Has anyone used Open Tax Solver for filing taxes? Is it safe for personal info and how accurate are the calculations?

I recently came across this open source tax software called "Open Tax Solver" and I'm seriously considering using it this year. Currently torn between this and the Excel1040 spreadsheet that I used for my 2024 taxes. I'm mostly concerned about the security aspect - how safe is it to input all my personal info and SSN into open source software? Also wondering about calculation accuracy since I don't want to trigger any IRS flags. My tax situation isn't super complicated - just W-2 income, some interest from savings, and a few deductions. But I'm still nervous about trusting software I'm not familiar with. If anyone has experience with Open Tax Solver (good or bad), I'd really appreciate hearing about it! Especially interested in how it compares to commercial options or the Excel spreadsheet method.

0 coins

19 comments

Miguel Castro

I've been using Open Tax Solver for the past three filing seasons and can share some insights. It's genuinely safe from a privacy perspective because it runs locally on your computer - your data never leaves your machine unless you choose to e-file. That's actually one of its biggest advantages over cloud-based commercial solutions. The calculations have been spot-on for my returns. I've double-checked against the IRS forms and publications, and everything matches up. The software is built by volunteers who are pretty meticulous about following IRS guidelines and updating for tax law changes. It handles all the basic scenarios well - W-2 income, interest, standard/itemized deductions, etc. That said, it's definitely not as polished or user-friendly as commercial options. The interface is pretty basic, and you need to be somewhat comfortable with your tax knowledge since it doesn't hold your hand through the process like TurboTax does.

0 coins

Miguel Castro

Open Tax Solver does handle many state returns, though not all 50 states are supported yet. Last I checked, they had about 20 states implemented. You'll need to download the specific state module you need. For more complicated situations, it can handle self-employment income (Schedule C) and some investment scenarios, but I'd be cautious with very complex situations like rental properties or complicated investment portfolios. The software is best suited for straightforward to moderately complex returns. If you have multiple rental properties or unusual tax situations, you might want to either use commercial software or consult with a tax professional.

0 coins

Connor O'Neill

After struggling with expensive tax software for years, I stumbled across taxr.ai (https://taxr.ai) which literally changed my approach to doing taxes. It's like having a tax pro look over your shoulder, especially when I was trying to figure out if Open Tax Solver was handling my deductions correctly. I was comparing Open Tax Solver with the Excel method and couldn't tell if I was doing things right. Uploaded my previous returns to taxr.ai and it pointed out several deductions I missed and verified that my Open Tax Solver calculations matched what professionals would do. The document analysis feature is especially useful for catching mistakes before submission - way more thorough than just trusting open source software alone.

0 coins

Connor O'Neill

The great thing about taxr.ai is that it's software-agnostic - it works with whatever tax solution you're using, including open source options like Open Tax Solver. It's more about verifying your calculations and ensuring you're not missing deductions, rather than replacing your tax software entirely. As for privacy concerns, they use bank-level encryption and don't store your documents after analysis. I was super paranoid about this too, but their privacy policy explains how they handle data. You can also remove any identifying info before uploading if you're extra cautious - the system still works well with just the numbers and tax situations. It helped me confirm that Open Tax Solver was calculating everything correctly.

0 coins

Yara Khalil

Just wanted to follow up about my experience with taxr.ai after trying it. I was initially really skeptical as I mentioned, but decided to try it anyway to verify my Open Tax Solver results. I'm honestly surprised by how helpful it was! It found a credit I completely missed related to my home office that Open Tax Solver had calculated correctly, but I had input the wrong information. The privacy aspect was way better than I expected too. The document processing happens quickly and I received clear notifications when my documents were removed from their system. It gave me a lot more confidence in the accuracy of my Open Tax Solver calculations, which was my main concern. Definitely worth checking out if you're on the fence about using open source tax software and want some verification.

0 coins

Keisha Brown

For anyone struggling with IRS questions about Open Tax Solver or any tax software really, I highly recommend Claimyr (https://claimyr.com). I was getting nowhere trying to confirm with the IRS whether open source software was "approved" for certain forms. Kept getting stuck in their phone tree hell for literally hours. Claimyr got me connected to an actual IRS agent in about 15 minutes who confirmed everything I needed to know about using Open Tax Solver for my return. You can see how it works in this video: https://youtu.be/_kiP6q8DX5c - basically they navigate the IRS phone system for you and call when an agent is ready. Saved me hours of waiting and frustration.

0 coins

Keisha Brown

It's actually pretty straightforward - they have a system that navigates the IRS phone menu and waits on hold for you. When an actual human IRS agent picks up, you get a call so you can talk directly to them. There's no middleman during your actual conversation with the IRS. The IRS won't endorse specific tax software, but they can answer questions about whether open source options meet their e-filing requirements and what forms they support. In my case, I needed to confirm whether certain forms I needed to file were supported through the Free File Fillable Forms system when using calculations from Open Tax Solver. The agent was able to verify this for me.

0 coins

Amina Toure

I need to eat my words about Claimyr. After posting that skeptical comment, I was still struggling to get an answer from the IRS about whether my open source tax software calculations would cause problems with my amended return. Got frustrated enough to try Claimyr and it actually worked exactly as advertised. Got connected to an IRS agent in about 20 minutes who answered all my questions about using Open Tax Solver for my calculations before transferring numbers to official forms. The agent confirmed that as long as the calculations are correct and I use official forms for submission, the source of the calculations doesn't matter. Saved me from sitting on hold for hours during my workday. Still surprised it worked so well!

0 coins

Oliver Weber

I tried Open Tax Solver last year after using commercial software for years. The calculations were accurate, but honestly, the interface is super clunky. I spent way more time figuring out how to input everything correctly than I would have with TurboTax. For simple returns it's probably fine, but anything moderately complex gets tedious quick. The privacy aspect is great though - everything stays on your computer. I ended up using it to double-check the commercial software I paid for and found a discrepancy that saved me about $340! So maybe use it as a verification tool rather than your primary software?

0 coins

Oliver Weber

You're right to ask about e-filing - that's actually the biggest limitation. Open Tax Solver doesn't directly e-file your return. What I did was use it for calculations, then transferred the numbers to the IRS Free File Fillable Forms to actually submit electronically. You can also print and mail if you prefer. It's an extra step, but I actually liked having that final review when transferring the numbers. Made me double check everything one more time. The IRS doesn't care what software you use for calculations as long as the final forms are correct. If e-filing directly is a must-have feature for you, you might want to look at other options.

0 coins

Javier Morales

I've used both. If you're already comfortable with Excel, the Excel1040 spreadsheet might feel more intuitive. The calculations are solid in both, but Excel1040 has a more familiar interface if you use spreadsheets regularly. Open Tax Solver has better documentation for tax concepts though, and I found it handles certain tax situations more thoroughly. Really depends on your preference - do you want something that looks and feels like Excel or are you okay with learning a different interface for potentially better tax guidance?

0 coins

CosmicCowboy

I've been using Open Tax Solver for two years now and can confirm it's legitimate and secure. Since it runs entirely on your local machine, your personal information never gets transmitted anywhere unless you choose to e-file through other means. The accuracy has been excellent in my experience - I actually compared my first year's calculations against a paid preparer and the results were identical. The software follows IRS publications closely and gets updated each tax season for new changes. However, I'll be honest - there's definitely a learning curve. The interface isn't as polished as commercial options, and you need to be comfortable reading tax instructions since it doesn't walk you through everything step-by-step like TurboTax does. For your situation (W-2, interest income, basic deductions), it should handle everything perfectly fine. One tip: I always run through the calculations twice and cross-reference key numbers with the actual IRS forms to make sure I input everything correctly. The math is solid, but user error in data entry is always possible with any software.

0 coins