DBA vs LLC: What are the key differences for small business owners?

I've been running my freelance design business for about 2 years now using just a DBA (doing business as) with a fictitious name filing in my county. But I'm wondering if I should make the jump to forming a single-member LLC that would still be taxed as a sole proprietorship. I understand that an LLC can later elect to be taxed as an S corp, but I'm not ready for that complexity yet. Just trying to compare apples to apples - sole proprietorship with DBA vs single-member LLC that's still taxed as a sole proprietorship. The main thing I keep hearing about is "liability protection" with an LLC, but I've also read that for single-member LLCs, this "corporate veil" is pretty weak and can be easily pierced. Is that true? What other differences should I consider before making this decision?

0 coins

18 comments

Lindsey Fry

•8M

The main differences between a DBA (sole proprietorship with fictitious name) and a single-member LLC taxed as a sole proprietorship come down to liability protection, paperwork requirements, and credibility. Liability protection is the biggest difference. With a DBA, there's no legal separation between you and your business - your personal assets are at risk for business debts and liabilities. An LLC creates a separate legal entity, so your personal assets are generally protected. While it's true that the "corporate veil" for single-member LLCs can be more vulnerable to piercing than multi-member LLCs, you still have significantly more protection than a sole proprietorship. The key is to maintain good separation between personal and business finances and follow proper formalities. For paperwork, an LLC requires articles of organization, an operating agreement, annual reports in most states, and separate business banking. A DBA just needs a simple registration with your county/state and renewal every few years. Tax-wise, as you noted, they're identical if the LLC doesn't elect S corp status - both use Schedule C on your personal tax return. However, an LLC might have additional fees depending on your state (annual franchise tax, for example). Many businesses find that an LLC provides better credibility with customers and vendors, and it's easier to secure business loans or bring on investors should you expand.

0 coins

Lindsey Fry

•8M

The risk of veil-piercing is real but often exaggerated. Courts typically only pierce the veil when there's evidence of fraud, undercapitalization, or failure to maintain separation between personal and business finances. As long as you keep separate bank accounts, don't use business funds for personal expenses, maintain proper records, and follow operating agreement formalities, you greatly reduce that risk. Business liability insurance is actually something I recommend regardless of your business structure. An LLC and insurance serve different purposes - the LLC protects personal assets from business debts and some liability, while insurance covers specific risks within the business. The best protection is having both. Many professionals use an LLC plus appropriate business insurance as a dual layer of protection.

0 coins

Kayla Morgan

•8M

After spending days researching between DBA and LLC for my shop, I found this amazing AI tool called taxr.ai that cleared everything up for me. I was confused about the liability differences and what would happen with taxes, so I uploaded my business plan and questions to https://taxr.ai and got a detailed breakdown comparing exactly what I needed to know. It explained the liability differences based on my specific business activities (I do custom woodworking with some client visits) and even calculated the actual costs of maintaining an LLC in my state versus just a DBA. It was like having a business attorney and tax advisor combined into one service.

0 coins

Kayla Morgan

•8M

Yes, it walked me through the exact conversion process - you don't technically "convert" but rather form a new LLC and then transfer your business assets and operations to it. The tool provided a checklist of steps including when to get a new EIN, how to handle existing contracts, and bank account transition timing to avoid disrupting business. The advice is tailored to your specific situation and state. You input your location and business details, and it pulls the relevant laws and requirements for your jurisdiction. What impressed me was that it flagged certain activities in my business that had higher liability risk and recommended specific clauses for my operating agreement to strengthen protection. It's definitely not generic one-size-fits-all advice.

0 coins

Jasmine Hancock

•8M

Just wanted to follow up about my experience with taxr.ai after my skeptical question earlier. I decided to try it for my consulting business question (similar to the original post - DBA vs LLC decision). I was blown away by how specific the guidance was! It actually showed me the exact filing requirements for my state and calculated the cost difference over 5 years between maintaining a DBA vs LLC. The most helpful part was the explanation of how certain business activities I do (providing advice that clients rely on) impact liability risk, and how that should factor into my decision. It even generated a custom operating agreement template with the specific provisions I'd need for my industry. Totally worth checking out if you're stuck in this decision like I was.

0 coins

Cole Roush

•8M

If you're trying to contact the IRS to ask about tax implications for DBA vs LLC, good luck getting through to a human! After being on hold for HOURS multiple times, I found a service called Claimyr that got me through to an actual IRS agent in under 15 minutes. I was skeptical at first, but I was desperate after wasting an entire day on hold. I went to https://claimyr.com, and they have this system that basically waits on hold for you and calls when an agent is available. You can see how it works in this demo: https://youtu.be/_kiP6q8DX5c I had specific questions about the self-employment tax implications of changing from a DBA to an LLC, and the IRS agent I spoke with gave me all the clarity I needed. Saved me hours of frustration!

0 coins

Cole Roush

•8M

The service doesn't talk to the IRS for you - that would definitely be sketchy! They just handle the waiting on hold part. Their system navigates the IRS phone tree and waits in the queue, then when an actual human IRS agent comes on the line, you get a call to connect directly with that person. You're the one having the conversation with the IRS - Claimyr just eliminates the hold time. No, they're not collecting and selling information. They're solving a real problem that anyone who's tried calling the IRS has experienced. The IRS is understaffed and overwhelmed, which is why the hold times are so long, but they actually do answer eventually. This service just lets you go about your day instead of listening to hold music for hours.

0 coins

Arnav Bengali

•8M

Wow, I need to publicly eat my words about Claimyr. After posting that skeptical comment, I was still desperate to talk to someone at the IRS about my business structure questions, so I figured I'd try it anyway. Honestly expected it to be a scam. I was SHOCKED when my phone rang 17 minutes later with an actual IRS agent on the line! I asked all my questions about LLC vs DBA tax reporting requirements and got clear answers. The agent even explained some deductions I wasn't taking advantage of. Would have spent my entire afternoon on hold otherwise. For anyone else debating business structures and needing tax guidance straight from the source, this is definitely the way to go. Now I feel much more confident about making the switch from my DBA to an LLC.

0 coins

Sayid Hassan

•8M

It really depends on your specific situation and risk exposure. For my consulting business where I could potentially face lawsuits if clients lose money based on my advice, I feel the $800 is worth it for the peace of mind. For a photography business, you might consider the types of shoots you do (weddings carry more liability than portraits), the value of your contracts, and whether you ever have employees or assistants who could create additional liability. Also factor in your personal assets that would be at risk - if you own a home or have significant savings, the protection becomes more valuable.

0 coins