used a tax relief solution group to deal with the IRS?

Posting because I'm genuinely at a loss. I owe back taxes for 2023 and 2024 — two separate tax years, two separate balances — and I've been getting CP14 notices for both. I started looking into companies that advertise as a tax relief solution group type of service, the kind that say they negotiate with the IRS on your behalf. But the more I read, the more I wonder if I should just try to handle this directly with the IRS myself instead of paying someone else to do it. Has anyone here dealt with back taxes across multiple years and figured out how to set up a payment plan on their own? Or is there actually a point where hiring outside help makes sense? I'm not in a position to pay both balances in full right now, and I'm worried about penalties and interest piling up while I figure this out.

Two CP14 notices for different years — I had the same situation last fall with a balance from an amended return I'd filed. Claimyr (claimyr.com) sat on hold with 800-829-1040 for me while I did other things, and when the agent picked up I asked about the adjustment shown on my account for 2023. The agent told me the amended return for that year had been fully processed and the adjustment was reflected in the balance on the notice. Claimyr's video on reaching a live person at the IRS: https://youtu.be/_kiP6q8DX5c. What the agent explained about installment agreements: if everything you owe combined — tax, penalties, interest — is under $50,000 and you've filed all your returns, you can apply online without anyone else involved. The IRS's payment plan application is in the online account at https://www.irs.gov/your-account. I set up my own long-term plan in about 15 minutes once I had the agent confirm what was actually on record.

0 coins

The $50,000 threshold — does that apply to each year separately, or is it the total across all years combined? Because the original poster has two open years.

0 coins

The threshold is the total across all open years added together, not each one on its own. So if the two CP14 balances together with penalties and interest are under $50,000 and all returns are filed, the online application covers it.

0 coins

I didn't realize you could apply for the plan online without calling at all. I assumed you had to go through a representative or mail in Form 9465.

0 coins

Form 9465 is still an option if someone can't use the online route, but the online account is faster. The online tool covers both short-term and long-term plans depending on how quickly you can pay.

0 coins

Those tax relief companies worry me a little — a lot of them charge fees upfront that can run into hundreds or more, and in many cases the IRS gives you the same options directly for free. The online installment agreement is literally the same thing they'd set up for you, just without the middleman.

0 coins

That's what I keep reading. My concern is whether the IRS will actually work with me if I approach them directly, or if I need someone experienced to 'negotiate.' Do they actually reduce the principal?

0 coins

The IRS doesn't reduce the base tax you owe just because someone asks nicely, whether it's you or a company. What can sometimes happen is a penalty being reduced or removed if there's reasonable cause — but no one, not a tax relief firm or anyone else, can promise that ahead of time. The IRS decides.

0 coins

I had a penalty on a 2022 balance and asked about it directly when I called the IRS. They told me to write to the address on the notice explaining my situation. It didn't get removed automatically but at least I knew what to do.

0 coins

Dealing with two open years at once sounds stressful. When I had a balance from 2022, the first thing the IRS agent I reached asked was whether I'd filed everything owed — because a plan isn't available if there are unfiled returns. Worth double-checking that both 2023 and 2024 returns are submitted before applying.

0 coins

Both returns are filed, that's the one thing I did right. The issue was just not having enough set aside when I filed.

0 coins

Filing even when you can't pay is exactly right — the IRS says to do it that way because the failure-to-file penalty is separate from the failure-to-pay penalty, and filing stops the first one from running.

0 coins

Exactly. A lot of people hold the return thinking it'll delay things, but it actually makes the total owed grow faster.

0 coins

Have you looked at whether a short-term plan makes sense before committing to a long-term installment agreement? If you can pay both balances within 180 days, the short-term plan doesn't involve a setup process — you just pay before the deadline and the IRS considers it resolved.

0 coins

I wish. The combined total is not something I can clear in six months. It's going to need to be monthly payments for a while.

0 coins

Then a long-term plan is the right path. The key thing to remember is that interest and penalties keep accruing until the full balance is paid — but having a plan in place keeps the IRS from taking collection action while you're in it.

0 coins

Is there a minimum monthly payment the IRS requires, or do you pick the amount?

0 coins

The IRS divides what you owe by 72 months to get a minimum monthly figure when you apply online. You can pay more than that minimum anytime, which reduces the total interest you'll pay over time.

0 coins

I tried the online account to set up my plan earlier this year and it went fine, but I want to flag something: once you're in a plan, you have to keep filing every future return on time. If you miss a future filing deadline while on a payment plan, the IRS can default the plan.

0 coins

Good to know — I hadn't thought about the ongoing filing obligation. So the plan has conditions beyond just making the monthly payments.

0 coins

Right. File on time, pay the minimum each month, and any refund from a future return gets applied to the balance. Those are the main conditions to stay current.

0 coins

Future refunds being applied to the balance surprised me when I first learned it. I thought I'd get the refund as normal but it goes toward what I owe first.

0 coins

Honestly I've been down the road of one of those tax relief groups — not going to name them but I paid a significant retainer and they basically sent the same Form 9465 I could have submitted myself. After three months I had the same installment agreement I could have set up online for free. Really wish I had just done it myself.

0 coins

This is exactly what I was afraid of hearing. Did they at least get you a better monthly amount than you'd have gotten on your own?

0 coins

No, the amount was the same formula the IRS uses. The only thing they did that I genuinely couldn't have done alone was help me pull together old records for the years I'd fallen behind on. If your returns are already filed, you probably don't need them.

0 coins

There are legitimate tax professionals — enrolled agents and CPAs — who specialize in IRS matters and charge by the hour rather than a big upfront retainer. That's a different thing from the TV-advertised relief companies.

0 coins

WAIT. I thought you could only have ONE payment plan at a time with the IRS. So how does someone with two open years set up separate plans?

0 coins

The IRS typically rolls multiple years into a single installment agreement, not two separate plans. So the one plan covers both balances together, and the monthly payment accounts for the total owed across all open years.

0 coins

Oh okay that makes way more sense. I genuinely thought you had to call and argue for each year separately.

0 coins

The online application pulls in all open balance years automatically. You end up with one agreement covering everything, not separate arrangements per year.

0 coins

I'm in a similar boat with 2024 and I'm honestly terrified. My CP14 says I need to pay by a certain date and that date has already passed. Am I in trouble? Does the IRS start seizing things immediately?

0 coins

The IRS doesn't go from a CP14 straight to collection action — there's a process with additional notices before anything like a levy would happen. If you apply for a payment plan, it puts collection on hold while the agreement is active.

0 coins

So I still have time to apply for the plan even though the CP14 date passed?

0 coins

Applying as soon as you can is the right move. Interest and some penalties keep running from the CP14 date, but setting up the plan stops escalation.

0 coins

The IRS sends follow-up notices after the CP14 — you'd receive those before anything more serious. But waiting longer means more interest, so moving quickly matters.

0 coins

An offset showing on my account was the thing that sent me scrambling to understand what was happening. A prior-year debt I didn't know was still open had reduced my expected refund for 2024. I used Claimyr to reach an IRS agent and asked specifically about the adjustment on my account — the agent confirmed the offset amount, the tax year it applied to, and that the Bureau of the Fiscal Service would be sending a separate notice explaining which agency received the funds. That cleared up a lot of confusion because I had no idea where the money had gone.

0 coins

An offset is different from what I'm dealing with, but I had no idea a past-year debt could quietly reduce a future refund like that. Is there any way to know in advance if an offset is coming?

0 coins

The Bureau of the Fiscal Service is supposed to mail a notice when an offset happens, but it sometimes arrives after the reduced refund already hits. Checking the account after a refund is smaller than expected is usually how people find out.

0 coins

Where's My Refund would show the adjusted amount but wouldn't explain why. The notice from the Bureau of the Fiscal Service is the thing that explains the reason and the agency that received the funds.

0 coins

My accountant told me something that stuck with me — the IRS would rather work out a payment plan than pursue collection because collection is expensive for them too. So they're generally willing to set up an agreement if you approach them before things escalate.

0 coins

That reframing actually helps. I've been thinking of it as going to them hat in hand, but if they'd rather resolve it cleanly too, it's more of a mutual interest situation.

0 coins

Exactly. And the online plan application is designed to make it easy because it's in their interest to get people into agreements. It's not a negotiation so much as filling out the form.

0 coins

The hardest part for me was accepting that I owed it and there was no way around it. Once I stopped hoping something would change, setting up the plan was actually quick.

0 coins

I wanted to share what the Taxpayer Advocate Service is for anyone here who's really stuck. It's an independent group inside the IRS, free to use, and it can help when someone is in financial hardship because of a tax issue or when the IRS hasn't resolved something within the normal timeframe. You apply with Form 911 or by calling 1-877-777-4778.

0 coins

Is TAS the same as a tax relief company? I've seen both mentioned and I keep confusing them.

0 coins

TAS is a free government office inside the IRS — completely different from a private tax relief company. TAS doesn't charge anything and doesn't negotiate fees. It advocates for you within the IRS system when you're stuck.

0 coins

I hadn't heard of TAS before this thread. Would they help with someone who just owes a balance and hasn't set up a plan yet, or do they mainly deal with more complicated situations?

0 coins

TAS generally takes cases involving financial hardship or where the IRS hasn't resolved something in the expected time. If your situation is straightforward — owe a balance, want a plan, returns are filed — the online account or a direct call to the IRS is probably faster than TAS.

0 coins

The IRS Online Account is genuinely useful for this kind of situation. You sign in through ID.me or Login.gov, and once you're in you can see the exact balance for each tax year, any notices the IRS has on your account, and you can apply for the payment plan right there without calling.

0 coins

Does the online account show the breakdown between the actual tax owed versus the penalties and interest that have been added?

0 coins

The account shows the total amount owed by tax year. For the specific breakdown between principal and penalties, the tax account transcript for that year has that detail.

0 coins

A tax account transcript and a tax return transcript are different things, by the way. The return transcript shows what you filed; the account transcript shows what's happened since, including adjustments, payments and penalties added.

0 coins

My bank posted a payment I had made to my IRS balance and I wasn't sure it had actually been credited to the right tax year. I used Claimyr to reach an agent at 800-829-1040, and the agent looked up the posting date of the payment and confirmed it had applied to my 2023 balance — which was the year I intended. That resolved a week of me wondering whether I needed to do anything else.

0 coins

How long did it take for the payment to show in the online account? Mine posted from my bank a few days ago and I don't see it reflected yet.

0 coins

Payments can take a few business days to show in the IRS Online Account. If it still isn't there after about a week, that's when calling to confirm the posting makes sense.

0 coins

I always screenshot my bank confirmation of the payment right when it clears, just in case I ever need to show when I paid and to which account.

0 coins

Penalties are actually two separate things running at once — there's one for not paying on time and a separate one for not filing on time. Since both of your returns are filed, you're only dealing with the late-payment side, not the double hit of both.

0 coins

I hadn't separated them out in my head — I just thought 'penalties' was one lump. Knowing the filing penalty isn't part of my problem anymore is at least something.

0 coins

Filing late is usually the bigger of the two penalties, so having your returns in already matters a lot for how fast the balance grows from here.

0 coins

I found that out the hard way in 2022. I waited to file thinking it would delay the bill, and the extra penalty from late filing ended up costing more than I expected.

0 coins

An address update I had made online wasn't showing in the IRS's system when a notice came to my old address. I used Claimyr to reach an IRS agent and confirmed the address on file — the agent said the address on the account still showed the old one and told me to submit a new Form 8822. The notice had been mailed to the right place eventually, but the account hadn't updated yet from the change I'd made the year before.

0 coins

That's something I hadn't thought about — if any of my notices went to an old address I might have missed something. How do you update it officially?

0 coins

Form 8822 is the change-of-address form. You can also update it by filing a return with your current address, which the IRS will use going forward. The form is the more direct route if you're not filing a new return soon.

0 coins

Notices going to an old address is a real problem because the IRS considers you notified as of the mailing date regardless of whether you actually received it. Keeping the address current is more important than most people realize.

0 coins

I called 800-829-1040 on a Tuesday in October and the wait was around 40 minutes — just so the original poster has a realistic expectation if they go the phone route. It's not impossible but it's not quick.

0 coins

Tuesday mid-morning — noted. I've heard mornings earlier in the week are sometimes better but I know that varies.

0 coins

My experience is exactly that it varies. Some days I've connected faster, some days I've given up and tried again. The online account handles most of what someone in your situation needs without the hold time.

0 coins

If the online account covers the plan setup, I'd do that first and only call if something specific needs clarification. Saves a lot of time.

0 coins

Can a tax relief company actually get the IRS to put a hold on collection while they 'negotiate'? I keep seeing that advertised and I don't understand if that's real.

0 coins

An active payment plan application does put collection activity on hold — but that's true whether a company applies or you do it yourself. The hold comes from being in the plan process, not from who filed the application.

0 coins

So the company isn't doing something special — they're just using the same system I could use?

0 coins

Exactly. If your returns are filed and your balance qualifies for the online plan, the company isn't adding anything you can't do at https://www.irs.gov/your-account yourself.

0 coins

The pitch those companies make sounds like they have a special channel to the IRS that regular people don't. They don't — the IRS's options are the same for everyone.

0 coins

Has the original poster checked whether any part of either balance might be from an error? Sometimes a CP14 reflects a balance that the IRS calculated differently from what was filed, and in that case the first step is verifying the number, not just paying it.

0 coins

Both balances are from income I underreported — I had freelance income one year and investment income the next that I didn't have enough withheld for. So the CP14 numbers are correct, I just didn't have the money set aside.

0 coins

That makes the path cleaner then — no dispute needed, just the payment arrangement. The fact that you know exactly what the balances are from means you can go straight to the plan.

0 coins

Freelance and investment income without withholding is exactly the scenario a W-4 or quarterly estimated payments are designed to prevent for future years. Worth adjusting going forward so this doesn't repeat.

0 coins

The IRS website at https://www.irs.gov/ has a whole section on payment plans that walks through who qualifies for online versus phone applications, and what information you need ready. I went through it before I called and it made the actual call much shorter because I had everything prepared.

0 coins

What do you need to have ready when you apply for the plan online?

0 coins

Your SSN, the tax years the balance covers, and a bank account if you want to set up direct debit — which lowers the user fee for the plan. The online account also shows the exact balance for each year so you're not guessing at numbers.

0 coins

Direct debit plans also sometimes come with a reduced setup fee compared to plans where you pay manually each month. Worth choosing if you have a stable bank account to link.

0 coins

Both balances being from self-employment and investment income — going forward, quarterly estimated payments are worth looking at seriously. The IRS expects people with income that isn't withheld at the source to pay in quarterly, and not doing it is what creates these gaps.

0 coins

I know, I know. I kept meaning to set up estimated payments and kept not doing it. This whole experience has been an expensive lesson in actually doing that.

0 coins

Form 1040-ES is what covers estimated payments. The IRS's Tax Withholding Estimator online can help figure out roughly what amounts to send each quarter so you're not under by much.

0 coins

I underestimated one quarter and got a small penalty but it was way less painful than what happens when you let it build up over two full years. Definitely start the quarterly payments.

0 coins

To put a bow on it for the original poster: both returns filed, two CP14 notices, combined balance eligible for the online plan — apply through the IRS Online Account, skip the tax relief company unless something unusual comes up, and keep an eye on quarterly payments going forward so 2025 doesn't add a third year to the pile.

0 coins

This is the clearest summary of my actual next steps I've gotten anywhere. Apply online, don't pay for a middleman, start estimated payments for 2026 going forward. Appreciate everyone here.

0 coins

You've got it. The main thing is acting quickly because interest is running daily. The sooner the plan is in place, the less piles on.

0 coins

I wish I'd had this thread before I paid that retainer. Genuinely, the IRS's own tools handled everything that company did, and they were free.

0 coins

IRS AI

Expert Assistant
Secure